Interviews

UPSC interview, Air Marshal Bhonsle board, 17 Aug 2021 (2)

17 Aug 2021

Prateek Rao:

Chairman - Air Marshal A S Bhonsle Sir

Background - Btech, MBA, Credit Rating, IRTS

Hobbies - Cricket, Singing and Songwriting, Stoicism, Weight Training

Optional - Management

Home State – MP

17/08/21, Forenoon, First to go

Chairman

Be comfortable, take off your face shield. Remove your face mask and wipe your face off it is very hot outside you must be sweating. Get settled in your chair and then we can start

So I believe you have been here before? Have we met earlier ?

So, you are already aware of the process. I don't have to explain the process again to you.

Alright, so we will go one by one ask you a few questions. At any point of time if you cannot understand or cannot hear because of the masks please ask them to repeat the question so that you are absolutely clear on what we are asking. Also I want you to listen to the questions very carefully and then respond to what is being asked. Since you're wearing a mask and sitting a bit far try to be a bit loud so that we all can hear you okay?

Read the DAF - You seem to be a very high achiever and you have consistently done well in academics. You seem to have had a slight drop, I won't hold it against you – I think you are a very good student and you have done well and proving your mettle. Also I think that you have a lot of hobbies. You have cricket, music, stoicism, weight training.

I see now that you also sing isn't it, what do you do?

Where are you posted right now

Oh okay okay, but they are no longer recruiting IRTS are they? Are you the only one in your batch?

You are interested in stoicism, should you not be content with the current job you have as IRTS? Aren't you going for something that is against the philosophy of stoicism when wanting to change your service?

Prime Minister has announced that 75 bullet trains will be started in the 75 weeks, do you think it is too ambitious target

Why do you think we need high-speed trains what is the need of high-speed trains?

Okay, now tell me you have lived in in Calcutta, studied at IIM and also worked in Powai where IIT Bombay is, why do you think they are still called IIM Calcutta and IIT Bombay and not IIM Kolkata and IIT Mumbai?

We hear about changing of names very often sometimes Anglicised names are changed to Indian names, other times even some erstwhile Indian names are being changed in different contexts what are the pros and cons of changing names.

Okay, we have also seen that in many cases particularly like the Rajiv Khel Ratna award the name was changed to Major Dhyan Chand award. Tell me particularly if this is a good thing, regarding the Khel Ratna award to change the name?

Do you think we are a sports superpower?

M1 - Lady member

I will carry on from what chairman Sir was asking you about the railways. Now with the merger of services proposed in the railways how do you think it will affect the service efficiency of the Railways (she was not audible through her mask so I asked her to repeat the question since I was not able to hear)

Well that is okay, but my question is on service efficiency. The customer service that the railway provides how will that be improved?

Okay. Tell me about this stoicism what is this?

So CRISIL, what was your role?

M2 - Male Member

You are into music. Please tell me what is octave?

Yes but what is the change between two octaves, how much is the difference of frequency?

Okay, tell me what do I mean when I say decibel?

Okay, what kind of string instruments are there, since you play the guitar

Okay, coming to computer science, there is a lot of talk nowadays about an upcoming technology that is totally disruptive that will go beyond anything in computing power that we have seen till now and also something that will change the way computing process happens. Do you know what I'm talking about?

Yes yes, please tell me something about quantum computing?

What are the superposition and entanglement?

Okay, lastly what are the fastest bullet trains that currently run in the world any idea?

And what is the fastest that are Vande Bharat and other trains can go in India ?

Okay, what is the technology that is used in these trains which run at such high speeds?

M3 - Lady member

Do you know about this Har Ghar Jal concept?

You have lived in big city's like Mumbai and Calcutta what can be the challenges to water conservation in the cities and what can be done to take care of these challenges

How would you make people aware of the issues of water conservation?

Okay, now let's suppose that you are a subdivisional police officer and there is a clash between your team and mobs and it violent and what would you do?

M4 - Male Member

You spoke about Zeno and stoicism you said it was during the Roman time? But isn't Zeno from the greek time?

So tell me, who has been your idol?

Why do you like Dhoni?

Calculated risk-taking. Please tell me an instance from your job in CRISIL where you took a risk.

And tell me an event where you slipped up

You spoke about ambition, isn't the philosophy of stoicism completely opposite to being ambitious?

Chairman

So what will you do after the interview you must be very tired?

Please tell me what is so interesting about yesterday's match although you might not have been able to see it.

Yes, but what was the turning point of the match according to you?

But wasn't it a very risky decision it could have gone either ways.

What if it would have gone wrong what if India would have lost the match?

You spoke about risk-taking and Vision earlier. Do you think Vision and risk-taking or mutually exclusive or they go together?

Do you also think that vision and risk-taking is only for leaders and the person down the hierarchy doesn't have vision?