UPSC interview, T. C. A. Anant board, 12 May 2022 (Medical…)
12 May 2022
Date – 12 May 2022, Forenoon
Board – Dr. T.C.A. Anant Sir
Optional – Medical Science
College – Government Medical College, Kota
Profession – I worked as Senior Lecturer first and then as Junior Resident Doctor
Hobbies and extra curriculars – Badminton, Trekking, Wilderness camping, Trekking, Gardening, Photography, Editor of college journal, Secretary at Avekshaa (NGO)
My experience in interview – Very cordial board, interview was totally off beat, unlike mocks! I came out of the room satisfied with my performance.
Utility of mocks – Guide to dressing etiquette, how to avoid falling into trap of controversies. Just one bit of my personal advice, please do not let anyone bring your morale down! I gave 6 mocks, 4 went fantastic, 1 was not so good and one went horrible, the chairperson of that board ended up calling me arrogant and my confidence and morale went lower then the stock market. But then I talked to a very senior IAS officer 2 days back and he said “Beta tum waha Naukri maangane nai ja rahe ho k sir mai berojgar hu mujhe naukri pe rakhlo, unko tumhari zarurat h ye desh chalaane k liye, iss confidence k sath jao tumhara interview bahut acha jayega.” And I got the much needed booster dose against the disease that infests aspirants right at this crucial moment.
Questions asked –
Chairman – (he was eating a samosa at this moment)
1. So__, you graduated in 2018 ( I corrected him and said I graduated in 2019 because 1 year is compulsory internship), he said no further in this matter.
2. So why is it that young bright minds like you are leaving the medical profession and coming for civil services? Recently Honourable Health Minister presented data to parliament that there is shortage of doctors? (He was factually wrong at this as the HM had said that there is one doctor for 832 population, more than WHO norm of 1:1000 but I didn’t want to correct him at this moment because in that mock which went horrible was because of this fact itself and they took offence)
3. Ok. So you like wilderness camping? Tell me about it. (I shared my experience from my last camp)
4. When was this? Where did you camp before this? ( It was Dras)
5. Which group did you camp with? (I said that sir I didn’t go with any group, we were three friends)
6. So what camping gear do you use and how will you guide me if I wanted to go for a wilderness camp?
Member 1
7. So you’re a doctor. Are you aware of EUA, Emergency Use Authorisation and the normal process? ( I didn’t know about the normal process and I said sorry)
8. What are the ethical concerns in clinical trials and why is India the soft target for these trials?
9. What is the difference between NCEs and generics?
10. Can biologics be patented? ( I said yes but he double questioned, are you sure? I hope I’m right that biologics can also be patented)
Member 2 –
11. So during pandemic you must have seen the reverse migration. What do you think is this issue? Why weren’t we able to provide for migrants? (I fumbled here a bit and concluded by saying that administration should have taken a greater proactive approach)
12. Has the government done anything for migrants? (At this time the caffeine from Honourable Chairperson hit him and he got up using the toilet and I also stood up and ended up losing my concentration to the answer, sat back down and answered about all the initiatives)
13. There is lot of malnutrition in India. What are the precise statistics? What has the government done and what should be done according to you?
Member 3 (Lady) –
14. We have already talked about your interests. Now I want to talk about my interests. Can you name the mangroves of India? (I was only able to recall 3)
15. Name some bird sanctuaries of India, especially from Rajasthan. (my home state is Rajasthan, again I named only 3)
16. What is Project Tiger? (I don’t think I gave a satisfactory answer to this as I was not able to recall the exact figures but I did talk about its success)
17. So if you’re posted as DM of one of the district with rich wildlife areas, what will be your
focus? ( I talked about my personal experiences from trekking and she seemed to be very convinced)
18. So _, what do you think about the elderlies? Are we doing enough for them? (By this time she didn’t know the focus are of my NGO was elderly care and was amused to know the same and I shared my personal experiences and concluded by saying that we should not look upon a 65 yr old as a dependant and use the knowledge, experience and wisdom of these people in nation building, for instance, providing vocational education to childen as has been envisaged in NEP 2020)
Member 4 – (this gentleman wanted me to be Alexander the great and to conquer all the neighbouring counties for India)
19. What is your take on Russia – Ukraine war? Who is to blame? ( I blamed Russia as well as NATO, NATO for expanding eastwards and wanting to bring under their umbrella, Ukraine and Georgia)
20. So by this virtue, India should invade Nepal because it is favouring China? (I said we need to diplomatically engage and resolve issues)
21. But if China invades Nepal, should we not invade Nepal? ( I said if that is the case that Nepal has already been invaded then Nepal’s political leader would want to align with India and we should jointly do the needful)
22. Tell about Siliguri corridor?
23. Isn’t it a strategic challenge for India?
24. To secure connectivity between mainland India and NER, should we not invade Bhutan and Nepal and adjacent areas of Bangladesh to remove the issue altogether? (I said rather than coercive action and bringing them in India’s sovereign jurisdiction, we should bring them under our economic sphere, develop inland waterways, cross border road connectivity and capitalise on Kaladan project)
25. So you don’t want to invade them. Do you believe our intelligence agencies even have any sway over these countries? (I said we should continue intelligence gathering but respect westphalian values as well)
26. Was Sikkim part of India in 1947?
27. So when did India invade Sikkim? (I humbly corrected him and said Sikkim came to India out of free will and not coercion)
28. There is something called job satisfaction. Do you think a you being a doctor will have any satisfaction by working in ministries like communication? (I agreed and said that sir share this apprehension and I have given detailed thought to it and came to a conclusion that I will always work probono, I have great regard and interest in medical profession and will always continue that and we also see that many DMs and SPs who are doctors are establisihing their OPDs when residents go on strike)
29. Ok, thank you.
Chairperson – Ok, thank you.