Interviews

UPSC interview, P. K. Joshi board, 6 Apr 2018 (Madhya…)

6 Apr 2018

Chairman - Shri PK Joshi

Optional - Management

Background - BTech, MBA, Work @ Credit Rating (1 yr)

Home State - Madhya Pradesh

Duration - 30 minutes

Sequence - 2nd to go

Observations

* All members were making vigorous notes

* All were generally stoic, except Chariman and M1 and M2 - they were smiling and nodding.

* Chairman - was keeping time per member - looked at watch 2-3 times. He was following strict 30 minutes time per candidate I guess.

Chairman

Hello, please have a seat

You belong to Andhra, but you have stayed in MP. How come ? Did your family stay there ?

Okay, you have studied from NIT Surathkal, IIM Calcutta, worked for almost an year, you are so qualified - you could have gotten any good job in the corporate. Why come to these services then.

What are you doing now

Where are you staying nowdays ? Since how long ?

I see you have done your schooling from Gwalior. Can you tell me importance of Gwalior ?

Okay, let us talk about management a bit. How is it possible that a company makes 150 Cr profit but is unable to pay back a loan of 12 lakhs.

Okay, so lets say you are working for a bank. What ratios will you check before giving a loan to a company

Member 1 (Male)

You spoke about Gwalior, why did the Scindias come to Gwalior from Maharashtra ?

Can you tell me something about the Gwalior Fort. When and why was it built ?

Okay, so you have lived in Mumbai, Delhi and Kolkata. Can you compare these three cities on Air Traffic, Culture and Quality of life ?

Can you tell me how many million passengers each of these airports handle ? A ball park ?

Okay, in Madhya Pradesh there is a place called Sanchi. What is its importance ? What is the place ? Who built it ?

So, US has put some import curbs on steel. What is its implication for India ? Is there an implication ?

Can you estimate in billions the loss we will have

Is it right for America to do this? What can India do ?

Member 2 (Female)

What is the connection of the Scindias and Raja Ravi Varma ?

Okay, you play the guitar, who is your favourite guitarist? Only one?

So, you have done Computer Engineering. Tell me how would you teach to an 8th class student about the history of computers ?

No no, thats all fine. How would you create and hold their interest

Good, who all will you tell them about

Recently the MP government has passed a bill that awards death penalty for Child Rape. Do you think its justified ?

So all cases of rape should get death penalty. The SC has said only in "rarest of rare" cases. Is murder for murder right ?

Is death penalty the only deterrent in such cases ?

Member 3 (Male) (On DAF)

What is this Tata Social Enterprise Challenge ? What was your role in it ?

What is the contribution of the Tatas for social welfare in the country ?

(interjected)How is Tata Memorial a contribution ?

There is another educational institute that the Tatas have been associated for long. Do you know ?

(Nodding with dissmissal) Dont you think IISc ?

Member 4 (Male) (pressure guy)

Chairman - "Paani pee lo agar chahiye to"

Member 4 again

There is a recent call for creamy layer for the SC/STs. Do you think there should be a creamy layer ?

Good, why ?

Dont compare them to the OBCs. What about the rich SC/STs using resources meant for poor one ? There is no benefit for the poor.

But economic criteria is not the only criteria in creamy layer

No no, its not the major criteria. There are many other more important criteria than economic criteria. (Spoke a bit more) Okay, lets move on

Talking about human evolution, there have been many discoveries which are so old. But there is one in MP that goes way beyond most. Do you know about it ? (Bhimbetka)

How old are they?

Who discovered them? Indian or Foreigner ?

Have you visited?

What is so striking about these caves ?

Yes, the paint still looks fresh like painted this morning

How far is it from Bhopal

Okay, you spoke about Rani Lakshmibai. Was her story with Scindias a story of tragedy or valour ?

No no, from the point of view of Scindias, what they did wit

h her. Was it tragedy or valour ?

Okay, can the Scindias enter Jhansi even today ?

They cannot (Lady member - is it so ?) Yes yes, "aaj bhi vo Jhansi mein kadam nai rakh sakte" (All members had a laugh) (I smiled)

Chairman

Looked at the watch (it was exactly 30 minutes).

Okay, thank you.

3rd April, Forenoon

April 5th morning session

Last one to go

Optional: law

Hobby: travel, tiger enthusiast

BS bassi sir

Ch: you are not an engineer thats good

1)how’s your health?

2)Whats the use of preamble?

3)Have you attended moot courts?

M1:

1)jaipur whats the problem gahshsggdhdbdsnsvdvgdh

2) so how will you ghdhdhdbshsvav

3) i am saying gshshfddhddbdb

{lady member intervenes smiling} how will you improve the situation he meant.

3) have you been to rural areas hdgdgsgsgsgsb problems?

Lady member

1) which country will you travel if given funds

2) why?

M2

1) law is an ass?

2) is it?

3) long statement about pendency

Why is there pendency. Didn’t give time to respond.

4) undertrials dying is it wrong?

5) long statement again

6) you had commerce in class 12. Tell me bacisc of accountancy (no idea)

7) essentials of financial impropriety? (No idea)

M3

1) how many tigers in india? Steps taken to protect them?

2) whats mens rea?

3) canadian pm came. Do we have a good relationship with canada?

CM

1)What are biodiversity hotspots?

2)Sariska problems?

3)Recently saudi said something about Israel. Analyze. Good or bad?

P.K Joshi, afternoon, last one to go

Law graduate

IPoS

Jaipur

Optional Law

Total time: 20 mins

Chairman:

1. Read out my DAF loud.

2.difference between pledge and mortgage.

3. Mistake of fact under what statute, which sections?

4. Gauri shukla case, law of contract.

5 another case law on contract act.

6. When was PIN code introduced?

M1

1. do we need to amend IPC due to compoundable and non- compoundable cases?

2. A situation question on that.

3. What are compoundable and non compoundable cases.

4.What are principles of natural justice?

5. Is rti law good or bad?

6. What relief a person has if CIC refuses information?

7. Exceptions to RTI?

8. Fine for fake applications? Fine for denying information?

M2

1. Justice should not only be done but must also appear to be done. Explain. Cross questions.

2. Tell me a case law on mistake of fact(he took forward the question asked by chairman)

3. Ease of doing business. Just spoke the word.

4. Name a few wars fought by indian navy?

M3. Lady

1. What is #me too campaign.

2. Who strated it?

3 story behind it?

4. When do u fly kites? (Hobby)

5. Which law would you have practiced had you been a lawyer?

M4.

1. What is administrative law?

2 What are the judicial mechanism to adjudicate administrative laws?

3 tribunals under which article of Constitution?

4. 323A and 323B?

5. Where do appeal from tribunals go?

6 did they always go to high court?

7 discussed L chandrakumar case

8. What article deal with high court writ mechanism?

Chairman- thank you. ( btw today was his birthday, though i didn't wish him)

Overall, way too technical, only law except few questions.