UPSC interview, Manoj Soni board, 5 Apr 2018 (Gujarat)
5 Apr 2018
Riddhi Parmar M.tech electronics (specialization communication system)
Exp : Sr. Software engineer , Tahsildar
5th Apr
Board: Dr. Manoj Soni
CM: So you are engineer and opted for literature, how’s your feeling with it? : Answered
What it meteorological department doing? Why better prediction coming up? : Answered
Can you give me more specific and technical details regarding it? – Said I don’t know much.
Being engineer, ever you tried to find out about it? – answered
The Biggest crisis that Gujarat is facing right now? Answered (regarding water stress)
Why ? (with long question)
Follow up question about effect of water scarcity in Gujarat? – Answered
What is its impact on economy? – Answered
You are a collector of water scarce area and warning of draught has been issued that how will you tackle it? - Answered (focused on draught management along with economic activities sustenance )
M1 : What are issues with MNREGA ? – Answered
How can be tackled it? – Answered
What are statutory provisions with it. – Answered
What is petrochemical industry? (Many question regarding it. Gave answers for some and said I donot know just in hope to change the topic)
Historical importance of Gujarat ? Answered (stopped in between and changed question gave me only 3 mile stone events )
Do you heard about Somnath? – Answered
It was looted by? – Answered
Question regarding IPS profile. – Answered
M2 : I want to ask situation based question. Whether you wish to be collector or SP in itGave me number of options like revenue, general administarion , law and order etc and said to select. – I said for Law and order
Que: You are a collector , how you are going to handle riot? – Answer SOP
But SP is not cooperating you – Answered
Still not cooperating – answered
Yet he is stubborn - answered
Riddhi, he complaint against you and many other worst situation .. (It seems that he wanted me to quit saying you should also complaint against him . but I said sir, during such bad situation I would give priority to controlling riot, saving life and property and establishing peace, regarding personal issue or replying to such notice can be done later. )
Later few questions regarding police and petrochemical industry.
Few questions on GSAT, PSLV , Geo mapping , CSIR laboratory in Gujarat etc.
M3: What are new provision in interstate water dispute resolution ? - Answered
Any successful example where such dispute resolved? Answered
Why? Answered
Why can we do to solve such issue? Answered
What will you do if you are given chance to design policy? Answered
Industrial cluster of Gujarat? Answered
Regarding PM recent visit in some plant? - Don’t know (He gave hint and later I was able to give answer)
Questions on desalinations. – Answered all
M4: Your Hobby is weird ? (Pencil sketch n weird?) who inspired you? - Answered
Who is your inspiration , outside from your family? - Answered
Do you heard about POCSO? - Answered
I think women should not allowed in police services , what are you thinking about it? - Answered
So, being a women , how you are going to interrogate a child POCSO? – I said – I don’t know it.
Don’t you visited or seen such interrogation? - I said sir, I don’t and outsider is not allowed as per my knowledge.
What is difference between women police and man police in interrogation .. specially about rape victim ? - Again denied (Just want to end topic)
Follow up 1-2 question.
CM: Riddhi your interview is over. Wishing you very good luck .(2-3 line end note)
Overall , Majority of question related to Petro chemical industry (origine,issues , policies, new plant, row material etc.) and police services. Very little from DAF and some question comes as bonus (mainly factual). Questions come as bouncer. Manoj Soni sir is expressionless but very attentive and gave smiles too. One member has expression like in mood of fighting while one is changing expression if he don’t get expected answer so easy to predict counter question . One member was speaking very low volume and not at all audible. Last member was cool and happy all the time.
Vivek
History optional
10th April forenoon
Smita Nagraj board
1. Why we are preserving Native cattle breeds?
2. Why after push for exotic foreign breeds
3.unproductive cattle burden on farmer?
4. What to do?
(All daf-job related)
5. Question abt graduation
M1
1.diary writing hobby related.
2.sth about kabaddi ( daf)
3. Stubble burning and Delhi smog, how Haryana involved, what to do,
4. Untimely rain yesterday and impact on wheat crop
5. Water guzzling crops in Haryana, impact on gw, solution!!
M2 lady
1. Some scheme related to rural employment, didn't knew!!
2. Why Patanjali products are superhit, impact on other companies esp MNCs
Follow up questions,
baba Ramdev was the central theme ,
other 2-3 question don't remember!!
M3. 1.Last book you read!! Told a title
2. what you liked,2-3 pts told
3. Tell More. Added1-2
4.rti act and bureaucratic inertia, how to balance
2-3 follow up questions!!
M4
1. Should history be reviewed and rewritten periodically!!
Some grilling with counter arguments and follow up questions!!
2. Role of Nehru, was he Archit of modern India
3.was his economic policy a failure
4. Hindu rate of growth
C
1 what to do for agriculture
2 how to reach out to farmers
3 why policies not helping!!
Some solutions!!
Looking to members,
Ur interview is over!!
- overall cordial board, some questions stretched!