UPSC interview, Manoj Soni board, 9 Mar 2018
9 Mar 2018
Girish Badole
Interview date - 9th March
Dr Manoj Soni board
PSIR optional, Medical background
Hobbies - football,chess, documentary
Last to go(morning session) 35 Min
Ch - Lengthy question but basically why civil services when country needs more doctors.
Ch - what is farmers march from Nashik about And their demands
Ans- told about long march and demands
Ch- Didn't MH gave loan waiver last year?
Ans-explained about problems in implementation
Ch- Marches may turn violent, as a officer, what steps will you take?
Ans- Recent NDMA guidelines on crowd management,maintain law and order, adequate security personnel,curb provoking speeches, traffic management,etc
M1 -who Osmanabad named after
M1 - should health be private or public?
Ans- told both are complementary in Indian situation and gave reasons citing NHP2017, strategic purchasing,etc
M1- Is Ayurveda science or quackery?
Ans- said science and cited charaka, doctrine of Ayurveda
M1- Will you use Ayurveda in treatment?
Ans- said many ayurvedic preparations are prescribed today by allopathic doctors. Gave examples
M1- what are issues AYUSH face?
Ans- R&D, quality standards of drugs, Inadequacy in 2&3 health sector,seen inferior to western medicine,
M1- what is trickle down theory?
M1- Should railway be privatised?
Ans- said No, gave many reasons-like improving management, safety,4 lac cr given in budget, positive Social externality, mentioned railway issue in UK, Poor's transport, Hinterland connectivity, Roads sector still lag.
M1(Picking points from my answer)- why invest 4 lac cr, Is it good prioritisation
M1- what social externality Railway has that you were saying?
M2-So you worked in ONGC,
How many months?
M2-Any life saving experience as doctor
M2-How much is distance between platforms and From coast? Can we explore beyond current locations?
Ans- told EEZ limit etc
M2- What is Security system to protect platforms?
M2- What are other threats from coast ?
Ans- Terrorism 26/11,trafficking in arms,drugs, FICN,etc
M2- What coastal Security measures taken post 26/11?
Ans: mentioned CSS scheme, More funds, interceptor,OPV boats,Marine police, modernisation of Coast guard, proposed CMPF
M2- Anything related to detection of threats?
Ans- GPS on boats to track, NC3I for intelligence,
M2- he asked about AIS,radar systems onboard?
Ans- didn't know.
M3(Lady Member)-
M3- what is CSR( I'd mentioned in trickle down theory question)?
Ans- sec 135, 2% and evolution of idea from philanthropy, Trusteeship etc
M3- what is CSR criteria?are all company covered?
Ans-explained turnover,net worth, profit criteria
M3- Lengthy question on Companies using CSR for profit ,Do you agree or not?
M3- What is scientific social responsibility?
Ans- explained PM comment in ISC Tirupati, and scientists helping Society,Poor, rural population?
M3- more specific point which PM mentioned
M3 -said not recollect.
M4- You mentioned GPS, what's longform,which Country own it?
M4- Do we have anything similar?
Ans- told NAVIC
M4- explain about it
Ans- mentioned 7satellite, range, accuracy, types of usage(for defence, for others), Recent malfunction of atomic clocks etc
M4- So we need NAVIC sensor?
Ans- (I had mentioned need of NAVIC sensor in mobiles like GPS sensor)told ISRO,DoT are working on it.Then our citizens will start taking benefits of NAVIC
M4- What is GSO,GTO orbits?
M4 -about MH agrarian distress. Reasons?
Ans- explained all factors, water scarcity, Irrigation, high Input costs, indebtedness,Price fluctuations, Fragmented land holding, etc
M4 - What are provisions in budget for this?
Ans- told MSP related, 11 lac cr credit
M4 - what area budget focus?
Ans- Post harvest issues is more focus with MSP,20000 GrAM, Operation Green, FPO, Agro processing,agroExport,agri logistics
M4- What is Operation Green and how will it help farmers?
Ans- explained
M4- Anything about increasing farmer income? About E-NAM.Whats eNam
Ans- said scheme was started last year, this budget aims to coverage will be increased from nearly 300 to 550 mandis
Ans- asked about health insurance scheme given in budget?
Ans- Expl
ained NHPS.
Ch- Thank you, your interview is over. All the best.
Haaris Rasheed
Mbbs MS (orthopedics)
Sujata ma’am board
Forenoon session 9th march
2nd to go.
Ch- So , tell us something about yourself.
A- blabber plus reading about new advances in orthopedic surgery.
Counter- so recent advances and civil services, arent these opposites.?
M1- why is rural healthcare in shambles.
What are your views about karnataka flag
M2- south china sea, india pakistan, india china relation (regular general gibberish)
M3- recent advances in joint relacement surgery.
A- related to technique, and related to implant (mentioned both)
M3- corporate hospitals, hidden cut from implants, pharma-doctor nexus.
M3- do doctors lack empathy.
Q- what should be done.
Q- why are govt hospitals unhygienic.?
M4- medical tourism, advantages, is it an industry. What will general public get from this advancement. (Handled just okay.. not much satisfied)
Ch- something that you prepared and would like to tell us..
A- thought for 3 secs.. said no ma’am.. (had a flight of thoughts, hence decided to bail out and get out)
2 more ques by members
Q- do doctors and civil servants share mutual respect.
Q- views about living will.
Thank you.
Transcript
B.Tech IT
MA, JRF and NET in Pol Sci.
Beed (MH)
Board : Smt. Smita Nagraj
Date : 08/03/2018
Morning Session
5th to go.
Chairperson :
1. Why MA in Pol Sci?
2. Was pol sci helpful in broadening your perspective about the things around?
3. Explain political mobilsation in the context of Maharashtra or India.
4. Who was the leader of the India's first (farmer's) rasta roko that you mentioned?
4. What impact mobilisation had on Indian politics?
Member 1 (other lady member) :
1. What are the ways to secure the interests of groups in the democracy? What are the ways of power manipulation in a democracy?
2. You are DM of Beed and there is mob of protesting farmers that is becoming violent. What will you do?
3. What should be overall approach to India-China relations?
4. What is Doklam issue?
Member 2 :
1. Why India has politics based on identities?
2. Is identity politics good or bad for the democracy of India?
3. Difference between diversity of India and diversity of USA
4. Sense of nationalism vs different identities?
Member 3 :
1. Who was the US President who gave the slogan "It's the economy, stupid!"?
2. Can economics determine politics? Explain in the context of Trump and BREXIT.
Member 4 :
1. You are SP of Beed, the mob is becoming violent, what steps are there in riot drill manual book to control the mob? (Crowd mgmt - DAF related).
2. What is Saubhagya scheme?
3. I was on the trip from Shirdi to Hyderabad. During journey I saw dense tree cover in the Beed, but now the forest cover is degrading, what are the reasons of degradation?
4. How will you explain the concept of money laundering to a common man?
Chairperson again :
1. There are negatives of black money, but can you think of any positives of black money?
2. Is cash always a black money?
Thank you.
I said "Happy women's day!" Both the ladies smiled and wished back.
No questions on hobbies, specific current affairs and graduation background.
Dear friends. All and each whose interview is over here are requested to take little pain and write one's transcript and share with us. All interviews are unique. Please come out of your hides and share. We have 1k+ members here which means atleast 10-15 transcripts should come daily on average. Hopefully altruism wins with this reminder. Otherwise no benefit of such groupings. Thankyou
#Sharing_is_Caring
Check pinned msg for where to send transcripts of ur / ur knowns 🙏🙏🙏
Rahul Jain:
5th March
4th to go (Afternoon Session)
Board :Sujata Mehta Mam
Chairman:
1. Tell me about yourself? what have you been doing since 2016
2. Why Banking after engineering?
3. You can avoid answering this but why Axis Bank has bad name?
4. So is it collusion and ethics of bank personnel or lack of policy
5. Do you think one cannot manage preparation with job
6. what was your work hours and work days?
7. Should we privatise banks
8. What can be done to reform banks in future
Member 1
1. What was your case study on delhi airport metro? Who's fault was there?
2. (daf based) You have quit your job for UPSC...And it's a long process? Don't you think it has turned obsolete and tedious and there are changes required?
3.(Daf based) What was your work as Warden Nominee? Any innovation? was it like a class monitor or an administrator?
4 (Daf based) Sufi Music...What are it's basic principles? Hoe is it different from Bhakti Music?
MEMBER 2
1. YOU have done your schooling in private school?Do you think the education there is inclusive?
2. WHAT is inclusive education according to you
3. What is value education for you?
4. What values have you learned from your school? DO MISSIONARY schools focus on value education?If yes how?
5. In India many people takes private schooling then Why people break red light if they get value education in schools?
6. How have you used your chemical engineering skill set in banking sector?
MEMBER 3
1. Had nationalisation of banks failed? What it has achieved?
2. You have said a lot of scenario has changed?What has changed in banking Industry over the years and where do private sector takes the lead?
3. What could have prevented the PNB Scam?
Member 4
1. You belong to Guna...Any famous personality?
2. Smart city work in Indore
3. Tell me about heritage and food of Indore?
4. Why is MP not growing?
5. How IIT-B different from other IIT'S
6. How is IIT-B FEST different from other fests
Chairman:
1) Is there anything which we haven't ask ed and you have prepared?
2) Since you have talked a lot about UPSC process and has been through all stages any suggestion you want to give to us?
Thankyou!! Your interview us over
H S:
Background law: hobbies yoga, reading fiction
Chairman: Arvind saxena
Date: afternoon 09/03/2018
Gurmehar kaur s book: whether I agree with her opinions on Pakistan.
Supreme courts judgment on advance will and euthanasia
M1
Regulatory capture by medical council. Whether the national medical commission is a good step. What are the criticisms against it?
Yoga and diplomacy: does yoga diplomacy have any economic benefits for India?
M2
Why isn't law implemented properly
How to tackle corruption?
M3
Ins tarini;
why are women not allowed in combat positions in the army?
Israel diplomacy whether India is on the right path?
Why are women not allowed in combat positions in army
M4
Citizen charter
Electoral funding transparency
Why did you choose to become lawyer.
Comments: the Chairman was very polite. Other board members were also kind. Read the news of that day as I was asked about the Supreme Court judgment of the same day.
Jay:
Board: PK Joshi
Optional: Law
Present occupation: Power Sector
Graduation: Law
Interivew date: 28 Feb 18
Duration: 30 min
Chairman: Read out my DAF aloud for a few minutes - Name, schooling, graduation and where I have been working since then. I explained a little about what I do. He then asked about the profession of law as a practice. A few questions on Negotiable instruments and cheques.
M1: Quizzed on judiciary in general- PIL, role of judges, comparative constitution with other countries
M2: Understood my job profile. Questions on what the organisation does. How its role is different from the other regulators in the sector. Issues in the sector. Role of women.
M3: Broadly stretched the discussion of Chairman and M1 by asking further specific questions like why it takes so long for cheque bounce cases to be disposed off. Why does Supreme Court think its the almighty etc. Went on to NJAC after that.
M4: Meaning of Name. Asked if I was fond of my grandfather. From there he went to his native town (which is also mine). First question on that was if I like it? To which I simply said yes. Then he asked about the geography of the place. Most of which he only spelt out in his question to which I had to just agree. By this time I started wondering if these were trick questions because they didn’t seem like questions at all. Then he picked up on where we had left on PIL with M1. Rebuked the judiciary again. Most of it were mere statements and not in question form. Finally asked why judges think they are know it alls and keep getting into technicalities on which they have no expertise. Also started criticising a judge and when I said it wouldn’t be right for me to do so he said that if you can talk of positive stuff why cant you say negative stuff too and then said that PIL as a system has become so messy so I picked the cue from there instead of saying anything about the judge and ended it on that note. At this point the member cracked a joke on the judges and he laughed and explained it to the other members while the chairman said thank you interview is over.
Comment: The board was neutral. Felt like any other mock. The range of questions were restricted to my profession, law and significantly the judiciary. The board was cordial in the sense that there were no interruptions. Till it was the turn of M3 and M4, they didn’t look up one read the newspaper and the other seemed absorbed in something else. They also asked follow up questions on the same theme as had been asked before. Lady M1 only looked up during her turn to ask questions and after that she kept staring at the floor. No questions from DAF or current affairs. While M4 was asking questions in the form of lengthy statements, the chairman made a loud pen tap gesture to him to shorten it and a minute after that the interview was wrapped up.
amit k:
Name, - Amit kumar. Geography optional, ece,
Date 09.03.2018
Time 1300
Board chairman - Smitha Nagraj
I was the first one. As soon as I entered, cm asked about a demographic issue (illegal migrants) pertaining to my hometown. Why such a thing happening, what to do, shall we deport them, why no deporting etc etc. There were many Cross questions and at a point it was difficult to answer also.
M1- what is benami, how to curb etc. My opinion
Character of a place determine its criminality.. Explain... I answered and again many cross questions started. Cm also intervened.
M2( lady) - very cordial. Asked about state flag and legal and propriety issues involved with it.
Block chain technologies.
M3 - till now he was silent, and looked uninterested..
India Nepal, why blockade was done,
Ministries rationalisation ,
Prohibition adv and disadvantage.
And many cross questions in all of my answers
M4 - illegal migrants, how to curb this issue. My approach, etc.. Looked not much satisfied with my answers.
Cm - there are many group c and d employees in Central govt. What is you view.
Thank you.
My view, - total time around 30 - 35 min. I was not expecting this much grilling and so I was very disappointed after interview. I made some mistakes during the interview which could have been avoided. No questions from hobby, optional, work experience, Anyways.. Best of luck to all.
Digvijay Bodke:
Board: Ms Smita Nagaraj ( 2 ladies + 3 men )
Home State: Haryana
Optional: Sociology
Interview Date: 7th March 2018, First to go in the morning
Education: Electronics and Communication Engineering
Work Experience: Business Analyst in Cognizant (6 months)
Presently working as Income Tax Inspector for the past 2.5 years
Ch: Can you tell us how we can increase our tax collection
Ans: Madam the compliance culture in our country is very poor since the people do not have faith on the govt that their hard earned money paid as tax would be utilised efficiently. On many occassions we hear about scams due to which people lose the motivation to file their taxes properly.
Ch: I am asking you how to increase our tax collections.
Ans: Madam the interaction between officials and people should be eliminated and everything should be made online.
Ch: We are all salaried persons and our TDS gets deducted automatically but many people are evading taxes. What are the inspectors doing
Ans: Madam if an inspector colludes with a tax payer for his vested interests then it leads to a loss to the exchequer. A large gap exists between senior officers and junior officials which acts as an obstacle if any junior official wants to ask or tell something to senior officers, so this gap should be eliminated
M1: If you were made the Foreign Minister in 1947 how would you have managed our embassies
Ans: Sir at that time the world was divided in two blocs so I would have tried to balance between the two blocs and not lead toa lopesided arrangement
M1: What would have been your priorities
Ans: Sir my first priority would have been the economic interests of our country, then strategic and then geopolitical
M1: Everyone knows that black money is used in elections which is the root cause of the problems of our country. What can be done about it
Ans: Sir we can set up a seperate fund where the corporates can donate and then the money can be distributed according to the number of votes secured
M1: But the root cause is that corporates want their work done by political parties
Ans: Sir this step will eliminate this root cause and help in solving the problem
M1: What are your views on simulataneous elections
Ans: Sir till 1967 we used to have simultaneous elections but naturally over the course of time they have become staggered. So, now if we try to have simultaneous elections there will be a lot of practical difficulties. So, we can have elections of half states along with the central elections and half states after 2.5 years
M1: In our country due to First Past the Post system, even a person who gets 30% of the votes wins the elections. Why dont we go for any alternate system
Ans: Sir since we have a large diversity and a vast country, the Proportional Representation system is difficult to implment in our country since it is very dificult to be understood by the voters.
M1: But Nepal has recently gone for a mixture of the two systems successfully
Ans: Sir the size and diversity of Nepal are not comparable with that of our country so the same thing may not be successful here and also, I am not aware about the system of Nepal
M2: What is the biggest achievement of GST
Ans: Sir the pooling of their taxation powers by the centre and the states
M2: Tell some other benfits of gst
Ans: Sir it will help in eliminating the Cascading effect of taxes
M2: What is the cascading effect
Ans: Explained
M2: Tell some other benefit
Ans: Sir it will lead to and increase in GDP by 2%
M2: Tell some other benefit
Ans: Sir GST will also lead to an icrease in direct tax collections over the long term
M2: How GST can help in direct taxes, it is an indirect tax
Ans: Sir I am saying that an indirect benefit of GST would be an increase in direct tax collections also, For example if a person is making 5 crores profit, before gst he was not in the tax net but after gst, the income tax department will also get information about him
M2: What is our tax to gdp ratio
Ans: Sir for general govt it is 16% and for central govt it
is 10%
M2: Are
you sure ? The Prime Minister is saying that it is 12.1% but you are saying it is 16%
Ans: Sir I am saying that for general govt it is 16% and for central govt it is 10%. By general govt I mean Centre + states
M2: Our society is based on Social Structure or Economic Structure
Ans: Sir it is based on both social and economic structure like if a dalit becomes rich then his caste takes a backseat and his class is given more priority by the society
M2: But someone said the economy decides everything in society
Ans: Sir Karl Marx talked about it but it has not been proved anywhere
M2: What is Dialectical Materialism
Ans: Explained
M3: Madam can I ask him about service preferences
Ch: You can leave it, ok you can ask
M3: Why some people prefer IRS(IT) over IPS
Ans: Sir I think in IRS they are able to balance their personal and professional lives in a better manner as in IRS is overall a 9-5 kind of a job and out of 365 days only on a few days a person has to work beyond office hours while in IPS it is a round the clock job
M3: Ok so it is about the duty
Ans: Sir I beleive IPS is a more challenging job and they may not find themselves suitable for this challenge
M3: Do you agree that there is corruption in the income tax department or no
Ans: Yes sir there is
M3: On many occassions we see in news that senior officers in the income tax department are caught but the inspectors escape
Ans: Sir I think the entire chain is caught later on
M3: you know what are DA
Ans: SIr are you asking about Disproportionate Assets
M3: Yes
Ans: Sir those assets held by a person which are beyond his known sources of income
M3: There is some time period regarding DA like so and so ok
M3: Andhra is asking for special category status. What is its significance
Ans: Sir after the recommendations of Fourteenth Finance Commission regarding increasing the devolution of taxes from the central pool from 32% to 42% was implemented, the special category status has lost its significance. Earlier if 100% funds were given to SCS, now only around 1% of that amount is given so it is not worth now
M3: What is the criteria for SCS
Ans: Explained 4 but could not recall 5th
M3: You forgot tribal population
M4 ( lady intervened): He already told that one
M3: You forgot Hilly areas
Ans: Yes sir sorry I forgot that one
M3: Indians are rich but India is not rich ( he said something like that). What do you understand by this statement
Ans: Sir it means that the elites take the decisions in our country while the masses who are the mpst affected by these decisions are not involved in the decision making
M3: No I am taking about inequality in India. Tell me how much % of assets are held by the bottom 50% of our population
Ans: Sir I think the top 1% of our population holds around 60-70% of our assets but I am not sure about the exact figure
M3: yes you are right about the %
Ans: Sir then comes the chunk of middle class
M3: Tell me about the bottom 50%
Ans: Sir I am not aware about the exact figure for the bottom 50%
M4(Lady): The govt has taken so many steps for eliminating the Inspector Raj but it is still persisting and even becoming stronger. Are we regressing backwards. If you are made the CBDT chairman what steps you will take to remove the Inspector Raj
Ans: Madam I am telling you from my experience that a lot of powers have been curtailed and a lot of discretion has been removed.
M4: But the perception about Inspector Raj is still persisting
Ans: Madam since people are not well aware about the laws and rules, officials try to exploit them
M4: So what steps would you take as CBDT Chairman to remove this
Ans: Madam the gazetted officers are supposed to give information about their assets every year but the non gazetted officials are given a lot of liniency in this regard so this should be removed.
Then madam it should be made mandatory that no official can purcahse anything offline otherwise the assets would be seized
Madam court cases drag for years so special benches should decide cases in short period of time
and then only it
will act as a deterrent.
Then madam like in a school class everyone knows who is a good boy and who is a bad boy, similarly in offices also it is well known who is what kind of a person. But if a person brings anything to light then he is victimised. So this victimisation should be stopped.
M4: It is believed that in 1947 the voting rights should have been restricted only to the tax payers. What is your opinion on it
Ans: Madam I think instead of tax payers a minimum educational qualification should have been kept as the criteria because democracy was superimposed from the top due to elite preference and it did not grow naturally from the bottom and we did not have an egalitarian socio economic order and a participatory civic culture
M4: But we had very less number of schools and education facilities at that time then how we could have kept a minimum educational criteria
Ans: Madam at that time we were under a colonial power and we could not have had everything as per our wishes
M4: ( Smiling ) Ok leave it
Ch: Do you know about Natural rights
Ans: Yes madam
Ch: Explain them to us
Ans: Madam they are those rights which even if they are not mentioned in the constitution they are our rights
Ch: Can you give some examples
Ans: Madam like recently the supreme court declared the right to privacy as a fundamental right but even before that it was a natural right like I need my privacy
Ch: Give some more examples
Ans: Madam justice
Ch: Some more examples
Ans: Madam like the supreme court had given an order about the National Anthem in movie theatres but, the Right to Silence is a natural right
Ch: Ok which rights can be removed as natural rights
Ans: Madam like if I like someone's house, it is not my natura right that I can go and live in that house like in tribal areas also our movement is restricted.
Ch: Right to property
Ans: Yes madam
Ch: Give some more example
Ans: Madam right to profession can also be removed from natural rights like if a person wants to start an immoral profession then that cannot be allowed
Ch: Thank you
( Interview over)
Rahul Ratnam Pandey
Manoj Soni Board
Law optional
Kanpur home
1. Tell me about all the schedules of the Constitution?
2. Why was 9th schedule incorporated? Is it a weapon in the hands of the government. Has it ever been misused.
3. When was the Income Tax Act passed? Under which section do we file returns.
4. What are the salient features of Draft Human Trafficking Bill? Which agency will investigate under the bill? Do our neighbouring countries view the bill as inimical to their interests? Tell about the fund that has been proposed under the bill?
5. Tell about Sexual Harassment Bill. Salient features. Has the definition of sexual harassment being widened by the Act?
6. What is Civil Liability of Nuclear Damage Act? What are the issues regarding it.
7. The recent visit of the French President. What India can do regarding NSG membership from the visit? In what areas India and France have nuclear commerce? How many nuclear reactors has France set up on India?
8. What are the 3-4 major threats that Taj Mahal faces?
9. What is the Siachen dispute? From which point does the glacier start. What are the different claims if India and Pakistan? Name the valleys on the northern and western side of the glacier?
10. What are the problems faced by sugarcane farmers in Uttar Pradesh? Name recent state and central govt schemes for them?
11. What are paradise papers?
12. What are panama papers? Name the people whose names came out in panama leak?
13. What is basic income?
14. What are characteristics of a tax haven. (Asked 5 specifically).
15. What are NGOs and their role? As a DM how will you associate with them?
16. What are the problems and issues in Jammu and Kashmir? How will they get solved? When there is stalemate in talks how are talks an effective option?
17. Recently salary of three constitutional authorities have been increased? Whose and by how much?
18. What is PIL and how has it helped?
19. What is judicial review? Is there a specific article in the Constitution which provides for judicial review? What is Article 32? Is judicial review specifically incorporated in the USA constitution?
20. What do you think is the greatest problem that foreign investors face in India?
21. Which craft is Lucknow famous for?
22. On hobby what you research? Where you publish? First paper you published? Details of that.
Ajay:
12th march:
Bhosle sir board
First to go in morning
Ch: what's your height?
2. Headlines of today?
3. Reasons for PM's preference for younger ias officers at backword districts?
4. Why not state civil servants?
M1:
1. Favourate pub ad topics?
2. How will you handle mobs?
3. Curfew?
4. Long question on padmavat, something related to literature was also invoved, asked me to establish link between 3 things?( couldn't understand, said sorry sir)
M2:
1. Bcci issues, cricket reforms disussion and issues, spot fixing
2. How is eligible for aadhar enrolment? Only indian ?
3. Criteria for foreigners?
M3:
1. Issues with backward and tribal districts and your strategy to resolve?
2. What about education in those areas?
M4:
1. Tell about famous Gandhis?(daf)
2. Ideals usefull in civil services of Gandhi ji?
3. How will you handle violent protests?
4. What will you do if your subordinates are not listening to you in case of violent protest?
Ch:
Suppose you are advisor of North korean head of state, how will you brief him for meeting with usa president?
M1:
Role of china, iran, saudi etc in above meeting?
Few questions i might have missed!
Board was expression less and cordial
Interview Transcripts 2023 pinned «Please share any new Interview Transcript (CSE/IFOS) of 2018 session that you find ANYWHERE at the profile id @Yo_Yo_Choti_Singh (including your own one) asap. TIA #Sharing_is_Caring 🙏🙏🙏»
ashutosh:
DOI-09.03.2018, Arvind saxena
pub ad, electrical engineer, working in urban development ministry
1st one in afternoon
Ch: Why engineers unemployable? (2-3 cross questions)
India-china relations, why deteriorating, doklam issue, asked about recent statement of defence minister on doklam, cpec and india's reservations.
M1: Should we remove msp completely? I mentioned about deficiency payments and further questions on that.
AMRUT (3-4 questions, job related)
M2: What is standing of Haryana in India?
How to deal with indisciplined subordinate and corrupt senior in present job.
What is the problem of urban congestion, migration(3-4 counter ques)
M3: Housing for all urban component targets? too ambitious? no. of houses built till date? What is the major problem of HFA? Solutions
What is CISF? Role? why waste money on cisf instead give responsibility to local police?
M4: Why choke in tube? Role of condenser in fan? Ulb's and their source of revenue and problems? Something related to deficiency payments could not understand...
CH: Thank you. Your interview is over.
All faces were serious especially the chairman was poker faced. No light moments.
Srijan:
12 March, Morning session, 1st to go
Board : Dr. Manoj Soni, no lady member was there.
Background : Electronics Engg, 15 months work experience in private job (resigned), from Allahabad (UP), first attempt, Geography optional
Hobby : teaching underprivileged children.
Chairman: How are you feeling today?
Me: A bit nervous and happy as well
CM: Be relaxed, we will talk a bit and will try to know what you have to offer. Don't be nervous at all.
#I see you joined job and also left within a short time. May I ask you what prompted you to do so? Reply only if you like, no compulsions.
#I also see that you teach "underprivileged" (he gestured for underprivileged to be in double quotes emphasizing on that word). What kind of underprivileged children? Did you also try to enrol them in schools? What else did you do? Did you teach them as well?
#What according to you is any one shortcoming of RTE Act?
M1: There are so many social tensions in India. What do you think are the reasons for that?
M1: Is GDP growth along with joblessness ok for India?(I missed unemployment as a reason for Social tension may be that's why he put it like that)
M1: What is a chinaman bowler?(mentioned cricket in DAF)
M2: What are your service preferences? At IFS, he started :
M2: Name some global issues which most countries in the world are trying to work on.
(I told about sea lines of communication, WTO trade issue, Rise of China, etc. but missed global warming)
M2 : What is India doing for fighting global warming?
M2: Why are so many engineers coming to Civil services? What are the issues in engineering? If they get good engineering job will they stop coming here?
M3: What did you find interesting in the UPSC examination process? (I thought he was talking specifically about exam process and so I said reading humanities subjects after having technical degree). He interrupted saying what about this service, which post (I said DM).
M3: What are the roles of a DM? If you are made DM of a very remote area which things will you do 1st. (I said bringing governance closer to the people. He asked to elaborate).
M3: What else will you do? (I said something like plugging loopholes which was brought up again by Chairman Sir later).
M4: What has government done to double farmers income?
M4: You are from Allahabad which is a historical city. Tell me about Allahabad (told sangam, kumbha mela, city of PMs, Allahabad university 4th oldest in India).
M4: Aren't there famous personalities from Allahabad? So many writers,poets, etc? Didn't you get influenced by your city and write anything like poems etc? (I said no)
M4: Conditions of villages in India and in Allahabad as well, their problems, etc.
Chairman : You said about plugging loopholes earlier. As a DM, choose any 2 government schemes aimed at doubling farmer's income, identify loopholes and suggest ways how will you curb them (he asked me to take my time and use paper-pencil too).
I told abou PMKSY and PMFBY and started to tell about identifying proper beneficiaries to which he interrupted and asked to tell me specific loopholes in the said schemes. I said sorry Sir, I'm not able to recollect.
Then he asked if I would like to have tea/coffee to which I politely said no. He smiled and said thank you your interview is over.
My take: Super cordial board. Manoj sir is so soft spoken that you will instantly forget all your nervousness. Being 1st timer, they didn't grill me nor asked too many cross questions. I didn't even realize that it was already 30 minutes into the interview. Overall satisfied with the experience
Sujata Mehta board
History optional
B.E ece
Cm
Tell me something about yourself
What are your hobbies and interests
What ails indian sports
Has cricket and ipl benefitted other sports
Is media polarised
people like ravish kumar face death threats and trolls, what can we do to make them secure.
M1
Few questions on my home city
Use of digital electronics in administration
M2
Question on israel and palestine
Questions on demonetization
M3
Some social awareness campaigns in recent times
How can we measure the success of these campaigns
What kind of documentaries do you watch
Are biographies non fiction
Views of romila thapar on nationalism
M4
Qualities required in civil servant
A situation based question
Success or happiness which is more important
Chairman : P. K. Joshi Sir
Background: MBBS,
Job: Faculty in Medical College,
Hobbies/Interest: Not asked a single question.
Current: IRS (IT) Officer Trainee
Afternoon Session: 1st to go
Chairman(C): So you are working in Medical College as faculty till the date? But Your service Allocation IRS (IT).
1. So you are a doctor and now in IRS. Don’t you think it’s waste of money by the govt?
What are the qualities of a good doctor? Do you have it? And long discussion.
2. After blood donation what components can be separated?
3. Sickel cell Anemia, its distribution and why?
4. Can I ask questions on Income Tax? What are heads of Income?
5. Pension under which head?
6. Parliamentarian’s salary under which head and allowances?
7. Tax Planning, Tax Avoidance and Tax Evasion. Difference. Which is punishable by law?
M1:
1. Euthansia, Living Bill, Pros and Cons. Do you agree? What about Poor people? Discussion ventured into Right to Life
2. Expansion of Right to Life
3. Remedies for fundamental rights.
4. When constitution was adopted? Why 26th January Republic day and not 26th November?
3. Difference between NCM and CDM movement? Explain with example.
M2.
1. Picked up from Where chairman left. about Pension. Why we have already paid the taxes, pension is still being taxed? And follow up questions.
2. About Administration. Qualities of good administrators. Which experience at you job propelled you towards Civil Services. What your experience taught you about administration? And discussion.
M3.
1. Recent Updates in Medical Science
2. Follow up questions on Gene Editing technology. It’s advantages, concerns etc.
M4. (Lady Member)
1. Biomedical Waste Management.(Ref to My Job) Problems . Didn’t agree with me fully on the issue.
2. India-Afghanistan Relations.
C: Thank you.
Very Cordial Board.
Apurba Swarnakar:
DOI 12/03/18(A/N)
PK Joshi
2nd to go
Optional : Public Administration
CM .Name of your School and College.
Where r u serviceing
Difference between Management and Administration
6 SIGMA
Current portfolio and work
Why British made their capital in Kolkata.
Why Shift to Delhi, Year
2nd Mem. Why public administration
What u learn from PA and from my current Job
What r the quality to have an administrator
Why
3rd
What r u read and think( my hobbies is reading and thinking.
What to be invented to solve energy crisis
How hydrogen will converted to other materials.
Who is ur ideal person
Why.
4rth member.
My past service related
5 th mem
What is the difference between sympathy and empathy . example
What is ozone hole , How?
Environment related.
What is ABC method
Maslow hierarchy of needs
Which need u want to achive to become Civil Service.
Date of first tri color flag hostage
End. Some forgot
Sadanand Kasallu- IRS IT.
Btech IT..
B S Bassi...
3rd to go...noon session..
Here are some questions I can recall right now..
Italian election explain
Turkey sent forces in Syria..why..? Violated sovereignty..?
Surgical strikes..? Did India violated pak's sovereignty.?
Hot pursuit..?
Catalonia referendum, was it legal..? Should international community recognize such new countries..?
Bangladesh migrants, how to deal with it, steps taken...?
Latur earthquake steps taken
Nanded famous for..?
RTI benefits..?
Indian judiciary problem..?
World war 2 battle explain..
Overall cordial board,
But lots of unexpected questions...
Vedbhushan:
Date 12th march 2018
Afternoon session
Manoj Soni Board
Vedbhushan
Bsc physics, MSc astrophysics, MA political science
Hobby- badminton, motivational speaker
Political science optional
Bargarh district, Odisha
Chairman
1.You studied physics, did MSc in astrophysics then MA in political science? Why such diversity?
2. What is happening in Maldives?
3. Should we intervene?
4. Something related to odisha is happening here in India gate. What is it?
5. How long have you been in delhi? Have you been to this place?
6. Can you cook?
7. It would be nice if you invited us for some odia food
M1
1. How are these subjects related? Physics astrophysics and political science?
2. How are physics and Indian philosophy related?
3. Have you studied about nuclear reactions? What happens in the reaction?
4. How did Indian nuclear program develop?
5. So by nuclear program you only understand atom bomb?
6. What is India doing for harnessing it for energy?
7. How will you apply your knowledge of physics and philosophy in administration?
M2
1. Tell me three laws of entropy
2. Does entropy of a system always increase or decrease?
3. Power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely. What is your view?
4. A society has that form of government which it deserves. Comment.
5. There was a news today about something happeing in mumbai. Do you know about it?
6. What has happened in CERN? Why is it important?
7. Whom do you motivate?
8. Have you come across a complaint that teachers dont understand the psychology of children completely?
9. What can be done to remove this?
10. You had scouts, what is the history of scouting?
11. What did you do in rajya puraskar training?
M3
1. What are the sources of energy that we have?
2. Why should we prefer renewables?
3. India's major source is renewable or non renewable?
4. Have you heard about climate change? How do you know it is happening?
5. What is difference between weather change and climate change?
6. What is INDC?
7. India's commitment?
8. What is ISA?
9. What target does it have?
M4
1. You don't have a sirname. Why so?
2. You are from Ravenshaw which was earlier a college and now it is university. Why is it famous in Odisha?
3. What is the one thing that Ravenshaw has provided in graduation?
4. Were you in politics?
5. India is a big country, Switzerland has population of few lacs, still technology is more advanced? Why?
6. If you're made secretary of Department of science and technology, what would you do to promote research?
7. Where is your district? Is it near sambalpur?
8. Odisha is one of the poorest states, and your region specially poor. If you're allotted home state, and you are posted in your district. What three steps would you take?
9. How would you develop infrastructure? What are the challenges?
10. What can you do to ensure that tribals don't go to babas or tantrics and rely on doctor when ill?
11. What would be your first priority, infrastructure or health and sanitation?
Gary:
9th March
Dr Manoj Soni board
PSIR
Last to go(morning session) 35 Min
Ch - Lengthy question but basically why civil services when country needs more doctors.
Ch - what is farmers march from Nashik about And their demands
Ans- told about long march and demands
Ch- Didn't MH gave loan waiver last year?
Ans-explained about problems in implementation
Ch- Marches may turn violent, as a officer, what steps will you take?
Ans- Recent NDMA guidelines on crowd management,maintain law and order, adequate security personnel,curb provoking speeches, traffic management,etc
M1 - should health be private or public?
Ans- told both are complementary in Indian situation and gave reasons citing NHP2017, strategic purchasing,etc
M1- Is Ayurveda science or quackery?
Ans- said science and cited charaka, doctrine of Ayurveda
M1- Will you use Ayurveda in treatment?
Ans- said many ayurvedic preparations are prescribed today by allopathic doctors. Gave examples
M1- what are issues AYUSH face?
Ans- R&D, quality standards of drugs, Inadequacy in 2&3 health sector,seen inferior to western medicine,
M1- what is trickle down theory?
M1- Should railway be privatised?
Ans- said No, gave many reasons-like improving management, safety,4 lac cr given in budget, positive Social externality, mentioned railway issue in UK, Poor's transport, Hinterland connectivity, Roads sector still lag.
M1(Picking points from my answer)- why invest 4 lac cr, Is it good prioritisation
M1- what social externality Railway has that you were saying?
M2-So you worked in ONGC,
How many months?
M2-Any life saving experience as doctor
M2-How much is distance between platforms and From coast? Can we explore beyond current locations?
Ans- told EEZ limit etc
M2- What is Security system to protect platforms?
M2- What are other threats from coast ?
Ans- Terrorism 26/11,trafficking in arms,drugs, FICN,etc
M2- What coastal Security measures taken post 26/11?
Ans: mentioned CSS scheme, More funds, interceptor,OPV boats,Marine police, modernisation of Coast guard, proposed CMPF
M2- Anything related to detection of threats?
Ans- GPS on boats to track, NC3I for intelligence,
M2- he asked about AIS,radar systems onboard?
Ans- didn't know.
M3(Lady Member)-
M3- what is CSR( I'd mentioned in trickle down theory question)?
Ans- sec 135, 2% and evolution of idea from philanthropy, Trusteeship etc
M3- what is CSR criteria?are all company covered?
Ans-explained turnover,net worth, profit criteria
M3- Lengthy question on Companies using CSR for profit ,Do you agree or not?
M3- What is scientific social responsibility?
Ans- explained PM comment in ISC Tirupati, and scientists helping Society,Poor, rural population?
M3- more specific point which PM mentioned
M3 -said not recollect.
M4- You mentioned GPS, what's longform,which Country own it?
M4- Do we have anything similar?
Ans- told NAVIC
M4- explain about it
Ans- mentioned 7satellite, range, accuracy, types of usage(for defence, for others), Recent malfunction of atomic clocks etc
M4- So we need NAVIC sensor?
Ans- (I had mentioned need of NAVIC sensor in mobiles like GPS sensor)told ISRO,DoT are working on it.Then our citizens will start taking benefits of NAVIC
M4- What is GSO,GTO orbits?
M4 -about MH agrarian distress. Reasons?
Ans- explained all factors, water scarcity, Irrigation, high Input costs, indebtedness,Price fluctuations, Fragmented land holding, etc
M4 - What are provisions in budget for this?
Ans- told MSP related, 11 lac cr credit
M4 - what area budget focus?
Ans- Post harvest issues is more focus with MSP,20000 GrAM, Operation Green, FPO, Agro processing,agroExport,agri logistics
M4- What is Operation Green and how will it help farmers?
Ans- explained
M4- Anything about increasing farmer income? About E-NAM.Whats eNam
Ans- said scheme was started last year, this budget aims to coverage will be increased from nearly 300 to 550 mandis
Ans- asked about health insurance scheme given in budget?
Ans- Explained NHPS.
Ch- Thank you, your interview is over. All the best.
Interview transcript
Board- Bhosale sir
Time- 25-30 min
Optional- PSIR
Work- Assistant PF Commissioner
Hobbies- Teaching and Wathching Films
CP- So Aniket in next 25-30 min we will try to check ur suitability for the civil services. However u already look suitable from ur DAF. Graduation from Fergusson working as Assistant PF Commissioner. But we would like to know ur personality and u have to help us in tht. Use pen and paper, think ur answer and then tell us.
CP- U r intrested in teaching. Then he explained about coaching classe and their disadvantage. Then he said as Secretary of Education Dept in Maharashtra wht will u do to address the issue.
M1-
U play cricket. Tell me whether batsman can be stumed out on no ball?
How many no balls are allowed in the over? ( I said no such limit he said only one no ball is allowed.I didn't argue)
How will u rate our relation with neighbouring countries and then follow up question on why such rating?
China is building roads in our neighbouring countries then why not India? What is the use of buying defence equipment if we can not use it?
Do u know a govt scheme announced by PM regarding the same?
M2-
What is EPF,PPF and GPF? And the difference?
How the fund is managed in EPFO?
Whta is the investment pattern?
M3- Lady Member
What are the member's grievances regarding PF?
What is the biggest one?
Suppose u r posted in parent ministry what change u will make to bring down the grievances? Tell me two changes
Where will u like to work apart from Banglore? I said anywhere mam. Then she asked tell me one place then i said i will like to go to Pune.The she smiled.
M4-
What are the two oldest scripts and two oldest languages in the world?
Regarding EPFO what are the ways to know the balances?
How ur website is working?
Tell me about Nehru's foreign policy? Ur comment on the same
CP- Suppose ur posted as Collector of Raigad district(my home disrtict) what changes u will like to bring? Just tell the areas.
Which movies u have watched and liked?
U said newton? What is the biggest flaw in that character?
What is ur plan now?
I said i will have lunch now.
He asked what will u have in lunch?
I said i have not decided yet i will go and decide.
Ok what u prefer veg or non veg? So tht we can suggest.
i said non veg? He asked u r very hungry or u can travel? I said i cam travel not much hungry.Then he said go to the pundakar road. Thr r some restaurants where u can get good nonveg.He also guided me how to go thr.
Vikrant More
Optional- agriculture
M.sc - dairy science
Manoj soni sir
3 rd to go
Morning session
What is operation flood
Biography of Dr kurien
What u learned from it
Achievements of operations flood
What is NDDB
History of NDDB
( Gujarat connection- Soni Sir)
M1. Farmers protest in MH
Is loan waiver solution
What is long term solutions
Suggestions for dairy development in India
Sectors agriculture should focus
What are government doing in agriculture.
Why we have not been able to do agriculture department since independence
What are benefits of sainik school
How will you use it in Administration
E Governance example
Benefits of e governance
What more needs to be done in Dairy sectors
Sports culture how to develop
How to manage funds for sports
Marathawada drought why
What should be done
Is there MSP for pulses
What is water use efficiency
Can there be micrirrgation in North east
Government initiative for microirrgation
What is water use efficiency in Industry
What is RTI
What is link between RTI and Whistle blower act
INS Vikrant and INS virat
Generalist Vs specialist
Death penelaty do you support
For which all Crime u will suggest.
What is desi milk
How is disaster management in India
What we should improve D.M
What is bio toilet
Who developed Bio toilets
Very diverse questions
By This board.
No woman member
Ashok Chakravarthy
Pk joshi board
BE (Mechanical) + MBA + Consulting job + Badminton
Read out my qualifications from DAF..sought clarifications on name, place etc.
When did you join?
When will your training end?
What is your place known for?
How will you use tools and techniques in mechanical engineering in administration?
What is CPM? PERT?
What is ABC Analysis?
Can you use it in administration? How?
What is the origin of tax?
Of late we have seen cities expanding towards rural areas..what are the issues with such expansion?
What is a smart village?
Don't you think we need smart villages more than smart cities?
What should be your focus while developing smart villages?
Hide quoted text
Member 1
What are various Green House Gases?
What are CFCs and HCFCs?
Gas used in refrigeration and air conditioning?
What is the impact of GHGs and climate change on your place?
Some more can’t remember
Member 2
At which level did you play badminton?
What is the contribution of Pullella Gopichand?
Name other famous Indian badminton players?
Where did badminton originate?
Are you sure it was in UK? What if I said badminton originated in India?
You took a huge pay cut to join public sector, why?
What are the qualities of a leader?
How will you motivate employees when they have different needs?
Suppose you have to deal with a union leader who is raising some demands. how will you handle him?
Member 3
What is the state scholarship you have received?
What is the project you have done in consulting?
How would you rate your boss in leadership qualities?
What is the difference between a manager and a leader?
What is the cost of electric vehicles? And issues related to Electric vehicles- charging infrastructure, Lithium reserves, cost effectiveness etc.
Sundarbans has very dirty water..as an administrator what will you do?
Member 4
What are BS norms?
Which stage are we currently in?
What is the next norm..when are we adopting it?
How far are we from Euro norms?
What are the current problems in GST?
What is your department doing to solve these problems?
Is there a deadline fixed for solving these issues?
Thank you
Interview Transcripts 2023 pinned «Dear friends. All and each whose interview is over here are requested to take little pain and write one's transcript and share with us. All interviews are unique. Please come out of your hides and share. We have 1k+ members here which means atleast 10-15 transcripts...»