UPSC interview, Sujata Chaturvedi board, 6 Aug 2021 (2)
6 Aug 2021
Me: firstly we have to change the perception in the society that dalits or others are the same as everyone else in terms of constitutional rights or even by the laws of nature. for this education of the young minds is important so that they see others as equal to themselves. Next we have to make sure that we implement the provisions of affirmative action to improve their social standing . lastly from a policing point of view we need to make sure that the atrocities against dalits are fast tracked for faster justice.
member says – good
Member 2:
1. Do you know about the oilseeds and pulses program?
Me: I am not very aware about it sir. I will read more.
2. I will give you a hint. its related to increasing the oilseeds production. it is a very big component of imports . how much is it ?
Me: Around 20 metric tonnes sir but i am not very sure.
3. In dollar value I mean?
Me: I am not very sure sir.
4. Ok leave it. tell me about the water scheme which telangana has launched. it is mission bhagirathri right?
Me: I am not very well versed with it sir.
5. What is its impact in Telangana . think and answer .
Me: Sir, logically i would believe that the rice cultivation and the sugarcane cultivation must have increased.
6. That is correct . with all the hints i have given. members speak to themselves saying everyone there is growing rice.
7. So you are from Telangana or Andhra?
Me: Sir Andhrapradesh , Visakhapatnam
8. Tell me about the crops of each district of andhra pradesh?
Me: Sir i will start from the bottom. rayalaseema has four districts namely cuddapah , kurnool.
9. No I know the districts. Just give the crops fast. We have time constraints.
Me: Yes sir. Mangoes and orchard farming in rayalseema region. chillies in guntur nellore region. rice and sugarcane in east and west godavari region. next we have turmeric rice and some other crops in the north andhra region of Srikakulam, vijianagaram and vizag.
(member not very satisfied)
Member 3:
1. so tell me the schools have closed and the children have not gone anywhere from home. the marks were given for cbse etc without even exams. do we need such system as in do we need exams ? and what about digital education why cant we just continue with it because it js very easy.
Me: sir i would like to answer this in two parts . firstly with respect to the exams i think an end exam which decides everything for the student isnt desirable. maybe a continuous comprehensive evaluation over the year is more useful with an end semester exam having say 40-50 percent marks
2. but why have an end semester exam ? isn’t continuous comprehensive evaluation sufficient?
Me: (fumbled ) sir the aim is to create a skilled workforce with some common standards and this will be ensured if we have some uniformity in the form of end sem exam
3. but these are children and they aren’t exactly trying for jobs. ok second part?
Me: Sir , I think continuing only with digital education has its problems. we have a situation where most children live in one or two room houses and it is difficult for them to concentrate on online classes. secondly a family of four or five are dependent on the same Wi-Fi and it decreases the buffering speed of classes . and the most important reason is that a student who goes to school not just learns from teachers but also from peers and he learns to gel well with society . maybe a blended system is the way forward but offline component needs to be there.
4. But you say offline learning and we don’t have enough schools or teachers or infrastructure. we are winding already present schools.
Me: Sir in that case we should look into ways in which we can provide this infrastructure for the people because it is what is guaranteed by the constitution. and from a civil engineering perspective we can think of eays in which we can construct these school buildings or make them remunerative. for example 20-30 solar panels generate 1000 units fo electricity and this can give some income or cut down costs. also waste can be utilised to construct building and so on.
member nods and agrees
Member 4-(felt she was hostile)
1. So you work in coaching. should coaching industry be regulated and why?
Me: can I take some time madam.
(yes sure. wrote few words down.)
Yes madam. there is need of regulation madam. firstly there are some good parts in the coaching institutes for they hire the best talent and provide quality assignments and education for the children . this increases the chance of clearing the examination. but on the flip side there are problems as well in that the fees of coaching say iit coaching is exorbitant to the tune of 1.75 lakhs per year. and this is very inaccessible to a child from tribal area of Andhra Pradesh or otherwise. so we do need regulation to improve the good part and cut down the negative part.
2. Why not just go on with coaching and stop all public schools. the products of coaching do not know what a lab is and they have fake degrees. you must be known about it in civil services or IIT preparation.
Me: I am not very aware.
2.1- Arey you must be knowing about how the records of students are written by coaching institutes.
Me: Yes madam at the iit coaching level I do know this happens and this wrong doing must definitely stop through proper regulation.
3. Why not make the curriculum of iit in line with CBSE so that people from public schools as well do well in exams. should we not do it?
Me: Madam i think even if the curriculum is brought in line the examination of IIT is difficult and requires a good amount of practice and very good teaching. at the moment it is not available in the public school system. But I do understand the point madam . the idea should be to ultimately create a public school system where we will be able to increase the competency of students so that they dont have to go for coaching centers as such.
4. Presidential system is the best compared to parliamentary form. it is my view. what is your opinion?
Me: (was nervous by now) from the limited understanding I have if there one keader at the helm it might turn into a totalitarianism in some time...sorry not totalitarianism but dominance over other organs of the state. so I feel parliamentary system is better. but I will need to read more on this madam
5. What are the advantages of a presidential system?
Me: The policies can be implemented faster in a presidential system madam . I am able to recall this only at the moment.
interview is over. thank you. chair didn’t ask questions in the end. interview was close to 30-33 minutes
Felt like the board members didn’t have pointed questions especially the last two members and it was difficult to understand what they actually wanted to ask because they kept saying things in between.
Was calm throughout , except for the ending where I used the word totalitarianism. My take on the interview is that it started well but it slowly tapered down as time passed by .
Date 6/08/2021
Optional PSIR
Btech electronics
Fort trekking , writing marathi poems
Panel- sujata mehta mam
Forenoon session (Last to go..)
Chairman
- sangli flood reasons
-do u know committees related western ghats ?
- difference between gadgil and kasturirangan committee?
- should we go with gadgil or kasturirangan ? What is ur opinion ?
Members questions -
- technical questions abt poetry ( wht is ur writing style - muktchandh or other format ?)
- three pillars of govt (legislature , judiciary , executive ) independent or dependent ?
- which pillar u will represent after getting selected ?
- is it really independent ?
- why india lacking in chip manufacturing ?
- why china more developed than india ? Is due to our democracy ?
- which is better in one party dictatorship with more development and democracy with less development ?
- which is better direct democracy or indirect democracy ?
- so why india chose representative democracy ?
-gad ala pn sinh gela ( related to which fort ) and is it real story abt tanaji use ghorpad (monitor lizard ) to climb the cliff ?
- have u climbed that cliff ?
- police encounter related questions ( mumbai police)
- what do u mean by encounter ?
- representative democracy related questions
- ratnagiri fort speciality
Chairman - anything u want us to ask ?
Ur interview is over..Thank u. .
Anonymous
Board: Bhosle sir, Last person to go in afternoon round
Education: BTech IIT Delhi
Optional: Chemistry
Hobbies: Vipassana, Cricket
Chairman: then he read DAF aloud to all the panel members, appreciated good academic background and so on
1-What is nightwatchman in cricket? I answered to which he commented why don’t we say him Bali ka Bakra instead?
2-why chemistry optional?
Few more questions which I don’t remember
M1:
1-what is Ph?
2- Ph of distilled water Ph?
3-Give 3 definitions of acids
4- What are uses of iodine isotopes?
5- Difference between Law and order situation and internal security situation?
6- Difference between Law & order situation, Public Disorder, and Internal security situation?
7- Where should we draw that thin line between Law & order situation, Public Disorder?
8- You are from Gaya, who is Dashrath Manjhi?
9: what is vipassana?
10-what is the source of Vippasana?....then Chairman asked next panel member to ask questions as he was going to ask few more questions it seemed..
M2:
1- What are Perks?
2-should we call Housing & accomodation as perks?
3- How did you file ITR?
4- In what tax bracket your salary comes?
5-Reasons for rise in fuel prices recently?
M3:
1-Where did you do vipassana?
2- what are the physical difficulties in doing it?
3-How was the food over there, How did you managed eating habits etc?
4- you did vipassana till level 1 only, you don’t want to go for another level?
5- why did you start doing vipassana? Some more questions on it which I don’t remember
6- what is cryptocurrency?
7- how one can get cryptocurrency?
8: Told me one Chinese proverb which is curse, I was asked to explain it: “May you live in interesting times”
M4:
1-what are potential for India becoming global manufacturing hub?
2- why could not we do good in manufacturing?
3- evaluate Make In India. What are the reasons we could not do well?
4- You are SP of Naxal affected area, How will you handle the situation?
Concluded
PLEASE SHARE YOUR TRANSCRIPTS WITH US. ATLEAST MAIN QUESTIONS. PLEASE TAKE SOME TIME OUT OF YOUR BUSY SCHEDULE. AND DO NOT FORGET TO MENTION THE BOARD NAME
#Sharing_is_Caring
(Also please forward any transcript you get from anywhere like Whatsapp Group/ Social Media etc with us. As the Interviewed Person may not be on telegram.) 🤟
Share ur Interview/Personality Test Transcript(CSE/IFOS) of 2020 session that you find ANYWHERE at the profile id @Yo_Yo_Choti_Singh or @phukman @patriot_saint @shunyashashvata
#Hum_Honge_Kamyaab_Ek_Din 😊
Scout
2nd last to go
State : Uttar Pradesh
Optional : Psychology
Language of interview : Hindi
Hobbies : poetry writing, reading fiction.
Board: Air marshal bhosle sir
Chairmen - Welcomed, explained process..you can use English words..asked to removed shield..sit comfortably and be prepared for next 30 min discussion to know your suitability for Civil service..you need to speak a loud..it's okay we know the situation ( etc...)
So I see you have decent academics and work for NGO too..seems like you have these qualities..you write poems too which shows your sensitive side ( basically sir was literally trying to cheer me up and doing warm up as it was around 5 PM when I entered).
Than asked just 3 questions
1. What is theme of your poems?
2. Please recite your original work and give its background ( got confused with a line and were going to discuss that part but as I cleared that confusion, praised the thought behind it).
3. What time and how you chosed the civil service?
Right side members ( both males)
M1 - Asked many ques ( around 5) which I can't answer..was hearing those name for first time..like some book name, psychologists name 😅
Only answered question on Pavlov's conditioning. ( All were around my hobby non fiction books and psychologist)
M2 - Asked current based que
1. CAA, why people r against it?
Gave 3 reasons but wasn't satisfied much asked more.. again said you r missing something...than asked Which countries r included..asked communities included? Left out?
2. What do you know about insurance?(Father's background) What is professional liability insurance?.. persisted to try answering even after my sorry..later said okay leave it you are not reaching there.
3. What learning we got from Covid? Gave 3..asked more .. Follow up que on Atamnirbhar Bharat.
Left members ( both ladies )
M3 -
1.You spent a large part in your hometown please tell me something about your district? ( Unable to hear one aspect of it than second ma'am helped me to convey it)
2. You talked about digital education, are school important for children? I said yes...why? explained why.
3. Than why school closed in India while they were opened for kids worldwide?.
4. Science behind school should be open? I answered child immunity..than she went on to explain the scientific reason ( I patiently listened her..said thanks after nodding in agreement) later ma'am asked me why Indian parents r apprehensive even now?
M4 -
1. Okay what your NGO do?
3. How you get attached to it while living in hometown?
3. asked my favourite area of psychology? I answered mental health.. follow up question on same.
4. How to take care of mental health of orphans of covid? ( We discussed it well).
Chairmen..okay your interview is over now..you may leave..best wishes!
Went for 25 min approx..I may have missed 2/3 questions..will add if I recall any.
Devi
Board: Satyavathi ma'am
04/08/2021
Afternoon session,5th to go
Background
State: Kerala
Btech in Electronics and communication engineering.
Optional: Geography
Interests: Watching travelogues, listening to AR Rahman songs.
Chairperson
Asked me to remove the shield.
Read the daf aloud and started to discuss between them, on my native place.
1.Question on pronunciation of my native place and in which all languages,that pronunciation do exist?
2.Question on project during BTech ( mentioned in DAF) and subsequent questions on the same.
3.What type of travelogues do you watch?
4.Prospects of space tourism.
5.Won't the space tourism widen the already existing economic disparity, with only very few able to access it?
M1
1.Why AR Rahman songs?
2.Kerala doesn't have economic viability due to its geography,lack of hinterland etc.Do you think it is better to reorganize the state and club it with Tamil Nadu? Or is there any other possibility?
3.Geographical limitations force people to go out of Kerala.Explain.
M2
1.You have talked about traffic signals( project).Let us talk about traffic signs and went on asking about smart traffic controlling,what are the options for pedestrians in smart traffic control systems.
2.Need for labour reforms.
3.As part of labour reforms,if I chose to ban strikes,Is that possible.What is your opinion?
M3
1.What is Bhakti movement? Which all regions the movement existed? Some south indian saints associated with Bhakti movement? She went on to ask about Advaita Vedanta( which I told I am not sure about)
2.Opinion about the police force in the country.
3.When I began with positives,she interfered asking if you are satisfied with their performance- I told her about the limitations .
4.What are the problems with attitude of police?
5 . Discussion on IPC and CrPC- whether it need to be replaced with new codes,what are the problematic sections ?
M4
1.Which are the major mountain ranges in India?
2.Through which all states do Aravallis passes?
3.Through which all states do Western ghats passes?
4.Which mineral is found in Western ghats?
5.Geographical importance of Indus valley civilization ( When I took a pause to think, he restructured the question)Tell me recent news about india valley civilization.
Congratulations India #Neeraj_Chopra #Gold ❤️❤️❤️👏👏👏🙌🙌🙌