Interviews

UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 2 Sep 2021 (West…)

2 Sep 2021

Interview Transcript

Laxman Tiwari

IPS, PSIR

21/08/21

Smita Nagraj Ma’am Board, Forenoon- 3rd to go.

Chairperson

⁃ Your Cadre

⁃ Why so much violence in West Bengal(don’t tell about political violence)?

⁃ Policing challenges in Bengal?

⁃ How policing is different in Bengal from Bihar?

⁃ How to deal with communal violence and Caste violence?

⁃ Why no Peace committee in Caste based violence?

⁃ Will you take legal action in Communal violence cases?

⁃ SDM Lathicharge- GOOD OR BAD?

⁃ Do you think that our education system is based on giving degrees?

⁃ How to improve employability?

Member- 1

⁃ what is Nation State?

⁃ Appointment of SC judges, Models of appointment?

⁃ What kind of federalism in appointment of judges in India?

⁃ Is India a Federal state- Justify?

⁃ Is NEP just reiterating what already have been done?

Member-2

⁃ Why adult literacy needed?

⁃ Should we have a national plan for this?

⁃ Is it justified to educate adults under MNREGA?

⁃ Conviction rate is very low in India, what reforms needed in entire CJS?

⁃ Which vacancy should be filled first- IPS or Constables?

Member-3

⁃ Is it justified to keep a draconian law like Sedition in our democracy?

⁃ Why china being aggressive towards India?

⁃ Why Tawang is important for China?

⁃ What should be our strategy to counter china?

⁃ Why china claims South China Sea?

⁃ Name of country has dispute in South China sea but not a member of UN.

Member-5

⁃ What is string of pearls?

⁃ What are we doing to counter it?

⁃ Why south china sea is important for the world?

⁃ Why china did not accept World court’s’ judgement?

⁃ Why china wants to alter world order?

⁃ How can developing nations plan an action to counter china?

⁃ What is happening in Afghanistan?

⁃ Has India lost strategic position in Afghanistan?

⁃ Why India did not recognise Taliban?

⁃ What security challenges India face from Afghanistan?

⁃ What can we do?

Chairperson

⁃ What is our current strategy in Afghanistan?

⁃ Should we talk to Taliban? ( I said we should keep the option open given our traditional strategic sphere there. She asked to take a stand. I said Yes we can talk to them to protect our interests. I reiterated that there are multiple factions of Taliban who favour relationship with India, we can engage with them)

Thank You, Your Interview is over.