UPSC interview, Air Marshal Bhonsle board, 28 Aug 2021
28 Aug 2021
Interview Date : 26 .08.2021 [ AfterNoon , 3rd member to GO]
Graduation : Computer science & engineering , SASTRA University
Home district , East champaran(Bihar ) college : Thanjavur
Previous work ex: RINL , ONGC
Current : IRS (IT) 2020 (EOL )
chairman : Air Marshal A. S. Bhonsle
Interview duration : 35-40 minutes
Chairman
Asked me to remove the face-mask & face shield for photo verification . Said that we want to take 1 minute break and within that 1 minute you can use face wipe to clean your face and spectacles and also may drink water if you want. I did all and settle myself down.
After that , he explained the process about interview and also said that I may use Hindi or english both if i want. he also mentioned the one thing they want is that .. listen and understand the question very carefully and then respond after thinking.
He started reading information from my DAF like 10th school , 12th school , college , job , places i lived , my hobbies , achievement and leadership section information.
Asked about my college name and also my CGPA (is it a misprint )
He said lets start our formal interview Now
1.Tell me unique thing about Bridheshwar temple
2.What is unique about its nandi bull
3.what is unique about its Gopuram
4.Thanjavur sambhar is also very famous & what is the reason ? [did not know] => later he said you are not expected to know this ..
5.National education policy has 3C : critical thinking , creativity and collaboration What is collaboration in context of NEP ? [ talked about collaboration between Higher institutes of India with International institutes ]
6.Can you think about other type of collaboration which is possible [ Talked about interdisciplinary collaboration among different branches and streams , also about collaboration institute of national importance with private institutes etc
7.NEP is focusing on teaching the trainers : What are the steps taken by GOI to train the teachers ?
8.Follow up 1-2 question on that
MEMEBR 1 [LADY member ]
9. Lets come back to thanjavur again .. why it is famous [ talked about rice bowl of TN , Thanjavur painting , Saint Thagyaraja & Grand anicut Dam ]
10 . Why thanjavur painting is famous ?
11. why is there less startup in IIT ?
12. 1/2 follow up question on IIT ?
13. What engineers are coming to administrative job ? is it right ?
14. What are the issues with ONGC ?
15. How Information technology can help in improving ONGC performance ?
16. You were earning good in ONGC .. then why civil services ?
Member 2
17. What is unique about EAST champaran ?
18 . Can you tell me why Champaran satyagraha movement ?
19. why the steel prices were going up in pandemic ?
20 . 1/2 follow up question on that steel pricing and china supply chain disruption ?
21. You are from PSIR .. why there is visible shift from India -russia Bohemia to India - usa relation even we consider usa is not trusted partner ?
22. follow up question on that
23. You are in IRS .. Can you tell what one thing we can do to improve the tax collection ?
24. Any one thing which can improve the tax collection immediately ?
25. Should agriculture be taxed ?
Member 3
26. what are the recent development in the field of computer science ?
27 is technology is good ?
28. how can be we ensure that it remains good ?
29. what is the story behind name motihari ? [ gave 2 stories ]
30. which do you believe ?
31. What is the NIRF rank and Times rank of IIT D ? [ sir i don’t know... oh you don’t know this about your alma matter .. he thought i am from IITD .. clarified that I am from SASTRA university ]
32. Discussion back from IITD to ONGC .. what is production capacity of Bombay high and how much we able to recover ?
33. Recent incident about ONGC in Arabian sea
34. What went wrong there ?
35. Suppose you are made of incharge of such situation ? How will you ensure such incident did not happen ?
36. 1 follow up question on that and tell me 2 projects which you worked in ongc
Member 4 [Lady member .. not very much convinced ]
37. 1 question on Tamilnadu [ not able to recall]
38. You went from Bihar to TN for your graduation .. How did you manage your food .. [ every body laughed in that answer when i mention biryani being the true friend ]
39. why idli is nutritious ?
40. Blue revolution and its significance
41. You are from PSIR .. Can you tell how does the political map of india is chaining since last 10 years ? [ Misunderstood this questions .. first talked about India map issues on external front on Nepal , PAK and china ==> she said no no I am asking with respect to Centre - state : I talked about federals issues ] ==> she was expecting me to talk changes with respect to damn diu , UT of Jammu and ladakh etc //
chairman
42. what will you do after going from here ?
[ Interview ends ... could not answer last 2 question on expected line ]
SK
BB vyas board
Time: 30 minutes
Optional: chemistry
Dept: Aerospace
25th August, first one to go, afternoon slot
Very calming ambience in the room
Chairman
Interesting department!! (Aerospace)
Doesn't india need aerospace engineer?
Tell me difference between supersonic and hypersonic?
What is open skies treaty?
Drones, new age warfare?
In which region, did drones play crucial role?(Armenia VS Azerbaijan)
What should india do to improve drone sector?
What are the various regulators in civil aviation sector?
Any idea on recent Aircraft amendment Act?
What is your opinion on increasing exports and decreasing imports?
Have you heard Toykathon?
Seems you are against import substitution? (Yup), why?
What are India's top five imports?
What is liquidity trap?
Member 1
Why carbon has lot of compounds unlike silicon?(catenation)
Why Aluminium is extremely combustible?
Any idea on 2-DG by DRDO?
What is scram jet and ramjet?
What are the fuels used in this engine?
Which part of chemistry are you interested in?(genetics)?
What is the use of genome sequencing?(in reference to corona virus)
?
Member 2
What do you know about gas turbine, steam turbine engine?( Not much sir)
Then what are the engine you use in jet aircrafts?
Elaborate on recent changes to FCRA?
Caste census, should government go ahead?
What is the reason for increasing amount of floods?
Member 3
What is inclusive government/governance?
As a administrator how would you bring about it?
Small is beautiful book have you read it?
Any relavance of this topic in governance?
Tokyo Olympics in this crisis, waste of money and indifferent to people suffering isn't it ?
Member 4
Soft power with reference to india
Role of DGCA?
Power is driver of industry? What does it mean? Explain it with real life?
Date of Interview : 23/08/2021, AN, 4th to go
Board : Manoj Soni Sir
Background : B Tech Chemical Engg IIT B
Optional : Mathematics
Home City/State : Lucknow/UP
Hobbies : Reading non-fiction books esp. on international relations
[2 members on either side were seated quite close to the candidate; arrangement made it difficult to maintain eye-contact with all of them]
Chairman
1. You're from the City of Nawabs, do you also carry the attitude of Nawabs?
2. You studied from ICSE school. How do you think it is different from CBSE or state board, from the experience of your friends?
3. You also lived in Mumbai. Any life lesson you learnt in Mumbai?
4. Did you learn Marathi? Did you try Marathi food? A short conversation on Parsi food from my answer
5. Did you enjoy the city of Mumbai?
6. What is the role of the youth, and not the govt, in making India a Vishwa Guru by 2047? [The Chairman here tried to unsettle me a bit]
M1
1. Why the shift from Chemical Engg to civil services?
2. What will be the impact of disruptive technologies?
3. Impact of technology on bureaucracy in the next 15 yrs?
4. What changes can we make to bureaucracy to better adapt?
5. Which IR book you read recently. Tell me about it.
6. Do you think decision of President Biden to withdraw from America is wrong or do they have something else in mind?
7. How will the importance of West Asia change in the future?
M2
1. Did you sit for campus placements?
2. What is doctrine of lapse? How was it applied in case of Awadh?
3. Impact of technology like digitisation on a poor country like India. List negative social and economic impacts.
4. How is tech useful in the long term? How does tech lead to creation of new jobs? Would not driverless cars lead to joblessness?
5. What are bad banks? Are we not rewarding inefficiency of banking system through them?
6. Why was AMUL model of cooperatives not replicated in sectors other than dairy? Was it because in Amul govt had provided initial support?
7. Have you heard of "bleed India by a thousand cuts"? What is it and why?
M3
1. What are pharmaceutical and non-pharmaceutical interventions?
2. What is the use of referring Bills to Parliamentary Committees? Do they also fix accountability on the govt?
3. Coming to Afghanistan, tell me short term impacts of takeover by Taliban on India.
4. Now, tell me long term impacts.
5. You mentioned China. Why is China involved in Afghanistan? What will they gain from a friendly Taliban?
6. What should be India's immediate priority in Afghanistan?
7. Does the international community have a role in Afghanistan or are they helpless?
8. But do you think sanctions are effective?
9. If you are Perm Rep of India to UN, and UN is discussing whether to give humanitarian aid to Afg or impose sanctions on it, how will you address this issue?
M4
1. Tell me the most important landmark of Lucknow. What is its speciality? Anything you remember about its roof?
2. I think Residency is more famous. Your view? Which will be more famous internationally?
3. PM mentioned energy independence for India by 2047. What does he mean?
4. Based on the data you quoted, do you think we can even achieve independence?
5. Since you mentioned tidal, let’s talk about oceans. How does climate change lead to acidification?
[I could barely hear the last word, politely asked the member to repeat]
6. What will be the impact of acidification?
7. Our islands depend on sea water for drinking water. How will they be impacted from acidification?
Chairman
Thank you. Your interview is over. Stay safe and have a pleasant evening!
Overall, the board was very cordial and polite. They were eager to have a conversation and not a cross-examination (just as mentioned in PT syllabus). Even though the board’s interviews that day were delayed, they did not rush and gave adequate time to answer. The questions were asked mostly from DAF.
P.S. Snacks were available generously! :P
P.P.S. Stay calm and give your best!
BB Vyas sir
Optional geography
Bihar, worked in IMD,
Presently IPS trainee
Questions..
1..difference between paramilitary and CAPF
2.. Are theatre commands necessary for India
3..should there be civilian control over police and forces
4..how to encourage parents for allowing students to make sports as career
5..govt efforts on evehicles
6..vehicle scrapping policy
7..what is govt doing for green economy
8..women contribution in green economy
9..why does monsoon occur
10..how to reduce corruption in police
11..difference in structure of diamond and graphite
Shruti
Vyas Sir board
26th August
Afternoon 1st to go
Chairman :
1. You are the 1st one to come. How do you feel?
2. Given a chance, which slot would you choose?
3. India Japan relationship
4. What is missing middle?
5. What is cultural relativism? It's relevance today?
6. What is pesa act?
M1:
1. What is UIDAI?
2. Need for aadhar?
3. Difference between aadhar and voter id?
4. Who can get voter id?
M2:
1. How are banks doing in india?
2. Issues in banking?
3. How to reduce crimes against elderly?
4. Which is important primary education or higher education?
M3
1. What is leath machine?
2. What is FCRA? Need?
3. What MHA is doing to enforce FCRA?
4. How does UPS work?
M4:
1. What is ecofriendly behaviour?
2. Why are elements arranged so in periodic table?
3. Why prism is used?
Chairman :
All the best. You may leave now.
Jack
11th August
Smita maharaj Mam board
Btech mechanical engineering,
Work experience - Automobile industry, coaching industry
PSIR Optional
Watching football - hobby
Chairman - Role of coaching in competitive exams?
Difference between JEE and UPSC CSE exam process?
How to make the examination process better?
M1 - what you learnt in your past jobs that you can apply as a civil servant?
Why chose PSIR and not Mechanical Engineering?
Learning from Football that you can apply as a civil servant?
M2 - Should Delhi be given full statehood?
Issues of pollution in Delhi? How to tackle it?
IPCC Latest reports, Paris Agreement?
Refrigerants used in AC, it's impact on climate?
LPG vs PNG?
M3 - Solid waste management in Delhi?
Waste to energy plants in Delhi?
BS VI Emission standards - pros and cons
M4 - why automobile industry so successful in Chennai?
Impact of high customs duty on automobile sector
A K
Date: 25.08.2021
Board: Sathyavathi.
4th to Go, Forenoon.
Background: Chemical Engineering at NIT Tiruchirappalli, Group B employee at ICMR, Editor of College Magazine
Hobbies: Reading Science Fiction, Writing and Listening to Podcasts.
75% of the personality test was DAF based, some current affairs topics also included.
Room was brightly lit, members sit spaced out, observing from each direction facing you.
Chairperson reads out entire DAF with key points.
What is your role at your current office?
Why working there after studying at a good college like NIT?
What is ICMR doing currently? What role your institute playing in it?
(Made a small technical error with a word here, ma’am asked about it. Apologized and clarified the term. Seemed satisfied)
What does the result of the serosurvey indicate? Is it being doing nationally or just locally?
So, what must be done now?
Are you playing a role in genome sequencing?
Member 1:
Tell about your final year project. Asked me to clarify certain aspects.
So, what is the impact of SO2 emissions generally?
Can you tell me about Doha agreement between USA and Taliban?
Are the Taliban following the terms agreed upon?
Member 2:
So you like Science Fiction Writing? Do you write other kinds of fiction too?
Do you like watching Science Fiction Movies as well?
Who is your favourite author?
What do you like about his stories? (I had mentioned Asimov) Any key concepts you liked?
Will humanity be able to reach the level of Science Fiction?
Tell me 2 moves of China in Indian Ocean Region and 2 Counter efforts by India.
One more question that I cannot recall.
Member 3: (Seemed unimpressed by any answer I gave)
Do you believe India is a blessing for the world? (This is from economic survey, but I talked about culture and history - the answer was the India is the pharmacy of the world)
Asked about Medical Technologies - I started to answer about medical tourism, but he interrupted and said to talk about medical technologies. I apologized and he accepted.
He mentioned that pharma industries are polluting. What can be done about them. Short discussion where I mentioned some points. He said ‘we are already doing those things’. I said politely that more can be done sir.
Then he said that in ITIs, there are few courses on chemical industry. What can be done about it.
Member 4:
As a neutral observer, how would you say India has handled the COVID pandemic?
Do you know about OFB, what can you tell me about it.
Is it a good move by government to corporatize them?
Tell me about demographic dividend and demographic disaster.
Where is India at present?
So, why is there unemployment in India?
I felt it was a good experience. One member was constantly making notes while others were observing keenly. One member was not impressed despite all I mentioned. Chairperson was very cordial. Good luck, everyone else. Do not fear. Fear is the mindkiller.
M
Manoj soni sir board
26 August
Name: Meera
Daf details: state- kerala, sociology optional, btech in mechanical engineering
Chairman:
Why were you named meera? Is it connected to mirabai?
Who was mirabai?
Why sociology? Have you tried internalising the discipline?
Sociologically analyse the relevance of mirabai
Why was her reformative approach in caste and gender not sustained in the future?
M1
Why corona is spreading so much in kerala- give 2 main reasons.
What is happiness index?
Is spirituality an important aspect of happiness? If so, how?
Given a choice, between a totalitarian government with a very high economic development and democracy which one would you pick?
It is said that a poor man can do any crime. What's the point of democracy if people are not safe from crimes?
Do you think china will have a revolution in the next 10-20 years?
Has there been any pro democratic movements in china?
M2
Why did you choose mechanical engineering?how was your experience?
What are brownfield projects?
What is the government trying to do in the monetisation plan?
What do you mean by vision?
How do you define yourselves with your strengths?
What are your weaknesses?
M3
How would you use your mechanical engineering knowledge to bring about mechanisation of agriculture in your district?
Where will you source the money from?
What is the recent ipcc report about? What is the rate of warming?
How will it impact kerala?
M4
Opinion on girls in NDA
Sexual violence against prisoners of war
Is newspaper a social media?
Give 3 reasons to regulate social media and 3 reasons not to
Do you think social media can really be controlled? If so, how?
Chairman
If given a chance would you change your name- pick a name from the 3 Yashoda, Rukmini and Radha.
PS
Date 24 Aug 2021
R.N.Choubey Sir
Morning 3rd to go
Background-Production Sandwich Engineering,
PSIR,Mentoring,Auditor,Maharashtra.
Chairperson
Welcomed me.Asked to remove face mask if have RTPCR negative.
We are good people.This is not police interrogation keep smiling just like you are now.If you dont get voice ask to repeat.If you dont know say dont know .we know that everything cant be remembered. If you are not clear say im not clear.Where are you staying?Have you done breakfast.Shall I arrange some snacks for you ? Etc .(made me comfort).
1.Tell me your academic and work experience.
2.I will give a statement and tell me your opinion
-GST is compromise on fiscal fedaralism.
3.What if MH govts right to decide taxing is depend on Bihar Govt?Is it against your right to vote?
4.Should we Recognise Taliban ?If not then how will
India convey its interest?
M1(Not ready to convince easily)
1.What is Production sandwich Engineering?
2.I think Engineers should not be allowed in civil services.They are needed more in industries and other economic activity at present.
3.Do you think its wastage of Governments Money?
Partially if not completely.
4.I will give proposal tell me your opinion.
I think youth should not be given SDM and DM post.They do not have experience and some are arrogant.I feel that rather a person with age 50 should be given that post and continue that person till his/her wish to serve.Your views on my proposal.
M2
1.Why china came in Ladakh ?why chinas agression ?
2.In which country judges dont get retired?
3.In india today there is news that Tamilnadu CM is no 1.What he has done there ?
M3
1.Why MH is no 1 In GDP despite states like Gujarat and Karnataka is also trying hard to get it?
2.What about Ambanis and Tatas role ?
3.Which form of corruption is worst?Legislative,Judiciary or Executives?
4.In Pandemic many schools are off.Children are out of school.Tell me 3 ways to revive it.
M4
1.Indias constitution is longest.Right?
2.Tell me 2 things we borrowed from USSR.
3.How many fundamental duties in Indian constitution?
4.Are fundamental duties enforceable?Shall we make it punitive?
5.How to promote fundamental duty?
6.If you are DM then how will you ensure citizens participation?
7.Do you think Gramsabha is failure ?
8.Your views on naming of cities,roads,rewriting history etc. What should we do?
(In between one member said Shakespeares dialogue and everyone started laughing)
Chairperson
We have asked what we have to.Do you want to say something.
(I answered regarding Engineering, industry and governance)
Chaiperson-We appreciate you for this.We are happy to intetact with you.All the best.Your Interview is over.Thank You.