Interviews

UPSC interview, Manoj Soni board, 13 May 2022

13 May 2022

Name: Ashutosh

Board: Dr. Manoj Soni

Native State: Uttar Pradesh

Background: B.Tech ( Electrical Engineering) IIT Kanpur

Optional: PSIR ( political science and international relations)

Hobby: Sun Salutation ( Surya Namaskar), Meditation

Chairman Sir

1. You have very high CGPA, So tell me how did you get this, was it hard work or were you really passionate about Electrical Engineering?

2. So now you are aspiring for civil services, Is it a loss for electrical Engineering or gain for civil services? Overall nation is losing out a good engineer? ( told him that I will use my education knowledge in civil services, He replied well you will hardly get any opportunity)

3. Ok, so you have electrical background, tell me what is "integrated energy policy". Have you heard about it?

( Now this went a bit unexpected.

My reply: Sir I am not aware of exact provisions but....

Sir: What but? Do you want to take guess about it? Do you want to analyse word integrated and energy?

Me: Sir, if you permit

Sir: No, No, you don't treat policies like that. You should not make guesses on that. This is not the way.

Me: Sorry Sir.

I am shaken a bit from inside. But calmed my self immediately. I thought that I still have lot of interview questions left. Let's give our best in that)

M1:Ma'am

1. You good good marks in electrical engineering and still you choose political science as optional. This is like a crowd mentality. I don't find any leadership skills in that?

( I told her that I had analysed syllabus of many optionally before choosing so it's not crowd mentality. It's based on my interest. And leader is one who delivers result. I think I will be able to get good result by choosing PSIR. )

2. Tell me about judicial activism with some examples. Is is good for our country? What's your take on it?

3. These days we see lot of cases pending in judiciary. What steps are being taken to resolve that?

4. Have you heard the word Lutyens Delhi? Why is it in news these days?

( Told her that since new parliament is coming up, we are now transitions from Lutyens era building to new Central Vista and Parliament which are symbol of moving towards Atmanirbharta)

Ma'am: But Lutyens Delhi also refers to some old elites.

Me: Ma'am I'm not aware of it. Will read about it

M2: Sir

1. Women have been given permanent commission in army? Do you think it will enhance effectiveness of army? ( Looked happy when I replied in support of women permanent commission)

2.Recently Identification of Prisoners Act, 1920 was amended in which DNA samples etc can be take. What is your view on that?

(Me: supported amendment that it will lead to better criminal investigation bla bla. But I did not reply it in fluent English.)

3. But don't you think there is loss of privacy? Even for small offences, now police can take DNA samples etc

( I had not read about this act properly. So couldn't answer it with proper legal points. So gave a made up answer that govt and judiciary should develope institutional mechanism to prevent misuse of data and prevent unnecessary criminalisation of people. Again english was not so fluent)

M3: Sir

1. What is meaning of your name Ashutosh?

2. Is there any purana associated with Lord Shiva

( I roughly knew it was shiv purana. But I was a bit scared of taking anymore guess after being reprimanded by chairman. So simply said Sir I am not aware of it. Sir said it was shiv purana. I said ok sir)

3. Now listen carefully. My chair had asked you whether you joining civil services will be a gain for civil services or loss for electrical engineering. Answer me carefully.

(This time I decided to take a decisive stand now. And specially in question which involves choices between 2 options. I just answered that gain for civil services)

4. How is it a gain. You will hardly ever apply your electrical engineering knowledge as DM. You will be busy in administrative tasks.

( I replied him by an example that many remote villages lack electricity and how microgrids can be a solution in that. I explained how as DM I can support seeing up of microgrids etc. Sir Did'nt say anything to my answer. Simply passed me to next member.

In between Chairman sir went out of the room for a 30-40 seconds. I had a vague feeling that this is just to see my situational response. So I simply focussed on answering question of M3 sir and Did'nt get waivered by Chairman sir going out and coming in. )

M4 sir

1. You do Sun Salutation. Is it Surya namaskar. Why you used word Salutation. (Before I could answer question.) Ok anyways, how many steps are there in Surya namaskar?

2. Ok so, do you do meditation after Surya namaskar or before it.

( I told him First I do 30 surya namskar and then meditation.

He said 15 before and 15 afterwards. I said no sir, First I do 30 surya namaskar at stretch and then meditation.)

3. In ashtang yoga, dhyaana comes before meditation or after that?

4. Awadh region is about Ayodhya and all. Why is Shaam- e- Awadh famous?

(Told him about cultural dances, music that used to be organized in evenings since Nawabs times)

5. Ok. Why is Subah-e-Banaras famous?

(Told him about spiritual activities , prayers done in morning in Varanasi since times immemorial).

Finally Chairman Sir: It was nice talking to you. Stay safe in Delhi these days. Afterwards he said something which I couldn't understand.

Simply got up. Said thanks to all and then walked out.

Overall the atmosphere was quite nice. Even while asking me not to take guess, Chairman sir only pointed this out in a very calm and composed manner. The voice tone was still pleasant. All members gave adequate time for me to reply. 2 answers I did not know. For 2 , I couldn't frame it in nice and fluent English.

Chairman sir's room ambience is nice. For those in afternoon session, cakes, coffee, juice, water etc is there in waiting area.

One small thing: The gloves that are provided have white type of some dust on it, which may make black suit dirty. I feel that if we have a white handkerchief then it can be used to wipe off dust gently from gloves. I rubbed my gloves in a nearby newspaper and gloves became a bit dirty. So use white handkerchief.

Thanks to community for sharing their transcripts which helps in everyone's preparation. Here is my bit for it.

Best of luck to everyone. Sab Honge Kamyaab

Interview Transcript :

Date 11 May 2022 ; 12:30 PM

Name Manpreet

BTech mechanical engg NIT Jalandhar

work ex - Maruti Suzuki

Optional : Punjabi Literature

Home State -Punjab

Board: Smita Nagaraj mam

Chairperson

-what do u do these days

- what did u learn from the work culture of maruti(discussed india Japan collab)

- what Japan gets out of this venture(told about profit share and royalty)

- I believe just the name is Indian otherwise it’s majorly Japanese oriented (defended the Indian part )

- compare maruti, Tata and Mahindra

- Our cities are replete with traffic and pollution and we are promoting automobiles . Isn’t it a paradox ? (Discussed electric , hydrogen , CNG vehicles n vehicle Scrappage policy )

Member 2 : Sir

- Had discussed about Royalty payment to Suzuki ; so some ques about digital patents ( discussed about strengthening India’s IPR policies to boost innovation)

- U r from Barnala , tell me what would u do as DM to curb Prali issue(stubble burning )

- Bhutan has GHI , what is ur opinion India should also have it ? (discussed Indian concerns on economic growth and our current priorities )

- forgetting other ques if any by the member

Member 3: Sir

- do u think our Neighbourhood first policy has failed (defended the NFP)

-But Given the strain in our neighbourhood relations from fishing issues with Srilanka ; Teesta with Bangladesh (discussed about diplomacy and dialogue to resolve the issues )

- IMF has downgraded the growth forecast from 9 to 8 , why ? (Told Russia- Ukraine’s and supply Chain disruptions)

-Are u aware of Aya Ram Gya Ram (I nodded); what is ur opinion on anti defection act (presented the case for improvement in the act)

- what do u think about eco recovery post COVID (discussed about improving revenues and V shaped recovery)

- How will u tackle naxalism ; should op greyhound of AP be replicated in other States (discussed law n order ; development and need for dialogue and statewise solutions with example of Bihar )

Member- 4 : Ma’am

- You have done ur education in English medium ; why opted Punjabi literature

- which writers u read in that (mentioned Guru Nanak Dev ji ; waris shah; Amrita Pritam ; Shiv Kumar Batalvi

- Tell us about writings of Guru Nanak Dev ji

- Do u think vernacular language at primary level should be promoted

- which language u had in class 1 (punjabi ; Hindi ; English )

- why punjabi youth is emigrating ?

- what will u do to curb drug menace in punjab

member 5 :Ma’am

- you are a volunteer of Save the Soil movement ; what it is ?

- what did u do in it as a volunteer

- what did u do as NSS volunteer

- what is Kaizen?

- despite being portrayed as people s car ; why Nano failed ?

Chairperson

Last ques : Why punjab youth is not migrating to other Economic hubs of India but emigrating abroad (I said I myself migrated to Gurugram Mam and listed other pull and push factors of emigration); Thank you

Time : 30-35 min

The experience from entering the premises to coming out of the building was seamless and really supportive ; every person involved from coordinators to board members had a smile on their face and the ambience was quiet chilled out . I Enjoyed the process thoroughly especially the company of my round table group and the medical exam group :)

Wish you guys all the best :)