UPSC interview, David Syiemlieh board, 27 Jul 2020
27 Jul 2020
Date:27/07/2020
Afternoon session ,3rd to go
Board : David Syiemlieh
duration : Around 20-25 minutes
i entered the interview room after asking permission and wished everyone...(chairman and 4 members including a lady member).chairman asked me to take the seat and made me comfortable by asking to remove the face shield.He went through the DAF and told me am a good candidate for this and my parents will be proud enough(may be to keep me cool before starting the 'game'😂).
Chairman
Arun,do your parents have any complaints about you (i said after taking a moment that my mother always tell am not taking much food,he smiled and said oh is it.U have to take enough food at this age.This is your best age arun.)
#Ok arun lets start this is just a conversation and not an interview...we will ask somethng u ll reply accordingly,if u dont know just tell us that and if u cant hear our words just tell us to repeat ( since they were wearing mask the volume was low to moderate and i need to keep my ears keen to hear)
# arun where this bonsai originated ( my hobby part) - i told the answer including mentioning japan
#have u heard about QUAD,why japan is trying to close with india
Chairman pointed to lady member.
LADY MEMBER
#Arun you have got good marks in schools and college and we know you are a good doctor then why did u leave the profession to civil service (expected qn so i replied it)
# why kerala shows surge of corona recently
#What are the application of artificial intelligence in field of medicine
#how can we improve the use of generic medicine in our country
(lady member was always smiling and encouraging me to answr by nodding her head)
member 2
#you worked in a palliative care organisation, palliative care is only at its start in india.Can you explain whats our position and how to improve it.
#Any govt measures like schemes to improve palliative care in india
#have u read about a book regarding palliative care written by an australian nurse
(i was not aware about that book so i politely said no sir i didnt read that book,he said its okey arun)
#as a DM how to make urself as a motivator or role model for the youth in your district.
(i was not well versed with qns...eventhough i managed it somehow)
#what are the priority sectors in ur district if appointed as DM
(i said health,education especially of women and environmnetal protection including waste management - he specifically asked dont u want to improve economy arun?
i said yes sir and said couple of points in economh as well including traditional industries and MSME)
member 3
(He was the most enthusiastic person to ask question and trying to fix time gap by lookng at clock in between)
# Arun how mbbs profession help in administration if u become an IAS officer
#we know there is absolute scarsity of doctors now.At a time of scarsity of doctor how will u justify doctor to civil servant career change
( i tried to convince him by saying knwing the groud reality of health sector will make me better prblm solver and i could be a doctor to society )
#role of media in our democrasy,are the crossing limits nowadays
(i approchd a middle way there by saying there are issues - but he wanted to discuss more on it)
#how media can be controlled not to involve against issues of national intrst,can we ban them or control them ( i tried to bring concpt of media ethics and if they cross limits case by case consideration is better rather than blanket ban)
#even if we control traditional media there is social media ,how social media work along with conventional media
#what are the issues of social media ( i said issues of fake news..privacy and difficulty in regulation)
# how can we address these arun
(in between he share some points like honey trapping and issues of data leakage from our top institutions and officials.I agreed with his points - i felt some lack of clarity of thoughts in my answer with this member.but he was very encouraging and his mannerism made me to feel comfrtble rather than going to pressure
member 4
(he was sitting close to me and he was the most impatient member - he
e
snt let me to answer completely and even before completing one sentence he startd next question)
# what is survaillance capitalism,have u hears about it ,if yes tell me ( i said i heard about it sir in some context like western capitalist companies use our data for survaillance upon us - he gave examples of facebook google etc)
#by leaving mbbs seat,is it injustice to another person who wish to take that seat and producing another doctor to society
( but when i started to answer he jumped to next question,that made some pressure)
#whts silent valley issue
#why silent valley got its name
( when i said about the insect crickt is not present he asked its specific name - i. said politly that i dont knw sir)
#when are u expecting another pandemic in future
( he added me that if we protect environmnt,then environment will also protect us- i said yes sir and so he asked do we protect environmnt i said still lapses are there sir)
#if u appoint in health dpt how will u utilise ayush dpt along with modern medicine
#there is conflict of interest between these streams of medicine so how to use them
( i said they can have seperate space sir but everyone should practice evidence based medicine and need to use then in primary and preventive medicine)
finally chairman
okey arun your interview is over ,can i ask somethng else what did u eat for lunch ( i said i had snacks ,he laughed and said thats why your mother complain abt u,now i understood ,dont u like appam arun ,i said yes sir but i had it as breakfast,everyone laughed and two other members joined with him saying kerala appam is their favorite)
finally chairman said u r a doctor,so eat well stay safe
thank you arun u can leave now
i said thank you to everyone and left the room
( over all board was cordial and didnt try to stress me up,at some points i lost clarity of thoughts in my answrs and the face mask was always came down during answers so i need to keep it in place throughout the interview,otherwise it was good time)
Arun S Nair
Interview transcript
Chairman: Bharat Bhushan Vyas sir
Background: MBBS
Optional: Medical science
Date: 28/02/2020
Volga ganga connection
India doctors shortage .. should we give AYUSH doctors license to give medicines.. why do doctors not serve in rural areas.. how to solve this issue..
Patient safety .. dimensions of patient safety..
Medical ethics.. ethical issues you faced as a med student..
Why Drs prescribe unnecessary investigation..
How is organ donation regulated.. which organ is donated posthumously..
Active passive euthanasia.. checks and balances.. are too many layers in decision making a good thing..
Mental health act.. why going to psychiatrist is a taboo
What are half way homes
Why India performance in Olympic games is poor.. what are the recent changes.. which games are performing well..
Why prakash Padukone could not be a role model for his kids
What medical movies have you watched
Medical books that you read..
Epidemic vs pandemic.. where does coronavirus lie..
What suggestions do you have to improve national health mission..