UPSC interview, Air Marshal Bhonsle board, 22 Mar 2018 (2)
22 Mar 2018
Background: Petroleum Engineering, ISM Dhanbad, Writing Poems as hobby
Interview date: 22nd March, AN, Bhonsale Sir board, lasted around 20 minutes
Ch: reads DAF and then says..you are a poet...we will listen to your poem in the end but for time being tell me what characteristics do you have to be a civil servant ( I had counted three.. integrity, honesty, empathy...when he stopped me there and asked me to write these on paper) and then asked me to give an example of all three from your life...Answered using events from my college NGOs (for empathy), current work experience (integrity) and semeseter assignments(honesty) ( this must have lasted for around 3-4 minutes overall and probably was the best part of interview as I was not able to satisfactorily answer many questions from the board members)
He switched to the lady member..
LM1:
1. Do you know Bob Dylan
2. He was given Nobel prize for literature, was it right to give him.
3. Should musicians be given Nobel prize
4. Migration issue in cities, how to handle, what long term planning (Questions were not very clear to me and what she was expecting; couldn't give very satsifactory answers)
M2:
1.Agrarian distress and loan waiver..a long discussion and then question..is it right?
2. But other states also doing that?
3. Maharashtra did it twice..what do you think..Doesn't it discourage honest farmers who are paying taxes? ( I don't think he was very satisfied with my answers, my line of answering was that loan waiver is an immediate respite and not a long term solution, and it would be administratively difficult to go for selective loan waiver only for few farmers, hence a general loan waiver is done once, but yes it should not be repeated too often)
M3:
1. Do you know about Superbug?
2. Mining impact on ecology
3. Alternative to Sand as construction material
some more factual qns
M4:
1. Who is science minister of India?
2. Why open cast mining is done more, what are the risks? Which law governs it? it comes under which ministry? (At one point of time, I had to say Sorry sir, I am not very much aware of the mining aspect as I did my graduation in petoleum engineering :(
3. DBT in fertilser; if it has to be done in rural areas,what are the challanges..
Chairman in the end:
1. maritime security of India..Think over this for 10 seonds and tell me 4-5 dimensions
2. Tell me your best poem?
(Have already recited this poem many times, so was able to recite easily..
pathik hu mai, dig-bhramit nahi,
Suksham awakash me Hu, Sthaayi viraam me nahi,
Ye Jo Chand lamhe Mai Roya, ise Mera ant na samajh,
Jaguga Mai, Uthuga mai, dauduga Mai aur cheer Kar ke ye kshinit tam, pahuchuga Mai us manzil Tak.
Kyuki pathik hu mai, dig-bhramit nahi, kshanik avakash me hu, sthayi viraam me nahi.)
The interview ended here..
Overall cordial borad, was able to answer chairman questions in good way, but not that satisfactorily of other members question.
Fingers crossed now.