Interviews

UPSC interview, Sujata Chaturvedi board, 23 Jul 2020 (4)

23 Jul 2020

Name: Sandeep Kumar

Maths and Computing, IIT, Kharagpur, 2019

Hobbies: Meditation, reading-writing poetry

23/7/2020

Board: Sujata Ma'am chairperson

Afternoon; 3rd to go.

Chairperson: [soft and very low voice— had to lean forward to listen properly]

1. Tell us about your education background and job experience, if any.

2. Why do you want to join civil services?

3. Over the years so many have joined civil service with noble intention, what have they not been able to achieve so far?

4. What is the digital divide?

5. Why is it a pressing issue?

6. What is the relationship between online education and digital divide?

7. Classroom education vs online education— which one is better?

8. How to balance then?

9. What was the recent controversy about covid testing in which the supreme court had to interfere? —[was not able to recall— ma'am gave hints about pricing then I got it and explained]

10. What is the current scenario regarding testing?

Member 1:

1. What is your opinion on the merger of ailing banks with stronger banks? Will it solve the problems? [before asking he detailed the situation and gave alternative options regarding this issue]

2. But don't you think it will make even the strong bank weak? [I had argued in support of it]

3. What is the genesis of NPAs?

4. What is 'bad bank'?

5. Is it the best solution for NPAs issue?

Member 2: [Very nice fellow :)]

1. You are from Madhubani and no interview will be complete without asking you about Madhubani painting. What are the key themes of Madhubani painting?

2. What are the themes of Vidyapati's poetry?

3. What is the most famous book written by Vidyapati which is read in India and internationally? [he seemed quite enthusiastic about Vidyapati— Unfortunately I could not recall the name :(]

4. There are very few hospitals in North Bihar compared to South Bihar, what is the specific reason? [Gave a general answer— did not know specific reason]

5. No, I am asking about specific reason— [fumbled a bit here]

6. Moving on, what is the Inter-state river dispute?

7. What changes has the government brought in recently? [ I talked about Inter-state river tribunal bill]

8. What is Jal Shakti mission?

Member 3:

1. Madhubani painters are not able to earn as much as they deserve. Middlemen seem to profit a lot. As a civil servant what will you do to ensure they earn more. [ gave specific suggestions— he gave 'excellent' remarks :)]

2. You earlier seemed to support the Jal shakti mission. What are the infrastructure challenges associated with it?

3. Key challenge is water. How will water reach a water-deficit region like Bundelkhand? [and some more related discussion on it]

4. You have studied mathematics and computing. What is a supercomputer?

5. what is the order of number of processors in supercomputer?

6. what is its application?

7. What is Big Data Analytics?

8. How will you use it to solve Bihar's problems?

Member 4:

1. what is federal constitution?

2. what provisions of Indian constitution make it federal? [talked about distribution of powers in 7th schedule]

3. what are recent trends in federalism in India?

4. what should be the role of governor?

5. what changes are needed in the role of governor? — [said 'aid and advice' should be mandatory just like the case of 'president]

6. But what about breakdown of constitutional machinery in states?

7. what is sold in ration shops?

8. Is it given to everyone?

9. Where does fair price shops get ration from?

10. From where does FCI buy? [I fumbled a little bit— he explained in detail what are all the options for FCI including import etc. — i said thank you]

11. do you support state selling liquor from liquor shops? [No]

12. why? [little loudly] [ i invoked article 47]

13. Which states have banned liquor? [I told Bihar, gujarat]

14. There are three states. Which is the third one? [Don't know— told me it is Mizoram]

Chairwoman:

1. Sandeep, is there anything else you want to talk about? [Always! :D] [Told her I want to talk about International affairs]

2. which issue in international af

fairs?[ told China-India relationship]

3. Okay, talk about trends in India-china relationship in recent times? [very broad question but gave me a minute to talk]

Thank you. You may leave.

Lasted for about 35-40 minutes.

Mask and face shield made it a little awkward. Mask kept slipping due to sweat and talk. Ma’am kept pointing to put on the mask properly.

M satyavathi

Forenoon- 29/7

Shivam Upadhyaya

Internship in Canada in smart building

Job- indian railways

Chairman

Read out daf aloud to all members. I will ask you only 2 questions

Q. IRMS your view on this.

Q. Concern that how non technical officers will handle technical issues and vice versa

Some discussion on this topic

Q. Definition of terms- green building green corridor and green house

Q. Where green house is used

Q. Difference between green building and smart building

M1- most grilling part- nothing related to daf

Q. Long monologue on Nps pension wala.

Said I don’t know

Q. Grilled- you are going to join railway you should know what changes govt made on pension and where it is invested

A- said i will look into it later

Q. Again monologue on capital market and how companies get investment

A- fumbled a bit said investments from people.

Q. Why people invest

A- Returns on knvetments

Q. What they look while knvestjng

A- profits of companies past trends

Q. What will you look into and how you will invest

A- said may consider a broker to take advise

Q. But what will you tell him

A- low risk and long term investments

M2- discussion on lac loc and border and differences among them.

Q. Why freight traffic has reduced in railways from 2-3 to 1-3 since independence.

Q. How to improve

Q. But how will Govt earn revenue(based on previous answer as i said scope to reduce freight fare)

M3-

Q. Long discussion on simultaneous elections.

Q. Concerns on this some counter questions.

Q. You do jogging. Advantages?

Q. Speed time and distance of jogg

Q. Internationally recommended jog speed and distance

M4-

Q. Your hobby is travelling. What you do while travelling.

Q. Why culture is important- based on previous answers.

Q. Why tourism is important

Q. Status of tourism in India

Q. What steps government is taking in this

Q. What is tourist footfall in india?

Q. Name 3 books you read - hobby

Q. What do you see in any profession al what qualities he possess.(don’t know from where this question came)

Q. But these qualities are of administrators. What about professionals?

Optional History

Name: Anonymous

Board : TCA ANANT

Date: 29/07/20

CHAIRMAN

Q: who is sam Higginbotham (education)

Q: you watch documentaries on which issues

Q: what was Cambridge Anlytica Issue (based on my answer)

Q: Dont you think having intimate info of electors is good?

M1

Q: tell me origin of locust problem

Q: why are the reasons behind outbreak

Q: solutions to tackle locust problem

Q: how herbicide is helpful

Q: what are the problems of administration

Q: name change of paryagraj good or bad

Q: what are the benefits

Q: saraswati river evidences

Q: kaushambi recent pottery findings(ancient mahajanapada site)

M2

Q: name few projects which delayed in haryana

Q: how public administration will help you as administrator

Q: what did you studied in history

Q: what are your favourite area

M3

Q: first said your personality is good but explain me about gap in your education

Q: khap panchayats role change as politician what will you do

Q: what if you are head of APMC in your district what will you do to tackle the issue of employee harassment (based on sonali phogat controversy)

Q: tell me about caste demography of hisar district

Q: views about intercaste marriage

Q: impact on society

M4:

Q: Did you watch only documentaries or you also watch movies

Q: we certify movies but not online content

Q: what are the problems of regulation

Q: what will you do if you are appointed as head of inquiry commission of vikas dubey encounter

Those who have not submitted their transcripts pls share at the earliest. This is something we give back to the community we benefited from. #Shring_Is_Caring 😁❤️❤️🙏 Pls share at @Yo_Yo_Choti_Singh or @Patriot_Saint or @Aaykarvibhag or @KaptaanJackSparrow

Interview Transcripts 2023 pinned «Those who have not submitted their transcripts pls share at the earliest. This is something we give back to the community we benefited from. #Shring_Is_Caring 😁❤️❤️🙏 Pls share at @Yo_Yo_Choti_Singh or @Patriot_Saint or @Aaykarvibhag or @KaptaanJackSparrow»

Arpit

29 July morning session

Background - Chemical eng work ex : 2 years HPCL state Rajasthan

Board- Bhonsle Sir hobby:cricket

Ch: future of petroleum industry

M1: - eng vs wi match

Challenges for Rajasthan

M2: India Iran

India -us

Why USA keep interfering in domestic affairs of other countries

Plastic pollution

Single use plastic

M3: strength and weakness

Self employment vs permanent job

Again ir India Afghanistan USA issue

M4: reliance as debt zero company and its implications

Petroleum current status and future in context of renewable energy

Why Rajasthan has not been dominated by centralised power like Mughals

Venezuela issue and why USA and Russia involved in it

Ch : why Chemical engineers do not get good opportunities in India.

What will u do after interview

Transcript

Bs Bassi sir.

27th july. Afternoon 4th to go.

Optional: Geography

Place: Bihar

Do you smell something? What's that? (Disinfectant used on chair).

Other than badminton what else you do?

Which is the movie you dislike?

Okay what is the movie you would rate the lowest?

Why?

Best movie? Why?

Tell me 5 elements in movie which makes it closer to ground realities.

M1

Geo as an advantage to india?

Geostrategic location of india?

Why geo is disavantage to India?

What is informal and formal sector jobs?

How to make informal to make?

Can we make all jobs formal as employers cannot pay for social security?

How to make jobs formal?

M2

Biodiesel defination?

Is biodiesel costly than diesel or not?

Paris climate agreement what commitments India promised to make?

Provide me data for tons of co2 that is targeted.

M3

For atamnirbhar Bharat do we also need atamnirbhar families, communities. Whose responsibility is it make India atamnirbhar- the central or state government?

As an sdm what will you do to bring atamnirbharta at grassroot levels?

M4

What jonre of movies you watch?

Do you watch sci-fi? Which one?

Have you watched gravity, interstellar, Marsian?

In gravity what is shown? Does it talk about existence of God?

Should cinema halls open amid covid times?

Can we not use Netflix etc to watch movies?

Chair

If I give you 70% and 99% alcohol which one is better disinfectant for covid?

Are you sure or guessing?

China is ahead in API manufacturing and we are still behind. Why?

How is API manufactured?

Can API be manufactured in India if we get relevent technology?

Thank you your interview is over.

Come here to see if this is your photo?

11th March,

Afternoon,1st to go.

Board : Manoj Soni Sir

Optional- Anthropology

Hobby- no question,

Interest- tribal culture

Ch: 1.Where are you currently living?

2. Do you like Delhi?

3. What you like in Delhi?

4. Tell me culture of any one tribal{talked about santhal}

5. Case - Me DM of A&N island and came to know sentinelese are dying due to some disease. As no one is allowed inside their territory including DM, what will be your coarse of action?

6.Will you resign for saving them?

7. What is your priority, law of land or constitutional morality.

M1:

1. Case: Me Officer in Forest area, came to know a tribal festival in which they kill many animal. What will you do?

2. Will you shoot when they have weapon and retaliating?

3. Why Naxalism prominent among tribals?

M2:

1. Do you know Christopher von Haimendorf? His contributions?

2. Leader of Santhal movement?

3. 100m sprint race world timing(daf)

M3:

1. What are issues with tiger conservation?

2. Case: Me as Police officer, Came to know that forest dweller family in Sunderban has killed the tiger. Upon reaching there you came to know that the same tiger killed member of their family few weeks back. What will be your coarse of action.

Many counter questions.

M4:

1. University of Roorkee was so marvellous and at par with other IIT then what was the need to make it IIT?

2. Why IIT Roorkee is not in List of eminent institute

3. What is Coding?(daf)

4. Why Software engineering job after grad in polymer engineering?

Thankyou

Om Parkash

Maths optional

Education: pulp and paper engineering

Exp: in IIT Jee coaching for 5 years

Board: sujata Mehata mam

Date:18/03/20

Chairman

1) Is this u?

2) tell me about urself... Education, work experience and all.

3) u worked in coaching..At what level u worked?

4) u worked in different coachings.. Are u satisfied?

5) what are the concerns?

5) so where we need to improve.. We need to change entrance system Or what?

6) Do we need to do something in school education?

7) don't u think coaching is harming our system?

8) why didn't u say that it should be banned?

9) ok... Ciggarette is also contributing in GDP and all.. Then what?

M1

1) u studied one of the subject as sanskrit? What is the status now

2) what do u think about things to be done to promote these languages

3) what gov has done to promote sanskrit?

4) In South America, one of the countries os facing economic instability and then political instability... Which country is that?

5) yes..Venezuela..Tell me about that? What was the reason? Which one was the main reason economic turbulence or political instability

6) students in higher instition like IIT, IIM are facing depression.. What's is ur view?

7) very few students are facing... Then what can be the reason?

M2

1) u studied pulp and paper eng.. Is it very rare? Why did u take that?

2) which subjects u liked there?

3) there is issue of paper waste? How to tackle that?

4) ok... Paper waste are recycled... How much?

5) there will be issue of supply of raw material?

6) what raw materials mills are using?

7) similar questions followed related to paper industry

M3

1) tell me about human migration in India

2) which country in our neighborhood has one of the best collaboration?

3) why bhutan?

4) any country between two country acts as buffer? Why bhutan?

M4

1) our country is facing economic slowdown and now the the outbreak of coronovirus? Which should be tackled first?

2) what government should to revamp economy?

3) what u are telling is all long term what can be done in short term?

4) what are the issues in paper industry?

5) there is rising concerns for plastic? Do u think paper can substitute that?

6) then again the issue of deforestation?

M5

1) government is opening new IITs.. Is it good?

2) but there is issue of quality in new IIT?

3) It is often said that teachers are not teaching.. Their quality is poor in IIT?

4) u hve mentioned in ur hobby.. That u practice meditation.. How do u do that?

5) in patanjali yog.. There are 8 limbs.. 3 limbs out of that.. What is that?

Chairman

1) I want to ask last question.. What is the impact of coronovirus in economy? First think for a minute.. Then reply

2) ok... Anything else u want to talk with us?

Your interview is over.

Mayur

Board - Bassi sir

Date 28/07/2020

Mech engg

Table tennis

Fort exhibition

PSIR optional

Interview time 35-40 min

Chairman -pull down ur mask

1. What was fort exhibition about?

2. Which forts u visited?

3. Tell me about sinhagadh fort?

4. Why u made forts of clay u should have used 3D modeling?

5. Have u seen 3 D modeling of any building?

6. Tell me technicalities about 3 D modeling?

Member 1

1. What is ur opinion on 370 and 35a?

2. What is according to u apt to revive political process in jammu Kashmir.

3. Should we give statehood to jammu and Kashmir as UT has its own advantage?

4. What is delhi's state different from other states?

5. What are different dimensions of wars?

Member 2

1.Critically asses covid response in maharashtra?

2. Tell me dharavi model learnings for other slums ? (I mentioned this so Q came)

3.Evaluate covid response at gram panchayat level, DM level centre level and state level.?

4.Have u involved in any covid work?

Member 3

1.What happens in power plant?

2.Tell me actual working?

3.Why coal power plants are seeing opposition all across globe?

4.What are pollutants emmited by power plants ?

5.What is global warming?

6.What is green house gas effect?

7.What will happenif there are no green house gases in atmopsher?

Member 4

1.Tell me countries in India's neighborhood?

2.Suppose u are in position of foreign sec, what one step u will take with neighboring countries. Tell me one by one counties wise

While telling I used some words where he asked counter question like what is middle power coalitions.

What are grievances of Nepal.

As question was open ended I talked on neighborhood fro almost 6-8 minutes roughly . Members were listening only few counters

3.why southeast Asian nations are stretegically important for India.

Chairman

1.If u r foreign sec, will u promote insurgency as promoted by Pakistan in neighboring countries with which India's has not so good or bad relation (this Q asked because in earlier questions I said Pakistan is not normal state).

2.What If foreign minister is asking u?

3.Will you follow his orders?

4.Will you resign or seek transfer as u differ ?

5.Asked to come close and check photograph.

Choubey sir

24.07.2020 FN

Kerala, Malayalam Literature optional,Computer Science BTech,Work experience:Bank,Judiciary

Hobby:poetry,singing

Chairman:

What did you have for breakfast ?

Tell us about your journey so far

Judicial appointments - consultation vs concurrence, constitutional backing

M1:

About Shankaracharya's contribution

Suggest one common thread which binds humankind

Exit interview

Role of hobbies in one's life

M2:

How poetry helps an administrator

Women empowerment

Why only one woman head for India

M3:

under which provision can bankers be barred from going on strike; should lawyers and judicial officers have a similar provision

which section of society is most important -politicians,bureaucrats,doctors,etc

Block chain technology

Tamil or Malayalam - which is older

Is Tamil the oldest language in the world

M4:

Mappila revolt

Any positive outcome of caste & religion in Kerala

Why alternative governments come to power in Kerala

Relevance of Kerala coastline

Coastal regulation zone ,wetlands

Chair: do you have anything to ask us

Augustus

Board: Manoj Soni

Date: 27 July 2020

Chairman:

* You have mentioned so many addresses in your DAF, where are you based in ?

* What have you been doing in Delhi for last one year?

* Have you given TED talk ( hobby : watching TED talk) ?

* What is the procedure to give TED talks?

* You might be having lot of ideas to give Ted talks , share some ideas.

* In three bullet points tell me about Delhi education model.

*Have you read about it in official documents?

* What's in happiness curriculum?

M1:

* Do you support statehood for Delhi ? Why not?

* Delhi is considered unsafe for women, do you agree? And what is the reason behind it?

* Housing for all scheme: civil engineering solution to it?

* What else apart from prefab structures?

* What was your institution's role in working with BMTPC ?

M2 :

*What's the price of gold these days?

*Can you tell me the price of 1kg of gold?

* Would you suggest someone to invest in gold ? What financial instruments?

* Two things for which your district is famous for?

* Why is it called gateway to the north east , as it is not in northeast?

* India foreign policy for Nepal : one positive, one negative aspect .

* Unofficial blockade: good or bad in your opinion?

* Nandan nilekani started a platform few days ago, do you know about it?

* One positive, one negative aspect about it.

* Visvesvaraya contribution to India? Which year did he die?

M3:

*How will you use knowledge of civil engineering in civil administration?

* What is National Building code?

* Some changes in NBC regarding fire safety done recently ?

* What are reasons behind fire outbreaks in buildings?

* How will you ensure compliance to norms?

* Any government platform that takes views of citizens directly for better governance?

M4 :

* Uses of jute?

* Would you suggest farmers in your district to continue with jute farming or to diversify?

* Any Air force base in your state?

* What is the historical significance of these bases ( world war 2 reference)?

* How is the course that you studied in b.tech different from your course in masters ?

Chairman: Is this you(photo)? Can you remove your mask and shield? Your interview is over . Have a safe journey.

Anonymous

Date of interview: 24th July, 2020

Board: Ms Sujata Mehta

Background: Electronics Engg, Sociology optional

Chairwoman:

1. Introduce yourself with respect to your education and professional experience.

2. Did you work under the Chandigarh administration for your project on Child Rights? (DAF based)

3. We see so many ill effects of social media, are there any positives as well?

4. How much time do you spend on social media daily?

5. Where do you read news from? What source do you refer to? Is social media a reliable source of information?

6. In India, we're adding billionaires every year. How do you see such news? (Ques was a bit lengthier)

7. Another very lengthy and complicated Ques followed. Unable to recall.

Member 1:

1. Explain your technical project. Some counter questions on that with respect to it's utility. (DAF based)

2. Ques on my internship at ALSTOM transport- about my role and some cross questions; if ALSTOM produces indigenous solutions?

3. Jio 5G- What all is it developing indigenously under this?

4. J&K(DAF based)- the unilateral change in status quo of special status- Do you think it was right?

5. What has changed on ground in one year?

Member 2:

1. You've stayed in so many places, what's your favourite place and why?

2. About Dogri literature of Jammu.

3. If you're appointed in J&K, what changes will you bring on ground, AS AN ENGINEER?

Member 3:

1. Difference between Kathak, Bharatnatyam and Odissi (DAF)

2. Very lengthy and twisted Ques.. Had to ask the member to clarify. It was on change in tourism industry in J&K post Article 370

3. Issues faced by India in the evacuation mission- Vande Bharat

4. Which commercial private flight has been started recently under the mission?

Member 4:

1. How will the situation in J&K improve?

2. Amazon forest fires-Climate change- challenges. What should international world do? What India is doing?

3. Disaster management act- we're seeing the implementation has certain flaws- rigid implementation- gave example of TN custodial death. What should be the changes in the disaster management policy of India?

Chairwoman: Is there any other area you would like us to ask a question from?

Thank you

Manju Chandran

Background: B.Tech ECE

Optional: Malayalam Literature

Hobby: reading fiction, writing poetry

Board: Smita Nagraj, 19th Feb forenoon session 1st person to go

Chairman

1. You are an engineer why chose literature as an optional?

2. Why do they say that engineering graduates are not employable?

3. Is there a positive attitude in India about corruption ?

4. What can people do to improve governance and service delivery?

M1.

5.Do you know what is a projectile? What component is constant in a projectile motion?

6." Rules are for those who follow" what do you understand from this ?

7. Is it good?

M2.

8. What do you know about liquid state electronics?

9. Do we have electronics manufacturing in India?

10. What do you think about achievements of ISRO?

11. What happened to Chandrayaan?

12. How can you improve quality of engineering education?

M3.

13. Basheer, O.V Vijayan, Thakazhy, ( Malayalam writers) who is your favourite writer among these? Why? Narrate one of his works.

15. Tell us something about Calicut.( Graduation from University of Calicut)

M4.

16.What are some fields of science where research is being carried out today?

17. Which among these do you think is going to be the most disruptive of them all?

18. Do you think robots can replace humans?

19. How can we improve India Srilanka relations?

20. Present a poem that you have written.

Chairman (based on the poem)

20. Do you think there is a place for people with minority views to go in India?

21. What if the minority view is destructive?

22. As an administrator how would you tackle a situation where your subordinate is not willing to work?

23. How would you take decision, if a minority view emerges in your area of work on what basis ?

Chairman:Bassi sir

Date: 29-07-2020

Forenoon session, last person to go

Timing: approx 35 mins

Background: Automobile Engineering, Indian Defence Accounts

Chairman:

Are you not satisfied with IDAS?

Is it boring?

How data analytics can be used in defence accounts(follow up question)

Are they doing this now?

Member 1:

Address of Tamilnadu bhavan

Changing road names Aurangzeb road to abdul Kalam road ? Opinion?

Future of IC engine

Member2:

What is the role of integrated financial advisor?

Why there are delays in defence procurement? Solutions?

Member 3:

Functioning of jet engine

In which sectors IC engines cannot be replaced in future?

Trade off between sales of more automobiles and road safety, congestion? How to tackle this situation?

Member 4:

Problems of differently baked people?

How to bring attitudinal change among the people?

Why different accounts services ? Why can’t we merge them?

Chairman: your interview is over

Mostly daf based and opinion oriented.Board was very cordial

Background - Electronics engineering

Hometown - Datia (MP)

Optional - Sociology

Music, Badminton

Afternoon session 4th to go.

Chairman - Bharat Bhushan Vyas

CM -

1. When did you decide to prepare for civil services?

2. Why civil services?

3. Tell sociologically what are the expectations of Millennials from job market, and what changes should employers make for that cause?

4. Three special things about Datia (Hometown)

5. Explain blockchain to a layman.

M1 (lady member)

1. 5 Places to visit in MP?

2. How Indore became cleanest city? Who played major role administration or NGOs? Are they keeping up the pace?

3. Architectural monument which resembles our parliament building? (It's present in nearby district)

4. What type of music do you listen? Favorite singer? Where was kishore kumar from?

M2

1. Which of the two sectors electronics or real estate more effected by COVID? Is it a good time to purchase TV?

2. Delhi sero survey for COVID.

3. Difference between virus and bacteria? Virus living or non living?

M3

1. India-Nepal relations, reason for tensions? Communist govt in china and Nepal, a reason?

2. How do we define developed and developing country? You would put India as developed or developing country?

3. Developed countries in Asia?

M4

1. Ethical hacking

2. Fiscal deficit good or bad?

I'm forgetting some of the related questions by M3 and M4.

CM - Thanks.

Very cordial board, was encouraging by nodding and appreciating answers.

(30-35 Minutes)

Ayush

Date : 27/7/2020 forenoon session

Board : TCA Anant Sir

Name : Ayush

Optional : Mathematics

Graduation : Civil Engg. , IITK

Hobbies : Mathematics in Poetry, Reading and Writing Modern Hindi Poetry, Interest in Numbers

Members were sitting very far from each other and extreme left & extreme right were at 180 degree.

Chairman- Read my daf (very small portion)

1. So u aren't doing any job, preparing full time?

2. What is the motivation, why do u want to join civil services?

3. What is mathematics in poetry?

4. Recite any poem.

Member 1 (Lady member) (right side)

1. What is the scope of infrastructure in India?

2. What are the 3 important sectors for infrastructure development?

3. Being a civil engineer, why didn't you join as engineer? Don't u think u would have contributed in infrastructure sector? (disaster response by me as I couldn't say anything and fumbled. 2-3 seconds later she moved to next question)

4. What is the status of women in your home town? Further cross questions

5. What are the social pressures?

6. What can be done to improve? ( couldn't answer properly, got a little nervous and fumbled a lot)

Throughout the interview she just gazed at me sharply, also a lot of problem in hearing.

M2 - he was speaking so low that I have to lean towards him to even listen... This caused me loose my composure.

1. What are the technical solutions to remove pendency of cases in judiciary? He also told exact figures of pendency. I answered on different line.

2. I am asking about the technical solution since u r from technical background? ( I couldn't recall any.. Said some stuff )Huge Blunder.

3. What is zero energy building? I heard geo-energy building... I confirmed then answered.

4 . Since u read and write modern hindi poetry, gave a monologue for 1.5 minutes approx. Then asked the contrast in earlier and modern poetry?

5. What do you think is better and why? (couldn't answer properly as he was not audible.. Asked long questions )

M3-

1. Gave a monologue on police encounters then asked why are police encountering everywhere in the country?

2. Follow up question.. Is judiciary incapable?

3. Is encountering a right thing?

4. What are the functions of Ayush ministry?

5. It's relevance?

6. Why alleopathic doctors avoid Ayurveda?

7. Why don't they trust and is their any scientific evidence to prove their efficacy?

( he wasn't giving any time to think... Reply quickly or he will move to next question)

M5- (listening me throughout)

1. By my past answers, He asked - Do u think civil servants are fulfilling there responsibility? He added that as per a ### survey, Indian bureaucracy is least effective in South East Asia... Chairman sir also added that there were some protests regarding this in India.. ( he was operating mobile since passing the baton to M1)

2. Who is your role model?

3. Why?

4. Suppose u become a civil servant how your life will change?

5. What will be the challenges.?

( I couldn't answer properly last 2 questions... I could have structured them better taking 5-10 seconds but due to m4 .. I was replying quickly)

Chairman just nodded. I couldn't understand that my interview is over. He nodded again to convey it's over.

I had to wait for 35 minutes outside the room for my turn as the panel was having breakfast. It made me nervous a lot as I was expecting call any second. Also as I entered the room, sir asked to sit down... I was still entering. Though it's a minor issue, it creates unnecessary pressure.

Mixed feelings about my PT. I may have skipped 2-3 questions.

All the best to everybody.

Anonymous

Board: Manoj Soni Sir

Date: 22 July 2020 forenoon

Duration: around 30min(12.53 to 1.25)

Background: Btech (comp)

Optional: public administration

Hobbies and interests: playing harmonium, Hindustani classical, mentoring, vipassana,

Chairperson:

1. How is your surname pronounced?

2. You can remove either the mask or shield if you are not comfortable (had fog on shield. Removed mask)

3. Your hobby is classical music. So what do you do? Play, sing or listen?

(Chairman comments: May God bless you to cure your voice so that you can resume singing again)

4. In this raining weather and this timing, which are the three ragas that can be played?

5. What is the timing of Megh Malhar?

6. Tell me the situation of covid in your native place.

7. Looking at Maharashtra, what is , or if there is any hope that corona will be overcome eventually at least in the long run?

(Chairman comments: Yes, Dharavi is an effective model not just at Maharashtra's level but now at global level)

M1:

1. So suppose if you get selected, then your joining will most likely get delayed by 2-3 months. What will you do during that time? Will you learn something related to the services?

2. Some states have multiple capitals. What is your view on having multiple capitals?

3. There are issues of data security in recent times esp they have a geopolitical angle, what is it?

4. What should be done by India to ensure better security in 5G technology? Any technical solutions?

5. To contain China we are going for multi-alignments. Is it going against NAM?

6. What could be the fallouts of such multiple strategic engagements?

M2:

1. You are computer scientist and a musician. Its a deadly combination. (I humbly said that i am just a computer engineer)

2. You play harmonium. What were the reasons that it was banned by All India Radio?

3. We are getting so much into these mobiles and technologies that we are losing ourselves. Do you think that in future our civilization can get endangered because of this issue?

4. What is your view on vertical construction of buildings in cities and limiting their geographical expanse?

5. So you agree with the idea? Can we start implementing it immediately from tomorrow?

6. (Long question)With respect to Indian Foreign Service they choose one foreign language in the career and then specialize in that country's affairs. Do you think that similar domain specialization should be made compulsory for IAS based on their respective graduation?

7. But how will deciding it after 7-8 years service work as it hardly has any exposure? Wont then graduation be the criteria?

M3: (lady)

1. So when sir referred you as scientist you immediately corrected him that you are engineer. Dont you think engineers can be scientists?

2. Where do you see engineers then?

3. You referred some technologies, tell me wrt Quantum computing, what is the difference between q-bit and ordinary bit?

4. What will be the impact of Quantum computing on security? Can India benefit from that?

5. Initiatives of govt to promote quantum computing?

6. What are the challenges or issues in Quantum computing?

7. Have you hear of 3D modelling of universe?

8. You have stayed in Pune, there are many famous labs in Pune. Which are they?

9. What is the speciality of NIV?

M4:

1. If in future there is occurence of a new event like corona, but not the same novel corona, can it be dealt with in a better manner?

2. With benefit of hindsight, what should be done so that in future if novel corona reoccurs we all can enjoy it without suffering?

3. What are the learnings from this corona pandemic? (Later Clarified, in context of labour)

4. Illegal works in real estate is an important issue in Urban governance. What has government done to address it?

5. What is the difference between the function of RERA and function of Municipal Commissioner of Pune or Mumbai?

6. What was the recent bank fraud in Maharashtra?

7. What is the full form of PMC? Why did it occur? What is the background of Wadhwans?

8. What happens to the money of depositers if such frauds occur?

Sahil

Optional : Chemistry

Education : B.Tech

Chemical Engineering

Home State: Punjab

Work : Indian Forest Service,2018

Board : Dr. Manoj Soni

Date : 12/03/2020

Chairman

1) What are your areas of interest?

2) Tell me some important social issues currently?

3) Have you heard about live-in-relationships? Your Opinion

4) Suppose a live-in couple has a child and then they decide to break up...can you imagine the mental trauma the child has to go through?Do you think such relationship are right for our socirty?

5) What is your opinion on people watching pornography within their own personal space? Should Individual autonomy guide all such actions?

M1:

1) Tell me about some important environmental issues

2) Expalain el nina and la nina events and its impact on India

3) Melting of polar ice caps and its effects

4) Impact of Climate Change on food security of India?

5) What is Earth science?

6) Tell me your strengths and weakness

M2:

1) What is issue regarding Capital city of Chandigarh between Punjab and Haryana? What is its solution ?

2) Why do farmers in Punjab burn paddy straw despite government restrictions?

3) Why should the Government compensate the farmers for not burning stubble...does it not go against the "polluter pays principle"?

4) As an Engineer tell me how can we solve the stubble burning problem

M3:

1) So your Hobby is reading memoirs...what memoirs have you read? (I answered karmayogi which is about E sreedharan )

2) Asked me in detail about the summary of the book

3) What leadership qualites have you learned from the book

M4:

1) Why do we need to remove the stubble before planting new crop?

2) Tell me about Malnutrition and Food Fortification in India

3) Why India lags in Global Hunger Index?

4) Have you heard about the term "Fraternity" in our Constitution..Explain its meaning.

Chairman: Thank You ...your interview is over

Duration : 15-20 mins..cordial board

Date 29th July 2020

Afternoon, Second to go

Board: Sathyavati Ma'am Board

IIT Kharagpur, Hobby: Teaching

Optional Maths

Chairman Read aloud the DAF.

Chairwoman: What have you been doing since 2018?

What is Young Innovator's Program? (DAF)

Your hobby is teaching and you have taken mathematics as optional. What would you do to remove fear of maths from students?

Member 1

1. The size of ships are increasing. What impact would that have on port?

Apart from logistics what impact do you think that would have?

2. What have been the contribution of Odisha to South East Asian nations as well as western India?

You know about migrants. They also come from Odisha. What is their speciality?

Member 2

1. You have a corpus of fund and you want to invest it. You have equity, debt, mutual fund, gold, bonds. In what proportion would you invest it?

Do you have idea about market and how it works?

Do you read headlines?

What is the current status of market today?

Why is it so?

Is there any problem due to that?

2. Do you know which pay commission made the most significant change in employees income?

It was sixth pay commission and it was because of economic growth because when economy grows income grows subsequently. Do you think a civil servant should have knowledge of market if he is investing in assets?

Member 4

1. States like Bihar and Odisha are rich in minerals but lack in development. Why?

But Naveen Patnaik govt is for a quite a long time and enjoys trust as well. So how that is an issue. Secondly, development is the solution to naxalism what is the problem then?

Member 5

1. Do you know about Look west Policy?

What importance does middle eastern countries hold for India apart from the fact that they are oil rich?

What else?

There is an angle of religion.

Continue talking.

Thank you. Your interview is over.

Background – IRS (IT), IIT DELHI Board – Smita Nagraj Ma’am

Date – 29/07/2020; AN (3rd to go) Optional – Chemistry

I was asked to pull down my mask and adjust the face shield by the Chairperson. CP

• How training is going on?

• What all have you done till now in your training?

• How can you use your graduation knowledge in IRS(IT)?

• Tax Fiscal Connection – model, positives, is it really possible? (long discussion over

it)

• Tax terrorism – definition, example and how to reduce it?

M1

• Agricultural land in Kerala is used for non-agricultural purposes. What are your

views? (cross questions on this)

• Lithium ore – name? (Optional)

• Li – which group in periodic table (other elements in this group)

• Use of Lithium

M2

• Textile sector problems

• why our exports are stagnant in textile?

• Why Vietnam and BD are doing very well but we are not doing so well?

• What should be our strategy to improve Textile sector?

M3

• Equalisation levy?

• Recent proposal of 2% on non-resident e-commerce companies? What is it?

• Will it affect the FDI in India?

M4

• Should we tax agriculture? (discussion over it)

• India is doing short term planning or long-term planning? Which one should we do?

• Should civil servant be allowed to become the part of Trade unions?

CP

• Do you think that we will having more economic equity in near future?

Thank you, your interview is over.

25 /02/20

Board: Bhonsale sir

Background:Btech in electrical engineering from IIT BHU

Optional:Maths

Places:Bihar, Varanasi, Pune

Hobbies: Cricket, Mentoring juniors

Chairman:

1) When was the last time you visited varanasi?

2) Steps taken to clean ganga

3) Any observable improvement in ganga river

4)

Member 1:

1) Contribution of SC Bose in India's freedom struggle

2) Are we forgetting the values taught by him?

3) What is digital detoxing?

4) How can we motivate children and youngsters towards digital detoxing so that they could participate more in social matters?

5) What is 4th IR

Member 2:

1) Who led the women's wing of Indian National Army?

2) Illegal drug trade in Punjab-Reasons

3) Influential persons are involved in these activities. How will you stop illegal drug trade as an administrator?

Member 3:

1) UN organisation involved in drug trade control

2) Golden Triangle and golden crescent

3)

Member 4(Lady member) :

1) Why are there so many NGOs in Bihar?

2) Orissa is also economically backward but does not have large numbers of NGOs-Reason?

3) Why is Bihar economically backward?

4) Economic steps and improvements of Bihar in last few years.

5) If same steps are taken in Maharashtra then what would be it's impact.

Chairman:

1) Why Bangladesh is growing at a higher growth rate?

2) Why are we worried about china's string of pearls policy?

Forgot few questions.

Name: Darshana Kumar H G

Board: B B Vyaas

Date and Time: 28th July 2020; Afternoon, first one to go.

Work Experience: 1. Infosys [ Total 6 years IT ( 2.5 years in USA @ Client location) ],

2. Dairy farmer [Since 2018]

Chairman:

Q. You are D K and worked in US and you started Dairy-farming Since 2018, It is interesting so tell me about your farm.

Q. How many cows you have

Q. Which breeds give more milk

Q. Did you take any Govt loan

Q. Consumer Protection

Lady M1:

Q. Karnataka tourism promotion

Q. Women issues in Karnataka

Q. What are the solutions for eradicating devadasi system

Q. Lake Pollution in Bengaluru

Q. Measures taken by Govt.

Q. Is it a success?

Q. What you do with cow dung

Q: You worked with NGO and working as a dairy farmer, why civil service

M2:

Q. Debt:Equity of your farm

Q. You worked for 6 years, how do flight take off. I said, i worked as a Software engineer sir, I am not aware of it now. Q. Okay, some technical question. I said, I don’t know sir

Q. Which fashion you do not like it in these days.

Q. How much profit are you making from your dairy farm

M3:

Q: Famous Kannada writers mother tongue is different from their literature excellency, what is the reason

Q:Your favorite writer

Q: What are the specialities of Poornachandra tejaswi

Q: He writes about forest and nature right? Why?

Q: Why China is behaving like this

M4:

Q: Dairy farm challenges

Q: Why foreign companies failed in dairy sector

Q: Why Milk Co-operatives are success.

Q: How do you implement a scheme to procure the Cattle dung to convert into vermicompost

Q: FPO

Q: Do you scale up your dairy farm? I said No.

Q: What are the the challenges

Q: Who will take care of it after you get selected

Chairman.

Q: Work Culture difference

Q: Some question which was related to why civil services

We wish you best of luck for your result. thank you

FINAL REQUEST:

ALL THOSE WHO HAVE GIVEN INTERVIEW THIS YEAR and haven't submitted their transcript till now can send it to us by today evening or so. After that it will be compiled and your transcript will not come in that. If you want to share , share it now.

You have to PM it to us @Yo_Yo_Choti_Singh or @Patriot_Saint or @Aaykarvibhag or @KaptaanJackSparrow . We will post it here in the channel.

#Sharing_is_Caring 😊🙏

Interview Transcripts 2023 pinned «FINAL REQUEST: ALL THOSE WHO HAVE GIVEN INTERVIEW THIS YEAR and haven't submitted their transcript till now can send it to us by today evening or so. After that it will be compiled and your transcript will not come in that. If you want to share , share it...»

Hello Everyone. Today we are here with busting of another high level fraud in CSE Market.

This is a person MANJEET SINGH who in the name of endorsements and congratulations, seriously misguiding Interview appearing/appeared candidates.

He claims that:

1. He knows CSE results beforehand. And mails to you to discuss further connections by saying that YOU ARE IN HIS MOST PROBABLE LIST !

2. Whosoever takes mock with him , due to a so called HAPPY SUPERSTITION , everyone get selected with top ranks and then SHARES PHOTOS WITH PREVIOUS YEAR TOPPERS by saying that they all have been associated with him beforehand!

3. He promises to share SCREENSHOTS OF RESULT with you well before actual UPSC declaration.

After our thorough research and communication with previous year toppers which he claims as his own - We found that

1. HE IS HIGHEST DEGREE FRAUD.

2. HE IS JON SNOW. HE KNOWS NOTHING.

3. HE JUST CLICKS PHOTOS WITH TOPPERS EVERY YEAR OUTSIDE VARIOUS COACHINGS IN DELHI and send those next year as previous year achievement.

4. Results are NOT AT ALL KNOWN TO HIM.

5. Receiving his CONGRATULATIONS MAIL had no connection with future selection in whatsoever manner.

MOST IMPORTANTLY:

6. He is an endorsement broker for some coaching which means offering benefits in lieu of toppers endorsing various coaching institutes. He visits , offers and clicks photos irrespective of your acceptance or denial of such offers - later shows it to next year toppers to FRAUDLY CONVINCE to accept such offers.

We have decided to highlight this fraud to all of you. Please share and talk about such things to all your known aspirants so that such fraudsters can be tackled suitably and NOT EVEN SINGLE SERIOUS ASPIRANT IS MISGUIDED/ GET TRAPPED.

We , along with many previous years toppers, are mulling over suitable LEGAL ACTION against this person soon.

Please do share with us any such fraud of general aspirant concern. Further post selection , be very careful about your endorsements etc because such Fraud people do take advantage of your name.

Best way out is that EACH AND EVERY TOPPER must openly share the VERY FIRST DAY AFTER RESULT about his/her BRIEF ENTIRE YEAR-WISE COACHING / MENTORSHIP HISTORY which s/he took and benefitted in any manner and post it on various aspirant groups and platforms. Such declaration can act as a strong deterrent and proof against all possible misuse of your name by such fraudsters of CSE Market.

Jai Hind. #Sharing_is_Caring #Hum_Honge_Kamyaab_Ek_Din

Interview Transcripts 2023 pinned «Hello Everyone. Today we are here with busting of another high level fraud in CSE Market. This is a person MANJEET SINGH who in the name of endorsements and congratulations, seriously misguiding Interview appearing/appeared candidates. He claims that: ...»

Sarma:

17.02.2020

Hon'ble UPSC Member Mr. BS Bassi Sir Board

Is this your photo?- yes sir thats my photo

Writing on quora. Hmm. Whats the last thing you wrote and when was it? - told about butterfly photo i clicked to a quora question on what was the most creative thing I did.

Is butterfly older than human in evolution?- said sorry don't know sir

Famous Butterfly quote? - no

By Muhammad Ali?- no

Ok what would you learn from a butterfly?-BEAUTIFUL- can emulate in our attire.

Ok then?-Flying like a butterfly in life

Ok then?-Face challenges in life like butterfly comes out of pupa.

But isn't pupa and larva beautiful?-i said it's beautiful in its own way sir. Told but butterfly is much more beautiful sir.

Which is more beautiful- Beauty in content or beauty in knowledge? -told beauty is in content more.

Justify it!-took 15 secs-told I find it beautiful more because all our knowledge accumulated till now is due to sharing of content our elders had.

So which is more important? Beauty without appearance but in content?- i told beauty in content without appearance is less preferred sir. In fact, beauty in content is supplemented by beauty in appearance sir.

M1

You told that you want to fly like a butterfly. Why don't you become a pilot?- told by saying flying i didn't mean as such but coming out with colors in life sir. Civil service will offer me opportunity to make an impact in society sir.

What are peaceful uses of space?- Satellites used in resources monitoring- remote sensing.

Okay continue- Used in border security which is key to peace (said ISRO planning GISAT). What tech is used in that satellite?- continuous monitoring sir.

Okay continue- used in Education delivery (Swayam)

Okay continue- Satellites key to mass communication like TV, Radio etc (INSAT)

Linked to ECE?- Smiled and told its definitely very basis for Mobile communication sir.

Okay Narayana, Whats cyber warfare?- Explained it as hacking, defacing, snooping (Pegasus example)

Is it possible to attack a nation without firing a missile but by using cyber warfare?- yes sir. Administration has revolutionized a lot. E governance era- delivery of services would be compromised.

How? - Denial of Service Attack sir, many bots ping and server will be unable to function- compromised.

Okay thank you. I also thanked sir.

M2 (lady)

What's current sex ratio and is it an issue? - told sorry mam, i do not remember exact figure but it's definitely above 900. And as far as my knowledge goes it has improved mam.

No it has declined- sorry mam, i am incorrect.

Okay tell me what's status of malnutrition in India?- UNESCO Report- 69% of under 5 deaths due to malnutrition, Global Hunger Index slipped by 2 positions from 100 to 102.

Whats the cause behind it?- told malnourished mothers lead to malnourished children. TN model where anganwadis give energy dense food to mothers and issue is largely resolved can be emulated mam.

Okay thank you. Thanked mam.

M3

What's this China's projects creating an issue time and again?- told CPEC- sovereignty first, connectivity next.

No, I'm not asking just about pakistan but also whole neighborhood- explained String of Pearls.

Is it an issue? - told yes it poses security issue. And that India actively engaging in neighborhood in advantageous areas like diaspora, people 2 people connect is addressing issue. Cited example of India extending line of credit to SL during recent SL PM Visit.

Okay thanks. Thanked sir.

M4

So, mobile photography is your hobby! Difference between mobile and DSLR?- DSLR bigger lens size so picture quality high, more manipulation like shutter speed, aperture possible. But mobile photography has its own advantages as it's easy to carry, portable and edit on the go.

What's a pixel? - explained with example. 48 M means that many pixels in image. More pixel more details.

Can you capture intermittent moments with Mobile?- with latest tech, yes sir possible- pro or manual mode has shutter speed controls.

What's EMI & EMC? Electro Magnetic Induction. For EMC said i don't know.

Use of senso

rs in c

ars?- told safety and energy conservation

How these sensors are adapted to different climatic conditions like gulf or kashmir?- told don't know exactly but this could be pre designed by company. He told its by linking with air temperature sensors as part of iot. I said thanks sir.

Okay thank you. Thanked sir.

Chairman

So Narayana your optional is Public Administration. Yes sir.

Corruption is a big issue in our administration. Yes sir.

As a Civil Servant, how will you address corruption?- Told about recent act giving bribery a offence. Would sensitise people that doing so will attract strong penalties. Employment of technologies like Block chain so no tampering of records can happen. Similarly, CCTVs in office.

Narayana, despite CCTV tender corruption is happening. Suppose 20% cut is planned to be given to official for approving a tender, how will you tackle that corruption?- told another technological solution like faceless tax assessment recently brought by govt, FACELESS tender assessment or evaluation would address the issue.

Okay Narayana. Thank you!

Thank you sir.

10 secs gap. Was still sitting.

You may leave. Thanked sir and members.

Interview Transcripts 2023 pinned Deleted message

Hello Everyone. Today we are here with busting of another high level fraud in CSE Market.

This is a person MANJEET SINGH who in the name of endorsements and congratulations, seriously misguiding Interview appearing/appeared candidates.

He claims that:

1. He knows CSE results beforehand. And mails to you to discuss further connections by saying that YOU ARE IN HIS MOST PROBABLE LIST !

2. Whosoever takes mock with him , due to a so called HAPPY SUPERSTITION , everyone get selected with top ranks and then SHARES PHOTOS WITH PREVIOUS YEAR TOPPERS by saying that they all have been associated with him beforehand!

3. He promises to share SCREENSHOTS OF RESULT with you well before actual UPSC declaration.

After our thorough research and communication with previous year toppers which he claims as his own - We found that

1. HE IS HIGHEST DEGREE FRAUD.

2. HE IS JON SNOW. HE KNOWS NOTHING.

3. HE JUST CLICKS PHOTOS WITH TOPPERS EVERY YEAR OUTSIDE VARIOUS COACHINGS IN DELHI and send those next year as previous year achievement.

4. Results are NOT AT ALL KNOWN TO HIM.

5. Receiving his CONGRATULATIONS MAIL had no connection with future selection in whatsoever manner.

MOST IMPORTANTLY:

6. He is an endorsement broker for some coaching which means offering benefits in lieu of toppers endorsing various coaching institutes. He visits , offers and clicks photos irrespective of your acceptance or denial of such offers - later shows it to next year toppers to FRAUDLY CONVINCE to accept such offers.

We have decided to highlight this fraud to all of you. Please share and talk about such things to all your known aspirants so that such fraudsters can be tackled suitably and NOT EVEN SINGLE SERIOUS ASPIRANT IS MISGUIDED/ GET TRAPPED.

We , along with many previous years toppers, are mulling over suitable LEGAL ACTION against this person soon.

Please do share with us any such fraud of general aspirant concern. Further post selection , be very careful about your endorsements etc because such Fraud people do take advantage of your name.

Best way out is that EACH AND EVERY TOPPER must openly share the VERY FIRST DAY AFTER RESULT about his/her BRIEF ENTIRE YEAR-WISE COACHING / MENTORSHIP HISTORY which s/he took and benefitted in any manner and post it on various aspirant groups and platforms. Such declaration can act as a strong deterrent and proof against all possible misuse of your name by such fraudsters of CSE Market.

Jai Hind. #Sharing_is_Caring #Hum_Honge_Kamyaab_Ek_Din

Interview Transcripts 2023 pinned «Hello Everyone. Today we are here with busting of another high level fraud in CSE Market. This is a person MANJEET SINGH who in the name of endorsements and congratulations, seriously misguiding Interview appearing/appeared candidates. He claims that: ...»