Interviews

UPSC interview, Sujata Chaturvedi board, 24 Jul 2020 (Delhi)

24 Jul 2020

analyzer 56:

Analyzer 56

Graduation: B.Tech in Biotechnology, NIT Durgapur, 2014

Optional: Philosophy

Hobbies: jogging and playing bongos

State: Delhi

Board: Ms. Sujhata Mehta (CP + 4 male members)

Date: 24th July, forenoon session

First person to go, around 10.10.......exit from main gate of upsc at around 10.55....10 minutes in security check and formalities....so, roughly around 30 minutes

Chairperson

Me: May I come in Ma’am

CP: Yes, yes come come.....she gestured me hurriedly

Me: Good morning ma’am, good morning sirs......(gestured a nod to every member (although it was very tough as each member had literally occupied all the four directions))

CP: Please sit

Me: with a bold voice, thankyou ma’am :)

CP: Raising my photograph, is this you?

Me: looked at it and then said, yes ma’am

CP: So, Analyzer pls introduce yourself

Me: Ma’am I was born and brought up in Delhi. I have done my schooling from xyz DAV Public School, New Delhi. I have done my graduation, Btech in Biotechnology from NIT Durgapur. I have also done a summer internship at CERN, Geneva. After that I have been preparing for this exam

CP: So, you are not doing any regular job?

Me: No Ma’am

CP: Any on/off job and why?

Me: No ma’am because I have been self preparing for this exam and I am fully dedicated towards the preparation.

CP: Fine. So, you have been to CERN? For how long?

Ans: Ma’am I had been there for two months from May to July.

CP: Tell me what your project was there.

Me: Ma’am i was working on Resistive plate chambers (RPC) which are used in detection systems. It was part of CMS project which is one of the two main projects which led to discovery of Higgs boson particle.

CP: Higgs what?

Me: Ma’am Higgs boson particle.

CP: oh, the god particle discovery. So, were you there when it was discovered?

Me: Ma’am, it was discovered in 2012 while I went there the next year, 2013.

CP. Okay. Tell me about the applicability of Nuclear energy post Fukushima Disaster in the world.

Ans: Ma’am Nuclear energy is a clean and renewable energy (Although it is a big debate! But ma’am didn’t raise any objection and was satisfied with my response). It could play a big role in sustainable energy. But, at the same time, we need to focus on safety and precautions of nuclear reactors because even small disasters could be detrimental for us. So, under appropriate facilities, nuclear energy holds applicability.

CP: Can you tell me about two nuclear projects which have been set up post Fukushima disaster?

Me: (i thought for 2 seconds) Sorry ma’am, I cannot recall it right now.

CP: Fine. Tell me what has biotechnology done in this COVID fight?

Me: A number of steps have been taken by Department of biotechnology like:

A consortium was formed for better academia-scientist and industry cooperation.

Kits for tests like RT PCR, RAPID antibody, antigen test were prepared by indigenous companies. I- lab facility under make in india was done to make such kits accessible even in hinterland areas. Biotech startups were promoted by clusters like andhra pradesh tech zone to scale up any projects.Recently, two companies bharat biotech and zydus cadila are now going for trial 1 for vaccination.

CP: Fine, regarding kits do you know a case in Supreme court which made big headlines in May-june... ( at this time, ma’am’s voice was so low and she was herself wearing a shield...that it was almost impossible for me to hear it..... I asked her to please repeat the question and also aligning my body a little bit forward on chair to hear.....she repeated it again)

Me:Sorry ma’am, I cannot recall it ( i thought she was referring to the faulty rapid antibody kits from china.....but i was not sure)

(not sure whether she asked one or two questions more)

CP: Okay, thankyou analyzer....she signalled to member 1

Me: Thankyou Ma’am

Member 1

Member 1 ( He was sitting near me on my left...i had to turn my head by 90 degrees to face him)

M1: what is your view on freedom of expression and censorship? Is it okay to censure anyone?

Me: Sir, freedom of expression is one of our fundamental rights. It helps an individ

ual to expres

s his/her ideas freely which develops his/her personality. But at the same time under reasonable restrictions like threat to public safety or sovereignty and integrity point of view, censorship can be applied.

M1: Fine. You have philosophy as your optional. You must be aware about Plato's ‘philosopher king’ . He talked about how a philosopher king should rule the society. Can you tell me about what he meant by it.

Me: Sir, Plato had talked about division of society on the basis of function. For example, he talked about slaves, warrior classes etc. Similarly, he gave the concept of philosopher king. On the basis of wisdom, a king should be selected for running administration. It was as per the situation which existed at that time in Athens. He believed people are not wise enough to select a ruler, so only a wise ruler should represent the state for the welfare of people. (just a day ago i had discussed this question and i forgot to mention the book-the republic)

M1: So as per him, the philosopher king should be selected on the basis of wisdom.

Me: As per the situation which existed at that time, yes sir.

M1: And do you know he was a communist?

Me: yes sir, Plato was a communist because he had talked about the role of community in raising a child. He had said instead of parents, a child should be raised by community.

M1: Plato had also talked about dialectics. And then after a long time, one more philosopher talked about the dialectical process...( At this point, I thought he would bring a question on Hegel so i was preparing points for it...) KARL MARX....yes he was also communist. So, how do both the dialectical processes different?

Me: Sir, Plato had borrowed the idea of dialectics from his teacher Socrates. In this process he used to raise rhetorical questions to discuss ideas and opinions with people. Plato had also talked about recollection of knowledge and how knowledge is gained through recollection. So, every person through deep thinking could get answers to philosophical questions. On the other hand, karl marx’s l process was based on dialectical materialism. He talks about how society has developed contradictions based on conflict of classes- proletariat and bourgeoisie. Since proletarians do not get their share in surplus value or means of production, they will revolt against this injustice through revolution to further evolve society. ( i forgot to mention from classes to classless society...but the member looked satisfied)

M1: Let's move from western to Indian philosophy. Why is Aurobindo's Philosophy so important to us?

Me: Sir, Aurobindo’s philosophy is also called Integral Advaitism. He had combined all ideas to one Super being . He had talked about raising consciousness to superconsciousness level. For this, he had talked about the process of involution and evolution. He was an important indian renaissance philosopher and contributed to the freedom struggle of india.

( again here i missed crucial terms like integral yoga, sachhidanand but again the member did not question anything. He seemed satisfied. Meanwhile Ma’am signalled member 2 who was sitting next to me on the right side)

Member 2

M2: Okay analyzer, it has been a crisis time for us due to covid epidemic. Can you tell me how?

Ans: Yes sir, Covid crisis has brought the entire world to a standstill. We have suffered immensely both physically and mentally. Deaths and agony of losing people, loss in the economy, etc. Practices like social distancing are useful in fighting the crisis but have taken a toll on mental life. At the same time, how our migrant workers suffered during this crisis has shown how we have been avoiding their problems.

M2: Tell me about how this pandemic has affected our mental life? Tell me two mental problems which were on the rise?

Ans: Sir ,we have seen how during lockdown many people got stuck at some places and they lost touch with their family. Moreover, practices like social distancing made it difficult to connect with our near and dear ones.There was an increase in cases of depression and suicides a

lso.

M2: Goo

d. One more mental problem was that of Anxiety, which also increased tremendously. So, can you tell me how we can overcome it?

Ans: Sir, few factors for increase of mental problems were lack of physical activity and lack of connection with our family members and friends. From a physical fitness point of view, we can practice exercises, I would like to give an example of my hobby- jogging. This has helped me to refresh during lockdown as it can be practiced even in a room at one place. At the same time, such exercises help in releasing neurotransmitters like serotonin and dopamine which reduces anxiety and depression. With respect to social distancing, I think sir, the digital world has helped us in coming close to our near and dear ones through video calling.

M2 : Very good. Now coming to the current scenario at Galwan valley. Can you tell me what equipment India has inducted?

Me: Sir, India is in talks with Russia regarding import of MIG and other jets I cannot recall right now.

M2. No problem, but there were some helicopters which were rovering the region. Can you name it.

Me: (At this time i thought i had seen clips of either chinook or Apache or both. But, i was not sure. Moreover, i had made mind i will not ask for guess also as it sometimes seem lack of decision making) Sorry sir, I cannot recall it right now

M2: No problem. Can you tell me what is the role of money in politics? Is it a problem?

Me: Yes sir, several reports point to use of money power to influence elections. This also leads to criminalisation of politics and is against fair election. It also leads to the rise of corruption. Stringent steps must be taken to curb such practices.

M2: yes tell me what steps can be taken.

Me: Sir recent steps like introduction of electoral bonds are in the right direction. Use of VVPAT machines can help us in detecting cases in certain constituencies where money power could be used to influence elections by matching the number of votes with slips. At the same time, awareness must be generated among voters about consequences of their decisions. They could be persuaded to vote on logic and development instead of money power. (He scribbled something while i was answering)

M2: What is the role of CVC

Me: Sir, Central Vigilance Commission is a statutory body which deals in corruption charges against public officials. It acts as a watchdog against such practices and several state vigilance commissions also help it in tackling menace of corruption.

M2: What about role of CBI and (one more body he mentioned) in tackling corruption

Me: Sir both the forces (could have used a better word like body or something) play an important role in the investigational process and solve cases. They deal in corruption charges also (i also mentioned some more points to which the member nodded agreeably he did not cross question and ma’am signalled the third member)

Member 3 ( he tried to make me uneasy, but i was like...ki farak painda hai :) )

M3: So analyzer you had been to Geneva. I think you must have gone for sightseeing. Mont blanc, lake geneva

Me: yes sir i have been to lake geneva but not mont blanc

M3: okay not mont blanc. Then , if we talk about lake geneva, there is a very strange thing about it. Can you tell me?

Me: sir, Lake Geneva has a Jet d’eau which is about 140 m of water jet.

M3: No, haven’t you seen how clear the lake water is :P so clean

Me: Yes sir, It is very clean and clear water.

M3: So tell me what methods are they using for cleaning that lake?

Me: Sorry sir, I am not aware about the technique.

M3: No, you are a biotech engineer, you must be aware about how lakes are cleaned.

Me: Yes sir, we can apply techniques like bioremediation.

M3: Yes, but you are not aware about lake geneva’s technique

Me: No sir.

M3: Okay, now we know how our country is focussing on sanitation and two cities have become leading examples in it- Indore and Mysore because of their waste collection methods. Are you aware of the two methods?

Me: Sorry sir, i cannot recall it right now.

M3: Comeon, you will become DM

in a few years

and you should be aware about such reports. No problem, i will tell you how both of them work. ( he gave a monologue for about 3 minutes, explaining in detail about both the projects)

M3: So which one did you like?

Me: Sir, thank you for explaining both the systems. I think both of them have their advantages...

M3: No, no take a stand. You can’t choose both

Me: ( indore is rank 1, Mysore is rank2 (as the member had said) i thought better to choose rank 1 city :P) Sir, in that case i will choose Indore.

M3: Why so, why did you not choose mysore? Can’t you see how model 1 has led to a mountain of garbage at ghazipur. Have you seen that mountain?

Me: yes sir, it is one of the major problems in Delhi right now.

M3: Then, how can you improve it using method 1? Do you have some techniques in biotechnology

Me: Sir, We can apply biosensors to detect the extent to which garbage has degraded and....

M3: Not biosensors, how will you use it will be a separate question....okay tell me about your project in final year.

Me: ( we all know what our final year projects are like :) but i had to come up with an answer)

Sir, it was a project regarding use of microbial organisms in plants and use of bioreactors to grow algae to treat wastage and generate electricity from it.

M3: plants?

Me: Yes sir, and there was use of a bioreactor. Moreover the project had more use of theoretical than practical dimensions.

M3: How much electricity did you generate out of that waste?

Me: sorry sir, i cannot recall it now.

M3: It was your final year project, you should have been aware of it...( Ma’am signalled M4 for questions)

Member 4

M4: So, analyzer you play bongos. Can you tell me out of these three indian instruments which one is closest to the bongos- Dholak. Mridangam and pakhavaj.

Me: Sir, i am not aware about pakhawaj but both dholak and mridangam have two drumheads integrated in one shell. However, Bongos consist of two separate drumheads on two shells ( i explained it through gesture of my hands). So , sir in my opinion the closest indian instrument can be tabla.

M4: No, but in my opinion, bongos could be compared with dholak as both can be tuned, isn’t it so?

Me: Yes sir, Thankyou sir, for enlightening me ( :P)

M4: Okay analyzer, you must have prepared your passport for going to switzerland. What are the changes you have seen with respect to how passports were made in 2013 and now? And under which ministry the passport comes?

Me: Yes sir, coming to the first question, in 2013 I had to go through a number of processes involving annexure work to make a tatkal passport....

M4: First tell me under which ministry it comes?

Me: sir, under ministry of external affairs

M4: Yes, good. Now tell me the changes.

Me: Sir like I was saying, now the process has become less cumbersome, red tapism has reduced. A lot of verification work has become online. There is a time limit under which passports can be easily availed unlike earlier times.

M4: Yes right. Now tell me what is a lookout notice?

Me: sorry sir, I cannot recall it right now.

M4: While going through clearance on airport, you come across a certain section which finally let you go through

Me: Sir, custom section

M4. No not that process, they particularly see your face, then your passport and then put a stamp and let you in. What is that department?

Me: Sir, Immigration department.

M4: Yes right. Immigration department. Now tell me under which ministry do they come?

Me: ( i thought for a few seconds, i was getting a gut feeling of custom...but i decided not to attempt and it was the best decision :) since-it comes under MHA(yet autonomous) and the intelligence bureau is also associated with it) Sorry sir, I cannot recall it right now.

M4: No problem. Now analyzer, you come from East Delhi.

Me: Sir...

M4: Do you not come from East Delhi?

Me: I was born in East Delhi but i was brought up in South delhi.

M4 :Ohh....he rechecked my DAF....okay so in south delhi....no no let’s go back to east delhi again for a while :)

Me: Yes sir, with a smile ( though under mask smile or no smi

le all seemed the

same. The only way to know is your quality of voice)

M4: In East Delhi, let us assume there is a problem of riot which can take place any time. As a DCP, how will you tackle it?

Me: Sir, can I take a few seconds to think?

M4: yes, you can.

Me: ( after a few seconds..) Sir, firstly, I will make sure that there is no intelligence failure. I will make sure information is available even from the bottom level of beat constables who are active at ground level

Secondly, i will make sure sufficient force is available to tackle any unforeseen events which can happen and prevent essential services from being disrupted

Thirdly, We can take help of technology like drones to check any suspicious activities in hotspot areas....

M4: okay, okay and tell me about legal actions which you can take

Me: Sir, I can take help of different provisions under IPC and CrPc to control the situation. I may even control gathering of more than five people if law and order situation is under threat.

M4: okay ( he was satisfied with my reply)

Chairperson again:

(i am not sure whether she asked one or two questions....before coming to the final question)

CP: Analyzer, do you want us to cover something which you think we can discuss?

Me: (i thought for a few seconds) Ma’am we can discuss vaccination.

CP: Okay, tell me why there is hesitancy for vaccines?

Me: Ma’am because of a number of reasons. Firstly, there are reports and cases about adverse reactions in some cases. Secondly, some people are unaware about the positive effects of vaccine

CP: what is herd immunity?

Me: Ma’am, herd immunity refers to a scenario when some people in a community are infected say 40-60 %. Due to which infection say, virus spread in an epidemic/pandemic , do not spread aggressively, thereby protecting other people from infection and thus breaking chain of transmission

CP: Okay analyzer, your interview is over, you can go

Me: Thankyou ma’am.

( i stood up nodded again, thanked other members with a nod and left)

Negatives:

Member 3 was not satisfied

Sometimes sujhata maam was inaudible.

Answers could have been better in some questions

Positives:

Not for a single time i had to touch either my mask or shield, no problem of fog and all. I was comfortable with both mask and shield

Member 1, 2 and 4 were satisfied

Sujata maam nodded all the time to my response so she was interested in the interview despite of a flat tv behind me :)

I answered only after thinking on the question raised, in almost 3 questions, i even took permission of the members to think for few seconds before answering and not a single time they refused.

Overall, it was better than last year, but let's see how the future unfolds :)

Naveen Yadav

Date-27 july 2020, AF

Optional-PSIR

Hobbies-Gardening,Watching biographical movies

Board- smita nagaraj mam

Chairman-

- why so many problems with student politics in jnu? What can be done?

- did u participate in student politics?how was ur experience?

- who is ur fav thinker in psir?wht views influenced u the most?

M 1

- should we go for presidential system?give reasons? For and against

- should India also have federation like that of USA?

- role of bismarck and sardar patel

- which biographical movies has inspired u the most? Wht message do u get from watching them?

M-2

- wht type of gardening u do?

- what are challenges in rooftop gardening?

- wht do u usually grow- tell me process

- should govt have power to ban foods? Wht abt nagaland govt order?

- is it right for govt to increase taxes when prices of oil in international markets are low?

M-3

- should india ban all kinds of import from china? What are the challenges- short discussion on that

M-4

- wht is south china sea?

- what r the issues?

- wht is the importance?

- explain the aggressive nature of china there?