UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 10 May 2022 (PSIR)
10 May 2022
Name-AKS
Date and session of interview- 10th May, Forenoon Session
Board- Smita Nagarajan Ma'am
Optional-PSIR
College- IIT Roorkee
Profession (if any)- Reliance (Jamnagar)
Hobbies- Nothing asked from here
Chairman:
1. You worked in Reliance for a short period. Why did you quit?
2. What is the relation between NSS and Civil Services? ( Member of NSS in college)
3. Isn't the administration in the rural areas doing their job well? Why do you think you felt the need to join services for bringing about change in the rural areas?
4. How do you measure change ? Which areas will you focus on to change if you are a DM?
5. Because DM have fairly short tenure of about 2 years in a particular posting, how do you ensure that this change is sustainable?
6. Did you see any visible change in the villages nearby your college when you worked there?
7. Long question- Wrt education, policies are made at centre/state but fail to get implemented at cutting edge level. Should everything be handed over to local self govt or education should remain to be centralized? Which is more preferable?
M2
1. Continuing on the topic of Change, how early in your tenure will you start bringing about this change?
2. There is a tool in management related to discussion. What is it? (She wanted to hear Brainstorming)
3. What are the essential elements/qualities you'll keep in mind while brainstorming?
4. How will you ensure a change in the behavioral mindset? (I had answered there is resistance to change in previous answer)
5. What is the difference between Risk Management and Disaster Management?
M3
1. COP 27 will be held this year. Will the agenda this year be on the same lines as Glasgow Summit or can Food Security and Hunger be an agenda this year?
2. The govt formed a new Ministry of Cooperation. Is it a step in the right direction? Will it be harmful to federal structure?
3. What are the issues being faced by cooperative sector?
M4
1. You worked in Reliance in Jamnagar. What are the good things it did to curb pollution there and what things it could have done better?
2. Since you are a student of Metallurgy, what are the qualities in a metal or material you look for in this time of Reduce, Recycle and Reuse?
3. When the Russia-Ukraine war ends, in what areas can India contribute in the reconstruction of Ukraine?
M4
1. There is view that armament lobbies in the US and Russia are promoting the Russia-Ukraine war. They don't want it to end. What are your views on this?
2. If NATO declares that Ukraine will not become a part of NATO, the war may end. Why is not doing so?
3. Suppose you are DM of a district. And you have 30% vacancy in you department. How will you now work upon bringing about that change you talked about earlier? Recruitment is not in your hands. What other steps will you take?
4. When you are planning for the district, will you consider the work done by previous officers? ( I had answered in an earlier question (#2) of M2 that I would first plan for about 6 months and then execute them.)
Your experience in interview- It was a good experience. Mostly opinion/situation based question. Most of the interview was based on my initial answer where I had mentioned civil services can bring about a change at grassroot level, which I had seen at micro level in NSS. The board was very cordial and listening carefully to every answer. Not much grilling. Except for M4 (deadpan face), the rest were smiling and nodding to your answers.
Utility of mocks (if any)- I had given 5 mocks. Good experience in Iashub, Chanakya Mandal and KSG. Mainly they help in correcting mannerisms and getting used to facing a 5 member panel.
All the best to everyone!!!