UPSC interview, Arvind Saxena board, 19 Mar 2018
19 Mar 2018
Tanmay:
Sh Arvind Saxena Board
Tanmay V Sharma
Profile- IIT Bombay, Electrical Engineering,
Research Internship in France, Another Internship in Goldman Sachs
Two Year work Ex in Goldman Sachs
19th March, Forenoon session
4th to go around 12pm
Lasted for about 25 mins. Don’t know for sure.
Abbreviation:
C- Chairman
M1, M2, M3, M4- members
Disclaimer: This is my recollection and I might have missed a few questions. Also some words in this transcript may have been modified that what was uttered in the real interview. I undertook three mocks Chanakya, NextIAS, KSG. Mocks were not very close to the real interview but the interview was closest Chanakya Mock.
C- Read about my profile. Asked is macroeconomics just a guessing.... Then he explained the context that 1997 crisis, queen of England convened meeting of top economist and talked about their inability to predict the crisis.
Me- I talked about ex RBI governor and he hinted about 2007 crisis
C- That’s just a one off case
Me- I talked that institutions should pick up the signs from such one off cases, also said something related to how macroeconomics is not guess by talking about Fiscal Deficit, etc predictions of economists.
C- Do you follow current events.... He said something about recent happening in Bangladesh?
Me- I have read a news that boats carrying arms from China are being captured in Chittagong and they were destined to create trouble in North East and also in 2018 Bangladesh Election
C- he talked something about how we say Bangladesh is friendly to us but so much Chinese influence... What's my opinion?
Me- every country looks for its national interest... so Chinese cheap finance are being utilized by them... but they also consider our interest while making strategic decisions.
C- Should we promote democracy in Bangladesh... said that 2009 elections were fixed. Zia now in jai. So should we help one lady and her party (he didn’t name her-Shiekh Hasina) to maintain power or promote democracy?
Me- Generalist answer that we need to look out for what is best for us and if current regime is more friendly that we should support her. Maintaining democracy is an internal matter of Bangladesh. We would like Hasina to win democratically. In the same way we are trying to protect democracy in Maldives.
C- Maldives-...he talked about current issue. Should we make such statements - like protecting democracy there- when we cant do anything? Its so small even then they are not listening. Your opinion?
Me- I talked that we don’t want to look aggressive in region- will impact other neighbours. But if situation demands we may intervene just like we did in past. C- but that was on the call of their president... Me- Right sir. C- so should we make such statements... Me- I told that Foreign service would have thought through this. C- ok you are giving them benefit of doubt, but what's your opinion. Me- I have read that we could have intervened within the first 48 hours before China intervened and after that we missed that opportunity. It reduces our credibility when India makes such statement.
C- Since you have worked in GS, tell me why tax havens are allowed to exist? They are a mechanism to save billions of dollars by Corporates. Why no action is taken against them?
Me- Talked about the steps taken by India- DTAA with Cyprus, Singapore and Mauritius. The tax havens are sovereign country and free to decide their tax policies. C- but US intervened in Iraq, etc.. and these tax havens are so small, why no action then? Me- Sorry sir, I am not sure.
M1- Discussed PNB reform. Does it affect foreign investors sentiments.
Me- talked about macroeconomic stability is questioned and thus yes it affects investors sentiments.
M1- What measures would you recommend as a representative of Fin min because it affects our economy?
Me- I told systemic reforms required, RBI power increase, ensuring accountability of culprits. The scam is about 11kcrore so not very huge from macroeconomic point of view. Therefore, we should take aforementioned steps actions.
M1- What short Term measure can you recommend?
Me- // had no
good answer- I believe he was hoping something on the lines of Fugitive Economic Offender Bill// ...couldn't tell anything concrete ...M1- ok so your are suggesting systemic changes. Me- yes. M1- ok
M2- Read my Daf, I have a personal question to ask, Me- sure... M2- Why do you wish to join government given you had a good job
Me- told my reasons which also included contributing directly to people life
M2- he talked about how can we quantify anyone's contribution.. Do economists not contribute?
Me- gave my defense - they do contribute, private sector and public sector both contribute. I want to work in the government at district level in the field.
M2- Jan 26 guest ASEAN. Difference between Look East and Act East.
Me- three Cs- Connectivity, Commerce, not able to recall the third C. // It came immediately in my mind once I confessed that I am not able to recall- Culture//. Oil companies exploring in Vietnam, $200 billion trade target. M1- but this used to happen before also. Me- defense partnership with Vietnam, stand on South China sea issue. Focus is more on execution part.
M1- What is South China Sea Dispute?
Me- talked about it. I was hoping this question
M2- Does the presence of word 'China' give more credibility to Chinese claim over South China Sea.
Me- No sir, Indian Ocean has India and it doesn’t belong to us entirely. (M2 wanted to hear this answer)
M3- You have hobby of cricket, puzzle solving and cooking. What do you cook
Me- Kari Pakoda + Chawal
M3- Something international.
Me- Sir,... paneer related items, nothing fancy though. (It was sort of light talk)
M3- Some finance related question that I cant recall
M3- Since you are from finance background -what is this phrase... bad money invites (attracts) bad money?
Me- I explained what I understood and asked if that's what she meant. She said not exactly but fine.
M3- Why are we capitalizing PSB?
Me- talked about inability to lend. Impact on growth.
M3- Isnt this a case of bad money inviting bad money?
Me- talked about recap plan and that govt is focusing on relatively well performing PSBs during recap.
M3- talked about Mrs Gandhi (Indra) ... nationalization. Do we also capitalize private if they fail?
Me- if systemic risk then yes like did in US. But generally no. PSB because govt is owner of this and responsibility lies on govt. to either sell it off or support it to run.
M4- Renewable. Costly. Why req?
Me- Climate change, cost coming down, ISA, global leadership
M4- France internship. Any place in India that can be developed like Nice (France)?
Me- Goa, Kerala- but already developed. Cleanliness needs to be ensured- SBM. Connectivity improved - UDAN. May be some other coastal site also.
M4- what new in Indo French relationship in last 5 year?
Me- Nu- Jaitapur, ISA, Counter terrorism, Rafale
M4- anything else in aviation sector
Me-Sorry sir I don’t know
M4- Solar or Nuclear?
Me- short term solar due to cost benefit and long term nuclear to exploit Th reserve. Problem in rapid expansion of nuclear - capital intensive and Nu waste. Solar also creates jobs.
Air marshal bhonsle board.
Last candidate to enter
Nothing from daf more situation based . Missed few questions here
1. You have shaved in the morning ?
2. Who invented razor ?
3. Brand abassador of gillete .
4. Explain the day i stop improving i will stop manufecturing razor
5. What is kaizen
6. You are dm of abc district how will you encourage team participation
7. Every peace treaty has seed of next war explain after ww1
8 after ww2
9 after russian disintegration
10 what is crytocurrency
11. Currency of venezuela
12. Advantage disadvantage
13. Digital divide in india
14. You are dm of xyz how will you help a victim of sexual harrasment
15. What is composite
16. Recently ultratech in news. Why
17. What is insolvency code
Bhonsle Sir's Board.
19th March.
4th to go in the afternoon session.
Background:
Law graduate, law optional, hobbies-tennis, watching documentaries.
CM:
1. You have a CGPA of 9.28. Why couldn't you score a 9.8 instead?
2. Tell me the difference between Rule of Law and Rule by Law.
Member1(Lady):
3. Amendment to Juvenile Justice Act post Nirbhaya verdict- But if the juvenile is shifted to mainstream jails with adult criminals, then won't they get hardened in nature and the scope for reformative justice would reduce?
-Was it a progressive move?
Member2:
4. Tell me the salient features of the Draft National Forest Policy. (From that morning's newspaper)
5. What in your opinion would become India's next new state after Telangana? More questions on merits and demerits.
Member 3:
6. What is the provision in Indian Evidence Act regarding admissibility of evidence of lie detector tests and brain mapping results?
7. What is brain mapping?
8. What is the significance of Indian PM visiting Palestine? More related questions.
Member 4:
9. What is the meaning of your name?
10. Why did you shift from Welham Girls School after 10th...didn't they have +2?
11. What is a foot fault? (From hobby-Tennis)
-What are the names of the different types of lines on a tennis court?
12. What are the different types of contracts under Indian Contract Act? -What are voidable contracts?
13. What age does the PCMA prescribe for child marriages for male and female?
-Is there any special provision for child brides regarding annulling of marriage?
-How much time are they given to make that choice?
Chairperson:
14. Have you watched the movie Dangal?
-Who do you think is the real hero in the movie? I said the father of the two girls.
-Asked to justify it.
-Don't you think the girls were the real hero?
-Don't you think the father did everything for his personal ambition?
-Make a case for the mother being the real hero in the movie.
15. What plans do you have for the evening today?