UPSC interview, Manoj Soni board, 4 Aug 2021
4 Aug 2021
Amrit Jain, Electrical and Electronics Engineering from NIT Warangal
Indian Defence Accounts Service 2019
Hobbies : Singing, playing guitar
Optional : PSIR
Board : Manoj Soni Sir
Interview : 4th August, Afternoon
Chairman
1)So Amrit, you are the last candidate for the day, Are you tired? Are you hungry?
2)Lets start, so you are 2018 batch IDAS officer?( I corrected him politely )
3)Okay, so your training has just finished, How do you feel about about your current service?
4)But then, I believe you want to get into a "better" service, if I may use that word gently?? Why?
5)So you play guitar? What kind of guitar? What kind of songs?
6)Okay, then what do you like to sing on guitar?(Indian bollywood) Okay, then you dont do classical songs on guitar?
7)Really, are you interested in learning Indian classical? Tell me the difference between Drupad and Khayal form?
8)Do you know anything about Gharana tradition?
9)What is your opinion on this statement, "Indian classical music has led to formation of several composite cultures in India"?
10)Should we make Indian classical music a compulsory part of higher learning education curriculum?Do you know anything about SPICMACAY, I believe its an acronym for something, Can you tell us its full form?
M1
1)Are you more comfortable in Political Science or International Relations?
2)What do you make of the threat of China and Sino-Pak axis?
3)How is India able to deal with it?
4)Which international grouping supports us against them?
5)Tell me something about Representation of People's Act? Who are observers? What is the role of Returning officer?
6)What is Model Code of Conduct?
7)Tell me how would you like to improve our policing?
M2
1)You are already into a finance service, Don't you think that Government should allow only commerce graduates or CA/CS professionals to enter into such finance services(IDAS, ICAS)?
2)Is excessive democracy a hindrance for growth of nations(particularly India)?
3)Ok you are right, but don't you think, too much of viewpoints on an issue bring policy paralysis in India?
4)Then how do you resolve it, you take a decision, but you are not able to implement that decision in India? Don't we need a very strict form of democracy?(He spoke at length about failures of African democracies)
5)But that is the issue right, Government is not being strict enough, Look at the timing of Kumbh Mela, don't you think we needed stronger government to disallow such events?
M3
1)Okay Amrit, I see that you have graduated from Electrical and Electronic Engineering from NIT Warangal(long back), Can you recall any of it ?(Dont worry I am not going to ask you anything from it)Do you think this engineering is of any use to you now?
2)Don't you think that this realization of serving better through civil services came very late in your life?
3)Why did that happen?
4)Okay, it is said that we are doing too much of auditing? What is your view on it?
5)But then, financial scrutiny of every administrative decision(procurement, proposal) is causing so many unnecessary delays?
6)Recently, I attended a conference in which all esteemed members agreed that we are having too many auditing procedures, ( they were all experts in this field ), What do you think needs to be changed?
7)Tell something about India's UNPKF in Srilanka adventure? How did it impact India-Srilanka relations
8)Talk something about Afghan situation and why is India so much worried about its security?
M4 (lady member who tried to ask a question earlier, but chairperson told her to wait till her turn comes)