UPSC interview, Sujata Chaturvedi board, 21 Sep 2021 (Delhi)
21 Sep 2021
Date- 21.09.2021
Afternoon session (4th to go)
Sujata Mehta Ma'am Board
Areas in DAF- Energy and Meditation ( Rest none of the area from DAF was touched)
The door to the room was open. I asked for permission to enter.
As I went inside, Chairman ma'am asked to take seat. I wished everyone and took my place.
Chairman Ma'am
1. Introduce yourself by giving details about educational qualification and job experience (If any)
2. How was your experience at IIT Delhi?
3. Tell me something about the Energy Studies Course you did.
4. Should India commit to Net Zero emissions as propounded by western countries?
5. At one end India is focusing so much on renewable energy and on another we are commissioning new thermal fired power plants. Do you see it as dichotomy when it comes to our policy?
6. Nuclear energy forms as part of our energy mix but it's overall contribution is quite low. Why is it so?
7. Ok now tell me is it the right time to have a relook at the capital punishment in India. What are your views on it? (Out of the blue question)
8. But the concept of the "rarest of the rare" is nowhere defined. How do one decide it?
One or two follow up questions which I am unable to recall.
Member 1
1. What are ultra supercritical coal power plants?
2. What is the issue of storage capacity with regard to renewable energy sources?
3. What are lithium ion batteries?
4. What are shortcomings of lithium ion batteries?
5. What are other new technologies in this regard?
6. What are government initiatives for improving storage capacity in the country?
Had follow up questions also.
Member 2
Ok so much talk about energy, Can we talk about economy? Are you comfortable talking about that?
1. What is revenue neutral rate?
2. Does under the present GST regime, we have any such rate and how much is that?
3. Did state revenue fall after the implementation of GST?
4. What is GST Compensation and issues surrounding it?
5. Is the issue due to fall in revenue or the government overcommit?
6. Do you know about FTA?
7. Should India sign FTA?
8. How is it possible under FATs to at one end secure National Interest and also open up the economy?
9. How is it possible in the negotiations?
Member 3
1. Why don't you use your surname when today we see people with middle name along with surname?
2. Tell me about the poet you share your name with.
3.Was he French or English?
4. Ok you were talking about the energy scenario. Around world, we don't see so much of outrages and blackouts as much as we see in India. Are the government only focusing only quantity and not on quality? Is it government failure?
5. How do you ensure that consumers pay for the services they avail?
6. How do one hold the DISCOM companies accountable?
7. Ok now I would like to draw a parallel for quality of service between telecom sector and energy sector. As you know that the prices of telecom services were very high on the past decade but today the prices are quite competitive. But when it comes to the quality of call and also of the internet is not at the same level as in the western countries. Why is is so? What is your evaluation?
Had follow up questions also for the answers I gave.
Member 4
1. How did you start meditation?
2. What are the benefits of meditation?
3. What are the biological changes you observe when you meditate?
4. What is the current renewable energy mix of the country?
5. How you do evaluate it?
6. What should be the energy policy of the country in the next decade?
7. What role should the renewable energy play in it?
8. What are the challenges when it comes to renewable sources of energy such as solar and wind.
9. Ok so we don't use the renewable energy as soon as we produce it and as you said that we have challenges when it comes to storage systems. There is provision to use energy as much as one requires and rest is fed to the grid. What is this thing called technically?
10. How do you evaluate India's performance when it comes to net metering? How are we doing in this regard? What is the policy of government of India when it comes to the same?
Chairman Ma'am Again
1. Should India promote biofuels?
2. What is Jatropha?
3. It was in news in past few years, what was policy of government with regard to this plant?
4. Would you like to discuss something in particular with us or want us to ask questions from?
Thank you. Your interview is over.
S
TCA anant board
Key words: ITS, JNU, Delhi, debating, Bahrain
1. TCA Anant
⁃ You are in ITS, what have you learnt in the last few months?
⁃ Theoretical knowledge of trade vs actual practice?
⁃ What the the opportunities and losses in trade with Europe?
⁃ Significant non tariff barriers?
2. Member 2
⁃ compare Jnu to other universities
⁃ Main USP of JNU
⁃ Why crimes against women haven’t gone down?
⁃ What can we do individually?
⁃ Should activism be included in syllabus of schools?
⁃ Favourite Indian authors of fiction and why?
⁃ Boxfit what?
3. Member 3- lady member:
⁃ what are the ways in which conflict in Afghanistan can be understood?
⁃ How should we help afghan women?
⁃ Situation of afghan women?
⁃ Difference between the education systems of Delhi and all other places you have lives?
⁃ Can the difference be tackled through new education policy?
4. Member 4
⁃ Do you know about debates of Roman Empire?
⁃ Do you know about debates of ancient India?
⁃ What is dialectics
⁃ Is this dialectics?
⁃ Have you read argumentative indian? Enumerate the debates in that?
⁃ Why our exports haven’t been able to catch up with imports?
⁃ Why are they still a small part of our gdp?
5. Member 5
⁃ Bahrain as a Saudi vacation home?
⁃ Culture of Bahrain?
⁃ First service preference? (IFS)
⁃ Should india have state funding of election?
Air Marshal AS Bhonsle Sir
Forenoon - last candidate
B.E. Computer Science (BITS)
Chemistry Optional
Dumka, Jharkhand
Chairman
Was instructed to take off my face shield and mask, wipe my face with the tissue and get comfortable. Was told to place the face shield on the table and keep my mask on.
Read out my DAF aloud.
1. What is the difference between Science, Engineering and Technology?
2. If an institute is named Delhi Institute of Science, Engineering and Technology, what courses do you think it will offer?
3. If not civil services, what alternate career path would you choose?
M1
1. Why do we always say that the Chemistry between India and Pakistan is bad and never say that Physics is bad or Mathematics is bad?
2. What did you do in IIRS? (Internship)
3. What is the latest version of ArcGIS?
4. Do you think we can have a technology where living things can be converted into non living things and living things can be converted into non living?
5. If such technology were to develop, what implications would it have?
6. If you have to set up a chemical factory, what things will you consider?
7. Have you heard about the book The Hindu Chemistry?
8. But I want you to guess, what do you think it would be about?
M2
1. Why are we unable to solve the issue of Naxalism?
2. Who is an urban naxal?
3. What is Ultra Marathon? (Marathon was mentioned in DAF)
4. So now we have a new player in Afghanistan in the form of IS-K? How does it affect the present equation?
5. What was the CIA chief doing in Afghanistan?
6. What implication does the situation in Afghanistan have on the rest of the world?
M3
1. You had a good job, so why did you make such a switch to civil services?
2. What has recently happened in Dumka?
3. Why was Jharkhand formed? Have the objectives been achieved? Where does it lack? (+ a few follow ups based on my answers)
M4
1. When was Jharkhand formed?
2. Tell me something about Birsa Munda.
3. What social reforms did he do?
4. What is the full form of Jio?
5. What is wrong with Computer Science? Why do we see so many CS people appear for civil services?
Chairman
1. What will you do after going back? (followed by small chit chat over my answer)
Your interview is over. You may leave