Interviews

UPSC interview, Sujata Chaturvedi board, 22 Apr 2018

22 Apr 2018

Sujata Metha mam Board

Ch: So Gowthaman U r from IAAS and do you accept that your Audit report turned down one government?

Ch: Is it a scam?

Ch: How was the figure calculated in 2G report?

Ch: How did such a big notional value become very nominal value afterwards

Ch: What happened in coal audit report?

Ch: Govt went for auctioning of spectrum after your report. Initially govt earned huge revenue, but in the recent auction govt was not able to mop up enough revenue. Why?

Ch: How to fix price for the resource like spectrum, coal.

Ch: Despite good demand in market spectrum auction didn’t fetch enough revenue. What is the benchmark to fix price?

Member1: She asked about what am I doing now

M1: Audit of ur dept has changed over the period of time. What is the new type of audit that u r conducting now.

M1: Im expecting one particular word from u

M1: Yes, What is it?

M1: Despite all ur good recommendations why there is no much improvement in the ground.

M1: Ok lets move away from audit. PM is using 3 words to describe the relation between centre and state. Whats it?

M1: Have u heard about Cooperative

Me: (Before she finishes) Mam Cooperative federalism

M1: No its cooperative competitive federalism. Whats is it Explain

M1: There is a structure put up for achieving this

M1: Niti ayog is old one, Tell New one

M1: What is it, Explain

M1: What is GST?

M1: How is it different from previous tax. Do u know the overview of it?

M1: This and all is ok, But I’m expecting a particular word from u

M1: Ok leave it. Have u heard about Twin balance sheet issue?

M1: How to solve it?

M1: Do u know what is the timeframe to declare a asset as non performing

M1: But RBI action will solve only one side of the issue. How to solve the issue on the other side

Member 2: Lets move on o totally different area. Tell me the border issues we have with china

Me: I started with Doklam Crisis

M2: There are more big issues

Me: (I was thinking. Have no idea what is he expecting)

Chairman Intervened and said take ur own time and use paper if u wanna gather points.

I was scribbling LAC, ArP, Doklam in paper. Have no ide what to tell. Became all blank. Mam said if u r not comfortable Ill ask him to ask from some other area. I said Yes Mam.

M2: Tell what all news u read in newspaper toady, yesterday about inside outside

M2: Tell me about Simultaneous election.

M2: You know how much of money was spent in say last general election.

M2: That is EC’s spending figure. How much the parties are spending

M2: Yes it is about 30000 crore. Do you think that simultaneous election can be conducted with current constitution. Or else what need to be done?

M2: Why constitution amendment and what need to be amended

M2: Why RPA need to be amended

M2: Coming to ur subject electronics. Why did GSAT Fail.

M2: What would have gone wrong according to u, it is ur subject

Member 3: U studied in john dewey school. Who is he what is his contribution

M3: Explain his thought and is he only philosopher or he is related to some other field also

Me: (Damn I prepared it during my first and second attempt why is he asking me now. I didn’t revise this) I said I do not know the details and Im not comfortable is philosophy ( Second time Mam intervened and asked him to change the topic)

M3: Being the student of Public administration Explain what is constituent power

Me: (Couldn’t understand the word and asked him to repeat three times and at last he wrote the word in paper and mam also pronounced the word by this time. ) I said don’t know

M3: Article 368 has the word constituent power.

M3: What are the limitations in amending the constitution

M3: Are they limitations. He was wondering

M3: How FR is a limitation

M3: But rt to property was taken away through CA which is also a FR.

Member 4: Do u know kesavananda bharati case. What is the gist of the case

M4: Did they specify what constitute the basic structure in that judgement

M4: Tel few features which are basic structures of constitutuion

M4: What do u think is the role of media

Me: When I said media should act He intervened and said don’t sa

y what media should be, Say what role media is playing now. I was thinking what to tel. ( Political biasedness of media, Fake news are running in my mind. But donno what to tell and how to handle counter question. Became blank)

M4: Lee kuan yew said if u r not controlling then they will control u. Should government control media

Chairman: Who should give the freedom to media when it is already ensured to them

Me: Yes mam Constitution through Freedom of speech and expression ensure media freedom. There are reasonable restrictions to it which should to interpreted liberally by the govt.

Chairman said thank you Gowthaman your interview is over. I stood up and said Mam Before leaving I would like to wish you all a Happy Civil Services day. All said Oh, Thank You. I said Thank You and left the room

Interview on 20/04/2018(A/N)

Manoj Mahajan

Optional:History

Hobby: Astronomy,writing,reading

Smita Nagarajan mam Board

3rd to go

Cp:So ur hobby is astronomy we will start from it and go through it

Are u aware about extraterrestrial life?

Why the scientists are so excited about it?(Fermi paradox)

According to you what are chances of extraterrestrial life?

Is it 50:50?(just guess)

Are you aware about fast radiowave burst?

Why there are so many radio signal/noise are coming to earth?(cosmic microwave background)

What is the significance of these signals?

So you are also interested in writing ...what do you write?(sarcastic poem on friends)

Why do you write sarcastic poem only?

Are u gifting them(poems) manually or on WhatsApp?(Aap to dostonke maze lete hai )(all of us laugh)

M1:How did you get interested in astronomy?

Did you read Carl sagan's book?And another 2-3 astrophysicists

Are u aware about scientists discussion of different forms of life in the universe?

How will you detect life on other planets?

Suppose life is a very different on other planets then how will you detect it?

Then what is life?

How will you define this is living thing and this is non living?

I think radio waves may be signals of different form of life.What's your opinion?

what is dark matter?how will you detect it?

What is dark energy? How will detect?

What are impact of dark matter and dark energy on universe?

What did you read?

Did you read autobiography of Nehru?

Some questions related to astronomy

M2(woman):

Tell me different radio source in universe? And some related questions

Are u satisfied with current form of nationalism?

Is it jingoism?

As a student of history how will you see current phase after 50 years?(phase of transition)

Tell me particular nomenclature for that?

What is your opinion about current trend of rewriting of history?

What do you learn from crowd management experiences?

How will you apply that knowledge in the administration?

(She was excited to know more but Nagarajan mam stopped her)

M3:I will ask you only 2 questions

1) How will tackle situation in Kashmir(Suppose you are countering terrorists attack in Kashmir and suddenly people come on road and pelting stone towards you.Then what will be your action plan?)

2) Pakistan is impeccable enemy of India. It survives only for hurting India.Then what will be 'permanent solution' for Pakistan ?

M4:

People are not learning from history.You can see from recent moral degredation.what is your opinion?

Yes people learn but they forget after sometime like we forget about values of our freedom fighter.What should we do to reverse this?( I was telling him about reforms in education system and...He said I got your point)

Tell me about economy of Jalgaon?

Tell me about different crops from your area,industrial development?(percentage).

And some more questions.

CP: You will be aware about telecom sector.People are getting the cheap internet facility but government is loosing revenue.What is your stake on it?

Now suppose you are in telecom ministry , even then your stand will be same?(may be different because I will get insight on full spectrum of crisis and professional knowledge about it after training, experience)

She said yes yes

Thank you your interview is over.

Experience:Panel was very cordial.Mam was looking/observing like innocent child and very receptive.Interview was on hatake track.I think I was able to tackle almost all the questions.

Interview Transcript- Gubi

18/04/2018

Board: B S Bassi

Optional- Geography

Hobby- Astronomy,Go game

Chairman-

1. Astronomy. What is it that you do?

2. What is Big bang?

3. What is Hubble telescope

4. What Hubble had to do with big bang?

5. What is black hole?

6. Universe is expanding, hone do , koi kuch ho raha hai, kya karna hai, Astronomy Kyon

M1: Lady member-

1. Pro and cons of simultaneous election(fumbled here)

2. Why issues would be mixed up of center and states if simultaneous election

M2: Gentleman

1. Rifle Shooting,swimming- hmm. You have done such good things in sports, why not continue ?

2. Are you planning to continue?

3. Ok, tell me issues related to mining in our country?

4. Rohingya issue- Should we forcefully send them back?

5. Suppose all others measures have failed , now tell me what should we do? (I said nothing is impossible in diplomacy)

6. No, suppose Myanmar say they don’t want them back , should we send them back(I said temp camp with registration certificate as a temporary measure)

M3:Gentleman

1. Go game- what is this

2. Recently PM went to Sweden, what is it that can have from this relationship

3. One or two question , fact based question – don’t remember

4. What does CDOT company do?(worked in CDOT)

5. What is GIGO in computer systems

M4:Gentleman

1. What are your service preference

2. Suppose you are in Naxal area, you are commanding officer and thre can be mines under your road , what will you do?

3. And can also be surrounded by Naxals , what would you do?

4. What are the things that we can do to handle our maritime challenges?

Chairman again-

1. Indus system

2. Where does it start and direction of its flow

Your interview is over , you can go now.

Dr. Manoj Soni Sir Board

Optional- Sociology

19th April Forenoon (First to go)

Ch:

Read details of DAF

So Mahesh your are from Sinnar...

Is it a city ? Population ? Distance from Nashik ?

Nasik has been famous for many reasons...

So lets take foreign policy of india. Is that okay with you ?

Orientation of foreign policy since last 4 yrs.? Determinants ?

Areas affected inside country and outside ? In education sector ?

Ok

M1:

So you work in HAL ? Which section ? Natute of work ?

Tell me about fatigue test of undercarriage. What is total life of aircraft ? Of Su30mki ? How it is decided ? Why 25 yrs only? And not 24 or 26 yrs exactly ?

Recently many countrys have enquired about buying LCA Tejas..but HAL is not eager to sell them ..why ?

Dasault denied transfer of technology to HAL. Why ? So you accept that there are issues that needs to be tackled in Hal's quality output ?

M2: (Lady)

Lets talk about Maharashtra.

What is contribution of MH in India ? Historically ?

Maharashtra's geography ? Diversity ...

Maharashtra's coastline ? Contribustion of coastline to other parts of MH and India.

M3:

What kind of exprience do you have in teaching ? What is this Teacher's Day ? Why ?

Status of primary education sector ? Are we succesful in achieving quality education in primary ? But still we see in many schools one teacher is teaching whole school... How to solve this ?

What is this quality inspector ? (Job) . What is the class of post ? Class one or two ? (I said no sir its class 3 equivalent). So you are there on Diploma basis ? Then why did you join HAL on diploma basis since you have completed your engg ? (,,I clarified that I joined it then I was undergraduate..later I completed engg).

Then what was your purpose to join HAL ? Has it served your purpose now ? What if HAL promotes you And transfers you to other state ?

M4 :

Do you live in HAL township ? Why not ?

What is SBM ? Launch date ? Status in your town Sinnar ? What is this odf, odf+, and odf++ ?

Measures taken by Sinnar Administration ?

Pangarkar time is running out...so inshort...1 is for Best and 4 is Worst...How will you rate your town's SBM success ?

Ch:

Thank you ..(Then suddenly got something clicked...)

Mahesh what is your plan after interview , Medical exam ? Are you going to stay in Delhi for 2-3 days ? (I said No sir ...I have no plan to stay...leaving immediately after medical ecam.)

So you will resume your job immediately ?

..(I said yes sir.. It's Duty's Call)..

Thank you.

20th April 2018

Chairman : Smita Nagaraj

Afternoon session

Optional : Geography

Mechanical Engineering

Home state : Delhi

Chairman :

1. Tell me about yourself ?

2. Criteria to identify the urban area in Delhi

3. What shall govt do with the land acquired and not used for that purpose for long period of time. Shall it be returned to farmers ?

M1

1. role of executive and legislature in signing the Treaty?

2. role of state in signing the treaty ?

3. role of state in implementing the treaty ?

M2

1. questions on basketball. and Shot put. Did you play basketball in US or India.

2. How far have you thrown.

3. Indo- US issues on IPR laws? - compulsory licensing, Generic medicines, Patent infringement etc.

4. change in Indo-US relations after transition from President Obama to President Donal Trump. (Area of convergence in defence, LEMOA, etc as well as area of divergence in Trade, protectionism ).

M3

1. sustainable development

2. water policy

3. how to ensure treatment of water

4. 3R - reduce, reuse, recycle policy

5. water treatment capacity in India ? only 40%

6. National action plan on Climate change - solar, Himalayan ecosystem, western ghats, etc

7. shortage of water resources

8. DBT - Direct Benefit transfer

9. Has it benefitted the government ?

10. If you are made district Magistrate than how would you ensure success of DBT with emphasis on food security policy

11. what shall be criteria to identify the beneficiaries.

12. Socio-economic caste Census - How successful is it in removing the middlemen.

M4

1. Indo- US Civil Nuclear deal

2. What India sacrificed in the deal (didn’t know that)

3. why we signed civil nuclear deal. - access to nuclear technology, raw material i.e. uranium supply for our reactors, energy security. etc.

4. history of the deal - Pokhran Nuclear test, Nuclear sanctions, etc.

5. Who is David Coleman Headley

6. LeT

Chairman

1. Difference between education system in India and US

2. Asked about my stay in US. (BE from USA)

3. What is more important : teaching pedagogy or resources for success

4. who is culprit the institutions or students for the poor performance of engineering graduation outcomes in India.

Ok you can go. Thank you.

observations

1. No questions on optional, Mech Engg, Hobby

2. Board was very cordial especially the Chairman

20th April 2018

Chairman : Smita Nagaraj

Afternoon session

Optional : Geography

Mechanical Engineering

Home state : Delhi

Chairman :

1. Tell me about yourself ?

2. Criteria to identify the urban area in Delhi

3. What shall govt do with the land acquired and not used for that purpose for long period of time. Shall it be returned to farmers ?

M1

1. role of executive and legislature in signing the Treaty?

2. role of state in signing the treaty ?

3. role of state in implementing the treaty ?

M2

1. questions on basketball. and Shot put. Did you play basketball in US or India.

2. How far have you thrown.

3. Indo- US issues on IPR laws? - compulsory licensing, Generic medicines, Patent infringement etc.

4. change in Indo-US relations after transition from President Obama to President Donal Trump. (Area of convergence in defence, LEMOA, etc as well as area of divergence in Trade, protectionism ).

M3

1. sustainable development

2. water policy

3. how to ensure treatment of water

4. 3R - reduce, reuse, recycle policy

5. water treatment capacity in India ? only 40%

6. National action plan on Climate change - solar, Himalayan ecosystem, western ghats, etc

7. shortage of water resources

8. DBT - Direct Benefit transfer

9. Has it benefitted the government ?

10. If you are made district Magistrate than how would you ensure success of DBT with emphasis on food security policy

11. what shall be criteria to identify the beneficiaries.

12. Socio-economic caste Census - How successful is it in removing the middlemen.

M4

1. Indo- US Civil Nuclear deal

2. What India sacrificed in the deal (didn’t know that)

3. why we signed civil nuclear deal. - access to nuclear technology, raw material i.e. uranium supply for our reactors, energy security. etc.

4. history of the deal - Pokhran Nuclear test, Nuclear sanctions, etc.

5. Who is David Coleman Headley

6. LeT

Chairman

1. Difference between education system in India and US

2. Asked about my stay in US. (BE from USA)

3. What is more important : teaching pedagogy or resources for success

4. who is culprit the institutions or students for the poor performance of engineering graduation outcomes in India.

Ok you can go. Thank you.

observations

1. No questions on optional, Mech Engg, Hobby

2. Board was very cordial especially the Chairman