Interviews

UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 11 Mar 2020 (Bihar…)

11 Mar 2020

Name:

Board: Smita Nagaraj Ma'am.

Date: 11th March, 2020. Afternoon Slot.

Duration of the interview: 25 minutes (approx.). Third to go.

Graduation: Civil Engineering, IIT Delhi-2018.

Hobbies: Following Cricket and Teaching

Optional: Mathematics

Home State: Bihar (Kishanganj district)

*No questions asked on hobbies and optional.

Chairman Ma'am:

1. Are you working?

2. So you come from an IIT. IITs have become elite institutions and are also associated with brand value. This has led to neglect of other higher educational institutions. Your view? (In the answer, one of the points I mentioned was about NPTEL initiative of IITs which is benefitting other college students as well. Member 4 will pick up NPTEL related questions later)

3. You came to IIT because of its brand value? Isn't it?

4. You could have gone for research had research been branded like the IITs. So don't you think branding plays an important role in your decision making?

4. People join Civil Services because of brand value. Your opinion?

(I tried to highlight the good work of Civil Servants and how they inspired me. Also I said Civil Services is a 'lucrative' career option. Member 4 will pick this up later)

5. Tell me one civil servant who inspired you?

Member 1:

1. (*Very technical question on current affairs and I said I don't know.)

2. Difference between toughness and resilience? (Civil Engineering question. Chairman Ma'am will pick this up at the end)

3. When toughness approaches resilience? ( He asked me something related to elastic properties of material. I couldn't understand the question clearly. I replied that I don't know).

4. Why are we promoting Electric Vehicles (EVs) in India?

5. Challenges in EV adoption? (First point I said was the import dependence of EV batteries on China)

6. Suppose we somehow get EV batteries at low cost. What other challenges are there?

7. Do you know something about the storage capacity of an EV battery. Isn't it important for EV adoption?

8. How long does an EV battery last?

9. Is your district an aspirational district? (I said no. But the adjoining districts- Purnia and Araria are aspirational districts)

10. What is Aspirational District Programme?

M2: (Bihar related questions)

1,2,3. (*Three questions on recent developments in Bihar. I said, "I don't know" on the trot.)

4. What are the main issues in Bihar?

5. The problems that you mentioned are there since decades. Still the situation has not changed. So the Civil Services have failed?

6. There are many Civil Servants produced by Bihar. But most of them don't want to be in Bihar. Will you work in Bihar?

( I said this is my first choice)

7. You would be working because of local contacts in Bihar. Isn't it?

8. Problem of illegal gun manufacturing in Bihar. Isn't it prevalent?

9. Which act the State Government brought to tackle illegal gun manufacturing?

M3 ( This member was always in disagreement mode):

1. Problems created by digital giants ( like Facebook) in India?

2. What are cyber crimes?

3. Is the government doing enough to prevent them?

4. Hacking done by one country on other countries. How should India respond?

5. International efforts on Cybersecurity?

(I said Budapest Convention. This time he agreed with me. Probably because this was his last question)

M4:

1. Why is data called the new oil?

2. How data is oil for an automobile?

3. What should India do to harness the benefits of the data revolution?

4. Why should we promote online education?

5. Do you think that online courses as in NPTEL can replace the conventional courses taught in colleges?

6. Problems with NPTEL courses?

7. Why is Civil Services lucrative to you? (One of the point I mentioned in the answer was public interaction)

8. However there will hardly be any public interaction in Indian Defence Estate Service. Then how would you justify your answer?

Chairman Ma’am:

1. Which quality would you prefer: toughness or resilience?

(I said both)

2. No, No. Choose one of the two? (I said toughness)

3. She said she would have chosen resilience.

( I said that for me toughness is important as it a

llows me to absorb the negative energy associated with failure. Ma'am if someone chooses resilience I am fine with it)

4. Okay you are fine with it. Thank you. Your interview is over.

At last M1 told the answer to question no. 3 asked by him. I thanked him for the answer.

Thanked the other members and left.

*Overall the Board was cordial.

Interview Transcripts 2023 pinned Deleted message

Anjali Birla

Date - 20th March , noon session

Optional - pol science , graduated in it only.

Hobby- spirituality , freestyle dancing

worked for LGBTQIA employment in college

Kota , Rajasthan

[ wrote the details from form here because every mock I took they said it’s going to be entirely from daf because I’ve written some catchy stuff but apparently there were 0 questions from it .

So the exam remains random at this stage too ]

Sujata Mehta mam’s board

Ch - 1. introduce yourself

2. So you haven’t worked or interned ? ( this is my first attempt and I did it right after college and I mentioned ngo thing yet ! )

3. Some random soldier case study and social media not the BSF one . Ethical issues in it .

( said on the lines of social media privacy etc . )

4. So should there be counselling regarding usage of social media , who should do it - govt , civil society or pvt companies

( all should , children given mobiles not knowing its repercussions and how they’re data is being used ; govt make laws , civil society - must be responsible , pvt companies - cooperate and comply )

5. Gene editing by Chinese scientist . Ethical issues in it .

( !!! Said all the points vision magazine wrote )

6. So should doctors make a voluntary agreement amongst themselves ?

( use it for research like genome mapping , genome of coronavirus being studied but yeah voluntary - I gave her bait so that questions come back to recent current affairs but to no avail )

M1 - really old , incomplete and repetitive questions

1. Did USSR fall because of Gorbachev policies

Said that was the tipping point but there were underlying factors like corruption etc .

2. So it didn’t fall cause of Gorbachev ?

I just said that !! But smiled and said more regarding party dictatorship , people were not happy and la la .

3. Tell the political systems of following countries - Russia , Belarus , Ukraine , kazakhstan

At that moment , I could’ve not told their capitals also . Told Russia’s system said sorry for others and just to sound cool said Serbia’s system ( not asked shouldn’t have said but I knew so said it )

4. What is euro zone crisis

Explained

5. What is Greece crisis

Subset of eurozone , repetitive

M2 - don’t know why thought economics is my optional even when he seemed to be reading my daf all along.

1. Why not science

Said I like arts and la la

2. What are the types of market . Tell me in economic terms as you had economics .

I said open closed market - wrong

3. No like oligarchy, perfect market

Said now can recall but had eco in 12th so can’t remember clearly

4. South China Sea issue

Answered well

5. Strategic angle

Answered

6. Geographical angle

Answered

7. Difference between territorial sea and EEZ

Answered

8. Contiguous zone

I knew but it skipped my mind , said sorry

9. will a Pakistani ship coming in Indian waters ( territorial ) need permission?

Said yes

10. What is contiguous zone

I gave surprised look like I just said that I don’t know ofc with a smile ..

M3 - half questions , repetitive , tried to put me in a difficult spot

1. So you have pol science as optional , what were the constitutional changes made for introducing gst ?

said gst council and taxation structure

2. What changes ? With article

Said sorry to recall !

3. what items outside gst ?

Answered

4. Difference in taxation between alcohol and petrol

Said don’t know ( really did they again forget I don’t have economics !!! )

5. j&k reorganisation act

answered

6. No of districts in Ladakh

don’t know

7. Simultaneous elections , constitutional changes to be brought for it , but they way he asked it was a very very ill framed question .

Talked about constructive vote

8. Position of rupee wrt dollar

Told

9. Why this not good for India

Answered

10. Why some section bag for increasing the value of rupee

Answered

11. Which country does it for it’s good

China

M4 -

1. Very ill framed questions , he was so confused . Sanctions can US put

Said it can but India doesn’t recognise

2.Nono , I’m saying can India put ?

I said ya but it won’t have that much effect cause dollar is the exchange medium internationally so it’s clout is way more and hence it’s sanctions impactful

3. Green tribunals in the way of development

Asked NGT ?

4. said yes

Said sustainable development and la la

5. But delays

Said expedite the process , bring more transparency.

Ch - do you want to tell us an area we missed from daf

My mind was like you missed the whole Daf !

But I smiled and said no

Okay you may go

Now I did a very very weird thing . I thanked and looked at my chair for 3 seconds to see whether it’s on the right place or not . Idk if they’ll find it weird or not but I find it very weird now 😅

Overall board was cordial ofc they’re not going to shoot you so writing cordial makes lil sense . Mam was nodding throughout and seemed interested in my answers but probably she does that for every candidate .

My experience says don’t study for interview , chill in the quarantine days . exam remains random and marking arbitrary !

Have a good day !