Interviews

UPSC interview, Sujata Chaturvedi board, 6 Aug 2021 (3)

6 Aug 2021

Anonymous

State: Bihar (Kishanganj district)

Date of Personality Test (PT): 06th August, 2021; 2nd to go (Forenoon)

Chairperson (CP): Sujata Mehta Madam

Optional: Mathematics

Graduation: Civil Engineering , IIT Delhi- 2018

Hobby: Playing Cricket

Work: IRS IT-2020 (on Extraordinary Leave till December 2021)

PT Experience:

*No questions on IRS IT, Cricket, IIT Delhi and Bihar*

My PT Room was not that big (it was roughly a 20 feet x 20 feet room). Hence, there was no mic in the room. The members were separated from each other by about 6 feet.

Room door was already open. I entered the room wearing a face-shield, mask and hand gloves (provided by UPSC). All the members were also wearing masks throughout the interview (only 2 members removed their masks while asking questions during the interview).

Greeted the Chairperson and then other 4 Members (1 lady and 3 gentlemen).

CP said that I may remove my face-shield if I want. I removed the face-shield and kept it on the table in front of me. However, I was wearing the mask throughout the PT (The candidate just before me was scolded by the board for removing the mask without the permission of the board).

CP then showed me two passport size photographs and asked whether it was me (However, she didn't ask me to remove the mask to verify me). I said , "yes Madam".

Trivia: These are the photographs submitted by us during document verification on the date of PT and the Board writes our PT marks at the backside of the photographs.

Chairperson (CP):

1. Introduce yourself by giving details about your education and work.

2. What are the ideals in the Preamble along with 'Justice'?

3. Arrange the four ideals as per their importance and also give reasons for the same. ( I said , “Madam, 1. Justice 2. Equality 3. Liberty 4. Fraternity“)

4. Shouldn't Equality be placed before Justice? ( I said if there is Justice then there will be Equality)

5. Define Liberty and Fraternity.

6. Is there Justice in India?

7. Difference between Law and Justice? ( I said Law is the means and Justice is the end).

8. Section 498A of IPC is there. We have the burden of proof on the accused. So, you think Section 498A is doing justice? (Question about Sec 498A came up randomly. I never mentioned any keyword like IPC or Sec 498A etc.)

I said, "The Supreme Court has said...."

CP: No, forget about the Supreme Court. Tell us your opinion.

(I said yes Madam Sec 498A is doing justice because there are crimes against women in India like domestic violence. So we need Sec 498A dealing with cruelty by husband and his relatives.)

CP cut me short at this point and said thank you and passed the baton to Member 1.

Member 1:

1. So we were talking about Justice. In India there are huge pendencies in Courts. You know that Justice delayed is Justice denied. Don't you think in India Justice is denied?

2. Now assume you are the Law Secretary of India. How will you solve the problem of judicial pendencies?

3. Suppose you are made the Collector of a district. There is a welfare scheme which is to be implemented. The local politician in the district is asking you to post two of his known officers at a particular posting where there is scope for corruption. What will you do? (2-3 follow up questions like don’t you think if there is some corruption then everyone will be happy as the scheme would be implemented easily. I said that means is also important and corruption ultimately hurts the common man the most.

The member continued his follow up questions and stopped only when I said, “if I am the DC then it will my responsibility to ensure corruption free administration and hence I will deny the request by the politician”)

Member 2:

1. Have you heard of a place in Jharkhand which is famous for cybercrimes? (I said, “Yes Sir. It is Jamtara”)