UPSC interview, Arvind Saxena board, 22 Feb 2018
22 Feb 2018
Name- Avinash Singh
History optional
Hobbies- Diary Writing and Motivational Videos.
BE(2014)
22nd Feb ,Arvind saxena board,first one to go,10.05 am to 10.35 am
CH- Reading out basic details(name,graduation,etc) and said he is from Gujarat(I am from UP , but temporarily residing in Gujarat) and I said yes.
Ok, your college is good. Tell me something about placement in your college.
ME- Sir, placement is held at GTU campus where companies visit. Around 20 student got placed in L&T etc.
CH- Did you sit for placement?
ME- No sir.
CH- Why ?
ME- Sir, my father is in government service, so I wanted a govt job.
CH- Are you in job or selected somewhere ?
ME- Sir, I got selected through CAPF 2016.
CH- Which department you were allocated ?
ME- BSF
CH- Havent you joined ?
ME- Sir, I am yet to join and will be joining when CH asked ‘will you join’.
CH- We are seeing some case of fratricide, low morale among jawans regarding leave etc. As a commanding officer, how will you deal with it ?
ME—Sir, I will clear out priorites like first priority will be towards our service, guarding LoC etc and if I can allow leave within law, will grant, but if not then will try to motivate him about our priority as well as try to have some alternatives.
CH- We see there is chances of national security etc to be compromised while using mobiles for contacting family,uploading video etc . So, I think we should not allow the use of Mobile. What is your opinion ?
ME- Sir, we are a democratic nation and soldier are working round the clock so they need mobile,etc to contact their families. But we can have some SOPs, restriction on using social media etc.
CH- So you are favouring for mobile ?
ME-Sir, yes and I will also give one particular example like my father is posted at Kutch border where there is telephone booth from where he calls me twice/thrice a week. So, we can have such similar arrangement.
CH remarked- Ok. So you are talking about community telephone. I said yes.
CH- What do you write in diary and why ?
ME- Sir, I write my daily activites, and it helps me to express myself, helps in maintaining the discipline of writing daily as well as to know my emotions and to visit my memorable events when I have spare time.
CH- Do you like to read and why ? So, what you have read in last 6 month apart from your syllabus ?
ME—Sir, I love to read about ancient history. I haven’t read any book, but I used to read about kings.
CH- Which newspaper you read(I said- IE, TH).Have you read the TH today ? Tell me todays article in OPED page?
ME- yes sir, it was related with ISRAEL policy with Syria and middle east.(CH- No, I am talking of OPED page). Sir it was related with remittances.(CH- tell me the crux) . Evolving nature of remittances as well as dependency on it with special emphasis on kerela.
M1-India is not taking correct approach in Maldives crisis. Whats your take on it ?
Me-Sir, this time situation is different and we have rising China and we cant have zero sum game with China. Its better to have wait and watch and built global consensus to pressurize Maldives.
M1- What was earlier stand and you are not favouring invasion of Maldives ?
Me- Sir, earlier in op. CACTUS 1988 there was appeal from government so we helped but this time there is demand from Nasheed and not from Govt. so we cant act aggressively as it may affect our own interest like in NEPAL when we put economic sanction. However if Maldives public demands India help, then being a responsible nation, India can help her.
M1- What do you think is it right on the part of INDIA to have shown cold shoulder to CANADA leadership ?
Me- Sir, there were some issue related to Khalistan in past years , but we shouldn’t have shown cold shoulder since we are known for our hospitality as well as we have 3% PIO in Canada.
M1- Do you know of Naga accord and why we need integration camp in NAGALAND(I have done 1 camp in Nagaland).
Me- Sir, historically Nagaland has been out of mainstream and in 1951, 99% supported for independence then we have 1963 formation of separate state of Nagaland and in 1975 Shillong
accord. Finally in August,2015 we have peace accord(NSCN-IM) which is not yet made public and there are some contentious isssues related to Nagalim demand and there are more than 20 tribes each claiming representing Naga issue. Since, Nagaland forms integral part of NE,the gateway to ASEAN and to bring Nagaland into mainstram we have integration camp in Nagaland.
M2- Tell me why legislation is not able to succeed in Rural education ?
Me- Talked of RTE and its failure citing ASER report.
M2- Dropout rate?
Me- Sir, I didn’t know the exact data, but its higher in classes 6th to 10th (He was expecting female dropout).
M2- Ujjwala scheme and its benefit and how are targets identified?
Me- Ujjwala is about LPG distribution , women empowerment and health like reducing indoor pollution. Target is based on BPL criteria(I asked Sir, I don’t have exact knowledge but can I try so he said yes,then I answered).
M2- Declining value system in forces and other dept and what you will do ?
Me- General answer like Yoga, motivation,regular interaction, ethics classes etc
M3- what are the lessons of History. Answer in 1 sentence ?
Me- United we stand, divided we fall. Like we saw in Turkish,Mughal and finally entry of British and partition in India.
M3- What did you observe today while coming here?
Me- Sir, I was living in flat so I took a cab to Upsc, in between I was huge traffic and crowd in early morning which is not seen in Gnadhinagar where I live as well as there were garbage piles burning causing huge pollution despite delhi being heavily polluted.
M4- So, how will reduce traffic problem?
Me- Sir, in delhi we can try U shaped loop like in Gandhinagar we have and it will help in reducing congestion as well as proper following of traffic signal as well as emphasis on alternate mode of transport and use of public transport.
M4- There is no space in delhi, so how will you do it ?
Me- Sir, we need holistic approach like developing nearby areas so that crowd can move there and developing line like today I saw Magenta lines(in construction) to cater more public
M4- Why Engg/Docs moving towards CS. Why we don’t have Sundar pichai type persona ?
Me- Asked 30 sec to think and then Talked of poor condition like gave example of Gujarat Engg colleges poor employment and thus moving towards CS. However nowadays we are having StartUps where youth are moving there etc. (He said I am talking of research etc and then said ok leave it )
LM- First female to have solo flight but crime against women is increasing etc so it doesn’t mean much ?
Me- Mam, It matters a lot as it gives moral strength to other halves that they are not confined to house only and they will compete with their counterparts etc etc.
LM- Have you seen any female stuggle(I was about to say my Mother, but she said obviously not your mother )who has bring some reforms.
Me- Talked of pandita ramabai.
LM-Earlier in your answers you talked of kings and then democracy so isn’t it contradictory . History is all about kings ?
Me- Mam, History is very vast not just limited to kings and political history but also includes Social,Economic, Environmental history. And I am inspired by kings who have done something good for nation.(CH nodded his head and said he is talking of Nation building kings)
LM- Tell me any 3 marvellous structure in India?
Me- Qutub Minar, Taj mahal(She was not satisfied and said I am talking of post independence) then I said DAMS, and since I was born in early 1990s so I saw the rise of METRO, and now there is talk of bullet trains etc. She said Ok.
CH- Ok, Avinash. Your interview is over. All the best
Observation- Very cordial board, and there was no uncomfortable question .