Interviews

UPSC interview, B. S. Bassi board, 27 Jul 2020 (Sociology)

27 Jul 2020

Patriot Saint:

Board : Shri. B. S. Bassi

DAF content around which questions revolved : Tribal related NGO work, NSS, Internship on drones at National Aerospace Laboratories, E&C Engineering, Ex-SBI PO, Ex-Chip design Engineer, Head of Digital Financial Literacy Campaign in SBI branch

CH:

Do you want to use your mike? I said no sir, (He said he will be able to hear my voice if I talk in same pitch)

1. Why did you join NSS? (I said based on father's suggestion, good platform to contribute something to the society)

2. What did you do to contribute to the society? (Said 2 works, he said tell more, I told 2 more including camp we did in the tribal area)

3. That is ok, but are you following up any? (Here I told about tribal related NGO work which I had joined as follow up work)

4. What are you doing for their upliftment? (I said 3 works, he wanted to hear more - he said go on, I again told 2-3 more works)

5. What is affirmative action? (I said definition, but he wanted to hear more, I went on speaking till he signalled enough - gave lots of examples here positive discrimination - reservation, tribal sub-plan, schemes, special protective laws etc.)

M1:

1. You were part of digital financial literacy campaign. What was your role. (I said I was head of the campaign)

2. What did you do to achieve digital financial literacy? What impact it had on people there? (Answered well)

3. You have worked in banking sector. What is amount of bad assets in SBI? (Politely said, do not know exact amount, said percentage)

4. Recently IBC is amended in the light of COVID. Can you tell us features. (I said suspension of IBC for a year) (I think he wanted to hear more amendments, which I didn't know, as it was specific I said I knew only that) What will be its impact on NPAs? (I talked about deferment of EMIs, loan repayments for 6 months, but it is going to rise by 6% as per recent RBI Survey)

5. Recently govt is planning to privatise PSBs except 5 out of 12. What is your view (talked about Narasimhan Committee recommendations, global banks, technology, bad loan issue etc.)

M2:

1. Companies act was changed in 2013 to include CSR. Can you explain what it is, criteria on which companies contribute, sectors they contribute. (Here made one factual mistake, instead 5 crore profit, said 500 crore - he corrected me, I said sorry sir, I got confused in this)

2. Question on NGO, not able to recall now - what are the ways in which NGOs work - he was talking about human rights, environment etc. It was long Q, but I answered it, do not remember it now.

3. Source of funds to our NGO from CSR route

M3: (Madam)

1. Long question - she wanted to know limitations of NGOs (I said 3-4 points, but she wanted me to say outcome orientation is missing)

2. She now asked me how we are able to ensure outcomes - tell figure of income, survey etc. (- I said we are able to see change in lives of the people we are working - I explained how its contributing to income generation etc., do not have exact figure of income increase - and also highlighted approach through which we are able to bring outcome orientation - feedback mechanism, participation etc.)

3. Long question - What is image of China in your mind? (Crux) (I said rising and expansionist power, which want to showcase its growing tech, military, economic prowess, beat USA etc.)

4. She wanted strategic angle of China's approach (I talked about debt trap diplomacy, salami slicing, string of pearls - she asked how many ports China is building and mention some ports - I said I didn't know exact number of ports, but mentioned Gwadar and all) (She had OBOR in her mind - she spelt out this and I explained OBOR then)

M4:

1. You have done internship at NAL. Tell us what did you learn there (told 3 points)

2. You have done project on drone. USA keeps using drones. (Kind of long question, but he wanted to know some drones by USA) (I asked, sir, are you talking about predator drones - he said yes, and asked me to mention few more, I said I don't remember)

3. Somebody sitting in Florida will kill someone in west Asia using dron

e (long question)(he was indirectly referring to killing of Iranian Revolutionary Guards Chief, but didn't say explicitly). How ethical is that? (I said sir it depends on who is being killed, told if it is terrorist then it is ethical) (Here he wanted specific keyword which I didn't mention, hence he framed next Q)

4. What would have been pros and cons if we had used drone instead of manned aircraft in Balakote airstrike (I talked about 2 pros, but before I could start cons, he cut me short and mentioned what about collateral damage (this is the word he wanted in previous answer it seems) - killing of civilians - I said sir, that issue can be taken care if we design drones with more precision.

5. How will you use your E&C knowledge in civil service (talked about smart irrigation if get opportunity to work in agri department, work for technology transfer from countries like USA, Israel if in IFS, use of e-governance etc.)

6. You worked in this company for few months. What was your work? I told about iPhone network chip project which I was part of, then told about some features, but highlighted we were only designing, but fabrication is done in Taiwan.

CH:

Mr. X, is it your photo? He was showing it from some long distance, but I was able to see, I said yes sir, he asked me are you confident or just making out from there, I said I am confident, then ma'am sitting besides me asked me to go near bassi sir to check photo, I went and again he asked - I said yes sir, this is my photo only.

Thank you. Your interview is over.

Duration was almost 30 minutes. Overall feeling average though I was confident through out, but questions were long, I was not able to bring out specific keywords which they had in their mind. I might have missed some questions. Also did one factual mistake, which I don't know how board will consider.

Our channel admin Patriot Saint's Interview Transcript. 👆👆👆 He has contributed a lot for proper functioning of this channel this year despite his own time being equally valuable. We wish him best for his bright future. Aap log bhi dua kariyega 😁🤲🤲🙏🙏❤️❤️

#Sharing_is_Caring

#Hum_Honge_Kamyaab_Ek_Din 🤟🤟😊😊

Graduation: MA English Studies IIT Madras

Optional : Sociology

Hobby: Writing poetry, following memes, yoga

The board was cordial and tried to put me at ease. Chairman went through the daf and gave compliments to lighten the mood.

CH: feel free to remove the facesheild. It makes you look like an astraunat.

I thanked him and removed.

CH: you have consistently performed well in academics. Passed out with a 9.28 cgpa and first rank. How have u consistently managed to perform so well.

CH: I saw that you write. You have published three books. Good. You have done literature. What did all did you study for your course.

CH: Okay I will give you two qoutes. Tell me what you make of it. " A Rose is a rose is a rose". "What is in a name, A rose by any other name would smell as sweet'.

Me: ( I got confused between Shakespeare and Wordsworth). Sir I have heard both the qoutes sir but I am unable to place the exact author at the moment.

CH: That I okay. I don't care about the author so much. Tell me your interpretation of it.

(Gave my interpretation. He was convinced)

CH: I see that you have worked on gender.

CH: Is there a movement for Transgenders in India ? any law etc ?

( Spoke about pros n cons of transgender bill)

CH: Good. (He asked M1 to carry on). From this point onwards chairman seemed preoccupied.

M1: What themes have you written about?

M1: Are you from Chennai ?

Me: Sir I was born in Chennai but I am a Keralite. After my birth my parents shifted back to Kerala. ( I didn't want him asking me questions on Tamil Nadu which happened in my last interview 😐)

M1: Okay. You have done sociology tell me one major social issue of Kerala.

( Spoke about alcoholism, binge drinking which in turn fuels other evils like domestic violence and suicide)

M1: I want you to tell me, is there a specific social reason for this issue?

(Social sanction plus daily wage earners with better disposal income due to high wages in KL looking for an easy entertainment after taxing physical work and drinking as a rite of passage to manhood)

M1: I'll comeback to your birth land. The Covid is happening mostly in urban are and Chennai is no different. What do you think are the specific features of chennai that has contributed to this.

Chairman asked M3 to proceed

M3: what is sanskritisation?

M3: what is the difference between poetry and prose?

M3: you practice yoga ? What is the difference between yoga and yogasana?

Chairman asked M2 to carry on.

M2: What is OBOR and BRI? What's the difference between the two. Why was the name changed?

M2: How many SDGs are there? Do you think given the circumstances we can achieve this goal in time?

(17. Gave stats about poverty, out of school students, domestic violence etc in context of covid. Said we will have to extend the timeline realistically speaking but we should work towards it with losing momentum)

M2: Coming back to drinking, Do ladies in kerala drink alcohol?

M2: Rule of Law and Civic sense, do they come at a premium? ( I really didn't understand the question and I told him the same, so he clarified). You said people are drinking etc, even otherwise we see people not following the rules. Do you think rule of law and civic sense come at a premium.

(I still didn't understand and generally spoke about citizens having civic sense, need for value education, better implementation of laws etc)

CH: What is Article 21? We see many times people are denied access to health how is this linked to Art 21? ( I asked him if he was talking in the context of Coronavirus. He said in a general sense).

LM: India got independence in 1947 along with another country. But despite being independent for so many years we are far behind. Even if we leave out pakistan, and compare ourselves with other neighbours, many have done much better than us. Is democracy a failure?

( Praised democracy. Compared with China. Talked about freedom, economic growth being meaningless without adequate rights etc. Corruption as the root cause for issues. Plus solution)

Lady member: What is union, state and concurrent list.

LM

: Don't you think more revenue generating things are given to centre and areas where more work is needed is given to states? How can we reconcile this?

(Said that it is a balanced division. Spoke about national issues needing a concerted effort vs decentralisation, bottom up approach, etc)

LM: How can states address the finance gap?

(Spoke about gst, compensation cess and states own revenue through gst excluded products including alcohol)

LM: okay so say that states can have tax through alcohol. So on one hand you are saying alcohol is bad and then state is also selling alcohol. Isn't there a paradox?

(Spoke about democratic state respecting individual's freedom of choice and how prohibition would lead to blackmarkets and spurious liquor which will have even more detrimental impact on health. Plus need for value education, behavioural change etc)

LM: okay then what about drugs? (She was smiling and laughing in a cordial way)

(Drugs are extremely addictive, can spur violence resulting in social chaos).

CH: You said people are not happy in China. And that they have no freedom. What is the source of this information?

(Mentioned about general perception, death of Doctor who warned about covid, poor labour laws etc)

CH: What you are saying is propaganda How did china grow ? What policy in the 60s did they undertake?

( Talked about Deng Xiaping in 70s and focus on manufacturing)

CH: china grew because of land reforms that they initiated in 1950s. And their policy on education. Mao said that the rate of growth in education must be more than the rate of growth of GDP. Even to this day they follow this.

Me: I will definitely read more about it sir. I had no idea about these reforms.

CH: I take your answer. But you must learn to not take things at face value. I'm telling this because you are a teacher. One must learn to respect our enemy. But otherwise we are happy to have a humanities student. Thank you your interview is over.

Graduation: MA English Studies IIT Madras

Optional : Sociology

Hobby: Writing poetry, following memes, yoga

Board : David Syiemlie sir

The board was cordial and tried to put me at ease. Chairman went through the daf and gave compliments to lighten the mood.

CH: feel free to remove the facesheild. It makes you look like an astraunat.

I thanked him and removed.

CH: you have consistently performed well in academics. Passed out with a 9.28 cgpa and first rank. How have u consistently managed to perform so well.

CH: I saw that you write. You have published three books. Good. You have done literature. What did all did you study for your course.

CH: Okay I will give you two qoutes. Tell me what you make of it. " A Rose is a rose is a rose". "What is in a name, A rose by any other name would smell as sweet'.

Me: ( I got confused between Shakespeare and Wordsworth). Sir I have heard both the qoutes sir but I am unable to place the exact author at the moment.

CH: That I okay. I don't care about the author so much. Tell me your interpretation of it.

(Gave my interpretation. He was convinced)

CH: I see that you have worked on gender.

CH: Is there a movement for Transgenders in India ? any law etc ?

( Spoke about pros n cons of transgender bill)

CH: Good. (He asked M1 to carry on). From this point onwards chairman seemed preoccupied.

M1: What themes have you written about?

M1: Are you from Chennai ?

Me: Sir I was born in Chennai but I am a Keralite. After my birth my parents shifted back to Kerala. ( I didn't want him asking me questions on Tamil Nadu which happened in my last interview 😐)

M1: Okay. You have done sociology tell me one major social issue of Kerala.

( Spoke about alcoholism, binge drinking which in turn fuels other evils like domestic violence and suicide)

M1: I want you to tell me, is there a specific social reason for this issue?

(Social sanction plus daily wage earners with better disposal income due to high wages in KL looking for an easy entertainment after taxing physical work and drinking as a rite of passage to manhood)

M1: I'll comeback to your birth land. The Covid is happening mostly in urban are and Chennai is no different. What do you think are the specific features of chennai that has contributed to this.

Chairman asked M3 to proceed

M3: what is sanskritisation?

M3: what is the difference between poetry and prose?

M3: you practice yoga ? What is the difference between yoga and yogasana?

Chairman asked M2 to carry on.

M2: What is OBOR and BRI? What's the difference between the two. Why was the name changed?

M2: How many SDGs are there? Do you think given the circumstances we can achieve this goal in time?

(17. Gave stats about poverty, out of school students, domestic violence etc in context of covid. Said we will have to extend the timeline realistically speaking but we should work towards it with losing momentum)

M2: Coming back to drinking, Do ladies in kerala drink alcohol?

M2: Rule of Law and Civic sense, do they come at a premium? ( I really didn't understand the question and I told him the same, so he clarified). You said people are drinking etc, even otherwise we see people not following the rules. Do you think rule of law and civic sense come at a premium.

(I still didn't understand and generally spoke about citizens having civic sense, need for value education, better implementation of laws etc)

CH: What is Article 21? We see many times people are denied access to health how is this linked to Art 21? ( I asked him if he was talking in the context of Coronavirus. He said in a general sense).

LM: India got independence in 1947 along with another country. But despite being independent for so many years we are far behind. Even if we leave out pakistan, and compare ourselves with other neighbours, many have done much better than us. Is democracy a failure?

( Praised democracy. Compared with China. Talked about freedom, economic growth being meaningless without adequate rights etc. Corruption as the root cause for issues. Plus solution)

Lady member: What is union, sta

te and concurrent list.

LM

: Don't you think more revenue generating things are given to centre and areas where more work is needed is given to states? How can we reconcile this?

(Said that it is a balanced division. Spoke about national issues needing a concerted effort vs decentralisation, bottom up approach, etc)

LM: How can states address the finance gap?

(Spoke about gst, compensation cess and states own revenue through gst excluded products including alcohol)

LM: okay so say that states can have tax through alcohol. So on one hand you are saying alcohol is bad and then state is also selling alcohol. Isn't there a paradox?

(Spoke about democratic state respecting individual's freedom of choice and how prohibition would lead to blackmarkets and spurious liquor which will have even more detrimental impact on health. Plus need for value education, behavioural change etc)

LM: okay then what about drugs? (She was smiling and laughing in a cordial way)

(Drugs are extremely addictive, can spur violence resulting in social chaos).

CH: You said people are not happy in China. And that they have no freedom. What is the source of this information?

(Mentioned about general perception, death of Doctor who warned about covid, poor labour laws etc)

CH: What you are saying is propaganda How did china grow ? What policy in the 60s did they undertake?

( Talked about Deng Xiaping in 70s and focus on manufacturing)

CH: china grew because of land reforms that they initiated in 1950s. And their policy on education. Mao said that the rate of growth in education must be more than the rate of growth of GDP. Even to this day they follow this.

Me: I will definitely read more about it sir. I had no idea about these reforms.

CH: I take your answer. But you must learn to not take things at face value. I'm telling this because you are a teacher. One must learn to respect our enemy. But otherwise we are happy to have a humanities student. Thank you your interview is over.