Interviews

UPSC interview, Sujata Chaturvedi board, 21 Sep 2021 (2)

21 Sep 2021

S

Board-sujata mehta mam

Date of interview-21-09-forenoon(first candidate to be interviewed)

Hobbies-reading non fiction,mild excercise,tutoring,isha kriya

Optional-anthropology

Graduation-civil engineering

Entered and greeted members....mam said sit down...

Chairperson-introduce urself (it was a long intro...I thought of adding issues I want to contribute into as a civil servant-mam was listening passionately-apart from intro I said 4 issues in which I want to work-education,gender issues(lgbt,women) and tribals..

Mam said ok lets pick up efucation...

Q-what issues you see in education (talked of other than infra,funding,I majorly focussed on value based education and absense of society and parents in education curriculum...

Q-mam said how you will inculcate parents and society?

I said ptm meeting where parents can be awared about skill of their children,how issues they need to discuss how to discuss etc...in society I taljed of nukkad natak etc where behavioural change can be brought in...

Q-then she asked who will oversee all this-i answered in terns of collaboration of every stakeholder...then she countered wat will dm do here?

I answer in terms of dm being a umbrella entity who can oversee whether things are going in right direction....

Then chairperson asked member 1 to ask

M1-i will start with education sector only,issues he again asked and wat new education policy doing abt it?(I answered in term of funding,language as a barrier ,vocational eduvation then answered how nep is a ray of hope in this direction)

-wat this desigmation of school captain is...i answered that this is top most position given in my school...he said good...

He then said letzz now move to economy -tell me wat are the prospect of our ecinomy? (I answered aatmanirbhr bharat,then he stopped in between that I am not talking only post covid economy our economy was slow before that tell me major issues (I answered in terms of skill development,ease of business,jobbless growth) then he asked wat are labour intensive sector...I.answered in term of textile,footwear,msmes etc...then a bell rung from outside ,meanwhile chairperson was strucking a pencil for 2-3 times,signalling member 1 that ur time is over...

Member 2- discussion with education (not able to recall exactly wat he asked) then he abruptly moved to stubble burning...asking wat u can do as a policy maker (I answered something on lines that stubble can be a value material,there can be storage,and stubble can be mixed with soil)...then he counterd he was so inaudible that I was not able to get what exactly he was saying but somehow I understood gist of the question that was related to environment policy how will you design...that was a big question...in between a be rung...I was answering...he nodded and said think about this more ...I said yes sir...

Member 3 - praised me for my credentials first...marks nd all in school and colleges,then asked which book u have read -I talked 4 books -- out of 2 (siksha,and I am malala was on education)he said u r seriously very passionate about improving our education sector...

Then he asked why do mild excercise? Why not intense (I answered he nodded)...

Then he said lets come back to civil engineering...that was a long question where he quote lot of figures and stats and question was why too much road accident...I answered in technicalities (like potholes because of poor material,poor forecasting of traffic etc) then he countered by saying I agree ur point but stats show that 90% of road accident because of reckless driving....I said I was not aware of that stat but added I agree that sir and told h issue of reckless driving in my home district rewa....again be rung...

Member 4-

Tell me about malala (I answered)

Have you ever done intense excercise (I added that during collg I was into gym but after preparation was not able to carry that fwd so mild only now)

Then he askef about technologies which will come in next 10yrs and how to use (answered ai,big data)I was adfing on he said tell me how big data is used (answer in crimin justice,agriculture ,education)it was a long discussion then bell rung

Chairperson again-what is laalbatti culture? (Answered )

Ur vuew on that? (I said it creates division of soviety on have and have not and added on sayong govt recently banned it)

Then she asked ok so suppose as a sp if u want to go to a place now quickly nd u dont have any batti isn't a problem? (Answered wat I have seen in indore that in between roads a separate section from where in emergency ambulances can go,something on this line can be done)

Then she asked if u want anything else to be asked?

I said mam tribal affairs?

Then she asked...is a tribal culture one thing or there is difference (I answered there are many culture) then she asked how we should go abt it (answered that mam one size fit all approach doesnot go well with tribals...so we need more decentralized planning )...she asked who are stakeholders for that I answered local bodies,gram sabhas,people

She said okay...good shubham.you may leave now...ur interview is over.I thanked everyone...

Mam including entire oanel was very inaudible at times I had to shift very closer to the member asking question...and at times I had to say I was not able to hear properly but they repeated question again...

Overall a very good experience.overall they were quite engaging and wanted to have a discussion rather than interrogation....

J

Date : 01-09-2021

Optional : Anthropology

Background : B.Tech in Mechanical Engineering , VIT Vellore

State : AP

Chairman Sir ( Shri R N Choubey)

1) Introduce yourselves with an emphasis on educational and professional experience.

2) Why did you work in software firm being from mechanical engg discipline. So, your mechanical knowledge didn't help you in getting a job. Right ?

2) One idea of Gandhiji with which you don't agree.

3) Gandhiji vs Bhagat Singh - whom do you support.

Member 1

1) controversy in Lakshadweep and follow up questions.

2) strategic importance of Andaman and nicobar islands

3) name 2 islands in A&N which are recently announced as development hubs.

4) tell us about sentinelese tribes.

5) what is creamy layer concept, what is the limit , how agriculture income is measured to identify creamy layer.

6) should we bring creamy layer concept for sc/sts ?

Member 2

1) probs with India's HEIs

2) solutions for the same

3) Is NAM relevant now

4) IT industry in India

Member 3

1) Criminal tribes/ Denotified tribes related laws and comparison between those laws

2) Why DNTs were Denotified before a new law was enacted ? What was the government's logic behind this denotification ?

(Lowest point in the whole interview)

Member 4

1) what's happening in china- pak- india border

2) how are we dealing with those 2 countries

3) You were discussing about QUAD with other member. Why there is huge attention towards Indo-Pacific these days ?

3) India is a developing country , can we invest so much money on defence neglecting development and welfare ?

4) prioritise between cybersecurity, maritime security, land border security in terms of investing limited resources India has keeping in mind the vulnerabilities.

5) using cricket's growth story give suggestions to improve our medal tally in next olympics.

RG

Board - TCA ananth sir

DAF - IRPS probationer, mechanical engineering, job in honda cars india Ltd, Jhabua and Alirajpur.

September 20th, 2021

Chairperson-

What are you doing currently?

Why your service is not mentioned in DAF?

Pls rationalize this choice of taking anthro as a subject despite mechanical background?

M1

AI is a futuristic technology. Are we as a country ready to brace it? Pls tell me pros and cons of this tech? Why are there apprehensions?

How can you apply it to your tribal hinterland?

M2

Tell me one scheme that brought great change to jhabua?

Are there any PVTGs in jhabua?

What tribes reside there?

What is the difference between TED and TED talks

M3

Women in armed forces? Is it a good decision? What's your take?

Electric vehicles and govt policy. Where do we stand now?

One more question that I can't recall

M4

Why is manufacturing sector not able to take off?

What can we do?

What are the challenges in India due to which Electric vehicles are still not popular?

EV technology is unaffordable right now? Should we bring it for rich only and not for the poor?

What alternatives do you suggest?

Thank you.

D

Board- A.M. Bhonsale Sir

Date- 07.09.21

Afternoon, second last to go, 5:15 to 5:45, PSIR

Entered room, greeted the board.

Bhonsale sir, straightaway asked what’s your height? You are so tall, well built. What is you health mantra? { Parents and lots of fruits)

Then started reading my Daf.

He then said, I forgot to ask you to sit. Please sit, remove the mask wipe your face, relax and have water if you want. Given one minute time to settle down.

He then introduced me to the process, said we will assess you on our conversations, you can take time, use paper and pen in case and answer. Your medium is English but you can answer in Hindi too if you are more comfortable.

Read out my education alma maters, NCC, NSS, JRF, hobbies and details.

So as you are already into excellent institutions and academics for long. What’s your take on NEP?

PM talked about न्याय and शक्ति (justice and empowerment) with reference to importance of mother language. What’s your assessment?

How mother language can help augmenting development and serve the underprivileged?

Have you seen the last test match? What was the turning point? Are you happy with the team?

When is the next match scheduled?

M1- How can we develop tourism, attract international tourists and more?

Why tourists sceptical about India despite natural and cultural richness?

What is the scepticism about National Monetisation and do you really think it’s for the good?

M2- You studied history, why history is politicised, is the discipline a science?

Why call for banning of books and changing history ? What are facts ?

You are a member of board and get a complain to ban 3 books. How will you take action?

How Naxalism historically makes your region difficult?

Why are we not able to defeat naxalites?

M3- IR your specialisation, how do you see transitions from times of Nehru with reference to our relations with China, US and Russia?

Is Russia still a friend and valuable?

Why India-Israel relation not moved further? Should we engage with Israel?

Can India change it’s position in terms of Palestine Issue?

Should we go back to Afghanistan?

What challenge we face from Taliban?

What are India’s options?

Rapid fire round

M4- You studied from Netarhat? What is that motto written in front of your school gate? * Attadipa Viharath” ( Be your own light- Buddha)

Who said that ?

What is the shloka written beside in Sanskrit in your school ? Do you remember and recite? From where the shloka has been adopted?

You read poetry, memver himself recited four lines of “.....the woods are lovely dark and deep.” Who wrote it, which Poem? Which country is the author from?

Where the mind is without fear. Who wrote and what is the name of collection?

Which cricketer’s autobiography is “A century is not enough”?

Novak Zokovich, Roger Federer, and Nadal. Which countries they play for ?

What is the meaning of Olympic motto?

Chair- Ok, your interview is over. Hope you enjoyed it. What will you do now?

Said- will go and write my Phd. ( Will not take your restaurant discount )😆

Said, good luck but enjoy and chill also before.

Sure sir. Thankyou.

Answered most, few hiccups in the the rapid fire round. Rest interview was smooth and cordial.

P

Smita Nagraj board

20th September

forenoon

Last to go

Duration : 30 mins

DAF : economics optional , BA MA Eco , DU , JNU , Haryana , badminton

Chairman

1. What have you been doing since post graduation

2. Difference between US model of economic development vs Western European model

3. Views wrt social expenditure

4. Role of government of India in reducing social development gap

5. Role of private sector

6. Follow up questions on the same topic

Member 1

1. National monetisation pipeline wrt reducing inequalities in the country

2. Economics of farm laws and the related agitation

Member 2

1. Indianisation of judiciary

2. Judicial reforms required

3. Why UTs are important

4. Why should we not merge Puducherry with Tamil Nadu

5. What is the strategic importance of Puducherry

Member 3

1. Internal security issues for India

2. Role of taliban wrt India’s internal security

3. LWE origin

4. Where has it been concentrated geographically

5. What can be done

Member 4

1. Name of the new chief minister of Punjab

2. 2 sports persons who won 2 medals at olympics

3. 1 thing that you learnt from Jnu

4. India’s border with Afghanistan and Indonesia

5. If you are to be made the foreign secretary , tell me 3 steps you’ll take to resolve India pak issues

6. Anything that you would like the board to ask you ?

R

Rkg

Transcript

DOI-20/9/2021

Daf related to Maths, Technology

TCA Anant sir board

Chair:

1.What you have been doing since last 2 yrs

2.Why join civil services?

3.What did you do in Unnat bharat abhiyan?(Related to my answer)

M1:Grilling mode, soft speaker

1.What is personal, professional integrity??

2.What is difference between successful and worthy person?

3.What is AUKUS?(current based)

F1:

1. Why Grouund water table going down in UP?

2. What tech can be used to reduce and monitor it?

3.How can farmers be shifted away from water guzzling crops?

M2: Himself spoke a lot

1.How maths manifest in universe?

2.Maths and music relation?

3.What can be solution for preventing neglect of talent in students?

4.What is NEP doing in that regard?

5.Contribution of ramanujan ?

M3: Grilling mode on

1.What are solutions developed by UBA?

2.Why regional solutions not replicated through out country?

3.What can be done to make it happen?

Chair: You may leave now, it lasted 25-30 mins

S

Sujata mehta ma’am board

17th sept. , forenoon, 2nd to go.

Geography optional

Background-Civil engg

Hobbies- travelling, reading novel, watching movies and web series

Hometown- amethi (U.P.)

Chm-

1-Amethi is prominent constituency, what do u thing are extra challenges one has to face while posted in amethi?

2- suppose u are posted in amethi, tell me the specific challenges and what steps will you take?

3- what eill you do to spread awareness?

4- what mediums will you use for spreading awareness?

5- can election commission help in this situation (situation of businessman political nexus) ?

2-3 more follow up question.

1st member- (very serious)

1- your hobby is travelling, tell me how travelling enhance your personality other than increasing your knowledge?

Then follow ups

2- your optional is geography, tell me 2 economic development steps which you will take to develop a region, and don’t tell all that bookish things, tell me two ground level steps.

Again 2-3 follow up questions.

2nd member-

I can see your hobby is watching movies and also reading novels.. so tell me there is one famous author in india whose many novels have been transformed into movies.. can you recall his name?

2- ok now tell me his novels which has been converted into movies.

3- you belong to musafirkhana ( a place in amethi district) , can you recall a song contain the word musafir?

4- ok, recite the song.

5- you are from gautam buddha tech. University, dont worry i’ll not ask anything from gautam buddha, just tell me , govt had introduced ₹50 note a while ago, what monument has been inscribed on that note and ia it related to buddha? How?

(He smiled and said ok thank you)

3rd member- ma’am

1-You were assosiated with an NGO. What is the name?

2- ok, what was the NGO doing?

3- what was your role in the NGO?

4- do you think NGO are working good in india?

5- then, have you heard that govt. is banning the license of several NGOs, why govt is doing so? Should govt regulate the licensing for NGOs?

2-3 follow ups

6- what ground steps you will take to better the landfill sites.

Tell me two steps that you will take.

(I said waste segregation at source, and waste to energy plant)

7- how will you spread awareness for waste segregation? And isn’t there already a law for waste segregation?

Ok thank you.

4th member-

1-you did civil engg?

2- there is a lot of flood in UP, do you have any blueprint on how to deal with recurrent floods in UP?

3- floods due to shifting of river, how will you deal with that?

I told 2 points, then he said- thats all?? I said yes sir that is waht i’m able to recall currently.

He said- Thank you.

Chm ma’am-

Ok, your interview is over, you can go now.

Overall good experience, interview was 30 mins.

One member was looking like he wants to stress me, both ma’am were very cordial.

DAF points:

Home state-Jharkhand.

Education-B. Tech mechanical engineering

Job-L&T hydrocarbon engineering

Board-Mr R N Choubey

Chairman:

1.Please introduce yourself emphasizing on educational qualification and profession.

2.In agriculture ,next growth axis after Green revolution in order to improve yields.

3.Follow up about the answer given.

4.Situation based question-you have surrounded a naxal camp on receiving intelligence, made them aware about shootout if anyone tries moving, still some women move about. Will you shoot?

5.Follow up on the above question.

Member 1:

1. 2 failures of govt in the handling of covid pandemic.

2.Hobby related to short story reading hindi-authors and stories.

3.what did u learn from it?

4. Contemporary relevance of the said story.

5. New problems of agriculture.

Member 2:

1.should we scrap history teaching in schools?

2. How to induce interest in history?

3.Motivation for civil services.

4.Official language act and use /relevance.

Member 3:

1. In Hydrocarbon sector which dept did u work?

2. What were your responsibilities?

3. What is the future of hydrocarbon?

4. Can we seek complete independence from hydrocarbon related business?

5.If made an advisor to jharkhand CM, what suggestions will you give for improvement of jharkhands stunted growth?

6.will forest produce based industries destroy the forests?

7. SEZ and significance.

8.How come Kerala public school in jharkhand? (My primary school was Kerala public school)

Member4:

1. Is there a similar tribal cooperative (i had mentioned this in one of the above answers) example among US natives?

2.Why IAS?

3.How to convince people to accept GM crops?

Chairman:

Would you like to add something?

Thank you. Your interview is over.

All board members were cordial.

Thanks and all the best.

G I

Sujata Mehta Board

DAF - Dentist, Anthropology, IR

Time 25-30 mins

Chair

1) Introduce yourself.

2) When did you graduate?

3) So you have not practiced Dentistry?

4) What is mission Indradhanush?

5)Compare it with the present covid vaccination?

6) Should vaccines be free? Why?

7) Now tell points why they shouldn't be free?

8) Can you take Vaccine whenever you want?? There is an 84 day gap right? ( I Said I was talking about 1st dose)

9) Should Health Services in the country be free of cost?

10) Which Services should be free acc to you? You think ambulance should be free? 2 others

M1

1) Why is it difficult to make vaccines for virus and not for bacteria?

2) Is anything related to the cell wall?

3) Features of NEP that you liked?

( Subjects from different fields, credit bank, multiple exit and entry)

4) It was there before also. Student could switch between fields. What's new then?

( Few more questions)

M2

1) Why only india Centric IR? Not interested in others?

2)You said healthcare should be free, but people are having so many kids, why should an honest taxpayer pay for the extra kids?

More follow up questions

M3

1) Stages of Healing of tooth socket after tooth removal

2) When is the bone formed?

3) When did Agriculture begin in India?

4) Stages of Human evolution?

5)How did humans effect ecosystem in every continent?

6)Have you heard of Homo Florence? Tell me about it.

7)What are your views on Aryan invasion Theory

M4

1) What are SDG Goals?

2) Is health part of it.

3) Is India part of it?Have you read a research paper on India and SDG?

4)What is Cop 26?

5) There is so much Tax evasion in India, what are the reasons?

6) Only Foreign MNCs are doing? what about domestic companies, they don't do it?

7) Any recent global news about Taxation ( G7 Global minimum tax)

8) What is cultural Anthropology

Chair

1) Continue About Cultural Anthropology.

2) It is said that NEET favours urban elite Students and has lead to coaching culture. What do you think?

Do you want us to ask you on any topic? I said IR.

3) Should we use Indian diaspora for our Foreign policy Goals?

4) What if tomorrow china uses Indians of Chinese descent to promote their goals?

V

Board: R N Choubey Sir

20th september 2021

DAF: Btech (Mech) DTU, Mtech (Design) IITD, ESE- 2019, BRO (probationer), Madhubani painting

Chairman:

Made me comfortable

1. Are you superstitious? (Said no with a pause)

2. Seems like you were about to say yes, then you said no

3. What are your views about women keeping fast for their husbands?

4. 4 judges came out to media. Why? And do you think it was the right thing to do?

5. You said public faith in judiciary. Have you heard of tareekh pr tareekh? What is it about?

6. How many cases are pending in our courts?

7. What is the avg time of disposal of cases in India?

8. You still think that your argument of public faith holds good?

M1:

1. Why ford had to shut it's shop?

2. But other players are doing well. How?

3. As a design engineer, what changes would you recommend in ford design to increase their sales?

4. Given that both petrol and diesel cost the same, which system would you incorporate into your design?

5. Logistic costs are increasing. How does it impact our economy?

M2 (Lady)

1. As a design engineer, design a policy for women empowerment? Your original policy.

2. Govt policies in these areas?

3. Have you heard about any famous shg model? (From previous answer)

4. To which state this model belongs?

5. Tell me more about this model?

6. You mentioned about NRLM. What's that?

7. Madhubani as SHG. Commercialization steps by the government

8. You make these paintings as well?

M3:

1. What is barter system?

2. Do you know about Atal tunnel?

3. Tell me a specific sensor name used in it.

4. What is collaboration and inter disciplinary in NEP?

5. Is collaboration limited to foreign universities?

6. How corporate collaboration can help in NEP?

7. As a mechanical engineer, how would you proceed for collaboration with corporate to float a course? Which course would be your priority?

M4:

1. Who is your best friend

2. What would she tell if I ask her your strengths?

3. Your weakness?

4. You could have done well in private. Why ESE and CSE?

5. How was your experience in IITD compared to DTU?

6. If you were DC, Chamoli, and you mother calls to tell you that your father has few days left. What would you do?

Chairman:

Do you want to tell us or want us to ask from a particular area?

Just

Chair - Smiti Nagaraj board.

Chairperson :

1. Your are from TN, is it your first visit to delhi?

2. Before this visit, what is your northernmost place you visited in India?

3. What are the places you visited here?

4.What what is your first impression when you landed in delhi?

5. In your impression, Is Delhi justified to be the capital of India?

6. Many automobile companies are leaving India, Why? What are the implication to TN?

Member 1 -

Why Tiruppur is famous for textile industry?

Apart from cheap labour, capital what other factors? Is there anything spl there?

Even though South India has many ports, why columbo became a major port?

Why we are not implementing setu samudram project?

Considering QUAD , AKUS , Do we need to allow USA to land and operate force against China? As we can't handle the chinese single handedly.

Member 2-

Long question - Social media freedom vs security of the state?

What we learnt from Covid?

Member 3.

Who are the inhabitants of India?

Is there a relation between baluchistan and South India?

Is khilji a settler or invader?

What is haiku? (Hobby)

Why ISL is not able to bring the glory to football, if hockey league can do to men's hockey?

Who according to you is the greatest women badminton at present?

Mention 3 greatest leaders of 20th century who can be remembered for next 500 century?

Member 4 :

Who is Durkheim?

" Technology and its advancement will change the societal values" is it true? If yes then explain.

What is the constitutional provision to eradicate Untouchability, as a sociological student tell me the solution.

What is tangible and intangible culture?

What is poona pact? How many articles in the constitution and how many amendment we are having?

7th September

TCA Anant sir Board

History graduation, political science optional, hobby yoga (no economics background)

Chair

Why do you want to go for civil services?

From your daf it seems that you cleared your graduation in 4 years, why did you take long?

What were you doing as a part of community involvement since you're from open University?

You mentioned migrant workers issue, what was done and what would you have done differently?

M 1

Why open University?

What will you do if you don't clear civil services?

We've moved from NAM to QUAD, similarly and difference then and now

What is happening in Afghanistan? What should be India's response?

Taliban has not invited india to swearing in? Do you think we should still engage with them?

Your first preference in service is?

What did you do as headgirl?

M2

Jharkhand is rich in coal , but we are moving from coal to renewable. Will that not impact Jharkhand's economy

What is GDP

What is Production linked incentive scheme. Some sectors?

Which are the sectors in electronics?

What is the GSDP of Jharkhand?

M3

I think intolerance is increasing, what do you think?

Domestic violence is a big issue, more so in rural areas , your take

(Suppose) You and your husband both will have jobs, but your husband doesn't help in household chores, what is the solution for this?

Some writers removed from English BA syllabus in DU. Are you aware? Which writers? Why? What is the issue behind the controversy?

What is the latest news on Chandrayan 2 ?

M4

What is the one mistake that we made in ancient and medieval India that we can learn from?

In which year was Jharkhand created? Do you favour small states or large states?

Do you think our policy on South China sea is good?

So the limit of Territorial sea is ?

Transcript

TCA Anant sir board

Date -21/9/2021

Background – Madhubani, Bihar| GGPS Bokaro | Chemical Engg. Plastics and Polymer | BIT Mesra Jharkhand

Hobbies – Running | Hindi Movies with a message| Developmental Stories

Chairperson:

1. SWOT Analysis of your district (Madhubani).

2. Ways to tackle Weaknesses?

3. Why Madhubani to Bokaro for intermediate(11th and 12th)?

M1:

1. Is defence infrastructure boosting, need of the hour or waste of resources?

2. Cybersecurity related threats and possible ways forward?

M2:

1. Should plastics be banned altogether?

2. Possibility of single-use plastic use in circular economy (e.g. road building material)

3. Every movie has a message, what is special about Hindi movies with a message?

4. How do you decide that a movie has a message without watching it?

5. What do you mean by developmental story?

M3:

1. Attracting investment in your district? Basis (Situation based, addressing investor’s forum with your state CM)

2. Promotion of local products (Makhana)?

3. Steps to be taken to promote economic growth in your district (in 2 years)?

4. On college placement?

M4:

1. About Vidyapati, a famous Maithili poet?

2. Another famous personality of this region (Mandan Mishra)?

Chairperson: Thank You, Your interview is over. (around 30 min)

Interview Transcripts 2023 pinned Deleted message