UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 11 Mar 2020 (Telugu…)
11 Mar 2020
• Board: Mrs. Smita Nagraj Ma'am.
• Name: Aditya
• Date: 11-03-2020 @ 3:50-4:20pm
(Mech Engg-2017, Sociology Optional, Chandrapur(Maharashtra).
CHAIRPERSON:
-Aditya Sit down(smiling)
-What were you doing after graduation(2017) didnt you prefer to do job?
-What was placement at your college?
-What was the placement in your dept?
-How much of them where in core(mech engg)?
- Why so low?
- So aditya dnt you think we as society have reduced to ourselves as people with substandard adherence to quality?
-But this is what we observe at various levels and institutions?
-what mechanism and legislations we have in place for citizens to register their complaints with authority or make them accountable?
- is RTI good? Had it helped?
- tell me any scam you think has been unearthed by RTI?
-are you sure 2G scam was unearthed by RTI(grim look)
-ok(smiling)
-others?
- What will you do to make sure that a road gets built as per the standards and not low quality?
-ok (smiling)
MEMBER 1:
- So Aditya you come from chandrapur? What are the main highlights or specialities of it?
- Have you visited any mine?
-How much coal reserve are there?
- How many mines?
-What are malpractices in coal mining?
- Anything other that diversion of coal to non-beneficiary company by means of smuggling?
-Are you aware of some uranium deposits found in your district?
- What percentage of Tribals in chandrapur?
- Which are the tribes?
-Do the tribals benefit from naxals?
- Why naxalism in chandrapur-gadchiroli?
-Why dont they support govt. Initiatives?(
- How will you enhance the development of tribals?
- Which tribe is most ancient in your dist.?
- Isnt it kolam?
- Should vidarbha be seperated?
-Why you feel so?
-But representatives would get more representations, and they make such demands?
-Ok(smiling)
MEMBER 2:(sir grilled me, cut me short while speaking asking question on above the other)
+ Aditya you come from vidarbha region many farmer suicide why?
-what about suicides in marathwada?
- isnt credit a major problems?
-cant we have cooperatives to solve problems of farmers in vidarbha?
- maharashtra budget and farmers welfare?
- sugarcane a water guzzling crop still grown in western maharashtra why?isnt it ecological damage in long term at cost of incentives?
- your hometown is near to anandwan. Anandwan model can it be replicated in some way to increase farmers income in vidarbha and such farmers org.?
- is miyawaki it really promising and how?
- why its called miyawaki?
MEMBER 3:
-started with saying now we relate with something mechanical oh forget something manufacturing.
-gave very long explanation about percent of sectors in economy and their contribution to gdp.
- how can we improve this share of manufacturing? Dnt you think aditya it will me good idea?
(I asked for a few moment to think, sir was like yes aditya this question is very thoughtful i expect you to think abt it and then ans. Smiling)
- yes defence export and manufacturing good, space domain good but on broad based sector like automobile what are your views?
- Yes EV and scraping infra. Good?
- Again explained me of atomic research in India and said our strength is valued more here ,why?
- yes denial of technology was a major reason bt why we excelled in this domain?
- (smiling)Yes aditya you are not supposed to know abt all of this although.
MEMBER 4:
- Aditya you heard abt the PMC bank failure? Why it failed?
- ah, you are making it very simpler? Yes exposure to single entity and its default was main reason. Ok then how do you asses when a bank will fail?
- yes crar, roa, npa are of concern. As u said crar of 9% under basel 3. But you know in NPAs we dnt know what amount is sustainable gave long explanation.
- asked again one question i dnt remember
CHAIRPERSON:
- If you were to work in any sector apart form the civils which wud had it been?
-(lightening and sharply) then what holds you back what are you doing here( smile)?
- ok(nodding) so can you solve all problems over here?
- oh so your approach would be better.
Ok Aditya your Interview is over.
_____
Thank You Ma'a
m,
Thank You Sir
( Overall board was very cordial, engaging and giving positive vibes, smiles exchanged, ma'am was noting down something on a piece of paper, she also moderated the time of each board member.)
Medicals and Final results are not correlated. Pls don't message us asking the same again and again.
CSE 2019 FR Speculations*
Final Results speculations only from credible Insiders.
https://t.me/CSE19_FR
CSE 2019 FR Speculations* Final Results speculations only from credible Insiders. https://t.me/CSE19_FR
B. Rahul
27 /02/20 , Board: Smitha Nagaraj madam
Background: Btech in Electrical Engineering from NIT Warangal,
Work experience: Asst.Engineer in TSSPDCL(Discom) ,currently on EOl
Optional:Telugu Literature
Place: Telangana
Chairman:
1) So you are on leave. What is your company’s Leave policy?
2) When did your company got formed? (I replied the date and also said earlier it was a part of Andhra Pradesh Discom) ,
3) Why both your states (Telangana& AP ) don’t want to go together even in one sector? Why complete separation ? (not convinced with my answer)
(Then questions started revolving around Inter-state problems)
4) What are the interstate problems ? and many follow up questions
(madam is intervening and expecting more )
(while answering I said inter state migration as a problem even pre –Covid 😉)
5) Is that actually a problem? What are they? Then what is government doing ?
Member 1 (Aged one) :
1) Do u know about Narla Thata Rao ? I said no sir, then he explained me .
2) What are the problems in Power Distribution sector ? Explain about losses ?
3) Which state is in better position and why?
(while answering He said ,I am asking something and you are saying another )
4) What to do for improvement of overall power sector ?
Member 2 :
1) What is in the news regarding Supreme court.
(At that time International Judicial Conference was held in Delhi )
2) What is the controversy there?
(I said, one Judge was praising PM Modi in public platform )
3) What is the name of Judge ?
4) Is it wrong what he did ? Don’t afraid ,Tell your honest opinion ?
5) Then what he could have done ?
6) What are the advantages of privatization ?
7) Explain in the context of DISCOMS on ground level ?
8) If efficiency is the problem, why can’t we improve that in Government sectors ?
Member 3 :
1) What is Naxalism ? Explain their ideology ?
2) Telangana got succeeded in tackling this problem ,how ?
3) Then why Chattisgadh and Maharshtra were still struggling ? Why can’t they replicate your state model there ?
4) If you are the DGP of Maharashtra what could have be done ?
5) Does Central Home Ministry is doing enough in fighting against Naxalism ?
(Member 1 got intervened ,madam with your permission can I ask him a question then chairman said yes )
6) Can we do Surgical strikes on these Naxalite affected areas ? Take a stand and substantiate your view.
Member 4 :
1) Define Nationalism and Patriotism ?
2) What is the difference ?
3) Which one is better according to you and why?
4) Can you provide a live example ?
5) What Defense equipment India is buying from US in recent concluded agreements?
(Trump visited India 2 days earlier )
6) What are the specifications of those helicopters ?
7) What measurements should be taken for domestic production of Defense equipment?
Chairman :
1) Even since these years why corruption still persists ?
2) Why there are more demand of dowry in your state ?
( I explained and at last I said in recent times many educated youth are not in favor of dowry )
3) Give me an example then ?
Member 2 : With a smile ,asked me Are you married ? I said No
Then he asked will you take dowry ? then I said No
Then with smile he said everyone says like this only but after getting service you people demand more ....
Everyone laughed at this moment and
I said No sir, Its against my Conscience.
Chairman said your interview is over and you can leave .
Overall very cordial board . 30 Minutes of interview and in that Chairman only took around 12 minutes. every member encouraged me to answer more points , even they helped me a little bit to do so.
30th July 2020
Forenoon Session
Air Marshal Board
Arun K
Chairman:
NCC Motto?
What according to u is discipline?
Self Discipline?
Few more questions. Forgot. Mostly allowed to speak more.
M1:
What was your position in IBM?
Speak about Artificial Intelligence
Digital india
Previously we had good relation with S.Lanka. Why recently deterriorated?
In this situation should we interact with China through BRICS Platform?
M2:
Was your graduation knowledge(petroleum) useful in IBM?
How Geography of India played a role in development of Vedic civilisation?
What about the role of Vindhyas in Vedic period?
Why cyclones are more frequent in Bay of Bengal than Arabian sea. ?
M3:
You are posted in SBI that too in tamilnadu. Why are you looking to move away through civil service?
I have heard something about pudukottai(native) Tell me some more about the administration and unique things
Is still ppl are living in social harmony through improved literacy because of Arivoli Iyakkam( follow up question)
List he biogeographical regions of India.
MR:
Financial inclusion ?
Upi and wallets difference?
Types of wallets
Digital india 9 pillars tell 2 or 3.
I ll help. Speak about e kranti.
(Still said could not get it)
E kranti is e delivery of services. Speak about it.
Jam Trinity
Was it successful?
Digital infrastructure speak about it
What are the techniques in bringing internal control in the context of accountability.
Digital infrastructure as a utility speak about it.
What is utility.
Chairman -
U refrained from biogeography regions qn. Try.
Petro dollar
China paying Iran in yuan what is the effect on America.
Thank you.
A M
Board : Bhonsle Sir
Background :
Indian forest services
IIT Roorkee
Metallurgical engineering
From : Uttar Pradesh
Hobbies : swimming , reading comics
First one to go on 30 July 2020
Chairman:
1.You can remove the mask so that we can see you.
2. Lecture on being comfortable and just do the conversation. We have judged you. Just talk ij any language or write on paper. Just Express, think and answer.
3. Gave a definition of administration by himself.
4. What is 'welfare' in administration based on the definition.
5. What is 'moral way' again based on definition.
6. What is more than provision of goods and services in the term welfare.
7. How our young officers should deal with making administration more efficient given the changing times and requirements.
Member 1 :
1. Born in Allahabad and recent visit to it
2. Tell the mythology of kumbh and then why mela is organised.
3. Tell about project tiger.
4. Is the bureaucracy successful if we see this tiger surge?
Member 2 :
1. Have you faced ragging.
2. Has anyone else in your college faced ragging.
3. Are joint families declining
4. Adding India with veto powers in UNSC will create another veto based on national interest and other non veto countries will suffer.
5. You have not read biology then how the interest for forest services.
Member 3:
1. What is biodiversity
2. Any law or structure related to it nationally and internationally
3. Tell about cartagena protool
4. What are living modified organisms
5. How is genetic modification done.
6. Importance of zinc in general
7. It's extraction and mines in India
Member 4 :
1. What's superconductivity
2. Where we see it and any practical application
3. How electrons move in superconductor
4. What's nanomaterial and usage.
5. How properties of materials vary in nano dimension
6. AI and job loss. How to deal.
7. AI and importance of emotional intelligence.
8. Relevance of human intelligence.
Chairman:
1. Gave quote to explain: everybody is a genius, but if you judge a fish by asking to climb it will lead whole life feeling foolish....'
2. Relate to the new education policy released today.
3. What do do plan to do after interview is over.
4. Suggested for going to UPSC museum as I am being freed very early.
Thank you, your interview is over.
Aranya
Pl find attached transcript
Board – Sujata Mehta Ma’am,
Month – March 16 , 2020
Optional – Anthropology
Background – Btech Electrical, work Ex - mobile-telecom sector and electrical PSU
CW –
1. About yourself
2. Privatization of BSNL – should it be done
3. Why BSNL not able to perform
4. Why Nokia mobile failed
M1
1. What is Nanotech, what are its benefits, uses
2. Archimedes principle (DAF based)
3. What is surge pricing
4. Direct and Indirect tax – difference
M2
1. Should allow Huwaei or not
2. What is the immediate remedy of ‘1’ above (asked by CW )
3. Should we save Vodafone or not
4. Legal interception of phone calls – its requirements, impacts and relevant provisions in Act (DAF related)
M3
1. Machines used in hydropower
2. Small storage plants
3. Should we go for hydro power
4. Run of river projects – what are they
5. Pump storage – what is it
6. Issues in electrical sector
7. Solution to issues of Discoms
M4 –
1. About differences in people in different states I lived in
2. What are some features of Himachal Pradesh I liked (DAF)
3. Why so many temples in Himachal Pradesh
4. What is difference between running, walking and jogging
CW –
1. Sectors that should be considered strategic
2. Anything that I have to say
Arun Krishanan
30th July 2020
Forenoon Session
Air Marshal Board
Arun K
Chairman:
NCC Motto?
What according to u is discipline?
Self Discipline?
Few more questions. Forgot. Mostly allowed to speak more.
M1:
What was your position in IBM?
Speak about Artificial Intelligence
Digital india
Previously we had good relation with S.Lanka. Why recently deterriorated?
In this situation should we interact with China through BRICS Platform?
M2:
Was your graduation knowledge(petroleum) useful in IBM?
How Geography of India played a role in development of Vedic civilisation?
What about the role of Vindhyas in Vedic period?
Why cyclones are more frequent in Bay of Bengal than Arabian sea. ?
M3:
You are posted in SBI that too in tamilnadu. Why are you looking to move away through civil service?
I have heard something about pudukottai(native) Tell me some more about the administration and unique things
Is still ppl are living in social harmony through improved literacy because of Arivoli Iyakkam( follow up question)
List he biogeographical regions of India.
MR:
Financial inclusion ?
Upi and wallets difference?
Types of wallets
Digital india 9 pillars tell 2 or 3.
I ll help. Speak about e kranti.
(Still said could not get it)
E kranti is e delivery of services. Speak about it.
Jam Trinity
Was it successful?
Digital infrastructure speak about it
What are the techniques in bringing internal control in the context of accountability.
Digital infrastructure as a utility speak about it.
What is utility.
Chairman -
U refrained from biogeography regions qn. Try.
Petro dollar
China paying Iran in yuan what is the effect on America.
Thank you.
Ravindra
RG
Electrical engineering
Bassi sir
No current affairs
Cm. Why a wire over transmission line structure is it for birds to sit and have a bird's eye view?
M1.
1.What is Smart grid?
2. How to increase efficiency?
3.Supercritical tech in power plant? Related parameters?
F1.
1.What data to use for having idea about a place for governance?
2.Hdi, gender adjusted etc.
3.Qualities of civil servant?(I vomited nolan)
M2.
1. Why watch Ted talk ?
2. Where main event held?
3. Last watched video?
M3.
1.How to use data analytics for rural areas?
2. Sex ratio of up, today and in 1900?
2.how to correct sex ratio in up?
3.Tech and non tech measures?
4. Women safety?( I told about an app)
Cm
1. If made lg, what one thing to implement in first week?( Go to samadhi , close eye and then answer)
2.why no work in smog tower till now?
3. Have you seen himmat app?
Overall average. M1 and M3 grilled as expected in this board. Adjusted mic many times as prompted by members.
Akash Goyal:
AKASH, 21st JULY 2020,3rd to go AFTERNOON, 3:15 PM- 3:45 PM
R.N. Chaubey + 4 male members, ( Long Inverted U shape table, I was sitting inside U)
Hobby(No qn): Playing cricket, Watching mastery sessions by Robin sharma
Optional: Geography
Home State: Uttarakhand
B.tech- ECE(No qn)
No qn on Job ex- IT sector(1.5 Years)
Achievement: Merit list Chemistry Class 12th
Sir may I come in?
Ch:Please come
Good afternoon sir.
Ch: Please take your seat
Ch: You can pull down your mask.
Rules:- So Akash we want to tell you it is a conversation, if you don’t know any qn, say I don’t know so that we can move forward.
So did you had your Lunch?
Sir I had my breakfast
So you must be hungry should we arrange lunch for you?
No sir, we had Maaza. Thank you
Where have you been staying?
Sir Uttarakhand bhavan.
Ohh, so you have come all the way from your home?
Yes sir.
Chairman:
Q1. Please tell about your educational background and job experience
Q2. Akash is one of the 5 elements in Hindu mythology, what are other 4?
Q3. Can you tell me 3 most important electoral reforms needed in your view?
Q4. What are the positives and negatives of a electoral bond?
Q5. So good now you know positives and negatives of electoral bonds. Tell me as a ECI what changes would you suggest?
Sir I would like the name of the donors be open to all.
Q6. Do you think anyone will pay, if names are disclosed?
Chairman was very pleasing and smiling throughout.
Ch: Passes on to other member
M1
Q1. So your optional is Geography, you know that dinosaurs existed in our subcontinent. Can you tell their names?
Q2. Recently there has been excavation of dinosaur fossils, can you tell where?
Q3. Can you tell the oldest river system in India?
Q4. What is the difference between Panchatantra and Jataka tales?
Q5. Where are India’s strategic petroleum reserves?
Sir it is in Pudur, Vizag. Also we are planning to have one in USA, but it is still to be finalized.
He said, he was asking something else, he repeated( I couldn’t understand what he was trying to ask :
I said I don’t know
The member didn’t look very convinced, and was kind of shaking his head in disapproval. Wasn’t happy I would say.
The chairman meanwhile was standing, walking, but appeared to be listening.
M2 (Was smiling and friendly)
Q1. You are from uttarakhand, can you tell why Himachal is more developed than U.K
Q2. Monkeys are eating all your crops, what should be done?
Q3. Said something like, in himachal not much monkey problem and all. Seeing my face expression he said ok I understand that u might not be having data for it. I’m just telling you.
Q4. So you are from dehradun right?
No sir, I was only born there.
Ok, but do you know something about dehradun.
Yes sir, little bit.
OK, so tell me what are the names of three Petroleum institutes in Dehradun.
Q5. The himalayan states and North-east states get funding in the ratio 90:10, then also why are they not able to utilize funds properly?
Q6. So what should be done for better utilization of funds?
M3
Q1. So you spoke about E governance( from last answer I gave), can you tell how can you apply it for better governance?
Member summarized my point- So you want officer incharge to be held accountable.
I somewhere said, community participation needs to be promoted. He said people will participate, but is it enough, shouldn’t they raise their voice. I said both are necessary. He then nodded.
Q2. Have you heard of UGC?
Yes sir.
What is the full form.
Sir Universal Grants commission.
What?
Sorry sir, University Grants commission
Q3. What is it’s role and function?
Q4. Ok, so now tell me what is UCG?
Sir I don’t know, will check it.
Q5. What is RTE act, and what were the recent amendments.
Q6. So do you have some idea about army, navy.
Yes sir little bit.
You know we have various commands in army. Tell me the commands of Indian army.
Q7. What is EIA, what has been amendments recently in Draft EIA.
Told about exemptions in strategic sector.
Q8. So what should have been done according to you?
Sir I thi
nk we should
define what actually constitutes strategic sector.
Q9. Tell me if you have to construct a road in strategic border area, and it passes through ecological area. Will you construct the road? Yes/No?
Member summed it up: So u will construct, keeping in mind ecology.
I said yes sir.
M4
Q1. What is AQI?
Q2. What are the gases?
Sir it includes oxides of nitrogen, sulphur, Carbonmonoxide etc
Q3. Tell me 2 other important constituents, which are very important.
I recalled and said, sir PM 2.5, and PM 10
Q4. He said what is the impact on health like Lungs.
I repeated same thing sir it is harmful for our Lungs. He said OK-OK.
Q5. Tell me the categories and range in which it is divided as you said earlier also.
Q6. Now listen carefully. Tell me, per unit cost of manufacturing is cheaper for coal or solar. He said did u understood the qn. I said yes. But he still repeated the same statement.
Q7. Will coal plants shut down?
Chairman:
So Akash it was very nice talking to you.
Anything you would like to ask or share with us? Or anything you expected us to ask, but we didn’t asked.
Sir my weak points.
Ch: Did someone tell you that we are asking weak points?(He Smiled)
I said no sir.
Q1. Why do you want us to ask your weak points?
Q2. If you don’t mind you can tell your weak points.
Very good.
Your interview is over. We wish you good luck for your life.
Thank you Sir!
Overall a good experience. Chairman sir had a very pleasing personality. Said I don't know in number of questions. (They didn't allowed me to settle , though I tried to remain honest, calm and confident).
Good luck for the results!!
Yash
Date : 28/02/20
Board : Sathyavathy Mam's Board
Optional - PSIR
Hobbies - Playing Piano, Meditation
What is your first name?
Why did you do distance degree?
Why do you want to join civil services?
Asked about Lydan Nadeshwaram ( piano prodigy)
Is WTO relevant?
How Meditation will help you in civil services?
M1
How the idea of Rann of Kutch festival came up and few follow up questions.( DAF)
Tell me about Wild Ass (Gudhkar ) speciality its status
Types of different wind instruments
What is the difference between piano and mouth organ?
What is the role of superstition? ( Could not answer it properly)
M2
Asked about Article 365 and few followup question
Rationale behind Concurrent list
Asked whether I have read any Harold Laski's book?
What is the meaning of Sarvodaya ?
What was Gandhiji's vision for India
Is India protectionist or open?
M3
Tell me about bhuj Earthquake and few follow up questions.
How can we manage disasters in general?
Describe India - EU relationship
M4
Role of Catalyst in chemical reaction?
What type of meditation do you do?
Asked me to name 7 chakras.
Name 1 major problem of Kutch and how will you solve it?
What was Narmada Bachao Andolan for?
All the best to everyone.
Sahithya M A
(Karnataka)
David sir panel
30th July 2020, the Forenoon session
First one to go
Optional: Sociology
Chairman
So you are Sahithya.. beautiful name Sahithya, please sit down.
1. You like Kabir Das dohe(couplets) , recite one of your favourites. Some follow up questions on the same.
2. Will dohe help you in civil service? Gave a scenario and asked me a relevant doha for it. Some follow up questions on the same.
3. Why do you like Kabir Das couplets why not Rahim or Surdas or Tulsidas?
4. Was Kabir more profound than all others ?
5. Have you heard of this couplet from Rahim das ?
6. You can give a try to Rahim Das as well, there are some good ones.
M1
1. What is this JENESYS ? (DAF)
2. Have you been to Japan ?
3. Okay, tell me few things that you like and dislike about Japan and Japanese lifestyle.
4. Have you heard of Satoshi Nakamoto? I will give you a hint ' Bitcoin'
5. What is India's strategic culture?
*unable to recall some questions*
M2 (lady member)
1. *Picked up from Chairman* - Not calling an evil an evil is a greater evil, what do you say?
2. Tell me an incident from your life where you have dared to call an evil an evil?
3. Gave me a situation where I have to deal with an evil person. (Narrated a long complex scenario and barely audible) What will be your strategy?
4. Explain to me India China relations from 1960 onwards.
M3 ( Everything regarding electricity, grids )
1. How much electricity is produced in Belgaum? Is it sufficient for your district?
2. Have you heard of AT&C losses? Explain.
3. Okay, so how do you overcome these losses? Give me solutions.
4. What is a smart meter? How does it work?
5. What is this one country one grid about? What is the necessity?
*Unable to recall some questions*
M4
1. You are a student of Sociology, so tell me about Human Development scenario in India.
2. How does India fare in gender parity?
3. What could be the reasons for the low rank in gender parity on a global scale?
4. Do you think 33% reservation in parliament will help?
5. How has the reservation in local governments helped women?
6. In this age when everybody is fond of SMS and chats, why do you like writing letters? Whom do you write to? How do they respond?
7. What is it so special about letters?
8. Okay, so now I will recite a couplet from Kabir Das collection and you tell me the meaning. ( It was like coming a full circle :) )
Chairman
1. So, Sahithya tell me what has been the high point for you in this interview?
2. Low point?
*some light moments in the end*
Before you leave, please verify if this is your picture. You may leave now Sahithya. Thank you.
The board was extremely accommodating. Chairman asked me to take off the mask and be comfortable. Since the hall was huge and members seated with a good distance between them, mikes were provided. All the members were patiently listening, especially the lady member- she was smiling most of the times. Positive vibes, frequent acknowledgement to responses and smiles.
The experience was rich indeed.
CA
Date: 21st july, afternoon
Board: PK joshi
Background: BSc and Law
Optional: PSIR
Home state: Haryana
Chairman: started reading my Daf and I was nodding and acknowledging. I graduated with law in 2018. Asked me what was I doing since then. Why didnt I go for practice, then shifted to subject questions:
1) What do you mean by contract by minor? Is it valid?
2) What is the difference between undue influence and coercion?
3) Who is a bailor?
4) Asked something about sale of goods act
5) what do you mean by the statement that "mistake of fact is allowed but mistake of law is not"
He was expressionless throughtout and was straight to the point.
M1: You have studied physics so tell about heisenberg's principle of uncertainty.
- What is state in political science?
- What is the difference between watercolour painting and other types of painting
- A section in IPC where mens rea is not required for punishment
- PIL system in India and How is it faring ( Judicial activism)
M2: You have done theatre, tell different types of theatre in India
- Is PDS system effective? Dont you think we should dismantle it? (A lot of counter questioning in this)
- You read non fiction, latest read? What was it about?
- Latest ordinances in agriculture sector, your view
M3: What qualities do you possess that will make you a good civil servant?
- Bullet train, is it necessary?
- 2 sectors in India's development where investment is needed
- You have organised blood donation camps, do you know about Bombay blood group?
M4: Tell me about india-iran relations
- Balochistan issue
- patriarchy in haryana, what are the issues
- Laws in India regarding corruption
- Under companies act, is there any provision where indian laws can apply on MNCs?
He signalled to chairman that he is done, then chairman said thank you.
I thanked everyone and left the room.
V A M Karthik
Board: B B VYAS
DOI: 17/03/2020 forenoon
Optional: Mathematics
Chairman:
1. Does your friends call you Karthik? What does it mean?
2. Is mathematics a science?
3. What is STEM and why is the government emphasizing on it?(Fumbled here a bit)
4. There's a report that only 14% of engineering graduates are employable. Do you agree?
5. I was talking to an IIT professor recently and he said all our computer science engineers need to be recalled for a one year reengineering course considering the technological advancements. Do you think that's necessary?
6. India is the 3rd largest startup hub. Your thoughts? What are the other two?
7. Suppose two ladies from guntur start an andhra achar business, will it be called a startup? What according to you is a startup?
8. The hon'ble prime minister wanted to travel to London but Pakistan Government denied permission over it's airspace. Is there a law to govern this?
9. Suppose you want to travel to London but not through Pakistan, what alternative route will you take? What would be the difference in travel time?
10. What countries will you encounter while going through this route?
11. Recently an aircraft was grounded because of a technical issue. Tell me the exact issue.
12. Nuclear triad. What can you tell me about it?
Lady member M1:
1. What can you tell me about electric flights?
2. There's a proposal to test human electric flight by the end of this year in a country. Can you tell me which one?
3. Women movements in andhra, be it shg or some other, are considered to be very successful. What's special about women in Andhra Pradesh? Why're they not as successful in other states?
4. Literacy rate of women in Andhra Pradesh?
5. You stayed in Pune. There's a very big palace of historical importance. Did you visit it?
6. Recently the government has made some changes to the packaging of one of the products. Do you know anything about it? It's related to tobacco. Now can you recall?
7. You like chess. Chess teaches us one very important lesson that's useful in real life. What is it?
8. The government made a decision to unilaterally extend the DD services to some countries. What can you tell me about it?
9. What did you learn in NCC?
M2:
1. Is India dependent on GPS?
2. Do we have plans to extend our IRNSS to the whole world?
3. What other countries have their own positioning system?
4. Have you heard of Greyhound?
5. What is it?
6. Is the naxal problem finished? Don't we need to worry about it?
7. What can be a long-term strategy to deal with the left wing extremism?
M3:
1. Why are IITs not producing research on par with universities abroad?
2. With in engineering research, what are the problems?
3. Is funding the only problem? What about brain drain?
4. What can be done to improve the higher education research?
5. Have you heard go Gaganyaan?
6. other countries have already done it. Is it necessary to do the same?
7. What are it's advantages?
S F
Date 29 July 2020
Afternoon session
B S Bassi Sir Board
Background- M pharmacy
Optinal- Urdu literature
State- Maharashtra
Ch-
1.Worked as medical representative which company?
2. What were the methods used by you for marketing?
3. Giving literature and sample legal ?
4. Worked for the polio awareness what is strategy for polio?
5. Eradicated polio why it is still given?
M1-
1. presented paper on sem cell what is it about?
2. What is the source of stem cell?
3. Which diseases it is given?
4. Embryonic and placental cell are same?
5. Should we legally permit organ donation?
6. Why not if we can help poor patient as well as the poor donor?
7. But Russia and China permitting this?
M3- Lady member
1. In current situation what role can pharma industry play?
2. What are the challenges and opportunities we are having?
3. Why we Still have costlier medicines despite having DPCO?
4. What you will suggest to improve this?
( I told that hospitals should reduce the surgical procedures cost)
5. What if hospitals are saying we are in business?
M4-
1. My question is about Ujaala,Ujjwala and saubhgya scheme.what are these?
2. How we can save electricity?
3. Wastage and avoidance what is the difference?
M4-
1. Are we having demographic dividend?
2. HDI parameter?
3. Then on these parameters we are not performing well?
4. Our rank is consistently degraded in HDI why?
5. Lets us take another example in GII also we are not performing well. Then what is the reason?
6. Do you think we can improve on this?
Ok thank you.
7. Can you recite couplet of Baba Farid?
Ch-
Do you understand Punjabi?
Is this your photo?
Ok Thank You
Today I had interview on the last day.. indirectly the ppl at upsc document verification desk told me that by this Monday or Tuesday ur results will be out.. When I asked them explicitly they told aise to date kaise bata sakte hai.He also said ki medical aur humara result ka koi lena dena nahi hai!!..
Ankit singh
26th Feb Afternoon Session, First to go
Board: Air Marshal Bhonsle sir
Optional: Sociology
B.tech(Computer Science)
Ch:
1. There is a general perception that kumbha 2019 was organised well. However i feel there were some deficiencies. Can you point out some?
(Realted to my work with an ngo during kumbha 2019)
2. What about mock drills for disaster management?
3. How would you react if there is a stampede as an officer posted over there?
4. What are the qualities you think a civil servant should have?
5. What steps would you take to ensure that you are accessible to the public?
M1:
1. Can i say that you were born after 1991? Can you point out why am i emphasising on the year 1991 when i can say at the same time that you were born after 1947?
2. Who played important role during the 1991 economic reforms?
3. Interpret one statement - "I am not concerned about the availability of food but i am concerned about the food wastage"
4. How do you think New India is going to be like? Focus areas?
5. What is goa famous for?
Can you point out which activity has been banned which used to happen earlier? Reasons for ban on mining?
M2:
1. Did the LPG reforms all happen in tandem? What about globalization?
Difference between globalization and liberalization? Many followup questions.
2. Highlight the positive and negative aspects of role of governor.
Governor of UP?
M3:
1. What is G77? Is China a member?
2. India is dependent on energy imports. Tell me the names of few countries from where India imports oil.
3. % contribution of nuclear energy? % contribution of renewable energy?
4. Tell me your opinion about the way ahead in the energy sector.
M4:
1. Have you heard about rath yatras? Which all are the places where it takes place? Where in odisha? Why? Names of all the gods and goddesses?
2. Positives and negatives of AFSPA. Followup questions regarding the same.
3. Tell me something about Rohingya muslims.
Ch: What are your plans today?
All the best for your medical tomorrow.
Note: Except 1, no questions asked from daf. No questions asked from hobbies, optional and educational background.
Not many questions related to the recent current affairs.
Manas
Place- Odisha.
IIT Delhi electrical.
30 July 2020 Forenoon, 11:55.
4/5 to enter, Satyavathy Board
With mask and face field, mask kept slipping from nose.
Chairwoman wished me Good Morning before I can.
CW:
1. Your first name is your name, or your middle name is your name?
2. Photo show face by lowering mask, then put mask again.
3. Present job (Odisha Civil Service), she didn't know Tahsildar is Group A service, some discussion why not Deputy Collector, M1 intervened and explained.
4. What is comparative politics (hobby blogging)
5. Compare India's politics from the past - I said eco libz, politics coalition.
6. Regional parties good or bad
7. Status of women in Odisha - then as a DM what will you do 5 things - I said edu hostels, textile jobs (she said oh women should do semi-skilled work), police safety, working hostels, paramedics (some discussion on that when I said AYUSH doctors can be trained like Chinese barefoot doctors in allopathy). I finally said my point is if we can't attract high skilled doctors, we can atleast train paramedics.
M1:
1. Odisha discom privatization was undone. IDK zero.
2. Steel furnace or pig iron. IDK zero.
3. Paradip frieght rail line. Used for passenger recent news.
4. Myanmar relations.
M2:
1. Story about my career, you are ambitious but why not CEO after IIT, why not remain in State services. Why IFS.
2. If you are foreign secy, what will you do differently wrt China. I said hard power. He said that's the work of Defence Secy. I said role of diplomat to know
M3: SIkh turban guy
1. NPA, merger, bad bank
2. Don't remember his questions
M4: probably some connection with Odisha
1. Suppose public comes with complaint that my subordinate staff asking bribe
2. What single thing Odisha needs for Disaster Mgt. I asked tanglibe or intangible. I guessed water, forecasting, medicines, structures, SDRF and I kept guessing. He said no, no, no and said thank you.
CW: Interview over.
Overall, lots of grilling and counter questions.
Manas
Place- Odisha.
IIT Delhi electrical.
30 July 2020 Forenoon, 11:55.
4/5 to enter, Satyavathy Board
With mask and face field, mask kept slipping from nose.
Chairwoman wished me Good Morning before I can.
CW:
1. Your first name is your name, or your middle name is your name?
2. Photo show face by lowering mask, then put mask again.
3. Present job (Odisha Civil Service), she didn't know Tahsildar is Group A service, some discussion why not Deputy Collector, M1 intervened and explained.
4. What is comparative politics (hobby blogging)
5. Compare India's politics from the past - I said eco libz, politics coalition.
6. Regional parties good or bad
7. Status of women in Odisha - then as a DM what will you do 5 things - I said edu hostels, textile jobs (she said oh women should do semi-skilled work), police safety, working hostels, paramedics (some discussion on that when I said AYUSH doctors can be trained like Chinese barefoot doctors in allopathy). I finally said my point is if we can't attract high skilled doctors, we can atleast train paramedics.
M1:
1. Odisha discom privatization was undone. IDK zero.
2. Steel furnace or pig iron. IDK zero.
3. Paradip frieght rail line. Used for passenger recent news.
4. Myanmar relations.
M2:
1. Story about my career, you are ambitious but why not CEO after IIT, why not remain in State services. Why IFS.
2. If you are foreign secy, what will you do differently wrt China. I said hard power. He said that's the work of Defence Secy. I said role of diplomat to know
M3: SIkh turban guy
1. NPA, merger, bad bank
2. Don't remember his questions
M4: probably some connection with Odisha
1. Suppose public comes with complaint that my subordinate staff asking bribe
2. What single thing Odisha needs for Disaster Mgt. I asked tanglibe or intangible. I guessed water, forecasting, medicines, structures, SDRF and I kept guessing. He said no, no, no and said thank you.
CW: Interview over.
Overall, lots of grilling and counter questions.
Krishna
Interview transcript
29/7/2020
Smitha Nagaraj ma'am
Optional : Medical science
Forenoon session
Chairwoman:
1.Are you currently working doctor?
2.Where is your PHC and how many doctors are there and how you take shifts
3.Is it ethical for a government doctor to do private practice(few cross questions)
4.despite of conduct rules banning private practice why most government doctors practicing in private
5. Do u practice in private
6.Do we really need rules and laws for making people to follow....why people not following good things by themselves
7.In a population how many percent people obey laws and why remaining people not following laws
8.Tamil nadu has strong private health care dominance so does public health care losing relevance in Tamil Nadu
M1:
1.If China dropped a bomb and killed so many people it's a crime against humanity but now with virus originated from china and Tedros of WHO helping China do u think they both should be tried for committing crime against humanity(few cross questions)
2. Is WHO politically biased
3. Is it necessary to conduct IPL when whole world is going through pandemic
4.who do u think is most needed for our nation :doctor or IAS
M2:
1. Why lifestyle disease is rising
2 . How to convince people to have good lifestyle
3. Issues with mid day meal scheme (in context of Bihar)
M3:
1.what kind of patients u see in your hospital
2.what is ED and under which act it derives it power and its role
3.does ED acts with any political motives behind
4.what kind of cases do u see in phc
5. WHO treatment protocol for Rabies with dog bite grading
6.are you not interested in pursuing PG and if u do what speciality would u choose
M4:
1. Is Tamil Nadu under Ayushmann bharat scheme and do they face any problem with it
2. Psychosocial impact of corona and how will you address it
3.Why so much cry and hue over baba ramdev's coronil while misadvertising is so common like fairness products promising fair skin etc (and some cross questions)
Chairwoman : Okay we will continue our ethics which left
1. Why private doctors are not prescribing generic medicines
2.Is it correct for a doctor to get favours from medical representative
3.issues with clinical trails specifically about informed consent
4.Do we need to conduct clinical trail for covax
Thank you your interview is over.
Yathish:
Board: Sathyavathi Ma'am
Session: Forenoon Date: 28th July
Background: Worked in an Educational consultancy for 3 yrs, Aerospace Engineering, IIT Kharagpur
Chair
Why from aerospace to education?
Why from education to civil services?
What work did you do in the education consultancy?
What have you been doing since the last 3 years?
Why did you not join an aerospace related job?
- Tried for ISRO but couldn't get through. Meanwhile I landed a good opportunity in education sector.
InSpace was recently announced. Why is private sector being roped in space sector so late?
What role do private space companies play currently in India?
- Largely assembly and manufacturing of space flights
Can you name any private companies in aerospace in India?
- Raj Hamsa and upcoming DRAL through rafale offset agreement
Do you maintain active interest in aerospace engineering at all?
- No I do not. I read articles or watch videos related to it when I come across though.
M1
Why countries plan manned missions to other planets?
- It's natural next step in space exploration. Catastrophic event could wipe out humanity on Earth. Lot of advancement in science through such missions. Mentioned NASA's revival of plans to go to Moon and establish it as base for further missions to Mars etc.
Is budget of ISRO justified when there are so many developmental challenges with the Nation?
- It's justified because budget of ~13k crore is peanuts. ISRO has become a matter of pride. Track record is impeccable - both cheapest and one of the highest success rates. Many spin off technologies. Could've mentioned that eventually it'll become self-sustaining because of Antrix and NSIL.
Which quality would you rate higher - leadership or loyalty?
- Both are important. Different circumstances may require officer to bring out one or the other trait more.
If your superior gives you a questionable order what would you do?
- I will put forth my opinion and thoughts based on sound logic. Expected counter question but there was none.
Will you put ethics and needs of service before your career aspirations if the need arises?
- Absolutely sir.
M2
This member explained a case study for 2-3 minutes and asked only one question at the end. Apparently it was something happened in reality.
You are Finance secretary - have to disinvest a PSU by putting equity on stock market. Merchant bankers are pushing for a high discount - around 15%. On average Govt. gives up to 5% discount for disinvestment of other PSUs. You are worried that 15% is a high discount and it may lead to charges of impropriety later on. So you approach the Finance Minister. He tells you he doesn’t know the technicalities of it but he's only interested in getting the disinvestment done - at any rate. What will you do?
- I will use my expertise which I do not have at the moment.
Immediately M2 interrupted me saying when I actually become finance secretary I am still not going to have any expertise (Because of generalists in bureaucracy). Chair and all the members laughed. Chairman got up and went out of my sight till the end of this particular discussion.
- I continued answering but got confused between oversubscription and undersubscription. I was arguing for lower discount thinking discount is bad for disinvestment.
M2 very calmly and helpfully explained that 15% discount will lead to oversubscription and that it's a very good thing. And that 5% could lead to undersubscription.
- I told him that I will not worry about the charges of impropriety as long as I assess the situation impartially. The merchant bankers have a conflict of interest because of which they are pushing for a high discount. So I'll go for 7-10% discount, or even just the average discount rate of previous disinvestments which is 5% - which will fulfill the needs of adequate subscription as well as Finance Minister's need that disinvestment should be done.
M2 said that's what happened in real life too. But that the equity was undersubscribed (implying that it wasn't the right decision). And
then he a
dded that at the last minute it got subscribed adequately because of "sleight of hand" by someone. All the other members started laughing. I didn't get what this joke was. Overall I wasn't comfortable with this topic and I didn't fully understand some of the terms used.
M3
Decentralisation of ministries - why not have some ministries in Delhi and some else where?
Why not have Supreme Court in Thiruvananthapuram?
If so much of Governance is happening online during pandemic, what need is there for all the different Govt. bodies to be in physical proximity?
- Currently the forced work from home has made governance suboptimal and inefficient. Quoted an example from today's newspaper where Maharashtra HC postponed Maratha quota case when solicitor argued that the case is too complex to be argued over virtual court hearing.
If MNCs and other companies can outsource their work or open up branches thousands of miles away why can't Govt do the same too?
- Companies make their decisions based on the motive of profit maximisation based on factors like availability of cheap labour, cheap input. For Govt, the pros of being physically proximaty outweigh the cons of inefficiency if they are dispersed.
M4
Name some aircraft that is statically stable.
- I don't know.
Name an aircraft that is not statically stable but is made artificially stable.
- I don't know.
Why are exhaust nozzles of aircraft shaped circular and not square or some other shape?
- Having a circular shaft allows for smooth exhaust. If there are cusped edges like that of square then vortices are formed which create drag which in turn decreases the efficiency of engine.
What is the most important trait required in team work?
- Team leadership followed by coordination within the team.
Interview is over. You may leave.
Overall - Chairman asked most number of questions. In the beginning it got so foggy because of mask and head gear that I was barely able to see her. This had a very mild effect in my thinking and answering. M2 and M3 got fixated on a single topic and asked very few questions. M4 looked very unimpressed. Felt that I should have got more variety of questions.
Abhisek tale
Bs vyas Sir board
Railway
Psychology
NCC
Meditation
Chairman:
1.what is meaning of your name
2. Why are suicide incresing
3. Can happiness index measure happiness
4.How will world be post covid.
5.Do we need strong leaders or great ideas
6. What are you doing right now. How many staff in Lucknow division.
M1:
1.What is Disciplinary and appeal rules in railway
2.exact provision for removal from services without conducting enquiry
3. Percentage of railway revenue as wage bill?
4.How will you use knowledge of psychology in administration.
M2:
1.new education policy.. How can psychologist play a role.
2.How role of psychologist will increase in post covid era
M3:
1.View on railway reforms undertaken. What are these reform
2.why WHO in controversy
3. How will US withdrawl impact who.
M4.:
1.What you did as SUO in NCC
2.How is NCC helping you
3 What you did at RDC
4.How much time you are doing meditation.
5.How it impacts your life.
Chairman.
Can you explain me MFN. Most favored nation
Akshay
Interview: 30 July 2020
3rd to go
Background: Haryana (Home state), Btech Biotechnology (IIT Guwahati), Kabaddi, Calesthenics, NSS, Maths optional
CH:
1. Recently many incidents of police over reach like Black Lives Matter, Custodial deaths of Father son duo in Karnataka and Vikas Dubey encounter. Why are they happening?
2. What to do regarding the same?
3. Why only Watching Kabaddi, why don't you play?
4. What is calisthenics?
(So your good physique is attributed to it - Light moment)
M1:
5. Why Biotech sector could grow in India?
6. People will becoming data rich before becoming financially rich. Comment
7. rovisions of Data Protection Bill (From my answer to Q4)
8. Govt exemption in the Bill. What govt does with the data?
9. Regulatory authority in the bill?
M2:
10. Indo Pak relations
11. DIFFERENCE between Haryana and Assam?
M3:
12. Use of Biotech in medical science?
13. Should USA isolate Iran since it will lean towards other powers like China if it does so?
14. Indus Valley Civilisation sites in Haryana?
M4:
15. What is Recombinant DNA technology?
16. What are GM crops?
17. What are toxins released in those?
18. Why India not adopting them?
19. Opinion about whether people should demand Clean air and water and local food as demand in elections?
CH again:
20. What are your plans today? (WATCH Shakuntala Devi movie)
21. Who is she? (Mathematician who calculates faster than conputer)
22. Actor? How can she calculate so fast? (Vedic maths)
23. Why Vedic maths not used often?
Thankyou, your interview is over.