Interviews

UPSC interview, P. K. Joshi board, 24 Jul 2020

24 Jul 2020

Pawanjot Kaur; Date of Interview: 24th July 2020

PK Joshi Board

6th one to go- called at around 12:30pm (Lots of patience and energy needed)

Duration-30-40 minutes

Optional: Commerce and Accountancy

Hobbies: Ashtanga Yoga, Contributing to Google Maps

The main challenge in post COVID Interviews lies in your handling of the mask-gloves-shield trio. They are all equally annoying. People with glasses face more problems as the moisture from breathing settles on your glasses and face-shield. If you are comfortable with contact lenses, kindly choose them over glasses. Also, be hydrated properly as you will sweat profusely throughout the process- thanks to this trio I mentioned. Please meditate in the days to come and focus on retaining your composure. It is the single most important thing in this round of the interview.

Chairman:

1. You are Pawanjot Kaur, right?

2. You did your graduation from SRCC, M.com from DSE, then taught in DU for around six months, why didn’t you continue in Academics and rather chose Civil Services?

3. Which subjects did you teach?

4. For how many years have you been preparing for Civil Services?

5. What is a balance sheet? I gave meaning/significance, Components- Assets, Liabilities and also talked about old and new format.

6. Does a balance sheet depict the true picture of the financial position of the firm, like you mentioned? To a large extent yes but accounting policies can cause some discrepancy

7. You offered Income Tax, right? What are the 5 heads under which income is taxed?

8. Under which head is the salary of MP and MLA charged?

Beckoned to ask M1 to take over

M1

1. You must be comfortable with trade and business, right? So tell me why are FTAs (Free Trade Agreements) not very beneficial for India?

2. What is our most important mercantile export?

3. Which countries/continent is India comfortable with, with regards to trade?

4. Major Export items?

5. Why refinery products?

6. Major import items?

7. Which of these is not a good deal for India?

8. Why is price of gold rising? He mentioned it has risen to Rs. 52,000. Is WTO system working well, as USA is warning that it will pull out of WTO?

9. He said perceptions apart, is the system totally broken etc?

Somewhere in the middle of this section, M1 noticed how foggy my specs and face shield were and asked me to remove it. Chairman intervened and asked me to clean my specs also. Was so relieved! Instantly thanked them both.

M2 (Lady member- with mask on it looked like she was frowning while I was giving answers to others, but when she started conversing, it looked like she was nice only)

Tip- Don’t be bothered about Panel Members’ expressions. They are all nice people.

1. You said in a previous answer that education sector needs reforms, what reforms would you bring?

2. Business Studies is a subject taught by CBSE in XI-XII, do you think it is a good idea?

3. There have been protests and unrest in various universities of Delhi, what are reasons?

4. What is the pain-point- I talked about college leadership not supporting demands

5. What have been the responses of college leadership?

6. Students are protesting and rioting, why shouldn’t they be stopped?

M3 (Mostly standalone questions asked in a mechanical manner, looked like he had a list of such questions already framed)

1. You have studied in SRCC, why does your institution have sky-rocketing Cut-offs?

2. Yoga is your Hobby, how many types of Yoga are there?

3. You contribute to Google Maps, how do you do that?

4. What is Urban Naxal?

5. Are we Non-aligned?

6. JNU students keep creating headlines every 15 days. We should shut the institution, there is no need for it. What do you think?

7. Who are the first women Fighter pilots of India?

8. Last and final question: Now we have GST, tell me the difference between Pre GST and Post GST scenario

While I was still expecting a volley of questions, M4 signalled Chairman that he was done and the Chairman signaled to me that my interview was over.

Tandoor

Board- RN Chaube Sir

Background- Mechanical engineering IIT MADRAS

Optional- Mechanical engineering

Hobbies- Playing and following cricket, watching Bollywood movies, teaching

Overall- Board was very cordial, especially CM gave warm welcome and said that it will be like discussion than interview and if u don't know answer you can just say no and interview was mostly on technical lines

Covid safety- allowed to lower the mask as it got foggy

CM

1) meaning of the name and what should we call you

2) How was food different in Chennai compared to North India and how did I adjust

3) Opinion about Live in relationship - counter questions like Would you go for it? Is it weakening institution of marriage? What about when a kid is born how to deal with that?

3) How do u describe yourself? Tell 2 strength and weaknesses (mostly rest of interview went on the basis of strength I told them- planning and implementation and the work I had done in the past on race cars)

Passed on to M1....

M1 (soft voice very tough to hear)

1) what parameters to take into account while designing electric vehicle? Suitable for India?

2) how to improve the aerodynamics of a car

3) Do u accept that there is problem of unemployability among engineers ( I said yes- no counter questions on why, how to reduce etc)

4) Should India go for 3 party system

5) Which khan you like most out of three khan's ? Why Salman khan last? Why amir khan at top?

Passes to M2

M2

1) What kind of fuels in the car can be used in future and issues in them? Which one will u chose in coming future eg biofuels, hydrogen etc

2) Do u know about Periyar ? (I got confused between prriyar and NTR 😆 but then I said yes after some pause) Are u sure? (Said yes)

Do u consider him as a modern reformer ? What was his idea about God ?

M3

1) So you from UP.... Would u play T20 or Test match in relationship with Nepal ? What are the issues in relationship? China factor? ( I talked about soft power here)

2) In coming future cars will be sent to scrap in 15 years when people want to use it for longer period lik 25-30 years how would you deal with such situation? How should automobile Industry handle the changing situations eg BS norms, e vehicles, new fuels etc

M4

1) What do u understand by soft power ? Who gave this term? (Told about culture, people to people connection, Project Mausam, aid without expectation eg Africa support, support during covid) then he said...there is something beyond this? (I didn't know )

2) Election commission allowing postal voting above 65 years. Why? Issues? How to solve this problem of ensuring fairness while deepening democratic participation at the same time

Passed to chair

Would u like to share or ask something that we might have missed

I shared

Thank you.. your interview is over and all the best for results

Smilna

Board - Smita Nagaraj .

Afternoon, First to go

Date- 23/07/20

Kerala State-

History optional, From Kerala.

Chairman:

Tell me what are you doing currently?

From your personal experience compare private and public sector, sub questions on corruption

M1

What is the status of industries in Kerala..?

Why there is no industrial development in kerala ..?

What are the positives and negatives of Ezhimala naval academy in kannur (Home District)

M2:

Why so many gold smuggling cases in Kerala..?

What is the solution for it..?

Is gold coming to our economy good for it..?

Tell me about India Sri Lanka relation..

What is your favourite area in history..? Why.? (Optional)

M3:

If I gave you an option for time travel which period in ancient india will you choose..? Why..?

How will you use the principles of Ashoka's Dhamma in administration.?

If you are appointed as an administrative officer in a district in Bihar, how will you promote local self government there..?

What will you do if the Sarpanch wont allow your reforms..?

M4:

Questions on the correlation between wealth and happiness and sub questions based on that

Smita ma'am again.

Are you a doer or thinker..?

Okay that's it.

Thank you. Your interview is over.

Interview Transcripts 2023 pinned Deleted message

Aniket Sachan

24 July

Board- T.C.A anant sir

Last to go.

Chairman read my DAF aloud.

CM- tell me which book you last read.

CM - what was it about? What were your key takaways?

CM- Do you agree with his conclusions. What you feel is different about India? ( Book was the billionaire raj by James Crabtree)

M1- ok, so you are from jalgaon, what are strengths of jalgaon?

M1- and what are the weaknesses?

M1- don't you feel the situation is peculiar. On one hand there is water scarcity in district. On other hand there is banana cultivation and microirrigation. Connect the dots.

M1- you also did industry defined problem. What was the problem( problem was regarding design of an EV charging infrastructure)

M1- tell me the algorithm for it.

M1- did you had fast charging accomodated in your solution.

M2 - who coined the term gilded age( from previous book)

M2- which other book you have read ( here I mentioned "the four" by Scott Galloway)

M2- what was it about? What you agree and what you disagree with

M2- why there's a problem. US has anti trust laws right?

M2- what India must do to safeguard itself against monopolies.

M2- does India has lobbying? No I am not asking if it's legal or not ? Is it there?

M3- which hindi poet lost his entire family in Spanish flu?(DAF)what's his most famous poem?

M3- what you know about chhayawad?

M3- here's a line tell me which alankar is used in it? (Couldn't answer) have you heard about anuprass alankar?

M3- you debate as well. Here is a topic, give arguments for and against the motion for 1 min each. Topic was - last 5 yr of the govt. has been a success.

M4- tell me evolution of political science over history and contributions country wise.

M4- which Indian political scientist you believe has given the most original contribution to the field. Why?

M4- differentiate between thoughts of Machiavelli and gandhiji

CM- thank you, your interview is over.

Note: I don't remember many questions. Overall ample time for speaking was given, wasn't interrupted even once. Entire interview was DAF based with few questions from contemporary thought currents due to hobby. Questions were pretty easy. Anant sir began operating mobile in between with short bursts of intent listening whenever an important point was being raised. Overall a decent experience.

Anonymous

Board: PK Joshi

Optional and graduation: Law

No questions about home state or Covid.

Chair:

1. Is this your first time in Delhi? How do you find it different from your city?

2. What is a contingent contract? How is it different from a wager?

3. Who is a finder of lost goods? Who is a bailee?

4. Holder vs holder in due course?

M1:

1. Which position do you play in football?

2. Pele or Maradona? Why?

3. Thoughts on Jose Mourinho as a coach?

4. As a lawyer, what can you bring to the civil service?

M2:

1. Natural gas pricing model in India?

2. Other petroleum products' pricing? Why aren't oil prices falling these days?

3. Private players in the downstream sector in India?

4. FCPA vs Indian bribery laws? Are you familiar with the concept of "greasing"?

M3:

1. What's the point of the ICJ? Binding vs enforceable rulings?

2. Which judge was a minister before? Name a famous judgement by him.

3. PILs are out of control. Thoughts?

M4:

1. Difference between film criticism and a review? Watershed Indian filmmakers through history?

2. "All history is gunk." Can you frame an argument against this claim?

3. What is the point of history? If it's open to reinterpretation, why even study it?

4. How should we look at Aurangzeb as a historical figure?

M3 wanted to ask another question, but the Chair looked at his watch and cut them off. He said "thank you, your interview is over."

Overall, it was an extremely polite interaction. Panel's demeanour was reassuring in the room, but unable to know for certain how they reacted/felt about one's performance.

Nandakumar N

Board - Smita Nagaraj Ma'am.

Forenoon, 5th one to go

12.35 - 1pm

24/07/2020

Malayalam optional, NSS volunteer, teaching, and following international issues as hobbies, From Kerala.

Chairman:

Tell me what are you doing currently.

(Said preparing and teaching in some coaching institutes)

Coaching means JEE coaching or ?

( Ma'am, civil service coaching)

Which all subjects you are teaching?

(Science and technology and current affairs)

How do you prepare for teaching?

(Mainly through internet. Since I have science background, sometimes I go through my old books. Also take inputs from other experienced faculties)

This coaching institutes are a multi million industry now, ...and we hear issues of unethical practices. Do you have any experience on that line?

(Ma'am, No, I never had such experiences with institutes which I was involved with. But I have heard of such unethical practices.)

What kind of unethical practices?

(Ma'am, sometimes the coaching institutes collect very high fee initially and don't deliver classes properly. And the students have to depend on other sources or other institutes. Also issues of purchasing result to get more admissions.)

Retired civil servants becoming a part of coaching - is there any issue?

(Ma'am, to an extent it is good. Because those civil servants have years of experience. And they can use it to mould young aspirants to become good civil servants of the future.)

Suppose they are in the interview board and one of their student is appearing for the interview.

Is there any conflict of interest.?

(Yes ma'am. In that case there's an issue of conflict of interest. Such cases must be avoided.)

Have you ever faced such ethical dilemmas?

(No ma'am. I don't think I have faced big ethical dilemmas like this in my life. But normaly it happens, but right now, i don't remember any specific experience.)

{Got a little nervous here, )

Like, telling your mother that you are going for tuition and you are actually planning to go for a movie.?

{Ma'am smiled and made me relaxed)

(Yes ma'am. Such dilemmas are common.)

Member 1

Okay your mother wants you to marry someone, but you have someone else in your mind, what will you do?

(Sir I think I can convince my brother..)

Ma'am intervened and asked the member, it's mother right?

( I could not hear the member properly, I thought he said brother)

Sir I think I can convince my mother easily that she will like the girl of my choice. And communication will not be an issue since I have grown up as her son.

Is there a conflict of interest? Ma'am asked.

(I said, no ma'am. I don't think so. )

She nodded and smiled. Haa, there'snt any.

Favouritism, corruption and conflict interest - what is the difference?

(I answered this with respect to an officer. Sir favouritism happens when an officer appoint his relatives or friends to a particular post. And corruption is misuse of power or position for personal gains. Conflict of interest arises when an officer's personal interest and public interest are in mismatch)

So favouritism is just about appointment of relatives /friends.

(No sir, it is the practice of showing bias towards certain group of people.)

Okay, tell me this. A Senior officer is firing an employee, on some perceived ideas. Is it right? What should be the criteria?

(Sir I don't think firing an officer without a thorough study is right. It should be based on merit. And the decision must be based on logical and rational considerations)

CM firing a minister? Is there a need for Investigation?

(Got nervous again, because I could not hear the question well, sir can you please repeat the question again?)

Sir explained it again.

(Yes sir, in that case too, a proper enquiry is important. We should hear what other side has to say)

No, no. That's not the case.

(He wanted to discuss it further. But ma'am requested the second member to start.)

Member 2.

(My confidence level gone down here, that affected my presentation)

Italian Marines- Why Marines where there, and explain the issue.

(Sir the issue is related to the s

hip called Enrica Lexie and indian fisherman got killed by italian Marines. According to the Marines, they thought the fishermen as pirates and fired. They were fishing in the contiguous zone of india.)

What zone?

(Sir contiguous zone)

What is the current verdict.

(Sir according to the verdict trail of the Marines will not come under indian jurisdiction and they will be punished under italian jurisdiction. And the affected people must be given fair compensation.)

What is Cabotage?

(Sorry sir,)

He spelled the word - C A B O T A G E!

(Sorry sir I don't know. I haven't heard about it.)

Tell me what is happening in Syria - who all are fighting? What they want?

(Sir in Syria a civil war is happening, which has turned into a war of global dimensions because of multiple foreign players. Bashar al assad regime is fighting rebels to continue his authoritarian regime. Rebels want freedom. And Kurds are fighting for an independent land called Kurdistan. ISIS, that is islamic state, with neglible presence now want to create an islamic state. Each side is supported by foreign powers)

{Wanted to explain it further. But time was running out. So next member started with his set of questions}

{This member was not very satisfied with my answers. And I was under pressure.}

Member 3:

What you mean by Pleasure of the president?

{It was actually a follow up of M1's question - CM firing a minister}

( Sir, the president is bound to act on the aid and advice of the cabinet, and president should take decisiona according to it. Even in the case of removal of a minister)

So do we need an investigation?

(Sir before giving advice to governor, the cabinet should do thorough investigation, not the governor. Governor is bound to act as per the advice)

{ Kind of realized and accepted that technically I was wrong about my earlier answer.Again got a little nervous, took a breath to stay calm}

What India can do in italian marine case?

(Sir we can closely watch and ensure that the Marines will get maximum punishment under the italian law, through the mission we have in Italy. And also we can make sure that the affected people will get fair compensation from italian side. Also we can work to prevent such incidents in the future.)

China is not accepting any verdicts, why can't we do the same?

(Sir we are a responsible democratic country which respects international laws and regulations.We follow the rules in which we are a signatory.)

Member 4:

{I was comfortable with this member }

What did you do as NSS volunteer.

(Sir I used to go and teach underprivileged student who were staying at Gandhi ashram once in a week. Also we took care of cleanliness in campus area. We maintained waste bins for that. We used to conduct blood donation camps. And we had our own NSS fest. Sir, these were the main activities)

History section history is your favourite?

(Answered ancient history)

Okay, tell me What lesson can we learn from modern indian history?

{It was surprise question, I was expecting something from ancient history, so took few seconds and came up with a not so structured answer}

( Sir when the Britishers, umm. When the foreigners came we were divided.. I mean we had a fragmented polity. And that weakened us and helped them to colonize india. Now as a country with diverse culture and social values we should be united.This will increase our strength. Sir we should learn this lesson from modern history)

Communal violence, what is core reason issue?

{Again unexpected, but related to my answer}

(Sir I think we don't properly understand about our religion and beliefs. Also we don't try to know about other's beliefs and religion. This creates intolerance in society. I think that's the core reason)

So you are saying we need to understand our beliefs system and that of others?

(Yes sir. Then we can have communal harmony.)

Indo bangladesh relations,? And china factor.

(Sir we had good relations since the independence of bangladesh, also we played a role in it. Bangladesh is a part of our neighborhood first policy. We have many

development projects there. Like the Rooppur nuclear power plant we are developing jointly with russia. china is acting aggressively in our neighborhood. Recently they exempted about 97% goods from bangladesh and trying for more engagements. It's a matter of concern. But we could tackle this issue.)

Is our domestic issues affecting foreign relations?

(Sir, domestic issues should not affect our relationship with others. Even if domestic issues are affecting our foreign policy with other country we can sort it out. We have that diplomatic strength to separate such issues.

Smita ma'am again.

What strength?

(Ma'am diplomatic strength)

What if I say the net gainer in ongoing india china conflict is third country?

(No ma'am we can be a gainer too. We work according to our aspirations and interests. We have our strategic autonomy and we are a major power.)

Okay tell me what makes us a major power, we are not the largest economy.

(I said we have the numbers, population.)

So you are saying a problem we face in the country can be an asset internationally?

(Yes ma'am we have the demographic

Dividend, and great potential.)

What is that one thing others are looking for?

(Market - said we are the largest market.)

So they want us to consume?

(Yes ma'am they want us to consume. But we wish to produce more and we want orhers to consume our products.)

So you are saying we have all the potential?

(Yes ma'am, we can be a manufacturing hub, also our economy is booming!!!

Made a huge blunder here. It was an accident. )

Ma'am laughed, asked really? I was trying to conclude and you are throwing options for more questions haa?

(Sorry ma'am it was a mistake. Our economy is not booming currently, I meant it was growing. we have all the potential to be major power.)

Okay that's it. Ma'am smiled.

Thank you. Your interview is over.

Thanked all members and left the room.

It was a good experience. Very cordial board.

Seeker

Board- Manoj Soni

Date.. 22/07/2020

State- Bihar

Optional-geography

Works at IMD

Afternoon

Chairman- you play flute. Did u have training for it? Do u play classical ragas?

Is IMD doing it's job at par compared to other countries forecasts? (Job related)

M1- u have studied from CBSE.. Tell me 2 things that we are doing good fit education? Two things that we are doing wrong in education? Two things that we can do to improve it?

Ok now tell me two things we did right during lockdown to fight with covid? Two things we could have dinner better to manage during lockdown?

What is integrated agriculture farming?

M2- tell me famous temples in Gaya (daf)..Why is Gaya famous for?

How can cricket be played in present circumstances? (Grilled here)

M3- How is IMD useful? What is it doing for agricultural insurance? What are the schemes for agricultural insurance? Objectives of JNV (DAF)? Has it been successful in reaching those objectives? How can it improve?

M4- have you heard about ancient silk route? Somewhere I read that it also passed through patna-prayagraj-delhi-amritsar belt.. Do u think it's correct? Ok how do we conclude that it existed here.. What are the evidences we see?

Have u heard about cryosphere? If polar bear goes extinct, how will it affect people in distant lands as in India? What are zoonotic diseases? Any correlation between climate change and zoonotic diseases? Can covid be called an example of climate change induced virus... Just only an opinion on it.... Your opinion May differ?

Chairman- thank you. Your interview is over

(Mask and Sheild created lots of frustration.. Once the chairman even told to correct the mask as it was coming down while talking.. Difficult to understandt board members expressions as only their eyes are visible)