Interviews

UPSC interview, P. K. Joshi board, 14 Mar 2018

14 Mar 2018

Hari Om:

Background

Education : B.Tech , Materials and Metallurgical Engineering, IIT Kanpur

Home State : Bihar

Optional : Chemistry

Selected in IFoS 2017-18 ; Interview Board (IFoS) : Shri P K Joshi

Date of Interview : 14th March , 2018

Board (CSE) : Shri P K Joshi ; Duration : Approximately 45-50 mins

Chairman

1. Started with his usual way. You belong to Patna ; you have done schooling in Patna , Bokaro and then did graduation from IIT Kanpur. Meanwhile you also did research internships. Have you also appeared for IFoS interview ?

2. What was the result ? When the training begins ?

3. What are your service preferences in Civil Services ? ( Reason wasn't asked )

4. See if you go to students of class 11 or class 12 , they want to become engineers , doctors or civil servants. But rarely someone wants to become a farmer. What do you think are the reasons ?

5. Suppose 10 years down the line , you have to shift this trend , what will you do ?

6. What did you do during your research internships ?

7. What did you learn ? What was the role of your graduation subject in the projects?

Member 1

1. Suppose you are also selected here in CSE and get IRS (IT) , what will be your preferences ? Will you leave IFoS ? ( Service Preference in CSE as IAS > IFS > IRS (IT) )

2. So you will stick with IFoS. Lets place IFoS in the preference list of CSE as well. Now preferences ? : Said : IAS > IFS > IFoS > IRS (IT)

3. What are the reasons for such preference ?

4. Where can you use your graduation subject knowledge in administration ?

5. You have been associated in NCC ? What did you learnt ? What activities you contributed in ?

6. Since NCC is associated with armed forces ; why didn't you took armed forces as a career option ?

7. You were also associated with Security Team in your college . What exactly was your role ?

8. Status of Defense manufacturing in India ? Where we are lacking ? Reasons

9. We are not able to make engines for our military aircrafts. What do you think is reason ?

Member 2 ( Perhaps a Chemistry Prof , Only Chemistry was asked )

1. The project you did as research internship ; is it commercially viable ? If not ? Why ?

2. What is oxidation state of Chromium in Potassium Dichromate ?

3. What are main group elements ?

4. What are transition elements ?

5. Name all 3d block elements ?

6. Why the transition elements are colored in nature ?

7. What is crystal field theory ?

8. What is arrhenius theory in context of reaction rates ? Explain it on paper.

9. Draw cyclopentadienyl anion and cyclopentadienyl cation ? ( The pencil nib broke down while drawing :D )

10. Which one is aromatic in nature ? Why ?

11. What is Huckel Rule of Aromaticity ?

12. Are you aware of the Mendeleev periodic table ?

Member 3 ( Lady member)

1. Your upbringing has been largely in urban areas. What are the common problems in urban areas ?

2. How you can tackle the multiple problems you have mentioned ?

3. Ask about few acronyms which I still can't decipher. She said its related to coastal management

Member 4

1. What is the alloy used in soldering ?

2. Suppose you have to join two gold plates. Here in we also use an alloy of gold and other element. Whether the melting point of the element used along with gold in the alloy should have its melting point greater or lower than gold. Take your time and then answer.

3. Why the melting point of element being added should be lower ?

4. What is certification used for gold jewellery ? ( Other member : arey let him get married first, then he may know :D )

5. Shows me the kinley bottle on the table and asks Who gives the ISI certification.

Chairman : Thank you. Your interview is over.

Overall , it went into too much technicalities.It was looking more of an interview for a technical position rather civil services.There were 4-5 I don't knows.

All the best who have interviews in coming days.

Karthik R

Bhonsle board

Optional- Geography

Graduation- Electronics and communication engg

Don't know how useful this can be because most of them were based on my DAF...

Chairman-

-How close are education and creativity in the schools? Are they going together? If not what is to be done?

Member 1-

-Do you know reliance fresh? How is its business model?

-What is a microwave? What is its frequency range?

-Is the frequency range fixed or variable for various purposes and also according to the countries?

-Can we use radar in space?

Member 2-

-Why is Kerala forward in many indices compared to other states?

-Make a short film on an issue concerning both Kerala and other states.

-Make a short film on any parameter wrt human development index, the issue should be a concern to both Kerala and other states.

-What is your opinion regarding the recent death of the person in attapady?

-What is the tribal to non tribal ratio at attapady?

-Has the harmony of Kerala society been affected by the recent death?

Member 3-

-Some very long question on some incident in Kerala which I didn't understand, so said I'm not aware of that incident

- What is crafting counterfeit foliage?

-How do you lay optic fibre - underground or with the help of poles? Which is better if we want to lay it up to Leh?

-What is Kumarakom famous for? What is responsible tourism?

Member 4-

-What does Karthik mean?

-What is the other name by which Kerala is known? And why so?

-Why Alleppey called Venice of the East?

-How is the condition of the backwaters there?

-How houseboats cause pollution?

-Is corruption less in Kerala?

Chairman-

-U had missed a point when u said about Alleppey, the food there...

-Why is Karimeen (pearl spot) so special compared to other fish in India?

Your interview is over...

Abhijeet Ranjankar

Optional: PSIR

Grad: B.Tech. EnTC

P K Joshi Board

C: Is Ranjankar your name or surname?

What's the distance between Solapur and Kolhapur(Graduation)?

Solapur is famous for?

Solapur and Kolhapur lie in Marathwada region?

Cultural difference between Marathwada and Vidarbha?

What kind of exercise you do?(hobby)

What is the difference between doing exercise in gym and regular exercise?

Which comedy TV shows you watch(hobby)?

On which channel they are aired?

Who is the owner of star network?

What causes pollution? Soil pollution

Ground water depletion?

M1(Lady):

Questions on Western Ghat, Gadgil committe, biodiversity hotspots, as an administrator how to conserve? Illegal sand mining. etc

M2:

Should I install Mobile towers above my house? answer as an engg. What is lightning conductor? followed by few basic engg. questions

M3

Why at all we need to protect biodiversity?

Questions on Stephen Hawking his contribution? explain black hole to us + basic science questions

M4

Why Hawking didnt got Nobel prize? CNR Rao's contribution, solid waste management + follow up questions

Overall cordial board.

Hoping for best!!

Kumar Swapnil:

Date - 6.3.2018

Board - sujata mehta

Forenoon

Second to go

Interview duration - 25 to 30 mins

Home state - bihar

Optional- medical science

education - MBBS, MD (pharmacology)

Hobbies - fitness enthusiast and aesthetic bodybuilding, exploring mughlai delicacies of Delhi, dancing (Western and freestyle), mimicry.

CP- is this your photo?

Me : yes mam.

1. So tell me about your self.. From where have you graduated. What are you doing now?

2. Did you opt MBBS by choice

3. So explain to me this whole thing.. MBBS.. Now doing MD.. And now looking to enter civil service.

4. Tell me one biggest deficiency you found in medical education

5. Solution

6.this nhps. Do you think it can help the poor people you have seen at your hospital

7. What should the focus of the government : primary health or tertiary health

8. But do we have sufficient doctors in India to cater to these needs

M1: so I see you are doing your MD in pharmacology? What is the reason for branded generics being so pricey in India? Is anything being done about it?

2. Bihar is sometimes very unkindly

Counted among the bimaru states? What do you think?

3. How does the social dynamics of bihar hurt the development there

M3. (LM) 1.so I see your interest is in aesthetic bodybuilding? What is aesthetic bodybuilding?

2. What is this hype about this size zero? What is it and as a doctor would you advise it?

3. so another interest of your is exploring mughlai dishes of Delhi? So you cook them or go out with friends?

4. Did you ever explore any food of pre mughal times? Do you have any knowledge about it?

5.coming back to aesthetics.. What is the vision and philosophy of aesthetics

M3. Picking up from conversation with the cp

1.So you talked about rationalising mbbs course for making family medicine level of doctors first. But no doctor today is stopping at mbbs level. They are going for specialisation and superspecialisation? Why is it so?

2. But don't you think these family medicine doctors will create inefficiency and the number of medical negligence cases would rise?

3.after raising a myriad of issues in one line.. Corporate hospital overpricing.. Medical negligence.. Wrong diagnosis.. Blah blah blah.. What is the institutional mechanism in India to deal with such things

4. Isn't there any role ethics in medical education? Did you have any such exposure during your mbbs course

5. So you were born in muzaffarpur? What is very famous about muzaffarpur

6. How has litchi helped to increase the level of farmers income there

M4. 1. So why did you change your school after tenth?

2. New aiims are being set up.. What are ppl not going there and still coming to aiims Delhi

3. But don't you think that it is somehow related to people's mentality that aiims Delhi is much better

4. Euthanasia. What is the present legal stance on it? What is your opinion on euthanasia?

5. Is butter chicken a mughlai dish?

CP : OK.. So would you like us to ask about anything else that you had prepared and we did not ask

2. Self taught or trained?

OK you may go now

Sujata Mehta board

Duration~30 min

C:

Introduce itself

When u join NPA

Farmer long march, demand??

Why farming unattractive??

Why MBBS?

Medical bond? For whole India?

Why doctor not going to phc?

National health protection scheme?? Needs in India special when primary infrastructure not developed?

M1:

Nurture vs Nature vs crime... Some f/u questions... how it is helpful in reducing crime...Criminal ka beta criminal Banega?? How prejudice dangerous to society??

India France relationship

Recent changes in China constitution? Impact on India?

M3:

Malnutrition? Is icds failed?

Cultural factors in malnutrition?

Where it is present urban rural both?

Suggestions for health sector?

Cyber security??

M4:

Generic medicines?

Medical tourism?

Unethical corporate practice?

How to create awareness about generic medicines?

Why pharmaceutical industry developed in Haryana and Himachal??

M5:

Forest right act? If Land were given to tribal then it reduces forest cover? Instead giving land should we focus on social forestry?

Swaminathan committee recommendation?

National medical commission?? How it help to increase doctor no. ?? Bridge course opinion??

C: any area we left?? No mam

Thank you...

Praveen singh:

15 March FN session MANOJ SONI SIR Board. 2nd Last to go.

About me: Grad:MECH. Engg.

OPTIONAL: PSIR

Home town Varanasi

C- So u r from Varanasi. Tell me one impact that varanasi has on u?

C- tell me one impact that U had on Varanasi.

C-what was done after it?

M1- how do ganga gets polluted in varanasi?

M1- how to solve it?

M1-any local org. Engaged in awareness campaign for ganga cleaning?

M1- namami gange-ground status.

M1- what can be done to clean ganga?

M2- how old is ur college?

M2- who was harcourt butler <my college name>

M2- what was his contribution?

M2-why fewer people know about HBTI kanpur?

M2- I see u have played cricket in college. Should india and pak. Play cricket?

M2-so untill kashmir unrest doesnt gets over till then no cricket?

M2- Do u support bullet train?

M2- expected fare?

M2- so is it<bullet train> only a rich-class venture—not for common coz very high fare?

M2- Do u support a policy where corporates be allowed only to gain profit uptoo certain extent and rest be transferred to govt.?

M2- What is the motive of corporates?

M2- Do u support that only rich be allowed to stay in a country ?

M3- what type of songs u sing? (hobby) and fav. Singer.

M3- Use of robotics in IPS-law and order. (robotics nowhere mentioned in DAF)

M3- Do u support cloning?

M3- merits of cloning?

M3- How to increase agricultural productivity?

M3- do u support GM crops?

M3- can machines be used in indian agriculture in all areas?

M3- tell me something about irrigation status in india and how it can be imrpoved?

M4- (sitting quietly with no expression)- How will u use robotics in LWE areas?

M4- recently a country went short of garbage for its waste to energy plants. Name it?

<i didnt knw-he told me sweden>

M4- What is good about Nordic countries?

M4- do u know anything about the pension scheme in sweden?

<i didnt know the ans.>

Remarks: Lot of cross-questions were there. DAF was covered and M3 surprised me with disconnected topics. Overall cordial board with lot of smiles. It took 40 minutes.

PANKAJ TIWARI:

Pankaj Tiwari

15/03/2018 Afternoon

B.S. Bassi

Ch: 1. You are working at Ankleshwar. ONGC has also bases at North East?

1st oil well was drilled at which location ? When?

Cities near to Digboi

District of Arunachal near to Digboi

Tell me about Brahmaputra

Rivers originating from Lake Mansarovar

Lohit, Dihang, Dibang merge at Arunachal or Assam?

Till How many years the oil at Ankleshwar would be there

Till How many years the oil at Mumbai offshore would be there

M1:

Is Iran our neighbour?

Significance of Iran for India?

USA-Iran enemity. Why it is?

ONGC ha something to do with Vietnam ? Is our stand right?

M2:

Tell me of any development program of Modi govt ?

Apart from agriculture?

Tell me about Energy Policy of Govt?

What is target of fossil fuel energy in New Policy?

Private sector role in Energy

M3:

Recent news of a chopper is being called as flying coffin?

Whose fault was it?

What should ONGC do to transport their employees. Private players?

Should be add new fleet?

Highest point on the surface of earth from the centre of earth

Don’t you think RBI is blaming the govt for its regulatory failure?

M4:

Why fisherman cross the marine boundary to fish into territory of other countries?

Till now to which country India has given maximum fund/assistance. Why?

You are already working in ONGC. Its paying you a lot. Why do you want to join CS

The problem & challenges of Civil services.

How will you be able to stand up against these challenges?

concept of needs BY Maslow

Chairman ! Thank is it you (Showing photo)

Your interview is over!

Hemant:

Background

Btech electrical engineering

Optional: political science and international relations

Hobbies: Reading IR and cricket

Board: Sujata Mehta mam

Mam:

1.is this your photo?

2. Tell me about yourself (she was looking at my DAF when I was saying)

3. You graduated in 2016, Did you get any job from college? (I said I didn't sit for any)

4. Why you didn't sit for placements?

5. You did iit becz you wanted to or you were pressurized by parents?

6. What is your view on society?

7. What is the population of India?

8. What are the population prediction about India in coming time?

9.What is divided in demographic divided?

10.What will happen if we don't utilise this dividend?

11. How much time you think will it take India to resolve all the issues in India like poverty, inequality, infrastructure gap and all that, take a wild guess?( I replied 30 years, don't know whether it was a good number or not).

12. What are the issues in Jharkhand?

13. Why you want to be in services?

14. So you want to be in services for personal development?( I said yes)

M1 (he wasn't sure of what he was asking)

1. What are the issues in Jharkhand? (Mam looked at him as she already had asked the same question)

2. So you are a computer Engineer? (I said no sir I am an electrical engineer)

3. Ok so tell me what is this skill India, no leave it. You tell me is skill India a success. ( I said sir it is too soon to say)

4. Yes yes you are right, tell me is it going in right direction?

5. What is corporate social responsibility?

6. Do all companies have to follow CSR?( I said I am unable to recall the criteria as such right now).

M2

1. Why USSR disintegrated?

2. Why Soviet Russia entered in Afghanistan?

3. Did disintegration of USSR affected negatively to India?

4.How this issue of North Korea improving relation with us and south Korea will affect India?

5. What is money bill? ( Here I was taken aback by this sudden shift of question from IR to this, I took a pause for few seconds and then replied)

6. What will happen if this bill is presented in Rajya sabha?

7. What is this whole issue about the passage of this bill right now in lok sabha ( read this in morning newspaper)

M3

1. Did Jharkhand aspirations of development materialise?

2. Jharkhand have the potential, why it is not moving ahead? ( 3 rd time same question, mam again looked at him)

3. Is naxalism a terrorism?

4. Difference between revolution and terrorism?

5. Which scholar talked about revolution for the first time?

6. Why Aristotle said about this?

7. Was inequality a reason given by him on his extensive study of causes of revolution?

8. Do you see inequality in Jharkhand a reason for underdevelopment?

9. He said something about a scholar and his book and few theory names given by him and asked me to relate this 3 theories in Jharkhand (I don't know from where he got that name as a political philosoper as I didn't heard his name or his theory so I replied no sir I don't know.)

He said no problem.

M4( he was looking at the clock for the whole time)

1. How is the relationship of India and Pakistan?

2. Kulbhashan Jadhav case has impacted relation and India is also not talking to Pak, how do you see that?

He asked 2 more questions which I don't remember

Mam:

1. This issue of DBT in PDS in Jharkhand, why do you think these civil servant implement such schemes despite knowing their practical invisibility).

2. Why this gap of reality in making of schemes in accordance to region?

3. What will you do as a civil servant to improve this communication gap between administration and local people?

4. What is the status of digital penetration in Jharkhand? ( I said I'm not aware of the number but it's quite low)

5. Tell me as per your personal experience how is digital connectivity there?

Ok is there anything you want to talk about which we haven't covered?

I said yes mam, cricket.

She smiled and said tell us about cricket.

What changes need to be there in cricket body and any thing you feel should be done to utilise it?

Thank you. Your interview is over.

Comments: cordial board. Main intervi

Rango:

Chairman: Bassi

Telanagana

Badminton

14 march

You play badminton. Singles or doubles?

What is fly by wire system?(DAF)

What is jyotirlinga? Does Telangana have any?

Pilgrimage places in Telangana?

Historical significance of warangal?

Where famous balaji temple is located? Is in AP or Telangana?

What is non aligned movement

What is multipolar world?

Is India one of the pole?

How you are saying India is a pole?

What is LoU and LoC?

What are the foreign forces present in Syria?

What is the justification for Russia intervening in Syria?

What about USA?

If there will be no constitutional safeguards for civil servants. What happens?

What is NAPCC?

What are the missions under it?

What is forest rights act?

What is wild life protection act?

What is the forest cover area?

How much population live in forests?

Bassi is expression less but he is ok