UPSC interview, Air Marshal Bhonsle board, 10 Apr 2020
10 Apr 2020
Rishu Priya, 30 F
ECE, 4+ YRS WORK EX at GM –TCI, 4th Attempt
RPF (CSE 2017)
19.03.20, Forenoon, 6th to go
12:30-12:55pm
Air Marshal Bhonsle sir Board
Hobbies: teaching under privileged children, writing short stories
Homestate: Jharkhand
RP: Entered and wished, CM read aloud my achievements, appreciated me for a “feel good” maybe.
CM: You know we are here to assess your personality through a conversation. We usually relax the candidates but you already are relaxed so we don’t need. You have gone through it once so you know how this works, so lets start straightaway.
You are in RPF serving as a ..what is your designation??
RP: Sir it is Assistant Security Commissioner Probation.
You training might be very rigorous, be careful about stress fractures.
RP: Yes Sir we have 5 periods of outdoor and 5 periods indoor classes but out Ustaads(instructors) are very careful and they keep reminding us that injuries are the worst thing. But sir, I am liking it as it is helping me reduce the weight that I have put on during EOL.
But still be careful about stress fracture, you must be knowing it, usually it happens in the legs.
You went to Singapore in class11th?
RP: Yes Sir, I went there as the state winner from Jharkhand in an event called race for awareness and knowledge. From every state a student and teacher were selected.
You have also worked at GM for quite long ? You must have learnt a lot of things.
RP: Yes Sir I learnt a lot because none of my parents worked in a corporate sector and it was a great learning opportunity for me. I became very responsible and also my accountability increased as since the very first year I had to take my own decisions without asking my manager. I even learnt to take decisions in ambiguity when the requirements were not clear but still we had to move on. Also, Sir I learnt leadership skills if I may explain with an anecdote.
Hmm..
RP : Sir when I got a good rating I was sent to a Centre of Excellence team which means that is better than even the North American Counterparts and the team members had a belief that participating in a co curricular activity is a waste of time and is done by people doing less important work. I had problems in integrating in that team and I asked my manager if we can participate in a cubicle decoration event and he told me you can do it if you want but you have to do everything yourself. It was a tough time convincing everyone but finally we did and the bond that we built was amazing and we even got prize. It was very good opportunity for me to integrate with the team.
Was the integration/bonding because you won . would it have been the same had you lost
RP: Sir the bonding was the process of the event. We laughed, cracked jokes, came to know each other’s strengths and weaknesses. Someone was good at cutting thermocol, someone was painting etc.
Rishu, it is often said that leaders have Tolerance to Ambiguity. What does it mean?
RP: Sir Ambiguity means something that is not clear and leaders have to take decisions even if things are not clear at the moment.
Interrupted... that is decision making in ambiguity, I am asking Tolerance to ambiguity.
RP: Sir, it means to tolerate the ambiguity and stay firm and keep working.
Ok I am done.
M1 BEGINS.
Rishu you teach underprivileged children. Who is underprivileged?
RP: Sir these are those students who not privileged to go to good schools or have supportive environment to study.....interrupted.
Good school or no school at all?
RP: Sir, the students whom I teach are from a Government school in Giridih district of Jharkhand. I teach them online through a NGO. Sir I try to show them the larger purpose of education for instance I show them places on the globe and tell them where they can reach if they can do homework regularly.
Recently Trump visited India. This is the first time a president has not come via Pakistan or didn’t go to Pakistan. What do you think about this?
Sir India and USA have great relationship and we are a strategic partners and relationship in all the three sectors defence, economy, diaspora and this visit was
to acknowledge this relationship by USA and amidst the present.....(He interrupted)
Is this SAE some company that conducts Supra SAE?
RP: Yes Sir , SAE conducts BAJA and Supra but I participated in BAJA and I got placed by GM from that event itself.
So you are an electronics engineer what was your role in the BAJA ?
RP: Sir both in BAJA and at GM I worked for the infotainment. In BAJA I made a collision detector.
What is that? You mean using sensors?
RP: Yes Sir using sensors
In this IT enabled world, what are the challenges in using IT for security?(very long question)
RP: Sir most important problem as per me is data handling as DATA is the basis of the IT enabled world so privacy is a big concern. For instance the face recognition systems.....interrupted.
How does it work?
RP: Sir, it stores the images of people in mob and then matches it......interrupted
I am asking how does it work?
RP Sir it stores the data digitally in the form of 1s and 0s (you means through marking) yes sir and then it matches them.
M2 BEGINS
You were the Editor of the Literary Society, you write short stories, How did you develop this skill?
RP: Sir, I see this as a medium of expressing my emotions and things that are in my mind and I get encouraged when friends read it and they can connect with it.
But I am asking how did you develop that skill?
RP: Sir I got interested in my childhood days when I read few SS.
So names like Dharmveer Bharti(few other names ) ring a bell?
RP: Sir I have heard about Shri Dharmveer Bharti but I have read the SS of few contemporary writers and of Manto. Also, Sir when I was undergoing foundation at the Lal Bahadur Shastri Academy in Mussoorie, I met Ruskin Bond whose stories I used to read in childhood.
But Manto is nowhere a contemporary writer. He is older than any of the names I mentioned?
RP: Sir he is not but recently a movie came about him and I got curious thatswhy I read few SS by him.
Railways you see is creating a lot of child criminals. Like if I go to Nizammuddin, I find many children begging, stealing etc. What can you do about this?
RP: Sir, children are exposed to these circumstances all over India due to poverty and also they have seen their parents doing only this. First of all Sir, I would make sure they are removed from that environment. I will contact a local NGO and near or within the station premises I would arrange for a place where these children can stay in good environment and counselled to study.
But what is their incentive to study. Why will they study?
RP: Sir I have myself heard from many children I have tried to counsel that “Padhne se kya milega”.Sir, for this we need to show them that they can get beyond their basic survival needs if they study and yes sir it will only be a gradual process. Also Sir, RPF is involved in rescuing many trafficked children and they can also be.........Interrupted.
You have worked in BSNL and you are also a telecom engineer. Recently, telecom companies have to pay huge dues. If they pay they will go bankrupt and if they don’t, they will run into a problem.
RP: Sir, Aggregate Gross Revenues are huge and they run into lacs of crores of rupees, but sir Government has recently announced a 20 year period to allow them to pay at their own pace. Interrupted...
Allowed or proposed?
RP: It is proposed Sir, I am sorry.
Thankyou!
M3 BEGINS:
RPF is a specialized force and and there is another force GRP.Is there a friction between the two?
RP: Sir RPF is Central force and GRP IS A part of the state police and yes there are coordination problems on the ground. RPF has limited powers confined to the 29 petty offence of the railways Act where as crimes related to passengers and their belongings and heinous crimes come lie with the GRP.
Recently sir while we were in the training academy, we were contacted by the SP of **** through our colleagues in other services, about 2 hardened criminals travelling in train from Patiala( corrected to Ambala) to Patna and they were not getting support from GRP. They just needed data like PNR, seat number and confirmation that they are sit
ting in. We coordinated with our seniors and staff and the 2 were arrested. I realized that better coordination can also prevent many heinous crimes.
Rishu, Jharkhand was previously called Chhotanagpur. Don’t you get baffled by this? There is Nagpur and then there is a Chhota Nagpur?
RP: Sir, I never thought as to why that name is?
Make a guess. It is something related to the late 18th Early 19th Century.
RP: Sir, that period witnessed massive tribal revolts in the Deccan and similar uprisings were there in Chhotanagpur region. But I am not sure Sir.
Interrupted, looks like you don’t want to answer that question. Ok next question. Jharkhand recently got separated from Bihar 2-3 years ago? Do you think the separation has been good?
RP: Sir Jharkhand got separated from Bihar in 2000. Sir the partition was mainly for the Tribal identity and tribal development. In terms of the social indicators like IMR, Literacy etc it has definitely improved and is performing better than Bihar and in some better than national average too.... Interrupted....
But is it due to partition or is it due to development?
RP: Sir, it is due to partition that a pinpointed focus on the tribals who constitute 27% of the population could take place... Interrupted..looked at the CM and said it was a very pin pointed question. Anyway I am done.
M4(LADY) BEGINS
How many women are there in RPF with you?
RP: Ma,am I am the only one.
In RPF TOTAL?
RP: In total cadre strength of around 180 there are about 18 women.
How will you ensure safety of women in the work force? I clarified –Ma’am in RPF? Yes!
RP: Ma’am first I would work on the sensitization of men. Also, I would counsel the women to come out and report such instances. I will also strengthen the Institutions like the ICC. Also I would like to implement something from my previous company. Every quarter, everyone had to pass a mandatory test on sexual harassment .This reiterated in the minds of men to be very careful of their conduct.
This reiterating this is very good, happens in USA but not in India. Generally people are only after strengthening Institutions.
Rishu about sports, Jharkhand has produced some eminent sports persons. Can you name 2 sports.
RP: Hockey, Archery
What is the conditions of these players today?
RP: Ma’am I have been reading reports that these ex sports persons are facing economic hardships and something should be done regarding their employment. Recently, Jharkhand Government has announced 2% reservation in Government jobs from sports quota.
Is there any place where they can go and practice now?
RP: Ma’am there is a sports complex KHEL GAON with world class infrastructure, there many trainings take place.
Have you been there?
RP: No ma’am, I went there when it was getting constructed. But I have heard that the facilities are really good.
CM in the end looking at members. Ok your interview is over. You may now go to your ‘Ustaads’ and get back to your training.
RP: Yes Sir I will.
CM: Are you on leave? When are you going back?
RP : Sir, I am on leave till tomorrow for medical. I will go back on Sunday.
CM: Maybe, they will keep you in isolation for a few days and not immediately allow you to train with others.
RP: Yes Sir, maybe.
CM: OK, Thank you.
RP: Thank you Sir. Thank you(looked at others)
DURATION: 20-25 MINUTES.
March 17, Afternoon,
Board- B.S. Bassi Sir
Educational background: B.Tech in Textile Technology from IIT Delhi, 2019 Batch
Homestate- Madhya Pradesh
Hobbies: Cricket, Introspection.
CM-
1. Why do you want to join civil services?
2. What are problems with govt services?
3. What are the issues in your college?
4. What changes will you bring to improve communication between faculties and students? (since one of the point of previous answers was about lack of communication between faculties and students)
5. Question related to textile sector.
M2 and M3 completely focused on questions regarding textile sector and follow up questions on my answers related to textile sector.
The questions were generalised in nature regarding current situation in textile, problems with Indian textile industry and how to overcome it.
M4
1. Why do we require army when we have air force? (he meant that air force can do operations like Balakot strike, so why do we need army?)
M5- the questions were related to textile sector and my answers to M3 and M4.
CM-
1. When will you shout at someone?
2. When will you scold someone?
3. Two examples of how technical textile can be used in daily life.
End.