UPSC interview, Air Marshal Bhonsle board, 18 Aug 2021 (2)
18 Aug 2021
Pranjal:
Pranjal Prateek
Relevant Profile: Optional – PSIR; B.Tech (Avionics, IIST), MBA (IIM Bangalore), Management Consulting, Currently in a Startup, Ranchi (Jharkhand); ISRO project on Power Distribution Systems, University Cricket teams, National Model United Nations, Playing Tabla, Reading novels about Intelligence Agencies.
Board – Air Marshal Bhonsle Sir; 18th August; 5.05-5.35 pm (5th to go)
Chairperson:
1. You have a beautiful name, what does it mean? Who kept it? Do you think name is important? Does it reflect upon the person?
2. Is that so, if it’s not important, and only deeds and achievements are important, then would you like if parents would have named you Shakal, Mogambo or Shaitan Singh? Agreed that he is a war hero, but Shaitan Singh from name seems like a ‘Parakrami’ person, what about you?
3. Your grades were high in IIST, were you a topper there? I have visited that institute; it is a unique one. Tell me, how it has shaped you? What changes did you experience in yourself, studying there?
4. What position did you play in the cricket team of IIMB and IIST?
5. Give me a brief description of Tabla as an instrument? Have you learnt it professionally? Tell me about the origin of Tabla?
M1 (lady member):
1. Our PM talks about aspirations of Youth and achieving them in the next 25 years till our centenary celebrations of independence. Taking your own example, what are the aspirations of the youth of our country?
2. How will you create an ecosystem of entrepreneurship and innovation in our country?
3. What are the reasons for drug issue in the youth? What should we do as a society, as a family to tackle it? What is the government doing with its laws and agencies?
M2:
1. Since your optional is PSIR, tell me, can a state government amend laws made by center on issues in the concurrent list?
2. Recently our PM chaired a meet in UNSC, what was it about? How many pillars given by him? Broad contours of the pillars?
3. What is the difference between Asia-Pacific and Indo-Pacific concepts?
4. Why do you only read novels about intelligence agencies, why not actual books written by former operatives? If you have read real books too, written by operatives, tell me their names and authors?
5. What is counter-intelligence? Which are the foreign intelligence agencies which have significant presence in our country? You have read their books, tell me at least a few from them? Ok, what is the full form of ISI? Why is it called Inter-Services Intelligence?
6. Haven’t you read books by foreign intelligence agency operatives? Ok, so tell me two famous operations of Mossad?
7. As an MBA and a consultant, tell me, how should I decide which hybrid annuity product should I invest in from a range of products?
M3 (lady member):
1. Since you are from Ranchi, tell me why the great PSUs of Ranchi are in a state of decline?
2. Has Jharkhand benefitted from its separation from Bihar? Tell me from economic, cultural, political, LWE perspective?
3. What do you think about Vodafone Idea going under and Telecom market becoming a duopoly? What are its advantages and disadvantages? What will be its implications?
4. What was this National Model United Nations? Which country did you represent and what was the theme?
M4:
1. I see that your grades were high in IIST, were you a topper there? (Exactly the same question as Chairperson Sir)
2. Why did Chandrayaan 2 lander fail to do a soft landing? But the flight was automated, why did we need constant monitoring of Altimeter data?
3. Tell me about your project in ISRO?
4. Tell me the difference between a Missile and a cannon? What about tracking in a missile? What about control and guidance systems in missile?
5. What taals did you learn in Tabla? Why only comfortable in Teen Taal and Kaharwa Taal? Why not Dadra, Jhaptaal and Ek taal? But you have learnt it professionally, so you should be comfortable in all of them? (Full on grilling for 2 minutes).
6. Ok Gentleman, in the first question asked by Lady Member 1, you said that we are best in Automation. Was it my mistake that
I hear you wrong, or do you actually think so? (I said that if you would have heard it, then its definitely my mistake. I wanted to convey that we are aspiring to be the best. He then told, okay that’s what you meant and passed on to chairperson).
Chairperson:
1. Pranjal, do you know about IQ, EQ and SQ?
2. Ok, explain to me what this quote means to you – “A person of low IQ but high EQ and SQ will always lead over those with high IQ.” Do you agree or not?
3. But what about SQ of Steve Jobs? (Since I used Jobs and Wozniack’s example in the previous question).
4. What will you do after this? What will you order? (I said I am not sure). Now I am very curious, you have to tell me what will you order? (I said something healthy, maybe from Subway). “Achha, Subway healthy hota hai?” (Sir joked and everyone laughed). Where are you staying in Delhi? Thank you, you can go now.
Overall, it was an amazing experience seeing the aura of the members and setup of the room. The board was cordial, patient, and perceptive. I didn’t know a few answers and could have done better in a few. All the best to everyone waiting for their PT, hope you rock it.
Pratik Dhumal
Date - 20 Aug 2021
Board - Air Marshal Bhonsle Sir
Time - Afternoon session. Last to go. Approx 30+ min
Home state- Maharashtra, Pune.
Btech Computer Engi -2018
Nirma University Ahmedabad
Optional- Anthropology
Work ex - Oracle - GIFT city Gandhinagar
Areas of interest- Game dev, teaching
Chairman-
So you graduated from Nirma.Tell me 5 qualities of Karsanbhai Patel?
Do they teach students these things?
Which is your one lifelong learning from your GIFT city's work experience?
Member1-
1. You did computers right.Tell me what is cryptography?
Then he talked 2 min about keys in cryptography etc and said leave it.
2.What will be the impact of quantum computing on cryptography?
I told about cryptography breaking and superposition
3.What is superposition?
4.Suppose you have 8 bits in quantum so how much possible 1/0 combination can be possible?
I again said about superposition and said I don't know the exact no because it will be too much higher than 2 to power 8
Not satisfied.
5.What is Ct scan ? Full form
6.Which rays are used in it?
7.Tell me 3 uses of nuclear energy?
Member2 -Lady
1. What is big data?
2.Suppose as a DM you have to manage migrants labours data how will you form an accurate database?
In one of the point I talked about feedback and missing links
3.How will you take feedbacks?
4.Now let's move on over data.
Women work force participation ratio in India is very low.Tell me laws for increasing that?
5.What is gift city?
6.What is so special about it?
Member3
1.Where do we find naga tribe?
2.Do they found outside India also?
3.Recent constitutional amendment related to them
4.PM on this independence day said about collective power of small and marginal farmers what does he talking about exactly?
5.You mentioned nuclear isotopes for cancer earlier tell me law via which any hospital or clinic can use them?
6.What is the tech behind MRI?
7.One very special thing about Gift city? I mentioned one and he said no.He was expecting about some special solid waste management there.
Member4-Lady
1. What have you done about game development?
2.Why we need ease of doing business index?
3.So as you mentioned about 10 parameters let's talk about registration of property.
4.Why it is needed and it's importance?
5.Tell me 5 major problem India is facing?
6.Why cooperative movement was successful in areas like milk but not in land ?
Chairman sir-
1.What will you do now?
I said that I will go and celebrate my friend's bday
2.Where?
3.Convey wishes from my side also.
Your interview is over.Best of luck.
Shubh
Keywords from DAF: BTech Computer Science, IRAS, PSIR, Chess
Bhonsle sir board
CM:
What is anti chess?
What do you think is easier, chess or anti- chess?
M1 (ma’am):
tell 3 significant international events that happened in August
tell 3 significant domestic events that happened in August
what accounting reforms railways is doing to improve public service delivery
what problems do MSMEs face in India?
M2 (sir):
how is Internet governed?
what is DNS?
how many routes are there in DNS (don’t remember this question exactly or what he wanted to ask, I said idk)
does India has cyber security policy?
what is critical information infrastructure? who decides what would be included in that list?
M3 (ma’am):
recently PM announced 75 new Vande Bharat trains. Does it require new tracks or can it run on old ones?
is railways budget deficit or surplus?
you are already in the services. Do you think civil services require reforms?
M4 (sir):
it is said that white has an advantage in chess because of first move? Why is that?
what is Big Bang, black hole? how can we say that universe is expanding?
you studied CS. Should I ask you about database management?
CM:
What are your plans for today?
Thank you. Your interview is over.