UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 30 Jul 2020 (Uttar…)
30 Jul 2020
आकाशगंगा
From uttar pradesh
B Tech in mechanical engineering
Literature of Hindi Language
Working in CPSU
Board - Smitha Nagraj madam
Date - 30-07-2020, afternoon, second to go
Chairperson
Come..., take chair.
Pull mask down and also pull the shield slightly down... Yeah OK (now only proper shield cover on face. Felt better as mask was below mouth)
1. What are you doing?
2. OK what was today's exciting work?
(I asked 'today's madam' to clarify)
3. Yesterday's or day before yesterday (answered - design of magnetic coupling)
4. OK what two things it will couple?
5. Why you want to come here?
6. I see you a typical case where you have been trained for, and doing the same work. By leaving it, you will be spoiling...
7. Do you think, technical work not recognized in our society? had it been recognised, you would have stayed?
8. It is said there is political interference in administration. What do you understand by 'political interference'?
9. Although not precise (my answer) but what will you do if a political leader orders you to do something?
(here some counter question)
For your information, you are not bound to do illegal work. (in the previous answer I said that I am bound if the order is in writing)
Passed on to member, M1
1. Your optional is Hindi literature. Which writer you like most?
2. What difference you find between writer in Hindi literature and writers in Bollywood?
3. Government stake in your PSU.
4. Composition of minority shareholders.
5. Should government sell its stake in companies?
M2
1. Do you think government should stay in business?
2. There are public sector companies in China. How they are functioning?
(not able to recall one or two more questions)
M3
1. You are from xyz district. It comes in Eastern UP or western UP?
2. Technically should it come in Eastern UP?
Should UP be divided?
3. We talk about reforms. If we look at lower level police personnel, they come from society where use of force is the norm. They do same in their service. How to address this?
4. During lockdown, job losses have happened. Many people are uncertain about their future. Should government give money to these people?
5. On one hand we have stockpile of Food grains, on the other hand people going hungry. As an administrator what you will propose?
M4
1. You talked about agri reform, FCI reform. Why to procure Food grains?
2. NFSA is fine but is it economically right decision?
3. How much is buffer stock limit. How much is stocked now... (answered 40 and nearly 80 MMT)
4. OK almost double. Do you know in Europe they give money to farmers to not grow crops? Should we also do?
5. Will it be right to discourage crop production?
Back to madam
1. There is so much wealth in temples. Charity is good think but if they are just keeping it should government impose tax on them?
2. Who will be the protesting against such decision?
3. But you know, administration in most cases is with government... Then?
4. OK leave it (I said sorry in previous question) what you say in agriculture? Should it be taxed?
5. But will it be worthwhile? Administrative burden and the outcome...
OK, thank you.