Interviews

UPSC interview, Sujata Chaturvedi board, 9 Mar 2018

9 Mar 2018

Ashutosh Kulkarni

9th March. Morning session. 5th to go

Sujata Mehta Panel

25-30 minutes

Background- Mech Engg, History optional, Pune

Chairperson-

Is this your photo

Tell us about yourself

You graduated from which college? Pune university?

You are an engineer. Why didnt you think of being a professional engineer in private sector.

What you did after 2015?

Which part is your favourite in history?- Ancient India

3 personalities that are special in ancient India

You were talking of central asian origin of Kushans and their assimilation. Do you think nationality and identities were prevalent then? (I said yes and explained)

Do you think geography defines national identity or is it something else? Should we be insistent on such identities?

There are certain states which preference to their own people while employing them. Do you think regional identities are increasing and should such preferences be given.

If such preference is needed in some cases,who should decide special privileges given to Sons of Soil?

There are also instances where people from other states are driven out. Do you think this is good?

Do we have multiple identities or a single identity? And do they clash?

Linguistic identities in India. Is there any state having one single identity. (No madam. It is intermixed)

Development of sub-regional identities is happening a lot. Should we acceed their various demands like that of a separate state? What terms and conditions for that?

M1-

What do you mean by the sentence- history repeats itself? Give examples of its positive and negative aspects

M2 (lady member)

You have done Mechanical engg. And you would be knowing many students who are in technical courses. What issues you faced while learning engg in the college.

What action is the university taking on those issues

Why is it that so many engineers not turning to research or teaching?

What problems do the teachers face in technical institutes?

How to improve them? How to change mindsets?

(Classical music as hobby) Have you not listened to Carnatic music? Why dont you prefer it?

Any such musical theatre in surrounding states of Maharashtra? (I said Yakshagana)

What are differences between Marathi Sangeet Natak and Yakshagana ( Marathi Sangeet Natak as hobby)

Why did Sangeet Natak develop in 19th century Maharashtra?

M3-

You mentioned the word assimilation 3 times. What does it mean?

But there are so many places where Ram is worshipped and Ravan elsewhere. How will you assimilate the two?

What is Love Jihad? Should it be banned?

Can inter-religious marriages lead to assimilation? But dont you think given the marriages are disrupting social peace, they should be banned?

M4-

What were the drawbacks that prevented the Maratha power from sustaining in the North?

You are from Pune. Is it under Smart City programme?

Tell me 3 priorities you would like to work on as an officer for Smart City in Pune. You said infrastructure. Its a broad term. Be specific

Why was Pune metro stuck? If it was proposed 10 years back, what took it so long to fructify?

The biggest problem in airport is land acquisition. Should Maharashtra acquire land compulsory from farmers for projects? Or how can this issue be resolved?

You know Delhi is a union territory. Should it be made into a total state?

So you are saying lets merge MCD and state government for better functioning rather than making it a state. Ok.

Chairperson- is anything that you want us to ask from your DAF that we havent?

Ok thank you very much.