Interviews

UPSC interview, Sujata Chaturvedi board, 2 Sep 2021 (Botany)

2 Sep 2021

Anonymous

Date 02.09.2021 (AN); 1st to go

Board: Sujata Mehta maam

Edu: BSc honours and MSc in Botany ;PhD (thesis submitted in August) from CSIR lab

Optional : Botany

Home state: West Bengal

3rd attempt, 1st interview With mask on all the time. Not even asked to remove to verify it.

CP :

1. Introduce Yourself.

2. You are going to be a doctorate very soon. After working so long in super specialised field do you think you will like the work of very generalist IAS?

3. Do research scholars get the respect they deserve in society?

4. Young IAS or IpS officers get better respect or not? Have you ever interacted? (Mentioned bharat darshan trainee visits to our lab here)

5. How are they? Were they arrogant or willing to interact?

6. Should we continue research on gm crops?

7. Why we are not accepting it? Why USA accepted but UK dont?

8. Will there be any illl effect of gm?

9. As a botanist, will you be in favour of promoting gm crops?

10. What you do as popular science communicator? (Hobby)

Member 1

11. After Covid, do you think we need more trees for immunity boost or pure air? Are we doing enough?

12. What else can we do to increase tree cover in metro cities?

13. Long talk on iraq, syria,libia. They are building extremely good infrastructures eg. flyover even better than delhi. Despite having autocratic ruler. Why?

14. Don't you think law and order could be better maintained by autocratic govt?

15. How many districts are there in India?

16. As a DM of any of these districts after few years, what will you do to improve state of affairs?

17. What are SDGs?

18. Do you think India can achieve the SDG goals as promised?

Member 2

19. Why the development of wb is kolkata centric? Why places like coachbehar and jalpaiguri are getting ignored?

20. It's not about infra only, do you have enough educational institutions there? (Mentioned 2 recently opened univ there)

21. Why WB don't want to share teesta water? Why is the river so important?

22. Do you think we took advantage in farakka treaty by not listening to Bangladesh demand?

23. Are there any flaws in these treaties?

24. Talk about some work permit and free movement between indo bangladesh. Do you think we can open border for local people in bengal?(said it will increase illegal migrant issue)

25. But won't people will be benefitted. They can go work in day and came back to india at evening. (Said we can do it in pilot basis, then open up if positive response and maintain proper transparency and safety measures)

26. You have studied in bengali medium. What you think about DU discrimination between cbsc and state boards. In 10+2 level, how can we bring down the disparity? (Talked about neet. But will be difficult in social sci. Still a common minimum syllabus may help)

27. You said same syllabus. But do you think you studied at presidency college say someone from munger will have the same capability as you have? (Said capability is individual but education environment will take more time to be same)

Member 3

28. What was your thesis topic?

29. Significance of it?

30. Most of the faculties in iit and other educational institutes are Bengali. Why bengalis prefer academic so much? (Mentioned less conducive env for business here)

31. Can't laxmi and saraswati go together?

32. You organised women entrepreneur conclave. How you see the idea of startup for research scholars?

33. Prosopis julifera. Invasive trees. How could you control? And 2 3 follow-up questions

34. You talked about NEET. Which state is constantly opossing neet?

35. What was their argument? (Gave wrong answer. Said language but he said rural people disadvantage. Accepted and said sorry)

Member 4

36. Name 4 biodiversity hotspots of india

37. Have you ever been to assam/ arunachal/ Meghalaya?

38. Are north eastern states poor? (Said poor if we see infrastructure but rich in biodiversity and ethnic diversity)

39. As a botanist, how will you help extract ing benefits of north eastern biodiversity?

40. Name few famous plants there.

41. Gave 3 4. Asking for more (said cant recall at this moment)

42. Are you in favour of planting oil palm there?

43. Why not? It will help the livelihood of people there? 44. Ill effects of monoculture?

45. But how can we then reduce import burden?

46. What alternatives you suggest?

CP at last

Do you want us anything else to ask that we left? (Said no) Good. Your interview is over. You can leave now.

Very cordial board. Chairperson had to intervene for limiting the number of questions. No cross questions. Mostly background related questions. Felt like conversation rather than viva in true sense. Members seem very responsive.

A

Chairman – BB Vyas

Date – 03/08 (Afternoon, 2nd to enter)

Qualification – B.Tech. (Electronics & Communication)

No WorkEx

Optional – Sociology

Hobbies – Writing on Cinema, Football, Defence & Security News

CHAIRMAN

1) What have you been doing since graduation?

2) So, you did BTech in ECE. Has the government has prepared a new policy on Electronics? When and what was it?

3) PLI came later, what were the earlier initiatives under it? Broadly, what did they target?

4) Has the govt also taken any such steps to boost IoT adoption?

5) What are the salient features of 5G? From a technical point of view, that is. How is it different from the earlier generations?

6) Under what Article is the Finance Commission formed? Which is the one currently in news? And what are the suggestions?

7) Has any specific step been taken for horizontal distribution?

M1

1) You like writing on cinema, what do you write about? Have you gotten it published anywhere?

2) What was the last thing you wrote about? (Ans – Antiheroes)

3) Where do you see these characters? Can you name some please?

4) Do you think other sports are suffering because of cricket?

5) About the Finance Commission again, there were arguments to enhance horizontal devolution to the hilly and underdeveloped states. Has something been done in this regard?

6) Some states submitted a representation over the population issue, are you aware of any such events?

M2

1) Why sociology when you have done BTech? Why not Electrical or Physics?

2) How will you use your technical education in your work as an IAS officer?

3) Now, the government is incentivising LEDs, why is it so?

4) What do you think must be done to improve our solar manufacturing process? (Very long question, cutting it short)

5) If you had to explain the photoelectric effect to a layman, how would you do it?

M3

1) Continuing from the electronics sector, why do you think we are lagging in electronics and chip manufacturing in India?

2) Now on Antiheroes, what are their characteristics?

3) What do you think a civil servant should be, a hero or an antihero?

4) But civil servants are often criticised for being aloof, even the PM said something about the image of officers recently. What do you think can be done to improve that?

5) Coming back to cinema, what do you know about impressionist cinema?

6) DO you know where cinema was first made?

M4

1) There are demands within UP for the bi/trifurcation of the state. Do you think it should be done?

2) Then why are such demands raised? In this case at least.

3) What is the process for splitting up or renaming of the states?

4) And what is the legal process for it?

5) What was the process followed in AP? You have lived there as per your DAF.

6) Now, what is the status of Article 370?

7) How was it done?

8) What articles were involved in the process?

Chairman (while leaving)

What is Natural Gas, CNG and LPG and what are their chemical composition?

Rajesh Kumar Mohan

Interview date : 2 september 2021

Board TCA Anant sir

Background : MBBS

CM: asked to take seat and read aload my daf.

1. For how long have you worked with Ordnance factories

2 Why did you leave that job

What are you doing now

3.What are your future plans

4. We need more Doctors or Civil servants

5. Tell me which CS with medical background worked nicely during 2nd wave

M1 female

1. You have stayed in chandigarh. Suppose you want to develop it as medical tourism hub. How will you do that.

2. What are 2 best and 2 bad things of TeleHealth

3. If you are posted at a distruct of NE India where infrastructure is not good. How will you ensure medicines reach there?

4. Name state govt using drone to delover medicines.

M2 male

1. Chandigarh is becoming a hub of drug abuse why ?

2. Recent changes in NDPS act. Are they good ?

3. What will you do resolve the drug problem?

M3 female

1. What are the common vector borne diseases in India

2. What can we learn from China

3. What should be done to tackle the problem of vector borne diseases in India

4. How will ragni help in solving attitudinal changes

5. How can ut be used in vector control.

M4

1. Lot of developmeng is happening around chandigarh like mohali and panchkula. Tell us about it

2. Comapre Haryana and Punjab in development

3. Why is Haryana doing good in sports.

4. But akhada culture is also resulting in criminal activities around ncr

5. What can be done to reduce the violence

Duration 26 minutes

K S

UG, PG - Commerce, IRTS

31st August '21

Smita Nagraj Ma'am's Board

Forenoon Session,

30-35 minutes

Good morning etc

Chairman:

Did you stay in your college hostel? How was the hostel experience?

Have you heard of Pinjra Tod?

Girls need to study, enjoy life. As warden what would you do to let them participate in college life.

Would you keep these rules equal for men and women?

What is one thing women face everywhere, now that you are out of institutions?

You know any cases of harassment?

Do people try and help? How do people help?

M1

Do you think this kind of harassment in metros comes under Vishakha Guidelines?

Have you heard of She-BOX? What's the progress?

Afghanistan issue. How did it go on for 20 years - tell from both US and Taliban side

Don't you think opium has to do something with this?

Covax and Vaccine Equity. What's the current status - and how is India contributing?

M2

AFG. Do you think USA was dithering on how to pull out?

Youtube. You would have access. Other kids don’t have access. Creates inequity. What issues do you anticipate?

What is role of coachings in education? What's the thought process behind the Chinese ban on it?

How do you think coaching need can come down. How to solve this?

Your thoughts on bullet train?

M3

Is the digital divide due to COVID or infrastructure?

What's the policy on EOL - is it choice?

Difference between a Vacation service and non vacation service?

What do you prefer micro-management or macro-management? Why? What's your reasoning?

Do you know of NEP? What are your thoughts on the 2-3-4 year exit programs?Have you read any research over how this works? Is it proven?

What do you know of NKN? Have you heard of it?

Tell me about Live-in relationships - sociological, economic, legal perspective?

M4

Tell me of the importance of community radio

Why Kerala 20000+ cases of COVID a day?

What of Seroprevalence?

What is Seroprevalence?

Health and education systems' role?

Nirbhaya fund - what is it, status of implementation?

Chairwoman: Okay. You may leave now.

N

Board - Manoj Soni

Date of interview - 27 August

Background - CA, Mcom

State - Gujarat

Optional - sociology

Hobbies - Trekking and Ecotourism

CM

About civil services decision nd all

5 places which are not tourist destination but have potential in Gujarat?

How will you promote tourism in such area??

M1

Criminalisation of politics - supreme court judgement and your opinion

Bhutan tourism (follow up from my previous answer)

M2

Gandhiji ideology about Governance?

About kutch region?

Caste census - positives & negatives

White desert - reason

M3

About somnath temple

Harami nala in kutch

Places you trek?

What all things you consider while preparing for trekking?

Next place you want to trek?

M4

Considering all your education background, you might be interested in share market??

Should pension and PF invest in share market?

Marriage as institutions changing - how, why and impact on society?

Should we tax agriculture income?? Who has authority??

A V

Date -2nd September

Morning session, 1st to go

Board- Smita Nagraj ma'am

BTech (ECE)

Optional- Anthropology

Place- Prayagraj, Uttar Pradesh

Chairperson :

- What are you doing these days?

- Did you notice any change in the ethos of your city after it's name was changed?

- Govt says that it makes decisions based on people's will , how does the govt get to know what people want?

-Recently, T.N. govt made a decision to appoint female priests. What's your take on that?

Should the state intervene in religious matters?( 2-3 minutes discussion )

You can answer in yes/no .

- Should the will of the majority override the will of minority?

- How will you decide whose voice is to be heard?

M1

- The literacy levels are low in india.

What can you do about adult literacy?

- Tell me about Nirbhaya scheme.

- What are the challenges with it's implementation.

- Online Gaming affects young children, in several ways.What can be done about it.

Should the state regulate it?

M2

- We see the situation in Afghanistan, the blasts at Kabul Airport, how do you see the future of Afghanistan?

- Should India recognise Taliban?

- Tell me about maritime security being talked about at UNSC?

- US transgressed India's maritime boundary. Was India's stand just?

- What does UNCLOS do?

- How can we control the pollution in Delhi?

M3

- You've studied Anthropology, it is often said that women anthropologists did not make enough efforts to study women centric issues.

Your take on that?

- Since you mentioned Ruth Benedict, do you recall her contribution and study about WWII

- What did the female Anthropologists study in India's context?

M4-

- Western scholars say that marriages in India are imposed.

Your take?

- Digital divide.

- Did covid pandemic create this divide, or it existed earlier?

- Take on live-in relationships.

Does it happen in rural settings too?

There's a possibility that it does, but we don't know about it?

Chairperson- Your interview is over.

No questions from hobbies and graduation subject.

Transcript

Anonymous

TCA ANANT BOARD

Management graduate

Afternoon - 4th to go

Hobby- newspaper reading, web series

Chairman-

1. What were you doing since graduation

2. Effect of amazon/flipkart on retail stores(follow up question)

M-

fundamental duties?

From where they are borrowed?

Which amendment?

Which article?

Do people follow FD?

Question on economic and cultural contribution of devi ahilya?

Teaching from college fest?

Top 3 moments from college life?

Top five potential micro-entrepreneurship opportunity in your city of residence?

Decline of newspaper (hobby related)?

Should should OTT be censored ?

Question on Marxism....it's relevance

Kerala has 'god's own country' what does your state have(slogan)?

Some follow up question

How newspaper can be made profitable

Two female penalists were there

On couple of questions I could not answer quickly so they either gave hint or moved on

In between the interview when a panelist was asking some question, chairman asked what was name of your college fest(related to question)

UPSC STAFF WAS VERY CORDIAL AND SUPPORTIVE

T S

03-09-20, Forenoon Batch, 3rd to go

RN Chobey Sir Board

DAF : Kerala, Doctor

Optional : Malayalam Lit.

Hobbies : Violin, Stand – up Comedy, Malayalam Novels, Indoor Gardening

Time- 11 am, approx 30 mins

The panel members were not wearing masks. There was no lady member present.

Chairman : Kindly take off your mask and place it on the table in front of you.

We are here to have a conversation with you. This is not an interrogation. If there is any question that you do not understand, do not hesistate to ask again. If you do not know an answer, you are free to say I don’t know. We do not expect you to know everything.

1. By what name would you prefer us calling you?

2. Please introduce yourself professionally.

3. What is your opinion on bringing doctors under the Consumer Protection Act?

Member 1

1. You have heard about the NEP 2020. Will it lead us closer to SDGs in 2030?

2.How will the adaptation of vernacular languages help?

3. Will the multiple- entry, multiple exit provision lead to more dropouts?

4. How will the new developments in Afghanistan affect the economy of Kerala?

5. Is Euthanesia currently permitted in India? What is your opinion regarding permitting Euthanasia?

6. Kerala has done very well in COVID management during the first wave. However, the cases are increasing now. Why?

Member 2

1. What is your opinion regarding granting combat roles to women in army? If you are on a medical board granting the same, will you set the same standards for men and women?

2. The government is giving more importance to traditional medicine systems now. Do you support equal importance for all the systems of medicine?

3. What is your take on granting Ayurveda doctors the right to perform surgery?

4. You have shown an interest in watching stand – up comedy. Comedy is comedy. But there have been many issues now following many comedy acts. Where should we draw the line in performance of comedy?

5. At this point the Chairman interrupted and asked me in which language I watch stand- up comedy and asked me about Indian Stand –up comedians

Member 3

1.Are mental health issues more prevalent among the women in Kerala? If so why?

2. Kerala was never really under any foreign rule. Is this statement true?

3. There is a place in Kerala called Sultan Battery. How did this place get its name?

4. You studied in Alappuzha. What are the issues affecting the place called Kuttanad?

5. What is the government doing to protect the farmers of Kuttanad?

6.Which is the major community in Alappuzha? What is the native language term for the community?

Member 4

1. I would like to ask one more question from Kerala. Why is there a huge problem of dowry in Kerala?

2. Suppose you are working in the Foreign affairs ministry during the time of previous minister Sushama Swaraj. Iran offers to give us oil at a very low price and the offer appears very attractive. But to get the deal, they ask that the minister go for the meeting wearing a Burkha. How would you advice the minister to proceed with the deal?

3. Would you apply the same standards while negotiating with Afghanistan regarding gender equality?

4. Is India taking the same stand about gender equality in the case of Saudi Arabia?

Chairman

We have asked you everything we need to ask. Is there something you would like us to talk about?

All the best. Your interview is over. You may leave.

Hello. This is my upsc interview transcript..

Shri:

Hi. This is my upsc interview transcript

-------------------

SD

Relevant info

B tech ece

Jharkhand

Sociolog

Hobby - making decorative greeting cards, doodling

Date - 31 August

Chair

1st explained everything cordially.

1 agr. Don't you think govt shouldn't club non telecom revenue

2

M1

1 you from ece. Role of drone

2 is it threat or any positives also

3 social media how it helps in spreading disinformation.

M2

You sociology. Tell me reltuon between max weber and industrialisation.

2 what did he say about capitalism

M3

1 what is impact of taliban rule on women and children

2 why India worried

3 impact on Pakistan

M4

1. Do you think coz of ict, impact on sanskritization

2 impact of reservation policy on sanskritization

3 do you think sanskritization still happening if you see around

Chair

SC amended constitution. Do you think this is right

Anything you want to say to us. I said baiut my hobby.

He said ok say something about it.

Whats difference between doodling and sketching.

OK candidate. It was nice talking to you.

V C

Profile

Indian Trade Service

2nd Attempt

Civil engineering from NIT KKR

Sociology Optional

Home state Madhya Pradesh

Hobbies Tennis, Volleyball,Trekking

TCA Anant

Chairman: Which all treks have you gone to?

Member 1: Switzerland and Himachal have similar potential but why Himachal lags behind Switzerland in tourism

2. If you are made tourism secretary what would you do?

3 What is carbon Neutral City ( Related to Daf)

Member 2

1 .Lot of landslides in Hilly Regions,suggest some civil Engineering solutions.

2 During rains roads get weathered down, suggest solutions.

3 You have been in Bhilai, how to replicate such planning across India.

4.What is role of citizens in Smart City

Member 3

1.Sand mafia issue in Mp..What is being done?

2.Alternatives to river sand?

3.Mp is home to such diverse population, how is it beneficial and problematic?

4.Which sector or factor exacerbate communalism?

Member 4

1. Split of MP and CG,20 years down the line, how do you see the benefits both states have reaped.

2 Latest Civil Engineering technology being used for construction

A C

03/09/21

Afternoon Batch, 3rd to go

Smita Nagaraj Board

Optional: Political Science and IR

DAF: Kerala, Btech EEE, currently working as State Coordinator for Tamil Nadu in Ministry of Social Justice

Projects: Electricity price prediction model at Adani, PwC Offshore Wind project, Urban planning evaluation of Panaji (Goa)

Time - 3pm, approximately 30 minutes

Face shield was not required, all members were wearing masks but they removed while speaking except the Chairperson.

Chairperson

• Please tell me what you are currently doing.

• Have you started monitoring projects? What are the states assigned to you?

• What was the process of selection for your job?

• Was the group discussion effectively conducted by the organisation?

• Do you think group discussions can be a reliable way to judge relative merit in UPSC?

• Do you think Adani Group is overstretching itself by expanding into multiple sectors?

• Do you think that government should have put restrictions on bidding for Adani as they have been given far too many airports for instance?

• Why IFS as your first preference?

• What are the regions from where maximum remittances are sent to India?

Member 1

• Elaborate about benefits/demerits of legal aid and especially with respect to Kerala

• What are the issues on the ground in the implementation of Lok Adalats?

• If you were appointed to spread awareness about the rights given by the Consumer Protection Act, what are the steps you would take?

• Kindly elaborate about the issue of women empowerment in Kerala even though it is a highly literate state that had matriarchal communities

• Do you think reservation for women is necessary in this regard

• You are using the term normative, do you mean Normative Theory by "x" author (don't remember)

Member 2

• What is the southernmost point of India?

• What is the strategic significance of Andaman and Nicobar Islands?

• What is meant by AFSPA and describe the special powers it grants?

• Do you think it should be applied continuously or intermittently to a region and give reasons for your stand

• Toddy is a big part of Kerala culture and is available freely, do you think it is a reason for alcoholism in Kerala

• What are the reasons for alcoholism to prevail in Kerala society, especially among men?

• Does data support the statement that alcoholism is quite prevalent in Kerala

Member 3

• Why is the diaspora split among NRI, OCI and PCI? Give reasons for such a classification

• If you were the Ambassador to Doha, how would you safeguard India's interests while making contact with the Taliban?

• How would we prevent alignment of Afghanistan with China and Pakistan?

• Is vaccine diplomacy a way forward in Afghanistan?

• What is your opinion about vaccine diplomacy of India?

• Do you think it was the right step?

• What is the Alappuzha model that has won global acclaim?

Member 4

• Tell me about issues with the SCA to SCSP scheme and Tribal sub plan

• You worked at PwC, tell me the differences in auditing in private and government firm

• (Chairperson interrupted and asked me what vertical I worked in)

• You have mentioned a project in electricity sector, tell me the future vision that you have in mind about the electricity sector

• With respect to DISCOMS, what is the way forward especially as UDAY scheme has not succeeded?

• You have done project on urban planning as well, what is your opinion about the issues with urban planning in India?

Chairperson

• Held up my photo and asked me to remove my mask

• Thank you, your interview is over

Just Chull

1/09/2021

Board- TCA ANANT SIR

Forenoon session

PSIR

25 min.approx

Ch- long term implications of taliban takeover on Inida.

No border with India de facto still terror threat from there. Why?

What if inclusive govt is not there in Afg?

M1- how r our relations in neighbourhood?

Any improvement?

What changes from look east to act east?

Probelms with neighbours and possible solutions.

M2- what Haryana govt doing in sports?

Which other govts?

M3- what lessons can we learn from Afg forces' defeat by just 70k numbered taliban?( corruption, leadership.. he then added commitment to the nation, thanked him)

As DC what steps to reduce corruption among subordinates?( here Chairperson asked an example of tech being used for corruption problm, I mentioned PDS then he asked how it reduced corruption in PDS and after that he smiled)

M4- What e governance initiatives will u take as DC apart from existing ones( took from tech I mentioned in previous ans)

As DC what skill dev missions apart from existing ones for women in Haryana?

Chairperson - Thank you.

Overall very cordial board.

No counter questions, no grilling, listening very patiently even to a 3 minutes answer.

Don't be stressed with mock interviews' review, you'll face altogether diff environment and questions.

All you need to do is remain calm and confident.

Don't expect anything like they will comfort u or smile( neither happened in my case) but yes they will be very cordial for sure.

All the Best.

Transcript

Anonymous

3 September

Afternoon, 5th to go

TCA Anant sir board

Graduation: Bachelor in Physiotherapy

State: Uttarakhand

DAF tags: Travelling, Cooking North Indian food, Surya namaskar, Volunteered a team to teach underprivileged children

Chairman sir: Why Civil services( generalist ) after BPT( specialist) ?

How will you use this subject in administration?

Why only North Indian cooking?

Member 1

Where do you travel? What steps should be taken to boost tourism in your state?

An example where a citizen does not recognize the rights of other citizen?

Follow up qs: About Swachh Bharat Mission, it's relevance, shortcomings and corrective measures.

Member 2( Lady)

Online Yoga classes: Pros and cons.

Technological advancements in Physiotherapy.

Member 3( Lady)

Me too movement: Why? How it affected women at large? Shortcomings?

Follow up qs on gender sensitization.

HC( Uttarakhand) granting legal entity status to Ganga. Why? It's implications.

Member 4

Bionic arm

Biopharma mission

Rishikesh ( My hometown) : Changes in past few years, what steps are being taken to correct these adverse changes?

Chairman: Your interview is over. Thank you.

Lasted around 20-25mins

The board was cordial and responsive:)