Interviews

UPSC interview, R. N. Choubey board, 24 Jul 2020

24 Jul 2020

Shivaraj saybanna managiri

Rajiv Nayan Choubey sir board

24 July morning session first one to go.

Details : IFS > IAS > IPS

Post graduation in construction technology and management

Hobby : jogging

Achievement : captain of university hockey team.

Current : IRTS 2017 batch probationer

CM :

( Read out my complete name and said, is it okay if we call you Shivaraj ? He made me comfortable by asking me to lower the mask to neck level and said that we panel members are interested in having a good conversation and like honesty. If you don’t know something, let us know and we will move to next question. Hope you have had breakfast shivaraj.)

Shivaraj, tell us briefly about your educational background

Okay so you’re already in railways, it means you will only be going up !

Shiavarj, tribals face a problem of being sidelined, difficulty of mainstreaming on one hand and maintenance of rich culture on the other hand. How do you think we should go ahead here ? ( I spoke of tribal Panchsheel and fine balancing in phased manner )

We have decided to double farmers income by 2022. Am not asking about how it can be done but Do you think its feasible ?

What is the rate required for doubling farmers income if he deposits in the bank ?

Now do you think its feasible ?

( Chairman nodded and smiled. Asked next member to take over )

M1 :

India is aspiring to be 5 trillion dollar economy. How do you think railways is supporting this ? What are the initiatives in this regard

What do you understand by citizens charter ?

What Is SCRA ?

Where is it ?

What is its current status ?

Do you think it was good move to remove it ?

Yes, we should’ve retained it and built more these lines and extended to other sectors like telecom too !

M2 :

can you name 5 women who are heading top positions around the world ?

It is reported that countries headed by women have performed better in tackling COVID ? Do you agree and what is the reason behind this ?

Tell us about india Myanmar relations

Do you think Myanmar is tilting towards china or india ?

M3 :

You have completed your education from Mangalore, surathkal right. Can you tell me why this region is the hub for education and banking ?

( I was not sure about the answer and said the same but tried to give a broad picture with members permission )

Okay if that is the case, just for the sake of discussion and not to counter your point of view, don’t you think entire coastal region should have excelled by that logic ?

( he asked me if I agree with him, I said yes and named few prominent institutions and banks in the region and I asked him I can make a guess. He said lets drop it )

What do you think are the key ingredients for E-delivery of services by government ?

What do you mean by digital infrastructure ? - key components ?

Okay shivaraj, majority of Karnataka is drought prone or faces water scarcity problems, if you are the made the administrator, what 3 measures will you take to solve the issue ?

M4 :

Lets talk a little bit more about Karnataka. Mutts/ sanghs broadly part of CSO are providing education but are also seeking tax benefits. Do you think it is right ?

Mutts also are engaged in politics. Should this be accepted ?

Shivaraj, Sri Lanka is a small island country, do you think big country like India should have relations with it ? What is there for India ? How should we go about in this aspect of maintaining relations ?

We are investing so much in High speed rail when we have other areas for development. We already have Vande Bharat running at great speeds, why do we need HSR ? Do you think it should be continued ?

HSR only connects areas between Ahmedabad and Mumbai ? Will it help ?

CM :

Okay shivaraj it was good talking to you. Your interview is over. Is there anything you feel we should have asked or anything you want to tell us ?

( I said sir, I have been the captain of university hockey team and am aspiring to be an Indian foreign service officer )

Oh Indian foreign service ?

Okay good. Best of luck

( I thanked everyone, got up and wore the mask properly and came back with a smile ! )

IIT KGP, IIM A

Workex - IT (1 year) abc Bank (1 y), ongoing (2year, presntly working)

Hobby - Value investing, paper folding, swimming, choreography

Optional - Management

Panel - TCA Anant sir. 23rd July, morning

Timing 35 minutes

Chair - Read my educational and job journey completely.

Asked whether students be disciplined or left alone to study.

Asked whether they done were wrong in their time?

Difference between organization and different roles post mba.

What is the role of CFO.

L1 - aked what happened recently in the xyz bank.

What would you say if 'T' is removed from 'management'.

Why do you paper fold.

Have you watched money heist? Said no, He told about the protagonist also folded paper.

L2 - what is value investing?

When will it find its values.

Objective parameters used to invest.

It's Difference from growth investing.

What knowledge is required.

Example of Einstein, buffet discussed.

What is long term/short term?

Discussed on the time horizon of investing.

What is denoted by share price - company/ sentiments

* Discussions went deeper on multiple nuances, examples of good companies like royal Enfield, Page industries

R1 - Types of mutual funds

Tax implication?

LTCG, comparison with normal income tax slabs.

What is LTCG, STCG, Intraday.

What is equity mutual fund.

Percentage of equity exposure in same - told that unaware

Reit ( answered completely wrong after telling that I didn't know it completely)

Mention Debt instrument with sovereign backing. (Told not sure but guessed it would be PF).

Went deeper into debt mutual fund( told didnt know as no exposure)

Why IIM A do not give out degrees?

R2 - discussed what is choreography

What was the play i had participated. No follow-up questions.

Asked some choreographers. Asked about saroj khan, her works ( told didnt know).He pointed out you should have known.

Whats is hongkong issue. History of same. How and what was china response and approach.

He asked history of student movement in Hong Kong. Reason for it. (Guessed it was Tianman square).

He further asked about the details . In failed attempt I told that I don't know and is compared with jaliawalah bagh)

Chair - interview is over you may go now.

No question on current affairs( except hongkong), home state (jharkhand), undergrad, swimming, HR question why how etc

Overall investing took more than half of the time. Panel members were watching closely and were Interested and and went very deep in investing. Asked some very sharp and pinpointed questions.

Panel members are seated very far. So seeing all of them is difficult while answering.

Native: Guntur, Andhra Pradesh

Qualification: M.Tech (Computer Science & Engineering) - IIT Bombay

Hobbies: Writing emails to editors, authors and government functionaries; Collecting interesting song lyrics and dialogues from Telugu movies

Board: Dr. Manoj Soni

Date: 24-07-2020

Time: 20-25 minutes (last to go before lunch)

Chairman:

1) Your name is xyz Both parts refer to Lord Krishna. Then why do you have two parts in your name?

2) How do you want to be remembered in your life? What is your goal in life?

3) Haven't you made any positive impact on others' life till now? Give examples (flowing from previous answer)

Member 1:

1) On what topics do you write emails?

2) Give an example of what you wrote about and the result

3) Do you know RTI? Have you ever used it? For what reasons? Did you get the reply?

4) You have a good academic record. Now why are you changing stream?

5) How can engineering institutions ensure that engineers remain in engineering? It is a lot of brain drain. What do you suggest?

Member 2:

1) What is your view on cryptocurrency? Should it be allowed or banned? Why?

2) Under which law the cryptocurrency can be banned?

3) How do you think 2021 will be? What impact 2020 will have on 2021?

Chairman (intervenes):

. Please remove your shield and mask - I need to crosscheck

. You must wear the mask now but wearing the shield is your choice.

Member 3:

1) What is Guntur famous for?

2) Tell me top-4 states in terms of GDP. Make a guess

3) Now tell me top-4 states in terms of per capita income.

4) Among Sikkim, Delhi and Goa - what do you think is the order in per capita income?

5) There is one public institution doing exceedingly well without reservations. What is that?

6) Why is there no reservation in armed forces, when it is there in civil services? Doesn't efficiency matter in civil services?

Member 4:

1) What is your view on granting permanent commission to women in army?

2) Why do you think it took 70 years to achieve that?

3) Which other country has gender parity in armed forces?

What is the status in US?

4) Guntur is famous for food. Is it still famous? What food items is it known for?

5) Tell me a traditional martial art from Andhra Pradesh

6) Is it popular now? Why not (as many martial art training institutes are coming up over time)?

7) What can be done to revive it? What can you do as an individual?

Chairman:

Thank you. All the best.

Analysis: Very casual. Nothing much from current affairs or educational background.

Aditya

Date 21/2/2020

Background :civil engineering

Optional - sociology

Hobbies-cricket and football

Home state -Delhi

Board -Bs bassi sir

Chairman

1. Is it your photo,- cant see clearly said yes, but it wasnt me, again showed me, i said no sir. He smiled and talked in hindi

2. Why you want to become Ias. Sir joked in between gundagardi to nhi karni.. everyone laughed

3. Why you didnt joined any company? your academic background is good.

4. Why not open a company?

M2

1. 27 october 1947 what happened?

2. Tell me something about 1947-48 war.

3 when un convention was signed

4.. Some civil engineering marvel that inspired you.

.

M3

1. Contributions of mn srinivas

2. Delhi is called rape capital, what we need to do.

3. Interstate migration is a issue.

4. Question on mgnrega

5. Gates of Delhi.

M 4

1. Difference between plebiscite and referendum. Follow up question on this?

2 indian economy and issues with it.(speak 2 minutes)

M5

1. Prefabricated structure

2. Grade of cement.

3. 5 cement company's name.

4 How to do rain water harvesting in village. Follow up question on this.

Chairman again

Tell some other building. I mentioned qutub minar etc.

How arches are bind

answered.

Wanted some specific name.

Replied - i would definitely read this sir.thanks sir.

Showed me photo again and smiled.

Overall a good experience.

Logan Paul

Board : TCA Ananth

Optional: PSIR

State : MP

First Attempt

Hobbies : Following international current affairs , cricket, dairy writing

Chairman:: Read my daf aloud.

Background of what's happening in Hong Kong. Few cross questions.

M1:

Effect of climate change on health?? Cross questions.

How coarse grain production is impacted by climate change??(chairman interrupted and asked me to clarify my point)

M2:

Machiavelli's main theory??

His book , his theory??

Are we following Machiavelli or gandhi??

Whom should we follow??

Are means really important ?? Should not we focus just on ends??

M3 :

What are the reasons behind china us cold war??

Are we truly a democracy??

Criminalisation of politics ?? Way forward??

Why charge sheeted should be baarred?? Isnt it against rule of law??

Won't it lead to ruling party charegesheeting every opposition leader and win all elections??

Why Panchayat raj not successful??

Sarpanch pati??

M4:

Magna carta??its importance?? Why was it introduced??

Trace evolution of British constitution??

What was Glorious revolution??

Books of r k Narayan?? (Daf)

His book made into a movie??

Famous books of Jane Austen?? (Daf)

Role of Gwalior in Freedom struggle?? Important personalities involved??

Why 1857 revolt failed??

Chairman: Your interview is over. You can leave.

Was a bit difficult to hear what they are asking due to masks??

Had to readjust mask many times but manageable . Was not asked to remove mask/shield.

Interviews don't go as smooth as seen in transcripts due to cross questions and interruptions .( personal opinion)

Overall based on daf and optional

Chaubey sir board

24-07, morning, second to go

Btech - electrical, iitk

2 year job experience - samsung and juniper networks

Psir

Hobbies- ml techniques, contemporary dance

No questions from electrical, ir or hobbies

Mainly social, culture, higher education, tech

Do you know about mask controversy?

*Told him basic idea and then he explained

Did you come by uber? What have they done to avoid infection?

Tell about your background academuc and professional

Something must have appealed to you in psir. Why did you choose it after btech?

Which thinker appealed to you most?

Relevance of marx?

Members:

Lockdown or no lockdown. Which one is better? *Compared west vs india

But in scandinavian, it was better. What would you say?

What is gotra?

Bioinfirmatics?

Foreign colleges opening up in india. Your views.

But if iits open in villages, would it have great outcomes?

What is wifi? Maximum data that can be transferred what is the limit? *not sure what it meant, said not throughput but volume of data

Khap panchayat should be banned ? Your views

Buddhism- how many types? *Not sure why this came up

Why so many types?

Name any two children famous today?

What would be your advice to greta if you were her elder brother?

Like dosa in south what is famous in north india? *Said poha

No , something made similarly like dosa? How is it made? *cooking not my hobby, neither mentioned it anywhere

Sexual harassment at workplace- should it be reduced or eliminated?

How to prevent sexual harassment at workplace? *Said - internal committee, awareness and stern action

Would these really help?

You are dm. Politician doesnt like your acts and buys media persons and newspapers start false reporting against you. What would you do?

Subsidies - should they be banned?

What should be done to make them effective?

One sector where you think subsidy should be banned?

What is smart payments and smart contracts?

M2m communication in governance?

Iit have brand value. Is it justified?

I am from manipal, and satya nadella is doing great. Do you think we should focus on others?

Iitians go abroad and leave their parents behind and parents suffer. How that can be controlled?

*Mentioned mawopasc act

Old age homes, is it a solution we should go ahead with?

R.N. Choubey sir's board

23/07

Forenoon, second to go

Work ex- Telecom and State police

Face shield and gloves compulsory, sir allowed to take down the mask.

C.M. sir:

Started with brief instructions to make me comfortable and asked me to remain honest while answering.

Is it ok to bluff or not according to you?

Brief Intro?

Do you believe in God? Give me one logical reason to justify your belief in God.

You have held 2 significant posts, give me one learning which you find important from both the jobs.

What is the difference between morality and spirituality?

M1:

Continued from CM sir's question that you said earlier one should not bluff but there are incidents from Mahabharata where they resorted to lie(he mentioned about the ashwatthama incident where yudhishthir lied), is it justified?

Certain follow up questions based on this.

If you are made the incharge of reforms with power of making any changes, what are the 3 reforms in police you will bring to reduce corruption?

More police persons will lead to more corruption, is it?

In your belief, 3 things since independence which should be proud of?

M2:

Cyber security- what can we do to improve it?

What do you mean by financial inclusion? What can we do about it?

JAM Trinity- What is it?

India has experienced many secessionist movements, mention any3 separatist movement?

M3:

Questions related to my current work in police and police training?

Should we abolish the ips and people from the state services should become the head of state police force?

Follow up questions.

Can Bhopal become the next silicon valley?

Should we organize Olympics in India?

Is it prudent?

M4:

Having anthropology optional, What do you mean by Folklore?

Mention 3 folklores of your town.

Kashmiri pandit rehabilitation-what measures are required?

Amarnath yatra stopped- good or bad? Way ahead?

Reservation in promotion, Should or shouldn't it be there?

Till when shall it continue?

Promotion should be merit based or not?

Chairman sir concluded the interview with best wishes.