Interviews

UPSC interview, M. Sathiyavathy board, 26 Aug 2021

26 Aug 2021

A G

Sathyvathi ma'am board

Graduation - Civil Engineering

Optional - History

PT date - 26th Aug

Last to go (around 4:30 pm)

Duration - 23 to 25 minutes approx.

Home state - MP

(I Was quite enthusiastic as well as nervous)

Entered room-

Ma'am wished me Good Evening Mr A

I wished everyone individually

Asked me to sit down and to keep face-shield on lap and to remove mask temporarily for face verification.

Started reading out my DAF for few minutes.

1) What did you do after completing your graduation and after resigning from the job.

2) You have history optional so tell me which personality has influenced you from ancient Indian history

3) What did you inherit personally from him

4) You so far praised him but tell me what exactly you inculcated in yourself

5) Okay then tell me which recent historical personality influenced you.

(I honestly said that whatever I read about 'em, I read that during preparation and nothing beyond that)

She smiled and passed over to first member

Member 1

1) So tell me Mr A about Secularism

2) How did both types of secularism model evolve particularly emphasizing upon Indian model.

3) Don't you think political parties in India these days acting against secularism

4) Okay Tell me about the concept of Smart cities

5) How many cities under Smart city mission from your state

6) Why Indore has been the cleanest city in row ?

7) Which state became the first state to implement NEP 2020.

(I read this question in some transcript but as I was going to search the answer someone called me and I forgot to search so had to say Sorry)

Member 2

1) Tell me three civil engineering projects in India that you are proud of

2) Tell me three international civil engineering projects which left you awestruck

3) What is your opinion on privatization of Air India

4) Who will provide pro bono services (Vande bharat mission , airlifting of expatriates under distress ) if you privatize these government players

5) Are you aware of GDPR ?

6) What's the effect of GDPR on India

7) What are E commerce issues and can you justify the regulation on them by the state.

Member 3

1) What is Rafale issue ?

2) Why Govt is not disclosing price and other details of the deal to public when we are a democracy

3) So if SC has given clean chit to the govt, will it absolve the govt from her responsibilities !!

4) Is SC 's judicial interpretation infallible ?

5) You are made a DC, if selected ! Then you will also conceal information from the public and if you are also given clean chit then administration will be at the labyrinth !!!

6) So National Security is over and above democratic principles and transparency ??

7) Tell me something about Malabar Rebellion

(Actually I very well knew but got confused in between Battle of Colachal and Moppilah rebellion and I am gonna regret this throughout my life 😏)

I said sorry sir I am not able to recall but if you allow then I can tell you about Moppilah rebellion and then he murmured something that I could not understand due to low voice and his mask

(That day I really realised the stress you hold on Hot seat and Doppler's effect 😛)

Member 4

1) What is the difference between Water Management and Water conservation

2) Tell me more about this ( I delineated with real life example)

3) Which country is adopting best practices in water conservation and management

(Isreal I said )

4) What's India' s rank in Water Quality Index

5) Tell me about Environment Impact Assessment

6) Tell me about Social Impact Assessment

7) Tell me about Contract Labour Laws reforms which were in news recently

8) Difference between demonetization and monetization of assets ?

9) What are the positives of Demonetization

10) What's the new trend in the past 4-5 years in the distribution of Padme Sri Awards

(I thought they wanted to drag me into political debate & I said it's merit based, giving few examples but then Chairperson interrupted and said we are not interested in types and other awards tell us about the trendz in Padma sri, how people are getting them in last 4-5 years)

I said I don't have enough knowledge so I am not privy to comment sir.

May be few questions are left out that I am not able to recall.

Then ma'am asked first member whether he had asked questions !!

And then she concluded wishing me good luck.

Members were not cordial as such but yes accommodative !!

Except ma'am, Almost all had poker faces and meagre zeal to listen because they looked exhausted or perhaps pretending to be (no one can guess actually).

Chairperson was looking at her phone repeatedly, may be timer or something like that !

Barely any question from Hobby and Optional but mostly opinion based questions.

I was anxious when I came out thinking I did not get proper time but it's okay !!!

Overall it was a nice experience...

Guruji

Smita Nagaraj Ma’am board

Background: IRS-IT, coal India Limited.

No other aspect of DAF touched.

Chairman:

Tell me in one sentence how this faceless scheme is.

What are the other areas open to corruption in the income tax department. What can be done?

Should agricultural income be taxed?

Which state in india do you think is best administered?

Why?

M1

There is compulsory military training for people in Israel...your take on this?

What is VsVs?(Income Tax)

How much successful it is?

What is the amount of tax collected under this scheme so far?

What is the exact relaxation to the Tax payer?

Is Brexit working for Britain?

M2

Why there is production shortfall of coal in the country?

What can be done?

What are the challenges to India’s mining sector?

What have government done?

Do you think future of mining is bleak?

Why persecution rate is low in india?

How can AI be used to increase prosecution?

M3

Do you think our prosecutors are lacking in drafting and argument skill?

Do you think victims should have choice to hire their own prosecutor instead of relying on public prosecutor?

You told that agricultural income be taxed but farmers are doing hard work, why not we keep them exempted?

Is complete agricultural income exempted?

M4

You talked about Delhi being best administered...why is it so?

But we are seeing huge water clogging problems in Delhi..why?

What is its solution?

Your take on IRAN nuclear deal?

What are the Security challenge in India’s land and water borders?

S

Board: Bharat Bhushan Vyas Sir

Date - 8th September

Order - last to go

Duration - 20-25 minutes

Background - law optional

State - MP

Chairman - Asked to remove the mask but keep the faceshield on

1. Tell me about Mandsaur.

2. What is social justice according to you?

3. Can you link Article 14 to the DPSPs?

4. Steps taken to double farmers' income

5. India's policy towards it's neighborhood in general

Member 2

1. Reforms needed in UN

2. Tell me about International Parliamentary Union

Member 3:

1. Difference between Ghazal and Nazm

2. Agriculture in your home district.

3. Are you aware about a recent externment order issued by Supreme Court?

Member 4:

1. What is India's policy on refugees

2. What is significant about wheat crop in MP?

3. Where is sharbati wheat grown in MP?

4. Difference between RTI and a Parliamentary question

Member 5:

1. Difference between International Humanitarian law(IHL) and human rights law.

2. Where would UDHR, refugee law - IHL or human rights?

3. Why Japan is important for India - 4 reasons

4. Tell me about jus soli, jus sanguinis, et al.

Thank you, your interview is over.

Overall very cordial board.

2nd Sept. forenoon; R. N. Choubey sir board – all male panel

6th to go in; 30-35 minutes

Name: Abhishek

M.Sc Mathematics from BITS pilani

Hobbies – Running, cooking

Other keywords in DAF – NSS, Satara, Maharashtra

No questions on hobbies, NSS, alma-mater, home district

(A big air-conditioned room in new building. Long horse-shoe shaped table. Distance between me and the panel was substantial so I was asked to remove mask. Face-shied and gloves were supposed to be left outside. So gave the interview old style!)

Chairman: Extremely cordial. I haven’t met a softer-spoken person!

Welcomed me. We are good people. This is not police interrogation. If you don’t hear our voice, ask to repeat. If you don’t know, say that. We know that everything can’t be remembered. If you are not clear say I’m not clear.

1. Tell me your academic and work experience in 1 minute. (Didn’t need that long! LOL)

2. How did you get interested in Mathematics when most students are so afraid of it?

3. Do you know something about Vedic maths? Do you use it?

4. How is it different from General Mathematics?

Electoral bonds – long discussion on it

5. Do you know about the financial instrument designed to fund elections?

6. There’s some controversy about it. Are you aware?

7. Now, tell me should details of such funding declared publicly, from perspective of an industrialist and from perspective of public?

8. So, tell me why should people know about details of such funding? So, tomorrow they may want to know my IT returns or something private?

9. Out of the 60000cr money spent in 2019 elections, what do you think was more, white money or the cash based black money? Nobody knows exactly, but what do you sense?

10. So, if you declare such funds publicly, as an industrialist, I would just go back to funding via cash? So, now tell me which is better, public declaration or no declaration?

11. What does involving EC do?

M1:

1. Mathematicians are respected everywhere– tell me why India and China produce such highly regarded mathematicians even today?

2. It is necessary for Mathematician to have a kind of divine intuition – Ramanujan is the case in point?

3. Okay let us move to IR. Situation in Afghanistan is quite bad. How do you think, this situation will impact India-Pakistan relationship? More friendly or not?

Some more questions – not able to recall

M2:

1. I’ll ask you a core Mathematics question – A long winding and never-ending question – AI, Machine learning, data, ... - use of mathematics in it – Logic in particular – so tell me about how *** logic is used here? – don’t recall exactly and didn’t know the answer

2. Another question on Mathematics and philosophical movement in the west – how are they related and how it began – current relevance of Mathematics in these philosophies?

Chairman sir asks him to move on

3. Okay, let’s come to IR. Minorities in Afghanistan are fleeing the country. But it has been seen that, they don’t want to come to India but rather go to US or Europe? Why do you thing that’s happening despite the fact that, they’ll be treated well here and get protection of laws like CAA?

M3:

1. So, you’re a mathematician. What is the connection between Maths and Poetry?

2. Does poetry help you in Mathematics? Do you read poetry?

3. Do you know about any of Nehruji’s contributions in Woman empowerment?

4. Did he face any difficulty in getting the Hindu code bill passed? Was it watered down to get it passed?

5. Who opposed it from his own party?

6. You come from Maharashtra. Tell me some reforms that have happened in cooperative movement in Maharashtra.

7. Are you aware about the new central ministry of cooperatives under a very strong minister? Do you thing it is a good step? What are its positives?

8. Have you ever met a Japanese person? – they’re very humble. But has it always been like that?

9. Japan has historically been a very aggressive country. But now they have changed drastically. How have they changed in terms of their military policy, nuclear policy?

10. Do they send any of their troops to fight outside?

M4:

1. DRDO has developed anti-missile interceptors. But it is only able to intercept missiles from Pakistan and not China. Now I can’t understand why? For me, if it can do one it should do both. Can you mathematically analyse some of the possible reasons for this?

2. Government has banned civil servants from writing their memoires? What do you think about it?

3. Yes, government would have some reasons for banning it and some for allowing it earlier. But do complete analysis for me – should civil servants write such books? What are the benefits? Should it be banned? Why or why not?

(Less number of questions but longer answers)

Chairman:

Okay Abhishek, we’ve asked you whatever we wanted to. Now, would you like to tell us about something?

Talked about my fitness journey with running hobby and diet. Told them that I lost 15 kg weight since last interview.

All were impressed and chairman sir said that we appreciate your discipline and resolve.

Sunshine

Board - RN Chaubey sir

Optional - Commerce and Accountancy

Date -9/9/2021

Sir said if ur RTPCR negative then u can remove mask and that it was not a police investigation So feel free to communicate...Also where questions are not clear you can ask again.. Meanwhile their snacks came and they were having same ..

Chairman

1.Introduce your academic background and work experience7

2.What police reforms has been taken and what more needs to be taken

M1.

1.Tell me about commercial laws of the country

2.Why Business men protested against GST laws?

3.Whats your opinion about GST

4.Which two states had boundry disputes recently

5.Lady Country heads that controlled Covid well..Name them if not then the countries

6.What are the Scandinavian countries ?

7.Which countries have high tax to GDP ratios.

M2.

1.Tell me about what happens next when audit Paras are final?

2.What is Public Account Committee

3.What are the land locked countries and what disadvantage they have?

4.Why Sea mode of transportation done when is slower

5.What kind of items be import/export through aeroplane

6.Which country has longest coastline and what is India's rank in coastline

M3

1.What is the use of Platinum?Where it is used?

2.Which states are having Inner Line Permit and which state is demanding.What is Inner line permit.

3.The evolving situation in Afghanistan

4.Whats need to be done for reducing tax collection expenditure..

M4 - Lady members

1.Whats the issue in recognising Taliban now

2.Why Exemptions were kept in GST one basic reason.( Discussion on same further)

Chairman do you want to tell something else

I told about the news read on V shape recovery of economy and further discussion on same.

He further asked anything else you wanna tell.

I told I started you tube channel in this lockdown and purpose of same.

He said thanks it was nice hearing from you.

Overall .. it was so smooth and nice ..Chaubey sir was so easy to talk with....one suggestion...Focus on your DAF majorly apart from current affairs.

Also be confident and believe that you gonna rock...☺️☺️

All the best to all.

Ifos PT - 2020

From 18th Oct 🙏

Category Wise distribution of Average Marks 👆👆👆 Also religion wise too (due to that Unverified media coverage) we see average is same, thus one can comfortably confirm non bias in Interview also. Source : CSE 2019 SELECTED CANDIDATES Marks list

Background- maths hons economics

Board R. N. choubey sir

Optional -PSIR

Afternoon session

Date of interview 9 sept 2 nd to go

Introduce yourself by highlighting your educational and academic background

Why do we need second house -

M1

You were part of nss what did you do in nss?

You won prize in rotary Club do you know what is it about

Why is coordinate geometry not used these days ?

What is trigonometry?

Tell me 93*93 -7*7?

M2

Why do we need economics as a subject?

What is monetarist?

What percentage of GDP do we spend for development?

How is monetary policy taken into action?

What is crr and slr?

How do we determine monetary policy?

M3

Why are we concerned about taliban?

Why should we be concerned it is so much away from us?

Should we recognise taliban regime

M4

Do we need civil service reforms?

What is karmyogi scheme?

What else do we need

What is schenzen area

What is geneva convention

Which convention else do you know?

How money will come for national infrastructure pipeline?

Do you think private sector will invest in it?

What else we can do for making it success?

Do you know about single window for FDI?

M5

what is nuclear policy of India?

What mechanism do we have for implementing nuclear policy?

How do we measure speed of aeroplanes.

Which countries can gang up against nato?

How should we go in terms of current foreign policy with respect to today's scenario?

I blabbered about Chinese bullying

What is quad? What is indo Pacific?

Chairman

Do u want to tell us anything

I mentioned about village bhandara? Leadership thing I learned there he taunted about the food there

Doing my duty. Here's my transcript-

bhonsle sir board

Forenoon

3rd in

Psir, Btech CSE, badminton, football, travelling, uttarakhand

Sir did the usual ritual of reading out daf, calming nerves etc.

1. Meaning of name

2. Origin story of name

3. Synonyms of name

4. Ind Afghan recent cia nsa talks

5. Pakistan is a winner?

Mem 1 (stern)

1.aspirational districts prog? What is it?

2. How many aspirational districts?

3. Messi went to which club?

4. Why not stay at barca?

5. Indian badminton better at Paralympics than Olympics. Why?

6. Name of dm who won medal?

7. Which state is he from?

8. Which district does he serve?

Mem 2 (receptive gentleman)

1. What is vpn?

2. Why in news?

3. Landslides in utk. You are the secretary suggest measures

4. Environment vs development how to handle

5. What would you do different in both covid waves?

Mem 3 ( strict, pokerface lady, always seemed unhappy with answers)

1. Why unemployment in india?

2. Follow up on my answer that structural issue of weak mfg- gave long speech on our mfg being better than most in the world. Still why unemployment?

3. Skill development (that's what she wanted to hear) initiatives? Why govt obsessed with skilling?

4. Follow up on my answer where I mentioned technology- which type? I said 4th ir

5. Name some 4th ir tech

6. Won't it lead to job loss?

Mem 4 ( 100% sure he was the psychologist)

1. Picked up mams statement and gave long speech. Gist was why farmers not getting money?

2. Follow up on my food processing answer. Will it end all problems of farmers?

3. How to enhance marketing and demand?

4. Give policy outline as rural secretary to solve farmers problems.

Bhonsle sir

What are your special plans for today?

He said ok you can go. But I couldn't hear so I sat waiting. He repeated. Asked to take along water and shield. Mask was always on except during initial verification.

Forgot to check time. But must have been around 35 minutes.

Special note- unlike earlier when we had to get documents verified at one place and were taken to the waiting hall later, this time it was at one common hall only. There's ac and washroom and refreshments and newspapers so don't worry. Also you need not wear sheild or gloves while waiting. When your turn is up the peon will escort you to the room and make you sit outside for 5 10 minutes. Won't even know the boards name till you are called. Stay relaxed. ITS NOTHING LIKE THE MOCKS! You will enjoy the conversation it's very relaxed. No personal qs no counter questions no grilling. ATB