Interviews

UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 21 Apr 2022 (Sociology)

21 Apr 2022

Name-

Date and session of interview- 21/04/2022, Afternoon, 1st to go

Board- Smita Nagaraj ma'am

Optional- Sociology

College-

Profession (if any)- Software Development

Hobbies- Football, Poetry

Your experience in interview- Overall good

Utility of mocks (if any)- 5 mocks, all okay, good advice from all

Chairperson

1. You left a good job. Do you think it was a risk?

2. Did your near and dear ones not stop you from taking such a risk?

3. 'Union and States' --> Why do we even need a union? Which is more important union or the states? --> Counter questions --> E.g. USSR broke and all parts survived... isn't it good if the states separate? (+ other interconnected questions)

4. What are some issues raised by states which are relevant according to you? (in the context of federalism)

5. What do you see as the future of center-state relations in the next two decades? Will there be more centralization? Is it good?

Member 1

1. Tell me something unique about your university.

2. You are associated with the Prime Minister's constituency. The people there have an extra chip on their shoulders. What are your views on that? Do you think it is good? What has the PM done in that constituency vis-a-vis developments?

3. Do you think we should stop IAS recruitment and only promote from the provincial services? --> counter questions --> E.g. there are articles like 'The IAS has failed the nation' Don't you think so?

4. Civil Services Day --> when Shri Vallabhbhai Patel addressed the IAS officers --> not when he addressed the IPS, IFS officers --> What are your views on this?

5. Context: Safeguards to our democracy --> Rank the four in terms of importance --> Opposition, Media, Judiciary, Civil Society

Member 2

1. Question and then counter questions on our federal structure E.g. Issues like CBI, Concurrent List

2.Have you read today's newspaper?

3. Heat waves are in news. Will they affect the hills? And how?

4. Have you watched the movie 'Kesari'?

5. Which is the most recent movie you have watched? --> What is it about? What was the best scene according to you?

6. Who won the last football world cup?

Member 3

1. You are from this college.. what was it called earlier?

2. Questions about number of IITs, whether there is dilution in quality due to increasing number, where will we get the professors?, data related to vacancies in IITs

3. Has Banaras lost its feel due to recent developments?

4. Should the GST compensation period be extended? --> explicitly asked for my view and explanation

Member 4

1. Question and counter-questions about student politics in universities, affiliations with political parties etc

2. We talk about secularism but we have universities with names of religious communities --> What is the history? Current situation?

3. What was the biggest shock when you shifted from engineering to Sociology?