UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 26 Mar 2018
26 Mar 2018
Name : Safin Hasan
Graduation: B.Tech (EC) in 2016
Optional: Literature of Gujarati Language
Hobby: Interacting with and helping to underprivileged section specially kids.
Board : Smeeta Nagaraj maam
-----------------
Chairman: please have seat.
See Safin, your optional is Literature which none of us know about so we will not ask you on that. (I was like... Wow )
But I would like to ask you about some social issues if you don't mind. (Bit scary)
We can see in India, there is caste system privelent in all regions. It exists in Islam too. Can you tell us why it is there in Islam and who are these castes.
Me: Yes ma'am, there exists a caste system and hierarchy in Muslim community. For example, Syyed, Ashrafi, even my caste like Julaya. This mainly because most of the people are converted to Islam. Some because of compulsion and some because they were convinced. And because of that preexisting hierarchy, they haven't been able to incorporate the concept of equality of Islam.
Chairman: How these people have been able to sustain this system despite the concept of Equality? Why there is still discrimination?
Me: ma'am , because the Muslim upper caste has been able to reserve the right to interprete the Islamic texts. Apart from that the lower strata of community has not even able to get such education and thus have always been under the influence of the higher caste.
Chairman: you have written Julaya as your caste. This is a Weaver community right ? ( I agreed)
Despite govt giving so much push for the textile sector and giving incentives, what we have seen is that the children of Weavers don't want to pursue the same profession. Is it the same case in Gujarat?
Me: Yes ma'am. Even the village I come from, was once known as a Manchester of my district. But today there is noone associated with this occupation.
Chairman: Then don't you think we would be completely losing our traditional industry of handloom? What is your view on that ?
Me: Ma'am , I think, it's not about loosing the tradition but about making it more specific. For example, in Gujarat we have Bandhani and Patola which still enjoy a good status in national and international craft market. We should make efforts to promote it.
Chairman: Very good. (Passing to lady member)
M1: Safin you have this rare combination of Technology and Literature. Can you tell me who is your favourite story writer?
Me: Mr Umashankar Joshi is my favourite story writer maam.
M1: Can you tell me about his story which you like the most ?
Me: Saap no Bharo (I made a mistake here, n said the name of his monologue drama, hope that gamble didn't come to her notice)
M1: what is it about?
Me: Maam it's about pathetic situation of daughters in our society. Story revolves around one such daughter and her mother.
M1: Though we are living in modern time, situation of women doesn't have improved much. What is the scenario in your region?
Me: Ma'am , in general what you're saying is true. But what makes me feel proud is that the village I come from has 100% female literacy and there are many couples who have only one daughter.
(Panel was impressed )
M1: Safin, do you know about online trading? Have you ever done online trading?
Me: No ma'am . But I have read about it.
M1: What are the issues concerning online trading?
Me: Though I am not much aware about it madam ,but online trading and E-commerce are the fields which have got prominence in today's world. It mainly suffers from online frauds where authenticity of traders and dealers is the main concern. Where there is full proof mechanism, there is no worries. But recently govt is drafting policies for the same. We hope the problems will be taken care
M1: okay Last question. There is a govt hospital, which denies the service to woman who is in her advance stage of pregnancy as they asked for advance money which the family couldn't pay. She had to deliver the baby on nearby busstand. Though the baby and minther both are safe, some woman organizations have been demanding actions against the authorities. As a head of District,
what actions will you take?
Me: Ma'am , in this case safety and dignity of the mother and baby have been compromised. I would take strict actions against the authority as per the laws which I am yet to learn.
M1: But the hospital is denying it. They say we haven't denied.
Me: Ma'am , no woman or family will go for public delivery of baby without the compulsion. So this is primafacie a case where services have been denied.
M1: Thank you...(passing to M2)
M2: Okay. Safin. Tell me about Madressa system in our country. What has been it's contribution and how relevant are those ?
Me: Sir, there is a historically Madressa has played a great role by providing free education and other facilities to the community. There has been very prominent figures on the history who had got the education in Madressa. But looking at the present context, this system needs an overhaul. There are some problems like poor infrastructure, lack of coordination between mainstream and Madressa education, avoidance of science and mathematics etc...
M2 : One university has been named as Banaras Hindu University. There is also Aligarh Muslim University. Do you think this is proper? Shall we name Universities like this?
Me: Sir we have to see the historical context behind this. These institutions were established in a period when some reasons existed. For example Aligarh Muslim University was established by Sir Sayed Ahmed Khan to spread education among Muslims so that they can compete with other communities in employment and other areas. But if we see in present context when we have adopted a secular Constitution, I don't see any need of that.
M2: Safin you might have heard about the role of these Deras and their influence on society. Even there are dectates from religious leaders and also it is in Islam. How these can impact society??
Me: Sir, in India relious identity is very strong. Everyone wants to be associated with religion. If we talk about Deras, they have provided equality in lower strata of society and a feeling of being in the main stream. They have also given psychological support to these people and hence they follow what their religious teacher tell them. Similar is the case with Fatwa in Islam. If we involve these leaders in political consultation over societal issues, it can impact society at large.
(M2 passing to M3)
M3: okay Hasan, (Chairman interrupted, "It's Safin")
Yeah right, Safin... There is a prohibition in Gujarat on Alcohol. But we all know that it's available. Just you have to pay bit more for that. So what do you think about this prohibition...
Me: Yes sir , Gujarat being the birth place of our father of nation, it has implemented a ban on Alcohol since the day one. But I think instead of going for blanket ban, we should try for spreading awareness about negative consequences of alcohol consumption and sensitization. Behavioral change is all what is needed. We can also take help from the religious leaders as we have discussed earlier.
M3 : but this prohibition has also gained support from women. In state like Bihar, they have implemented it for political scores. Do you think this prohibition or removing it can have negative impact on political parties?
Me: Yes sir, prohibition or removal of it do have the political consequences.
(Passing to M4)
M4: Safin, you have done electronics. Can we develop an app to curb the corruption in your District?
Me: Sir ,even the existing apps like WhatsApp can also be used for that. I can ask the citizens to reach to me over such issues and if I find any substance in the complaint, I would go into details if that case. Secondly, yes developing an app and reducing the manual contact between an officer and citizen would result in a lower level of corruption.
M4: There has been a case of gender divide as well as rural - urban divide. I'm sure that is the case in your state too. How will reduce this divide using IT and cyber technology.?
Me: Yes sir, in Gujarat we have this rural urban divide. For me the priority would be internet penetration in rural areas. Focus on e-govern
ance would also empower the rural citizens. Apart from that some critical services like telemedicine and tele-education would also help to bridge the gap.
M4: We have heard about cyber threats. Wheta are they? Do you think we should try to avoid the technology to save ourselves from the threat??
Me: Sir the biggest threat is about privacy of an individual and security of data. Like very recently we have seen this Facebook data theft. But abandoning a tachnology is not a wise decision. We should work on robust data policy and cyber security instead.
M4: Safin, literature is your optional. Do you know Hansa Mehta? What has been here contribution in Gujarati.?
Me: Yes sir, I have heard about her and she had also played a role in constintuition making. But sorry sir, I'm not aware about her contribution in Gujarati.
M4: no issues. Last question. There is very well known personality from Gujarat who is internationally recognized as a successful businessman. Can you tell.me?
Me: Sir , I think you are talking about Mr Dhirubhai Ambani.
M4: Yes yes... He stayed outside the country for many years and then he started business here. Can you name the country where he had stayed??
Me : Sorry sir I am not aware about it.
M4: It's Aden. Thank you.
Chairman: (She was very attentive throughout and often smiled )Safin, I think you seem to know a lot. You have answered all the questions very promptly. Tell me what you still feel that you should learn...
Me: (with smile) ma'am I still need to learn a lot
Chairman : (interrupted me). See, even you know this also that what you still need to learn. That's a positive thing indeed. Plz continue...
Me: ma'am I need to learn about many sports. In my childhood i couldn't get engaged in any sports because I had responsibilities and also had to take care of my younger brother as both my parents were engaged in labour work. Apart from that, I am very much interested in Constitution and I am studying on that also.
Chairman: Being an IAS , which state would you like to work in...
Me: I have filled Gujarat as my home state and being my first preference I would like to work there.
M3 : Do you know what is the disadvantage of that?
Me: yes sir, in that case your family members, relatives and friends expect a lot from you and you have to struggles with that.
(All members laughing )
M3: you have given very correct point...
Chairman: okay Safin tell me, If you get into IAS, how it will help you to improve?
Me: first of all, I would get into touch with intellectual class of the country and that would help me to build my thought process. IAS being a post dealing with vast no of subject will increase my knowledge, my critical thinking and decisiveness.
M3: Tell me one thing, do your coachings tell you to write such hobbies?? Dont worry, it's a normal think. Everyone needs a coaching and that's completely fine. Bit people write like helping blinds and somebody write cooking... N yours is also.quite different.... So do they tell you ??
Me: Sir, I have attended coaching but the hobby which I have mentioned , I have genuinely done work in that area for around 4 years during my college.
M3: Thats good.
Chairperson: Thank you Safin. Your interview is Over.
Me: Thank you maams and Thanks you sirs.
Have a good day to all.
Interview transcript :
Board: Smita Nagarajan
20/03/18:
2nd to go
Textile Tech., IITD
Optional: Geography
CHAIRMAN:
So you are from Bhagalpur, known for blinding incident, what were ur views?
Present a Case study.
Give Ethical, Moral and social dimensions of it.
Was there any Casteism involved?
What were views of different stakeholders involved.
M1:
Different Handlooms significance to India
What is Remote sensing and use to different stakeholders
Relation b/w Textile and geography
Unique quality about urself
Transformation in yourself @IIT
M2:
Role of BIMSTEC; comparison with SAARC, is it better? Should IMT be part of BRI
Rising conflict with China, Signifance of Doklam standoff? Can it be done again, Where?
Indian coastline length?
Significance of Rann of Kutchh (geographical)
M3:
Modi’s directive for exam stress lecture in every university
Steps for Tackling Corruption @ govt, bureaucratic and people level
Global revolutionizing research @IITs, IIMs
Why research not happening there?
M4:
Destressing initiative by India @ global level? (Yoga)
Yoga related to Climate Change
Chairman:
Marriage@ Gunpoint in Bihar Happens with u?
Is it illegal?
Your Interview is Over!!