Interviews

UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 11 Apr 2018 (2)

11 Apr 2018

SHAIKH SALMAN

Urdu optional

Chemistry & comp. science

Teaching poor students.

Date: 11/04/2018

Board: 👩🏻‍⚖Smita Nagraj Madam

☝🏻st one to go

Time :30 to 35 min (might be)

Bahar bohat acha mausam tha mai duaa kr rha tha ki Board me bhi aisa hi ho😜.

Jab document check karte hue bataya gaya k aapka pehla No. h to dil ki dhadkane tez or Tezzzz ho gyi😇.

Jab ek sahab aae or bola k chalo aapka no.h phr mujhe SN mam k office k bahr baitha diya.

(aise lag rha tha vision Hindu express survey ....sab bhool gya) Then i started asking qn to myself h r u? intro.etc.

then bell🛎 baji or maine apne aap se kaha CChalo bulaawa aa gya h.

Me:may i come in mam?

Yes please

Good morning Mam

Good Morning Sir's

(forget to greet one another lady member)

hv a seat. Thank u.

👩🏻‍⚖CHAIRMAN.

ham Hindi English mila k baat karte h (is se acha or ho hi kya sakta h)

1) So salman tell me about problem faced by Farmer in Aurangabad and Maharashtra.(bcz my background is Agriculture)

2) Do u think k debt bhi problem h?

3)Apke gaao me money lender h? wo paise wapas kaise lete h(recovery)?

4) GM crop introduce karna chahiye ya nhi??(phr thoda sa BT cotton or GM Mustard ke bare me bataya)?

👨🏻‍✈Member 1

1) Procedure for introduction of GM crop.

(GEAC and MoEF🤨)

2)Ppr konsa padha aap ne(IE)

3)Recently Happiness department konsi state ne banaya h?(MP and AP)

4)aapke hisaab se kya criteria hona chahiye?

(edu.poverty.personal satisfaction. philanthropy differ from individual to ind)

5) are u happy person? (yes) why??(thoda personal answr h😊)

6) Indias Rank in Happiness index?(133)

7) why India perform lower than Bangladesh and Pakistan.(soci. development + less population)

8) Achaa to china ki popln ham se zyada h? to uska bhi zyada hona chahiye tha par aisa nhi h?😳(govt hv taken many steps to improve it)

👩🏻‍🎤Member 2

( bohat khadus lag rhe the ye madam🙏🏻)

1) what is sustainable development goals?(UNDP-17 2030)

which is 1st

(No poverty ya zero hunger)(asked for guess)

2) what is status of poverty in india?

(Tend.21% World Bank 40%)

3) difference between Tendulkar comty and world bank poverty paramaters.

4) what is 3rd goal?

(i think its Health orEducation)

5)is there any goal related to energy?

6) steps taken by govt for energy security?

Me 1 Diversifying import basket

2 Nuclear plant

3 Int Solar All. 175GW RE. INDC.

7)Nuclear energy ka contribution kitna h?

can i guess ..yes aprox 3%

(lekin sawaal asaan puche😄)

👨🏻Member 3

Kahani sunai then

1)Nuclear energy produce karna safe hai kya?(if ensure safety)

2) Nuclear ko compare kro renewable or non conventional.

3)What r constraints with renewable?

(Location land transport availability)

4) suppose agar in ko overcome kr liya gaya to?(R&D ke baad) aap isko support karoge ya nhi??

(yes sir agr aisa hota h to Sustainable development and bla bla)

5) aap poetry likhte ho? Yes. kya likhte ho.kyu?

Sher: Tum mere pass hote ho goya

jab koii dusra nhi hota (momin)

jab bhi dil me koii aisa idea buble create karta h to mai usko likh leta hu.

6) kis topic pe likhte ho social ya ishq o aashiqui.(ye huii na baat)

me: sir suno recent wala😜(aise nhi bola)

Usulo par luta di h zindagi apni

ek bhi nhi hamara ye bhi magar pata tha.

7) aaj kal achi gazals likhi ja rhi h kya??

No sir bohat achi G likhi ja rhi h Basheer badr, Nidaf azli, Waseem Barelwi ne kaafi acchi shayeri lekhi h. contemporary societal issue, pr.

8) filmo aaj kal Ghazals kyu nhi dekhne ko milti?

Change of test (then sir said k ghazle thodi serious bhi hoti h na isliye bhi) Thank u sir.

9)Fvrt Ghazal??

Me:

Hazaro khwahishe aisi ki har kwahish pe dam nikle .

bohat nikle mere armaan lekin phr bhi kam nikle.

(bohat qns pooch liye sir aap ne pls bas bhi kijiye) lekin achhe puche.

👨🏻‍✈Member 4

1) what is DoNER?(N.east)

Functions??

who head it?

(sorry sir i m not aware of it)

2) NE me kitni states h?(7+Sikkim)

why plus sikkim

3)Sikkim ka strategic significance kya h?(international borders with Nepal China and Bhutan)

4) wht is chicken neck corridor?

aap gye ho kabhi?No.

tha ek Gao h naam bata sakte ho? No. lekin sir kya

aap darjiling ki baat kr rhe h?

No it is sillliguri islye isko sillliguri corridor kehte h

(Thank u sir)

5) wht is dokhlam? issue kya h? india ka kya concern h.

Bhutan ki Territory h. Chinese PLA & Indian Army. Indo Bhutan Friendship treaty. Chicken necks corridor only way(land) to NE.(phr sir ne thoda gyaaan diya Thank u sir) (He is my friend in board😜😜)

👩🏻‍⚖Ch. is Back

salman socho ke aap ek department ke head h waha apke 1 subordinate h jo bohat efficient h lekin corrupt h or dusre 2-3 log bade honest h lekin inefficient h.🧐kis ko chunoge aap.

Me 2nd then unki skill training, counselling se efficiency ko badhaya ja sakta h.

Ch.lekin aapko aaj hi kaam karna h to tum iske corruption pr bhi to rok laga sakte ho.

me : Use of Tech. Audit mech of department and proper accountability mechanism ka istemaal krke isko bhi pura kiya ja sakta h.

Ok salman your interview is over Thank you.

Thank you mam .

Ab kya bahar aane ke baad naachne ko man kar rha the lekin bahr peon khade huee the. un sab se haath milaya then Back to pavilion.

🧐Observation:

Board was very cordial. Helping me some time. No zyada grilling. overall one of the best experience of my life and i enjoyed it. Bas Marks mil jaye to maza aajaye.

Thank You for Reading💐. Take Care.

🙋🏻‍♂

Chetan Ahir:

Ladumor chetan:

Ladumor chetan:

Ladumor chetan:

B.pharm

11 April

Afternoon

Second last to go

Dr Manoj soni board

Medium of interview:- Hindi

chairman:-You know any thing about GNFC?( gujarat narmada valley fertizer company limited)

Ans :- don't know

CH:- you resigned the job or dismissed?(I worked 15 month as junior pharma at PHC & resigned)

Ans:- resigned

Ch:- why?

(Sudden Electricity gone for 30-40 second...total darkness in room...even i cant see face of my nearby member & vice versa...but I & chairman continued .....mood mar gaya tha...isme ye huva...)

Ans:- to prepare fully for civil service

Ch:- do u believe gujarat developed more in last decade?

Ans:-yes

Ch:- any bad consequence of development in gujarat?

Ans:- no

Ch:-what are bad effects of development?

Ans:- environment, inequality

Ch:-& in gujarat?

Ans:- not more bad effect

Ch:- what is the main aim of writing literature ?

Ans:- NIJANAND & social impact

Ch:- name one writer who is not writing for nijanand

Ans:- munshi

Ch:- confirm?

Ans:-yes

Ch:- Narmad s aim?

Ans:- nijanand & gujarati language development

Ch:- & about reform?( sudharo)

Ans:- yes sir

Ch:- was Gandhi Ji writer?

Ans:- yes sir

Ch:- aim?( nijanand or social?)

Ans: social ( samaj ko Sahitya se satya ka sandesh dena )

Ch:-have you read any literature book which is not in your syllabus?

Ans:- no

Ch:- I think u r not much interested in gujarati literature except your upsc syllabus

Ans:- yes sir...sirf upsc k liye hi liya he..kafi interest nahi he

Ch:-ohhhhhh.....

M1

Q:- what is use of pharmacy in administration ?

Ans:- diagnose, treat , cure methodology can be used in administrative issues too.

Q:- your interest in?

Ans:- eating( my hobby written in daf is DIARY WRITING)-( all laughed)

Q:- you cook?

Ans:- no

Q:- kis kis state Ki items khai?

Ans:- gujarat se pehli baar hi bahar nikala hu...muje gujarati Khane ka shokh he..

Q:-name some items

Ans:- gathiya, fafada, jalebi, dhokala, khaman, khandavi( chairman interpted...bus karo aab mere muh me Pani Aa jayega)

M2

Q:- what is statin/atorvastatin( name of drug)

Ans:- no idea

Q:::- what is global warming?

Ans:- answered

Q:-what are its effects

Ans:- answered

Q:- what is green house gas?

Ans:- answered

M3

Q:- function of navy?( first elaborated some thing & then question )

Ans:- answers basic....but not satisfactory

Q:- navy's role in anti piracy

Ans:- not answered

Q:- mission sent to moon, march, sun worthy???some critique said waste of money

Ans:- me sahmat nahi..stifan hawking ne kaha he hame 200-300 salo me pruthvi chhodani padegi...& many more...

Q:- what is aim of science?

Ans;- manav Samaj ka bhala karana

M4

Q:-Explain the chain of drug supply from PHC to upper level

Ans:- answered...some bluff...kyuki quetion was not formated well...

Chairman

( gujarat development k bad effect par vapis aye)

Q:- any other effect of development in gujarat....like....kisiko matru bhumi chhodani pade, apani sanskruti ko tyagna pade, rehabilitate karana pade....aisa bharat ya Gujarat me hua?

Ans:- yes..sardar sarovar & all

Q:- gujarat SARKAR ne solution kiya?

Ans;0:- yes...achhi tarah se kiya...explained...

Q: do u know detail of this sheme?

Ans:- no....

Thank u your interview is over...

Note:- some questions discussed more...but not elaborated here....like..antipiracy, gujarat development bad effect, sardar sarovar dam,supply chain.....etc....

Approx time:- 40 minutes....

Some question may be misses

Vishvadeepsinh Gohil:

Vishvadeepsinh Gohil

B.Tech CE, Gujarati literature.

Forenoon, 11th April 2018.

Dr. Manoj Soni Board

First one to go...

Ch

1. Shreemaan, aap kaunsi bhasha me interview dena pasand karenge?

2. Gujarat is a Coastal state how long its coastline is?

3. What are the three benefits and three disadvantages of being a coastal state?

4. Explain coastal led development (as I said it is an advantage)

5. What is literature?

6. Can I consider newspaper as literature?

7. Why do we need to study literature? how it helps in understanding the society?

M1

1. Should we promote MSMEs or Large Industries?

2. What is the difference between our SMEs and German SMEs

3. What we can learn from them?

4. Give classification of our SMEs

5. Why we are lagging in skill sector?

6. What Govt is doing for the Skill Sector?

7. What are the Targets?

8. Has it been lowered recently? Why?

9. What are the problems??

M2 lady member

1. Have you heard of san jose?

2. Why silicon valley established there?

3. Where in India we have our Silicon valley? Reasons?

4. Why Civil Services now?

5. How long IAS will serve as DM and in the field?

6. What are the other prospects of diversity of the job?

7. Is the supremacy of IAS in the bureaucracy is the reason?

8. You watch TV series where do you watch?

M3

1. Tell me one thing why defence manufacturing is important as a part of make in india?? 5 points only no explanation..

2. What is our defence budget as a % of GDP?

3. What do you think it should be?

4. Where do we stand in terms of spending on defence budget?

5. Tell me what is green budget and some innovative ways you would like to promote as an administrator?

6. Why there is fog in delhi? Reasons

7. What should be done?

M4

1. Do you know where is salt desalination plant is located in gujarat?

2. How to promote ICT in the Education?

3. Do you know about the fully ICT enabled university in India?

4. What was you graduation Project?

5. Where did you go for internship was it a big company?

6. Why our students are not Innovative?

7. What are the effects of global warming?

8. What were you doing since 2014?

Ch

1. Congratulations on your selection as Asst.Commissioner Now tell me you have given all the 24 service preference, would you reconsider it?

2. If you are selected in ICLS will you join it?

Thank you your Interview is over.

Interview transcript CSE2017

Date: April 2, 2018 Forenoon

Board Chair: Arvind Saxena Sir

Bio/Background details related to questions asked in interview: Female; Andhra Pradesh; IIT, BTech, Bio-engg; IIM, PGDM, General Mgmt; Optional subject English Literature; Worked for a few months in the private sector

Chairperson:

1. Why did you leave your job after working for 6 months? Did you not like it?

2. What were your roles and responsibities at this company? Please elaborate.

3. Which drugs were you responsible for managing as a product manager?

4. What brand names are these generic drugs sold under in the market, if they entered the market yet?

5. There was talk about biotech revolution in 2013 and beyond. I don't see anything like a revolution ever happened in 2013. All i see is a number of new innovations which have not taken off..like stem cell therapy, cord blood banks. What's your take on it?

6. Is it worth investing so much now on such new technologies when they are yet to be proven to be useful and widely applicable?

7. Do you follow journals of bioengineering or biotechnology to gain conviction in the future of bio-innovations?

8. What kind of news articles attract your attention in a newspaper?

9. What about neighborhood relations of India..does that not interest you too?

10. Tell me what you make of India's stand on Maldives crisis.

11. Do you think India's status was diminished in any way by being told off by a small island country like Maldives? Should India have exerted its stature instead of just standing by?

12. What is the threat perceived by India that influenced its stand?

13. So, how would India's stand on Maldives crisis be looked upon in the long-run?

Member 1 (The only lady on the panel):

1. What are the major reasons behind farmer distress in India?

2. What could be done to address it at the ground level?

3. Is farm loan waiver a viable solution in the long-run? Why do you think so?

4. What could be done to help famers psychologically?

Member 2:

1. You did B.Tech. from such a good college. And scored well too. Then you scored such a low percentage in PGDM. Is it average or low?

2. What was your exact CGPA in PGDM? So, why couldn't you manage a good score?

3. Let's talk about the utility of bioengineering..why do we pursue it if there are so many bioethics concerns?

4. If you were the DM of a district, and you had limited funds at your disposal..who would you give it to, if you have to choose just one..a 14 year old boy with leg injury or a 60 year old woman with breast cancer? Why?

5. Who would you give the funds to.. if the 14 year old boy has paralysis of the leg, and has a long life ahead, and 60 year old woman with breast cancer would only survive till 70 if she survives cancer? Why?

6. What are the bioethical concerns involved in the decision-making in these cases?

7. Have you seen the film 'The Island' that is on television quite frequently?

8. If the clone technology used in the film were a reality in today's world, would you support it or not? Why?

9. If I were a rich man, who could afford the technology for saving my life, just as shown in The Island film, and if you had the authority to allow it or disallow it, forgetting about broad consensus in law and society, what would you as an individual do..allow me to use it or not? Why?

10. Why so many jumps from B.Tech at IIT to PGDM at IIM to working in the private sector to studying literature? Explain to us.

11. Why English literature..what inspired you?

12. Are you familiar with the works of Vishal Bharadwaj, an Indian film director?

13. Name his adaptations of Shakespeare's plays.

14. How is the theme of Julius Caesar related to what's happening in the world today?

15. Which period in history would you adapt this theme of Julius Caesar in a film based in Indian settings?

16. Why this period..explain the similarities with the play.

Member 3:

1. What is 'women empowerment' according to you?

2. Is a matrilineal society an empowered society? Why?

3. In Meghalaya, there is matrilineal system

and there i

s evidently peace and prosperity in the state..should other states then adopt matrilineal system of property rights and other features of that system?

4. What is your opinion on women leaving their homes, their life behind to go to the husband's home after marriage, instead of men like it happens in Meghalaya?

5. What's the reason behind the clash between the police and IITBHU female students in recent news?

6. Are the laws in our country enough to empower women in India?

7. What needs to be done at the level of laws..should existing laws be improved or new laws be made?

8. What more should be done besides addressing legal systems?

9. At the ground level, what measures should be taken to change mindset to improve the status of women, especially at homes?

Member 4:

1. It is the season of child marriages in the country. Do you know the marriageable age in India?

2. What is the name of the related Act?

3. As a DM, what steps would you take you reduce child marriages in your district?

4. If you were the Head of the Marketing Department of a private company, what components would your marketing strategy comprise?

5. How would you decide pricing of a product in your strategy? Low or high..how?

6. What happens to pricing in a perfect competition scenario?

7. What factors of your marketing strategy you will change in such a scenario?

8. Give some ways in which you can increase sales without changing price?

9. What do you think is the most important feature of Patanjali company's marketing strategy that made it so successful?

10. Explain why the communication strategy of Patanjali company contributed to its success.

Chairperson: Your interview is over. You may leave now. Thank you.

...

afternoon session

Pk joshi board

chairman :

1. where is BPDAV ( my school )

2. what were you doing since your graduation

3. what is the difference between anthropology and sociology

4. name few pvtg tribes

5. what are govt policies for pvtgs

6. in a village children are more interested in grazing their cattle or playing . how will you bring them to school ?

members :

1. recently a famous professor by name Noam chomsky opined that computers will deter innovation . what is your opinion on this ?

2. what measures do you take promote innovation and creativity ?

3. what measures will you take to strengthen phc's

4. what is historical particularism

5. what is neo evolutionism

6. what are the reasons for increased farmer suicides in telangana

7. how do you compare 2 schools and 2 hospitals

8. tell me about your research topic alternatives to chemotherapy

9. what is gene therapy

10. what is domestic violence

11. As an SP what measures will you take to curb domestic violence

12. what measures would you take for women health

13. what are mandalas ?

14. do you know the significance of mandala paintings among tibetan monks

15. what type of mandala paintings you do

16. if you reach to secretory level what will you do to include traditional medicines in indian pharmacopoeia

17. how will you make our traditional medicine famous globally

18. what measures will you take to increase funding in R&D by pharmaceutical companies

thank you your interview is over

Ajit bhonsle sir board

1..india me intolerance bad rhi hain kya ??your take?...kya tolerance keval ak kitabi sidhant h?

2..universities ka nation buiding aur civilization me yogdan??

3....hindu succession act and women right?

5...5 important law about women in last century???

6...munro doctrine??

7....smart city mission?and progress?

8..beti bachao beti padao progresss?

9.....agrarian distress kam karne ke upay???

10..agriculture se other sectior me labour kese transfer kare???

Badime krishna

Geography

P k Joshi sir

Chairman:- read my daf loudly

1- what do u know about latur earthquake

2- what you do in river conservation? (daf)

3- how u undertook watershed activites?

M1:

1- issue of solid waste management 2- issue of plastic waste

3- communal violence what will u do as SP?

M2:

1- carbon sink,footprint,sink,credit,neutrality (daf)

2- about pollution through textile industry (graduation)

3- marathi saint poets(hobby)

4-literature diff of saint chokhamela and dyaneshwar ( didn't know)

5- findings of my paper presented (daf)

M3:

1- three imp international events happened recently

2- PMGSY

3- violence against women legal provisions to tackle it

4- sexual harassment in college ( as general secretary)

M4:

1- transport sector emissions? What should be done?

2- urban transport way forward

3- asked two geographers who worked on location? Their difference.

4- market center theory and impact of transport ( optional)

Overall good experience.

Thank you Mahesh Bhagwat sir and all other mentors.

For others All the best.

Arvind Saxena Board

09 April 2018

Engineering ECE, IT industry experience, IRS(C&CE), Trekking/ Backpacking, T. N.

C: You are Mr. (my name). Please take your seat.

C: (going through my DAF and reading aloud my degree, work experience, service experience)

Me: (responding affirmative 'yes, sir’ to all that was read by C)

C: You are already an IRS officer. Which year did you give the exams then. (still going through my DAF).

C: ..and now it is 2017 Exams. Aren't you going to miss your seniority. (Before I could respond he continued) I understand that you will have pay protection. But how about losing seniority. In another three to four years you may get deputed to central govt (of coz, I am already working for central govt, but C continued) and you become part with IAS officers’.

C: Anyway, you must have prepared an answer for it. Why do you want to switch service?

C: But you would lose your seniority.

C. Aren't you serving the people, now.

C: Which category of the people do you want to serve?

C: I mean rich or the poor. Whom do you want to serve.

C: Oh.. serve the nation.

C: You would have gone through the Newspaper. Which news attracts you the most. Say for the past 5 days.

C: Then you must be aware of Nepal PM visit. How do you see about India's stand on including Madheshi demand in Constitution of Nepal? Do you support it?

C: What's the difference between interference and intervention? (From my prev answer he derived these terms)

C: How do you see Maldives reaction to India's aid etc. Recently they returned the helicopter, denied to participate in joint exercise, opening up base for China etc.

C: Doesn't it affect India's presence in the geopolitics?

M1: You said you want to experience the district admin. If you are an SDM of a subdivision, what will be your priorities?

M1: Given a choice whether you are ready to prefer foreign service apart from Administrative service.

M1: Sino-Russian military relationship and its impact on India. How do you see it?

M1: How China is a threat to India's economic goals.

M1: what's the difference between anti-dumping and safeguard duties.

M1: (some situational questions on SDM)

M2: How do you empower the present day youth and help in their development if you are a SDM.

M2: Consider the city of Chennai. What are the avenues open for youth to actively engage for growth and development?

M2: what are the steps you recommend for improving the education system?

M3: If you are an SDM, how you would have responded to the Marina incident and Theni incident? (TN related) continued by nested questions in it.

M3: How you can use data analytics in the field of administration.

M3: Can mobile be used much more effectively for the people in a district than how it is used now. If so tell me how.

M4: How can you develop the students for active involvement in sports?

M4: Globalisation and Anti globalisation. How do you see the present day scenario of anti globalisation. Your views on it.

M4: How do you want India to be a strategic power? What should take priority in international relations.. interference into other nations affairs or by considering personal (national) interests?

M4: So you don't consider USAs way of involving in others territories?

M4: USA way or India’s present condition.

M4: How do you see Brexit?

M4: You wish to serve the nation. You could have done it through armed forces. Why not armed forces but civil services?

M4: Is there any financial implications in preparing for Armed forces?

C: Interview is over. You may leave now.

Transcript ...Ganesh kumar meena

13/04/18

Manoj soni sir

Optional ...History

Posted as ...Divisional accounts officer in cag

Total time ...30 to 33 minutes

First member to go

Chairman sir...

1...aapke job me kya duties h

2...Aisa koi incident jisme aapne govt ka paisa bachaya ho ....3 to 5 minutes on this topic

3...Aapke is incident me back door se samjhota ki koshish nhi ki gyi ...

4...70 lkh ka case jo apane btaya usme jimmedari kiski ty ki jaye...{6to 7 minutes on this issue }

M2

1...Pakistan and afganistan me india ka role

2....India ko afganistan me military deploy krni chahiye ya nhi

3...usa ki afganistan policy

4...Organisation me conditional question ...Three level ...

Kiski financial inregularties me role...3...4 counter questions ..

M3

Ganesh aapko ek gaon ko sadak se jodna h ...Aapke pas 10 gaon h kis gaon ko pehle jodoge..Indicators....

2...Forest land se related act

3...Campa ka purpose

4..Campa ke fund utilisation ke liye policy

5...naxalism ...Reason ....Area...solution Policy

5...aapko policy bnana h ...Kya banoge ..

6...Home ministry bhi ye hi kr rhi h. .

7...Long time and short time measures

M4....

1..Railway ka purpose...India me ...British period me. (Mam ...itna suddh hindi mt boliye main English ki hu )

2...Is railway model succes or not ..In british time

3... Imagine you are cag of india .....Ek project ko sanction krna h ...Financial consensus kitne level pr milegi

4...dpr bnti h to item rates kha se milti h ...

5..Dpr ke bad kya rates increase or decrease hoti h

6...Ek employee final settlement krta h bill ka ...Usne ek rupey ka payment nhi kiya ..Uski jimmedari ty kijiye.

7...fdr ...Sd...Performance guarantee kya hoti h ...

M5....

Rail tel

Cag coal scam

Cricket kb se khelte ho

Defence ministry ka 10...15 din pehle koi acha speech

Your interview is over ...Good wishes to u....Board was cordial and very polite ...