UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 7 Sep 2021 (Kerala…)
7 Sep 2021
Rahul Raghunath:
Name : Rahul
Date : 03-Sept-2021. Morning Session . 4th to go.
Board : Smitha Nagaraj Mam.
Background : Kerala , BTECH CS , Hobby : Travel Photography , Listening to Carnatic & Tamil Music
Enters room .
Got surprised by the arrangement inside the room . (Be ready for Surprises).
In that surprise i made a delay in wishing them . But Successfully did .
Mam Said you can sit down if u r ready .
Forgot to unbutton the coat and sat there . 😩
(No comforting words / explanation of the process / asking to remove mask to see my ugly face happened .—->Straight to business. Seemed they were done for the day and want to finish it of quickly )
Smitha Mam :
1. Why Tamil Music ?
A: Mam .. its very romantic .
2. Romantic?
A: Explained about Ilayaraja & AR Rahmans compositions .
3.Why Carnatic?
A: 2018 upsc pre qn on Tyagaraja -lord krishna . Forced me to listen to Carnatic .Now i am an expert . Everyone laughed .😝
3. 2018 passed out.. till now?
A: 1 year in Blore & 2 year in Delhi for preparation. (i feel i should have mentioned that its my first attempt. If anyone of you are - just bring it somewhere during conversation - sometimes they dont care to read ur DAF properly. )
4.WHy industries in Kerala are poor ? Tell me the most one Important Reason ?
A: Labour Union Culture
5. U think thats the most imp?
A: There r other factors like less land availability , high labour wages .
6. Tell me how u will tackle it?
A. Explained about UP Act for penalising damage to public Properties . Said i dont know what to be done with land. She gave me a disappointed look .
7. Dont u think each state has its own +ve & -ves. Kerala can focus on Service sector, isn't it ? Tell me a foreign country model which could be applied to Kerala .
A. Talked about Singapore & how we should focus on Ayurveda , Tourism in Kerala
7. Should State give patronage for Arts ? Should Corporates also give?
A:Said yes, and can be also included in CSR . Gave an average answer.
M2.
1. Sea level rise in Kerala . What be done ?
A: build magnets of employment in inner areas, train fisherman in coir,plantation, etc. Build Machan type houses as we see in vietnam & Cambodia.
Cant recollect further.
M3.
1. RTE? why additions in FDuties & DPSP ?
A: gave answer- average.
2.Definition of Child in various laws?
A : Said its till 14 in RTE. explained how it is leading to Child labour coz 15-18 can work in non-hazardous industries.
3. So u think Child should be <18 ?
A: Yes
4. Who is a Juvenile?
A: JJ Act : JJBoard constituted & they determine. Average .
5. Laws for Women Safety in Workplace .?
A: Explained about Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013.
6. Tell me about NGT ?
A. Said its a Statutory body to ensure Environmental Justice . I said it has judicial powers.
7. Judicial /Quasi ?
A; Sorry Sir, Quasi , thanks for correcting me .
M4: Grill Mode.
1. How to regulate Online Gaming in backdrop of Chinese move.?
A: keeping times for apps , & more focus on creatig awareness to parents about detriments of games - mental health iissues, addiction etc.
2. How to regulate online gambling ?
A: Dont Know SIr.
Rest i cannot recollect.
M5 : Gentleman .
1. Ban on Chinese Apps, impacts?
A: Firstly it was mostly Symbolic- after the Clashes @ galwan . Secondly - gave a push for domestic IT sector .
2. U think it helped Indian apps?
A: Yes.
3. whats the performance of Digita Inddia?
A : Said i am not satisfied. We have not achieved milestones. 30k panchayats in India doesnt have Mobile network. Talked about Odisha boy died after falling from cliff when he was searching for mobile network.
4. Tell me something about govt schemes in digital india like DigiLocker , Bharat Net , he mentioned few other schemes .?
A: Talked about them and also added National Strategy on Blockchain.
5. How to deal with Pakistan ?
A: Gave an answer.
Smitha Mam Said u can go.
Overall it welt like a rapid round . Ended quickly.
Though was mentally prepared to behave as suggested by mocks , my natural instincts dominated. Hand movements was splendid. Head movements sufficient . It was raw.
No much questions on Kerala .
No questions on COVID , why want to join CSE , Other Hobby , IR , Remittances to kerala , Kerala Model , Parents , Quotes , College/School , fancy qns , Leadership/projects in college.
I entered within one minute after the previous candidate exited. Means they are in a hurry. I felt they didnot read DAF in detail, but asked few qn from whatever caught their attention from DAF.
Takeaways:
1. Be ready for surprises.
2. Go with Zero expectations. Make a mindset that they will ask zero questions from that u have prepared . It would help you make a good conversation .
3. Smile till you faint . Even smile after that too.
4. Say i dont know freely. i wish i had said that more .
5. Take it slow. Breathe , give answers after properly hearing qn. Reduce your speed - turn on Grandpa mode.
6.Dont fall for their expressions. They may give a disapointing face . Dont care. if u fall for it , it will ruin ur confidence & calm .
All the best Everyone . !!
Enjoy that 30 mins . !
R
Bhonsle sir Board,
IPS
CM
What is 2+2 dialogue?
If you are OSD to MEA what 5 advices you will furnish in a 1-1 meeting?
M1
Why India not a permanent member of UNSC?
The Current system of Judicial appointment?
Which 4 judges came out against SC in media?
Which 4 players have hit 6 sixes in an over?
Which minority judge was involved in Ayodhya verdict?
Which judge gave dissenting judgement in Sabrimala case?
Which player defeated Suhas LY?
M2
Why there are so many PPP projects these days?
Water pollution and soil pollution sources and remedies?
Some other questions which I m unable to recollect
M3
Is Birth rate control' essential for economic growth?
When it's needed?
Which states have higher TFR?
What lessons we can learn from China in context of the Birth control?
M4?
Police perception in public?
Is it justified?
What will you do to bring changes at grassroot level?
Shouldn't an IPS work as a constable and also as an SI to understand people better and improve perception?
You write poems, recite one?
CM?
Women have to prove and men are born?
Another quotation which I m unable to recall.
Board was cordial and interview Lasted nearly 40min.
Chandana
Bharat Bhushan Vyas Board
Profile- Chem Engg BIT Mesra+ MBA, IIM Indore+ Work Ex Deloitte
Hobbies- Carnatic Music + Readathon Challenges
State- Telangana
Q1. You have two names-what do people address you as?
Q. You are still working?
Q. Why would you quit a high paying job and company known for good work culture ( Deloitte)
Q. When did this thought of appearing for UPSC Originate?
Q. Why did you not write the exam after graduation?
Q. Why not immediately after Post Graduation?
Q. Coming to Management- Tell me what is Management, what is Administration and what is Governance ( counter questions on Management)
Q. What is Good Governance
Q. Do you think our Foreign Policy has changed drastically in the last few years?
Q. How do you understand by Poverty?
Q. How do we measure poverty?
Q. Contributions of Ahilya Bai Holkar?
Q. Tell me her contributions sociologically
Q. What are Tax Havens
Q. Connect it to Global Minimum Tax Rate
Q. Hobby of Readathon and Goodreads Website
Q. What are current reading challenges you are taking part in
Q. Why did you opt for Sociology
Q. How will you use it in Administration
Q. Define Socialization
Q. Did marks feature in your decision of choosing sociology? It is consistently the most rewarding optional ( Told him, I did not think of it that way after seeing optional marks but I did consider limited syllabus as Criteria)
Q. What is most urbanized and least urbanized state in India
Q. Explain Urbanization as a phenomenon and in future if it will be inclusive - if inclusive will it be natural or state imposed
Q. Carnatic Singers- tell me 4 current practicing singers
Q. Why not mentioning Sudha Raghunathan
Q. Tell me about a leading music director from South India and his current controversy ( AR Rahman and some twitter trolling - he explained incident while I gave the name), your opinion on it
Q. NSS, NCC, Bharat Scouts and Guides- have these institutions served their purpose?
Q. In recent context, what is the most important thing for Comprehensive Nation Power, will give you a hint that Bhutan launched something in late 2000...connect it ( he was expecting Soft Power and importance of Qualitative Assessments like Global Happiness Index)
Q. ASEAN and SAARC what is difference in their working
Q. Differentiate Migration and Forced Migration
Q. Since you mentioned BBIN- What are the countries
Q. What is the other B and what are its problems for inclusion( I told Bhutan but there are environmental concerns)
Q. NEP- should states have separate policies
Q. Counter to you- shouldn't states want to protect their ethnicity and their history instead of uniformity of syllabus?
Thank you your interview is over
B J
Background: From Andhra Pradesh, Civil engineering, Sociology optional
Afternoon, 5th to go.
Chairman: TCA Anant
Discussed in detail about DAF
Asked about the region of Amaravati and Vijayawda and what is the situation now(3 capitals issue)
M1
Asked on hobby, which car would you suggest for city usage and why?
Tell me about the technical features of the car that you’ve suggested
Then about another hobby, which kind of and which language movies do u watch?
Tell me about the scene that moved u in 3 idiots movie
After I gave my answer, M4 added to it and everybody laughed
Having known the Afghanistan history and present issues, analyse the present issues sociologically?
M2
Asked about bullet trains
A) which cities it is going to connect
B) the total cost
C) is it worth the money being put in given the traffic between the cities is not huge? (Replied the symbolic value is much higher than the economic value)
D) How should we finance the project, collect charges later or use taxes collected? (Replied given the capital intensive nature and also to make it attractive for consumers to choose it over airways, a balance of both is necessary)
Given you are a civil engineer, other than normal infrastructure projects which sector do u consider important, by the time I replied he mentioned that he wants to know about housing
About housing for all
Criteria for beneficiaries selection
Asked to mention a few other flagship schemes of the government
Finally, why do u want to become a civil servant?
Smiled after answering and asked the next member to take over
M3( Sole lady member)
About a program(DAF) I was part of and my role in it ?
Given the present circumstances, what are the two major issues that you think are very important for entire world to fight together? ( Replied Climate change and then peace in Afghanistan, added reasons for the latter like terrorism and the large scale opium production)
Do you have any knowledge about accounting? (Replied No straight away)
Asked something about accounts (Replied, I don’t know)
Asked about CAG and the role of office of CAG
Who maintains the expenditures and revenues of the government?
Finally, You may get into accounting service also, don’t worry I’m sure you’ll learn about it if you get into it.
M4
Reasons behind the aridity of native district?
Asked a few questions on civil engineering - Principle of surveying and principle of finite element and etc
Asked about kirchoff’s law
Asked about my hobby
Chairman: Good, your interview is over.
Around 25-30 mins, Very pleasant experience and it was a cordial panel.
Mithun H N
Qualification : BE ( EC )
Optional : Sociology
Board : TCA Anant Sir
Date : 02nd September 2021 Afternoon
2nd Candidate to go.
Read out my details in the DAF.
Chairman:
Are you in IPS training now? Which cadre are you allotted?
You've already got home cadre IPS, still why do you want to be an IAS , the only service option you have filled?
How does your Electronics and Communication Engineering knowledge help in the field of policing?
Member 1 :
You mentioned proactive policing. What does it actually mean?
Can you give some instance where police forces failed to make use of it?
Are you aware of newly released Drone Rules? Mention some provisions of it.
How can drones be used in policing?
What are the concerns associated with drone usage by police?
So you're an engineering graduate. What project did you do in your final year? Explain
What is Agriculture 4.0 ?
Member 2 -
So you're from Chikkamagalur in Karnataka. Tell some interesting things about your district.
Who was Baba Budan? What is his major contribution?
What's your opinion on video recording the judicial proceedings and live telecasting them? What demerits do you see?
What do you think about the written advocacy? You feel it is advantageous?
Member -3
So your optional is Sociology. Who is your favourite Indian sociologist?
What concepts given by him appeal to you the most? Their relevance?
You must have heard about Mrs. Roopa Moudgil , an IPS officer from your state. What report did she give few years back which brought her to limelight?
Do you think it's right on the part of public servants to glorify oneself infront of media for their official work?
Bangalore traffic congestion is among the city's major problem. What has been done to address this? What more can be done?
Member 4 -
Spoke of farming techniques like organic , vertical farming etc.,
How we can ensure better market linkage of farm produce around the city with the markets in the city?
Karnataka is a forerunner in the IT sector on the country. Are you aware of the IT sector contribution to Karnataka's GSDP?
Also, in GST implementation and collection Karnataka is among the top states. You having worked in State Commercial Tax Department, from your experience, tell some initiatives and methods employed by the State ?
Chairman : Thank you
S
Board: Satyavati ma'am
Optional: medical science
Chairperson:
Read out my DAF loud, asked me about photograph and education.
What is Bastar phc model..?
Why did you want to work in chhatisgarh..?
What kind of improvement you've seen after the implementation of your model..?
M1:
Why we're using expensive remdisvir when cheaper alternatives like Ivermectin is available...?
There's lot of vaccine hesitancy in tribal regions how you're going to overcome it..?
M2:
What are the reasons for naxalism in Chhattisgarh..?
Why not in North East India..?
How can we overcome this problem..?
After andhrapradesh division many mineral resources been gone to Telanga how andhra can overcome this shortfall..?
M3:
If we construct more roads and improving digital connectivity in LWE area that may help logistics for naxals... What's your view in this regard..?
What is policy bazaar..?
What was your work profile..?
What if a person lie to on telephone..?
Which model is beeter for insurance policy verification... Online or ofline..?
What are the steps taken by the government to contain COVID19 pandemic..?
Have you seen any significant improvement in this year's budget allocations towards health sector..?
What is Arogya setu..?
M4:
What's your view on generic medicine..?
What about the unholy nexus between doctors and pharmacy companies..?
How can we check it..?
Why tribal people prefer quacks than modern medicine..?
Is it because of lack of doctors..?
Do you think your selection into service will benefit the society..?
But there's corruption how will you handle it..?
Chairperson:
Asked me to go...
Overall very cordial board
More of a conversation rather a Q&A session...
All the very best 😊
N P
Board: Shri Monoj Soni Sir
Time: Around 30 min
Date & Session: 7 September, Afternoon, 4th to go
DAF: PSIR, DANICS (P), Visited Lakshadweep Island recently, Work Experience in Real Estate for 2 Years
CH: (Asked me whether I'm comfortable with Face shield and permitted to keep it down, verified photo and confirmed whether he is pronouncing my name properly)
1. Are you already in service? Why didn't you mentioned in DAF? What's your experience in Lakshadweep? For how many days you were in Lakshadweep
2. One quote of President Roosevelt related to Youth (I have related this with Thought of Swami Vivekananda)
3. Are govt doing sufficient to build our youth? What one thing you would suggest that should be done?
M1(LADY MEMBER)
1. What you do in Microblogging? Since when you are doing? How many followers? Why?
2. Importance of Lakshdweep and Andman and Nicobar? Which Nations are trouble creating?
M2(LADY MEMBER):
1. What's life cycle approach?
2. Which sector is working towards that? (Not able to answer and now I realised that it's about Automobile Sector)
3. Why so many problems in Real Estate sector in North India? To whom we should make accountable? How's Maharashtra RERA working?
4. Do you watch movie? Have you watched Aligarh Movie?
M3:
1. Why Aligarh is famous? What's common between Aligarh and BHU? Why Gandhiji asked students to not join them?
2. How Maldives is different than Lakshadweep? Can we have same model of development?
M4:
1. SAARC and BIMSTEC?
2. US approach and impact on allies? Aprt from Afghanistan which areas are having divergence?
25 aug
Rajasthan , 2019 graduate , , electrical engineer
Cricket , following IR , PSIR optional
Sathiyavathy mam
Chairpersons
1. What are you doing since 2019
2. Your contribution as hostel secretary , follow ups
3. Explain ... Law is an agent of social change but law is an utter
failure , further discussion on it
M1
1. Laplace transform
2. Some qn on electrical machine
3. Gorkhaland issue , what should be done
4. Atmnirbhar bhart , pillars , what govt is doing
5. Impact of technology on employment , economy and further qn on them
M2
1. Floating solar plant , its mechaniam
2. qn on other power plants
3. Govt control on media , godi media/designer media
M3
1. Your learning as house captin , traits you gain
2. Independent director
3. Climate change , impact on poles
4. Corona effect in electrical
M4
1. RCEP , should India have joined it , further discussion
2. Should right to health b e made FR,
3. Mukhyamantri Chiranjeevi yojna ( state specific)
4. About kota ( education city , impact of corona, student suicides etc)
Few qn cant remember
Anonymous
03/09/21
Background - CA, BPCL
Board. - Choubey sir
Chairman asked about
1.ministry of cooperation
2.how it’s diff from a company
3.need for it
M1 -
1.about cryptocurrency. Dangers etc
2.madurai handicrafts - challenges and Way forward
M2
1.south China sea. Should India send its navy there
2.defence budget. Process ..
3.RBI autonomy
4.rbi dividend given, discussion on that
M3
1.about history. Dictators of Europe and Asia
2.about oil and whether the Middle East is changing
M4
1. Whether CA is an unethical profession
2.what’s being done to make it ethical
3.in Malaysia the tamils are being treated unfairly, should India intervene
4.what about Indian intervention in SL, East pak
Then chairman asked if I wanted to talk about something . I told about tax to gdp ratio, few questions on that that’s it.
Overall good experience. Keep cool and always expect the unexpected.
All the best everyone.