Interviews

UPSC interview, P. K. Joshi board, 23 Jul 2020 (Delhi)

23 Jul 2020

Date - 23rd July’20.

PK Joshi Board - 1st to Go

Name - Jayant Nahata

BTech, MTech in Biochem Engg and Biotech from IIT Delhi

PSIR

Hobbies - Reading Self help books, Vipassana Meditation, Journaling.

Award - Smokeless Cookstove project etc

Chair Person (Reading out some details and confirming)

So, what are you doing after graduation?

A - Sir, graduated in 2018 and after that preparing for civil services.

CP - Diff b/w Biotechnology and Biochemistry.

Ans - Told (first talked of Biotech vs Biochemical Engg but corrected midway for Biochemicals.

CP - So you are from Delhi. Which all places have you visited in Delhi?

Ans - Sir, Qutb Minar, Humayun’s Tomb, Akshardham Temple, India Gate

CP - What is significance of India Gate?

Ans - Told about British Indian soldiers martyred in WW1 like war of Gallipoli etc

CP- There’s another project nearby?

Ans - Yes, sir, National War Memorial

CP - What is that for?

Ans - Sir, it commemorates soldiers martyred in wars after Independence like 1965 war, 1962 war, Kargil war etc

CP - Why we see inflation in fruits/vegetables and not so much in cereals.

Ans - Because they are perishables and farmers are forced to sell early in APMCs.

CP - What to do about it?

A - Go for Food processing, contract farming with private players - we have passed a new ordinance for that and another to dilute hold of APMCs. Mega Food Parks Scheme and cluster based approach for processing.

M1 (male)- Tell about relations of China and Russia

A - Started from cold war times, talked of differences b/w Mao and Lenin (it is Nikita Khrushchev!), and since end of cold war relations good and because of Western pressure, both cultivated tactical partnership.

M1 - Any issues b/w the two?

A - Growing influence of China in Russia’s underbelly of Central Asian Countries + territorial claims by China like China claims Vladivostok etc (He nodded/agreed)

M1 - Asked about Non alignment and whether we still follow it?

A - Told about cold war concept etc and now new avatar of Strategic autonomy and multiple alignments. Quoted Hon’ble External Minister’s statement that we are only aligned to our own national interests. Gave examples of Russia relations despite CAATSA threats and supporting Palestine and its 2 state solution despite strategic partnership with Israel.

M2 (male - calm and pleasing looks) - We have 57 ministries and US has 14 etc. Why?

A - We have been following Min Govt and Max Governance. But due to specialisation in certain fields we have multiple ministries. And there is a recognition in govt to reduce further and we are doing that.

M2 - So which all ministries can we merge?

A - Sir, for long term energy security, we need to merge Min of Coal and Min of New and Renewable Power. (M3 will pick this energy security topic further!)

M2 - What about transport - we have Min of Shipping, Highways etc

A - Sir, yes. But, currently same minister heads Min of Highways and areas like Inland Waterways etc. But yes, we can definitely merge those.

M2- What is spiritual quotient?

A - Talked of connecting deeply beyond just our flesh and body. Having values.

M2 - So you read self help books! Who’s your fav author and why?

A - James clear wrote Atomic Habits. Practical insights to build good habits. Told few tips when he asked..

M2 - So Stephen R Covey has wrote 7 habits of highly effective people. What are those 7 habits?

A - Listed 4 and then said not able to recall more.

M2 - You won this award. Tell me about the smokeless stove and how it works.

A - Told about air draft mechanism, double top and a chimney - all resulting in less Indoor Air Pollution

M2 - Do you know fracking?

A - Sir, I have heard it in context of Shale Gas. To extract shale gas trapped in rock.

M2 - Asked on shale oil and where are reserves in India.

A - Talked of ONGC recent discovery in West Bengal of Rs 50,000 cr + KG Basin + Gujarat.

M2 - What about North East?

A - Sir, in Assam, yes.

M3 (male - He was interrupting a lot/not letting me finish (I guess as part of pressure tactics) and taking topics to a tangent from things I spoke +

seemed harsh)

M3 - What is energy security? how is our energy security? What are we doing for that.

A - Told of 85% oil dependance and how vulnerable like Iran geo-politics

Some counter questions on whether it makes us insecure or no. He said we will buy from someone else, what’s the issue then. (I held my ground) I said yes we can, but Iranian oil is cheap, oil quality good and 60 day credit period etc. Then asked on quality of oils, sweet oil etc - I said Texas oil..and said I don't know sir. Then he moved to other question.

M3 - Which is the country that is saying visit us before we drown?

A - Sir, I can’t recall.

Just when he was shifting the baton to M4, I said, sir Mauritius?

M3 - He smiled broadly along with M4 and said its Maldives, but yes, very close!

M4 (Lady Member) - Asked on More Crop, Per drop phrase. What is it? What are we doing for it?

A - Talked of shift to water productivity from land productivity. We are implementing PM Krishi Sinchayee Yojana, Har Khet ko Jal, Micro irrigation and partnership with Israel etc

M4- What are the technologies for saving water in agri?

A - Rain water harvesting, Drip irrigation, Drones for sensing soil/water, ISRO’s Bhuvan Satellite to map groundwater etc

M4 - What we are doing to climate proof agriculture?

A - Talked of drought and flood resilient varieties from prestigious IARI, National Mission on Sustainable Agriculture under National Action Plan on Climate Change + agro climatic planning.

M4 - Asked me schemes/govt steps for rural women?

A - Told about Ujjawala Yojana, Rural Livelihood Mission, SBA. On asking more, PM MVVY, ICDS, Beti Bachao Beti Padhao.

In between she confirmed about Beti Bachao Beti Padhao and Livelihood Mission.

A - Told of awareness, saving accounts etc in BBBP and of SHGs in Livelihood Mission

M4 - What is empowerment (I assumed asking in context of women)?

A - Empowerment means expanding the choice/freedom and capability for women- it has social, political, economic dimension.

M4 - So you know all about schemes! Tell me whether these schemes are actually empowering women.

A - (Being all positive and somewhat ) and Yes, definitely. Talked of how Ujjawal helped remove 8 crore women's drudgery to fetch firewood removed due to , toilets for women etc.

M4 - Its good they get LPG but do you think women have freedom enough to say that we wont cook.?

A - (Tried to be all positive and gave personal touch) Ma’am, these are long held social traditions. But gender parity is coming in terms of sharing household responsibilities. We see it in urban and peri urban areas and slowly in rural areas also mindsets are changing. My own personal experience of smokeless stoves project where I saw when women got financial empowerment, they earned respect from husband. And when these women went for project even outside the state, the males were ready to pitch in for their household work.

M4 - Nodded in agreement (as it seemed!) and looked towards CP.

CP - Okay, thank you.

I thanked CP and other members and left.

Overall

Was a good experience. Almost NIL questions on my graduation subject or current affairs/corona. Mostly on the DAF, optional and generic stuff. Didn’t have much issues in Mask and Shield since I was first to go, although for few seconds it becomes foggy. Happy that some luck helped in questions, answers to which I had randomly encountered - like Vladivostok example (in a youtube video), Shale in West Bengal, India Gate (from previous transcript - Thanks to this group!). Tried to back my answers with data, schemes and used key words (not jargons) from my field/hobbies/optional and maintained optimism.

Good Luck to other candidates! Rock it.

Pk Joshi sir Board

Afternoon session -2nd one to go

Optional -Anthropology

Hobbies- Cooking and Dancing

Graduation-BDS

Gurugram,Haryana

Female

Chairman

1.Have u ever visited Nashik (as birthplace was that)

2.What gurgaon famous for ?

3.If you are made Dm of gurgaon in which areas will you work ?

4.Why IAS after Bds ..when did u decide to prepare for civil service

5.India is called as rich country with poor people..why ?

Member 1

1.Who was first female doctor of india and of world ?

2.what is proton therapy?

3. What is PPP and example

4.what is carbon tax ?

Member 2

1. is flossing good for teeth or bad..what is your view?

Any alternative of flossing

2.In what areas Haryana economy is good.

3.Amazon investing in Reliance retail..Is it good or bad ?

4.what are blood diamonds ?

Member 3 (lady )

1.what is fast food ?

Difference between fast food and junk food .

2.what cooking oil is good for consumption

3.Are we importer of oil or exporter.How much oil do we import and why

4.If u are asked to plan mid day meal ..what items u would include in the meal

5.Do radio have any use today..when we have smartphones ..tv..and other gadgets

How can radio serve useful and in what areas ?

Member4

1.Difference between Sagarmala and Bharatmala.

2.Difference between Blue economy and Green economy.

3.Name some tribes which stays in isolation..should we develop them or leave them alone and how ?

4.First female dancer of india and of world

5.Tell me about lipulekh

Chairman: Ok u may leave now !

Mandar Patki

Date - 24th July (afternoon)

Board- P K Joshi Sir

Graduation - Mechanical Engineering (2018)

Optional - Anthropology

DAF - Electoral officer, Police Mitra, Journaling Hobby, Visiting Gram Sabha

Chairman

1. You are from Beed, you completed your graduation in Pune university. What is full name of Pune university?

2. Contributions of Savitribai Phule?

3. Books written by Jyotirao phule?

4. Difference between Mechanical and Production Engineering?

5. Technical mechanical terms- CPT, CRT (no idea)

6. Difference between Petrol and Diesel Engine?

7. What is Kyoto Protocol?

8. What is UNFCCC?

Member 1-

1. You are a mechanical Engineer, but have anthropology as a optional. Why so?

2. Why Covid is doing such a Havoc? What is impact on society?

3. Do u think india successfully handled Covid crisis?

4. Coming to anthropology, why we should isolate the tribes who are distant in their culture, why should we not integrate them?

Member 2-

1. Define Artificial Intelligence to a layman.

2. On one hand we are having demographic dividend, on other hand we are adopting AI. Isnt it paradox? What should we do to benefit from AI?

3. Do you know the name of aircraft which is using solar energy and circumventing the earth.

4. What is Carbon Tax? Does india have carbon tax?

Member 3- inaudible

1. You were electoral officer in college. Tell me, what government needs to do to increase people's trust in electoral process and what steps should we take. Tell me in points like 1, 2, 3

2. How to encourage people to come to vote, what steps are required?

3. Analyzing past 10 years record, do you think election commission has been impartial in its role? What is your opinion

4. You know water table is going down. Ground water is decreasing. What steps are required to improve water table?

5. You are from Maharashtra. Tell me how Saint Tukaram reformed society? What is his contribution?

Member 4- lady member

1. You have done your diploma in mechanical engineering. Then you have done your BTech in mechanical. Why didn't join job after diploma?

2. So you are not accommodating your sisters advice also as you are leaving mechanical for civil services. (based on my previous response)

3. Don't you think this is exact reason why skill india is failing, because youth like you are not joining jobs.

4. Tell me some reforms required in skill india mission.

5. You know India is demanding reform in UNSC. Why India is demanding a permanent seat in UNSC?

6. What are the obstacles to get a permanent seat in UNSC?

Chairman - Ok. Interview is over.