UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 6 Mar 2018
6 Mar 2018
Shival Tiwari:
Ms. Smita Nagaraj Board, AN session,
Optional: History
Grad: Electronics Engineering
From Allahabad, U.P., working as a Divisional Accountant with C.A.G. in Keonjhar, Odisha
CP:
1. You're working with cag, how is your experience..
2. Do you perform audit functions also?
3. Cag has been criticised recently.. Your view?
Follow up: but the recent court judgement on 2g suggests otherwise..
4. Lapses in audit.. What went wrong, do we need an audit regulator.. Some discussion related with that
5. did u come across any irregularities while working (I said no, she was surprised said I have heard every file contains some irregularities)
6. cag ko lagta hai sab chor hain.. Do you think it's the right way to think for an auditor (I said yes, the task of an auditor is to find irregularities so he must see everything with suspicion)
M1:
Asked a long question on how India was conquered by few persons coming from outside, asked me to connect this with electronics.. I started by emphasizing the role played by science and tech in war for example in 18th C, British had better navy.. He interrupted and asked something had happened in the past, when Alexander had defeated Porus, I said sorry sir I don't know... then asked do u know "falcus" (as I heard).. I said sorry sir.. Then again he started a lecture on art of war and said this was the reason.. Then said war is going on in electronics also, what is that.. I said a few things about cyber warfare.. a few follow ups on how cyber warfare will impact us.. I gave an example of possibility of aadhar data being hacked.. he said we can manage that.. Overall looked unsatisfied.. then again started saying something that u have done electronics then went for accounting now becoming administrator.. I could not get whether he is asking something or telling something.. So I said sorry sir I did not get ur point.. At which CP said he is saying u should have remained in electronics.. By this time the member realised he had taken his time well in excess (he himself said this explicitly) so she should switch to next one.. (Worst discussion with this member, no clearcut questions but long speeches)
M2:
1. Rajasthan's controversial bill on protecting bureaucrats..
2. was that only for bureaucrats or ex-bureaucrats also (I said not able to recall exactly)
3. should we protect them..
4. cow vigilantism.. Ur views
5. why are we failing in reducing incidence of tuberculosis (i could tell general healthcare related problems only)
6. do u know about 3 stage TB treatment
7. and what about resistance (told him about MDR tb and NDM-1)
M3: (ma'am)
1. You said auditors should see everything with suspicion.. but this has resulted in a situation whereby we have become experts in finding fault.. some more speech on this.. then asked who should regulate the regulator.. how would u ensure that auditors are regulated.
(Told her about audit standards, frameworks and guidelines)
2. then another long question on my priorities as administrator... I started with development issues.. She said tell specifically what u will do.. I took my time and told a few things on increasing accessibility to the govt. She then asked what systemic changes u will bring to address problems of people.. I gave a general answer
M4:
1. Divestment.. Should govt do that
2. what should be the criteria.. Should ailing PSUs be sold and well running ones should be retained.. I said that rather than looking at PSUs, we should look at sectors and the one in which private players can do the job there govt should vacate the space and in critical sectors govt should have PSUs
3. what are these critical sectors.. For instance oil is very critical for us.. Should we have PSUs there bcz global big players in oil sector are private companies.. I said that these are mostly the cases of developed nations, we have our own unique needs and also in nations like Russia and Brazil we do find state run oil companies
4. then he asked about Indian companies investing in oil fields in unstable regions like middle east, Venezuela etc.. don't
u think it's ri
sky.. I said yes it's risky but companies of many nations r investing there so we should not lag behind bcz we will have to diversify our energy resources..
5. then on India China relationship.. What is the perception about it.. Should we see rise of China as a threat or as an opportunity (I said we should see it as both, in some areas our interests converge eg. WTO.. in some other our interests diverge like border issues, trade deficit and exports)
CP: is there anything else you want to discuss (I had planned in advance to say no for this question but somehow the environment there could lure me to say yes.. I said my hobbies are programming, web development and blogging..)
1. What do you blog about?
2. recently there was a case when a DM posted on social media something about communal violence.. (Kasganj issue) should civil servants use social media? (I said no bcz anonymity and neutrality are key values of civil servants and it should not appear to people that the administrator is holding a particular viewpoint and therefore may be against some other viewpoint.. A few counter questions.. The interview ended with my statement that what he did was unwarranted and he shouldn't have done so)
3 persons including CP asked clear questions and I was quite satisfied answering them.. With M3 (ma'am) it was 50:50.. completely unsatisfactory with M1
Overall board was cordial, CP had made the environment very nice by the way she asked questions.
Interview Transcripts 2023 pinned «Please share any new Interview Transcript (CSE/IFOS) of 2018 session that you find ANYWHERE at the profile id @Yo_Yo_Choti_Singh (including your own one) asap. TIA #Sharing_is_Caring 🙏🙏🙏»
red_panda:
date-07/03/2018, FN session
board-manoj saini
optional- PSIR
grad: computer engineering
from haryana, working in ministry of agriculture.
Chairman:
1 So, you have been living in delhi for around 1 year.Tell me what difference do you feel between haryana and delhi?
2 You have done computer engineering, then you took optional as PSIR and now you are working in ministry of agriculture, so quite a diversity. Can you explain how did this happen?
3 If you had been the DM at time of Ram Rahim case, what course of action you would have followed?
4 Reasons for USSR disintegration?
5 What is glasnot and perastroika?
M1:
1 What exactly is happening in syria? Who is supporting FSA?
2 What brought you in your current job, why you didn't go for IT industry?
3 Why sex ratio so low in Haryana?
M2(lady member):
1 Have you heard about Rosseau? Tell me his maxim? What does it mean?
2 How do you assess Indian democracy?
3 What work exactly do you do in your current job? (2-3 counter questions)
4 What is Plant Quarantine?
5 There was a famous movie from haryana recently, can you name it?(dangal); what was the main theme of the movie and do you believe in it?
M3:
1 Two SAARC countries have pronounced emergency recently, can you name them?
2 Reason for emergency in Maldives? What is India's stand?
3 Was there any need of emergency in Sri Lanka, it was a simple law and order problem?
4 A european country's president is going to visit India, can you name him?
5 So, what will be on the agenda of the meeting between india and france? How will french bases help India?
6 What is this nuclaer deal between india and france. How many reactors are they going to setup in India? What is NSG?
7 Why is Indian Ocean Region important for India?
8 What are India's initiatives in IOR? Tell me something about IORA? How many members does it have?
9 India in the past has intervened militarily in 2 countries. Can you name them?
M4:
1 You said India has aspirations to be a global power, what should be our strategy for that? (2-3 counters)
2 How are the relations between India and China? What should be our strategy towards China?
3 What according to you is the future of the world order?
4 Why people of USA voted Trump to power?
5 How to deal with Trump's policies?
6 How do you see future of EU?
7 Tell me top 3 software companies acc. to market capitalisation?
board was very cordial, everyone was smiling throught except M4( he was expressionless throughout, don't know what was wrong with him 😝)
Maverick33:
Air Marshal Bhonsle sir Board.
CSE grad, Geo optional, 3yrs work exp., Eastern UP
7th March.
Started with sir's usual comforting lines..relax urself, sit more comfortably, pull chair forward etc etc. Think before speaking, there is pencil paper too, use that if feel like.
Chairman sir:
Started with please Introduce yourself.
[ told about hometown, schools, graduation, work and then reason for leaving job and also included a line about why civil services]
What difference did you observe about womenfolk of ur hometown and clg town, emphasised rural areas? [ I started with urban difference that visibility of womenfolk in public space in hometown is relatively less; in rural areas women participation in agriculture is restricted in my hometown although lower caste/landless women do work, but in clg town rural side I saw more women in agriculture fields; women are constrained in decision-making in hometown and didn't see it in clg town; difference in progressiveness ]
M1 :
Why is your hometown poor? [High population and pop density so landholding is low; return on agri is not good, and 95% have agri occupation; coming generation youths don't get much opportunity due to lack of industries and service sector opportunity]
How to increase productivity of small land holdings like of one acre? [ Focus on diversification, dairying, horticulture, food processing, aqua culture, contract farming etc]
Then asked, what is white revolution [ couldn't phrase properly, but talked about - drastic increase in milk production, based on cooperative model, whole value-chain got cooperatised and it helped in increasing income]
India-nepal relation, is it going in positive direction. [ Said it is not upto the potential, there have been ebb and flow in the relation; currently Nepal has started using China card, China is making highways/Rail and dry port in Nepal; their political establishment uses anti-india card for vote bank politics; India should focus more on strengthing the relationship]
What advantage can India have/use for strengthening this? [ sir, 1st geographic proximity, for eg in case of disasters like EQ it is India which can help better, people-people realtions, ethnicity, kinship relation of Madeshi and east up//Bihar, employment opportunity to Nepalese etc]
Should we close the open border between India and Nepal? [I straightway said NO, it will affect their economy etc, but said if instances like drug-human trafficking/smuggling etc get start due to this then we should definitely look into it otherwise open border is very important]
M2
Basketball : who is your favourite player?
Can India adopt college-basketball model - like Stanford and Harvard, where they even get Olympic medal [ a bit rhetoric answer, including basketball has less popularity in indian clg youth, court is not available is most clgs(only in big ones), and suggested if it gets popularized like hockey/kabaddi LEAGUE i.e. broadcasted events then we can definitely adopt that model]
My job related : why India doesn't have big chip-manufacturing sector. [ Couldn't answer well, started with Taiwan, SK, Japan etc have already captured most export market; India doesn't have raw material/semiconductors; also lack of "skilled labour" --- here I did wrong!! He cross questioned this.. ]
If Intel opens chip-manufacturing here, would it count as Make in India, as technology and capital will be theirs? [ Yes sir; land, labour would be ours, employees would get income/job, govt will get taxes, export will increase, would increase interest of other competitor and thus more FDI, employees would learn technology — and thus as happens in many cases, startup etc will grow for niche areas to cater Intel like units]
Why India doesn't have as much patent as US etc, even though when same type of India-migrant employees go there they get more patent. [ Talked about - here graduates do not prefer RnD/PhD and mostly focus on big paying placements after bachelor degree, and industry-academia collaboration is less; secondly as in my company for patent work one needs t
o devote ext
ra time and it sometime affects normal work output, and not thus not much encouraging among employees ]
M3 :
What is the difference between jugaad and innovation? [ Jugaad is frugal Innovation which mostly focuses on short-term improvisation, whereas Innovation focuses on making it more commerically viable, scalable etc ]
How to tap up this potential of Indian jugaad to create innovation? [ More collaboration with industry-academia-government , more funding and other support ]
What is the meaning of your middle name?
So, you are a student of geography, tell me 3 importance of Africa to India. [ I said, it is important source of material resources including copper; oil in sudan/Nigeria etc,. Then said Africa has about 53 countries and their help is important for reforming multilateral institutions like UN reform where 2/3rd majority of UNGA is needed, also said it is important for maritime security.]
He asked one more? [ Sir, Africa is going to be a very big market, and India can increase trade and export to it just like China has alread started]. He said "yes,i wanted to hear this"
A big case study,. Tldr; situation is , My car -- A bus -- next car with wobbling tire. You overtook the bus from wrong side, went to wobbling car, fixed the issue, came back. Then when the bus reaches to you, the driver and conductor came out shouting and about to hit you for overtaking from wrong side. How will you Protect yourself? [ Sir since they are two and I'm one, I'll use emotional argument and will shout "yeah, go on hit me once or twice, but do you know why I did this? I saved someone's life. Do you know that wobbling tyre can also happen to your bus, and you are traveling with 50passengers, I hope you realise the importance of saving life!! Etc etc.."]
M4 :
Should the process patent be allowed, like product patent? I asked whether I have to answer for pharmaceutical or in general...
[ Definitely mam, process is as important as product, if we don't appreciate process innovation and give royalty to the creator then it will lead to loss of innovation and creativity. We can take help of evergreening prohibition and compulsory licencing sections for frivolous patent.. //although these two are about product patent imo// :/ ]
Algorithm! How will you use it for preventing/catching bank fraud [ I gave big answer, about how we can now have algorithms which can exactly copy human intelligence in the form of AI, I said we humans as an Auditor, regulator, supervisor use steps like data analysis, pattern finding, balance sheet analysis etc; algorithms can do this in much larger scale, more efficiently. So by using big data algorithm, finding credit/earning mismatch, patterns etc we can analyse it better.. ] she was visibly satisfied, as mam repeated "yes by pattern finding!"
Chairman sir again -
India - SL relation : big intro, like this Prez vs previous Prez and their relation with India, and since China got the strategic Hambantota project, what lever does India have? [ After FTA,. SL trade with India has increased, and by increasing this and supplementing it with next level of SERVICES/professionals Liberalization we can help SL. They need doctors/engineers and we have plenty of it. When their trade with India as a percent of their GDP rises they will have more interest in this relationship.
By providing scholarships to their graduates in important educational institutions like IITs nits etc.
By leveraging cultural aspect, Tamil, Buddhism etc. ]
After demise of last CM of TamilNadu, do you think now Tamil issue can be solved easily? [ I didn't know exactly, but said Jayalalitha's demand and SL civil war and its repercussions coincidenced; but now there is normal situation in N and East SL so anyway it now won't affect much. Plus our demand of constitutional amendment and more devolution of power to local provincial bodies has been accepted ]
Is India doing anything for this in SL? [ Yes sir, don't know exactly but Affordable housing scheme, and other social infrastructures are being build by Indian assistance]
Saranya. TN. ECE. Agri background
1.What is 3D printing and explain it's working
2.shopian firing case is the judgement right?
3.If you are a DM of your district how will you improve tourism potential?
4. Cauvery dispute issue?
5.Is our foreign policy regarding Maldives and srilanka right?
6.How will you use ECE in administration?
7.Why Western ghats is eco sensitive? How to protect?
8.Two committees of Western ghats?
9.Does tamilnadu has state song? Is it sung always
10.Is India sending confusing signal to the world?
11.Have you seen movie 3 idiots?What is the message of it?
12.What is your favorite film of sridevi?Movie name?
13.Difference between 2 committees of Western ghats?
14.Does India need permanent friends?
15.What is Ponzi scheme?
Saxena Board
Arvind Saxena Board
06/03/2018
Afternoon session
2nd last to go.
B.Tech Mech + 4 Years work experience
Jogging, Meditation and Teaching
Odisha
Ch:
1. Justin Trudeau episode..PM of a state. ..With wife and kids. ... was it correct on Indian part for the kind of treatment?
2. Section of Indian diaspora called 'Republican Hindu coalition' in USA supported Trump during election. Do you think it was right on their part to use the word Hindu there?... (direct hit from boundary)
3. How is the diaspora community helping India?
M1 (Lady)
1. Olive Ridley turtles. ....mass nesting timing around the year? Why numbers decreasing? What steps has the government taken?
2. you have been in so many places around the country, what difference have you found among the people and their culture?
3. Do you think regionalism is good?
4. what should be done to promote unity in diversity?
M3
1. What is stealth aircraft? (Physics+ Aero modeling club during college)
2. Govt banned the 500 and 1000 Do he high denomination note o
3. which other countries had tried demonetisation and what were the effects?
4. Any other instance when the circulation of money decreases in the market?
M4
1. You were part of BAJA SAE (college activity). What did you learn?
2. Such competitions must be encouraging entrepreneurship, Should government be promoting it?
3. what do you like about jogging?.....have you run any marathon.....what speed do you jog?
M4
1. Changing of name of places. Is it right? Why is it done? Do you support it?
2. How to develop Odisha?
This is all I can recall.
The board was very cordial and allowed me to present my views. Saxena sir was as poker face as it could be. Couldn't make anything from his face. Only time will tell...
Wishing all of you the best of luck.😌
Bhaskar Jyoti:
My interview Experience
Brief Introduction about myself- I am Bhaskar Jyoti, a doctoral research fellow at Jawaharlal Nehru University. Prior to doing PhD I did Bsc (H) Chemistry from ARSD College, University of Delhi and MA in Political Science from IGNOU. Originally hailing from Saharsa, Bihar but had my senior secondary education in Bokaro Steel City, Jharkhand.
My interview was on 05/03/2018 in the afternoon session. I was really very frightened about facing the interview because in last 2-3 mock interviews the experts had advised me to look calm and stress free and keep smiling all through my interview, which according to them I was not doing during my mock interviews. The stress of good presentation was augmented by the apprehension of getting so called unfavorable boards. However, when the attendant announced that we were allocated Bhonsale Sir’s board, I took a deep breath and thanked Mahadev for being kind to me because he was known to be soft spoken and kind to candidates. I was the second person to go for interview. The first person who went inside took fairly enough time, so, my anxiety level was increasing with every passing minute. I was in apprehension that since the first guy had already spent significant time, so I might see a reduction in my allocated time. While waiting outside the interview room, the guard told me that since you are from Bihar and Bhonsale sir had recently been to Gaya for offering Pind dan to his parents so he might ask you questions from Gaya. Then he told me there is a lady member inside the room who was an IAS officer and she is very strict. His words were compounding my anxiety level, I told him okay leave about the board, tell me where are you from and how do you see election results of north east, then he went on explaining how the lotus had bloomed in Tripura and I got chance to smile as well as relax.
Finally the bell rang and I was asked to go inside and my ordeal had begun. Contrary to the mock interview settings, the chairman was sitting in front of me and two members were sitting on both the lateral side of king size table. After wishing the members, Chairman asked me to sit in the chair. I was smiling in between. He asked me to sit comfortably and stick my back to the chair. He specifically asked me to sit deep into the chair and then pull the chair little forward, I did as instructed by him. Then the conversation began, the account of which is described below in the conversation format.
Chairman (Ch)- Bhaskar, you are a suitable candidate for this service, we want you to be here. We will have interaction with you and will try to know your opinion on various subjects in next few minutes. You can speak in Hindi as well English, you can even mix the two languages, there is no problem, feel comfortable. There is a page and pencil in the bag, take it out and you can use it in framing your answer.
Me- Ok sir, I took out the paper and pencil from the bag, kept smiling.
Chairman- Bhaskar you are a smiling personality, is it natural or you are intentionally smiling?
Me- Sir its natural. Lady member, yes it seems to be natural.
Ch- Bhaskar we were seeing your DAF, you did BSc and then moved to some other subject, its interesting, could you explain the transition?
Me- gave the answer
Ch- you have the hobby of creative writing? When did you develop this hobby?
Me- Sir, during college days used to participate in creative writing competitions and from there I developed the hobby of writing poems.
Ch- asked few more questions, I am unable to recall now, then he asked the lady member to continue.
M1 (Lady member)- Bhaskar, do you know there is a finance commission in our country which is appointed every 5 years
Me- yes Mam
M1- Is there any constitutional provision for its establishment?
Me- yes mam, article 280 of our constitution mandates the formation of planning commission.
M1- Yes, good. There has been an important change after the recommendation of last finance commission, do you have any idea?
Me- Yes mam, the process of devolution of fund to the states has cha
nged after the recommendation of finance commission and it has increased from 32% to 42%
M1- yes, there has been a significant change after this, can you say what it is?
Me- Mam, earlier the devolution of funds to the states were partly under the control of planning commission and states always had dissatisfaction towards the disbursement of fund, now the finance commission fixed some criteria like forest cover, population (intervention of M1)...
M1- These were there earlier also..what new has happened..
Me- I tried to say something again, but she herself explained that now the centre’s control over devolution of fund has ended. (she wanted to hear these words)
M1- Okay, now I will ask you some question from political science.
Me- Thought in my mind that now the bad time starts...was really afraid which theory or thinker will she ask about..
M1- The government has done lot of thing to improve the economy in last year, among them GST was one important thing, do you think is it going to benefit the economy..
Me- (I was so happy from within I cannot explain you because I was expecting some core political science question and she ended with a normal GS question. I felt relaxed and then answered.). Yes mam, GST will benefit our economy on three fronts a) benefit to the consumers b) benefit to the business entities c) benefit to the government and explained few points under each heading.
M1- ok and then she indicated towards member 2.
M2- He asked me few questions but I am not able to recall but one question that I recall was- Bhaskar, can you name some neighbours with whom we have very good relation and other neighbours with whom we have bad relation?
Me- Sir we have exemplary relation with one of the Himalayan kingdom, Bhutan but our relation with other Himalayan Kingdom Nepal has deteriorated in recent times, besides Nepal we have tensed relation with Maldives also.
M2- and not with Pakistan?
Me- Yes sir, sorry I forgot to take the name of Pakistan.
M2-Bhaskar, if one is posted as an IAS what characteristics or traits should he have and do you think you have those traits?
Me- Sir one should have the leadership quality, team work spirit, empathy, honesty etc and I have developed these traits over the years.
M2- Oh you have already developed these traits...
Me- Sir, I mean I have tried to develop these traits ....
M2- Okay, where do you think you have shown your leadership skill?
Me- I am the president of JNU mithila manch and JNU creative writing club, both these bodies hold regular meetings which are attended by 200-300 members. Being the President of these clubs I have led them....(interruption)
M2 asked me some more questions but I don’t know why I have forgotten those questions..
M3- Bhaskar, farmers are in distress in our country, do you agree and why are they in distress?
Me- Yes sir, farmers are in distress but the reason of distress is different in different regions of India. We had two subsequent years of draught because of el nino so because of draught situation farmers were in distress in Marathawada and Vidarbh region in regions like Bihar, there is issue of perennial flood...(interruption)
M3- ok, so have we done anything for perennial flood?
Me- Sir, the government has started the river linking scheme but I don’t think river linking will help control flood situation in Bihar, flood can be controlled in Bihar by making dams....(interruption)
M3- But Nepal has objections towards building of dams? What is the problem in building dams?
Me- Sir, a large is submerged under dams, so Nepal has reservations against building dam.
M3- then what alternative is there?
Me- Sir, other than building dams, diversion of river water into irrigation canal can be done, and Indian government and Nepal govt has reached upon the MOU to divert the water of Son Kosi river to Kamla Balan. Sir embankments should be made all across the length of the river. It is necessary to reduce the vulnerability of flood, to do that people living in embankment area should be evacuated and there should be proper coordination between NDRF and SDRF.
M4- Bhaskar, you
have studied in European Studies.
Me- yes sir, I will ask you some question from Europe. There have been referendums and elections in west European countries recently. What impact do they have on Europe?
Me- Sir, the referendum in Catalonia was for secession from Spain and the 2014 referendum in Scotland was for the independence of Scotland from the UK. However at that time UK was part of EU, so the majority voted for being the part of UK but after Brexit the scenario has changed and the second referendum in Scotland being planned is for independence. As far as elections are concerned, there were elections in Germany, France and Italy and in all these countries there has been an emergence of far right parties and euroskeptic parties. German parliament is running in hung condition for last 5 months because Angela Merkel was not able to find a coalition partner. There has been an increasing hate sentiment towards immigration...
M4 asked some follow up question on France and Germany, I am not able to recall precisely.
M4- Bhaskar, you play badminton?
Me- Yes Sir
M4- Why has badminton grown very rapidly in recent years?
Me- Sir, Badminton is a fitness game. India has grown from generation X to generation Y and the next generation is looking beyond studies. Since badminton does not require 10-12 players it can been played between as less as 2 players so it has developed as a popular game among housing societies. Government is also incentivizing this game. Medals in Olympic are motivating youths especially the girls to take this game as a career opportunity. States like Haryana are running schemes like “Padak lao pad pao”, so all these together has helped this game to become popular.
M4- ok, there is a UK based model of education and another is US based. In first model elementary education is imparted free of cost while in the other upto phd education is free, do you think India should also adopt such model?
Me – Sir, the preamble of our constitution says India is a sovereign socialist democratic republic, in a socialist country welfare is the prime objective of a government. India has huge demographic dividend, 60% of our population is young. If we want to reap the benefit of this demography then we need to skill and educate our youth. Article 21a of constitution already has elementary education as fundamental right, only the elementary education would not help this country grow, so we should move ahead and avail cheap education at higher level, then only youth would write the epoch of country’s development.
M4- ok, should there be vocational education?
Me- yes sir
Chairman – Bhaskar you must be a debator..
Me- Yes sir, I used to debate during my college days.
Ch- do you think our education system promotes creativity?
Me- Sir earlier the focus was on rot learning but the scenario has changed now, both public and govt schools are taking initiative to develop creativity. Students from Kendriya Vidayalaya and Navodaya go for exchange program from one zone to another and participate in debate, painting competitions etc. Recently I saw a video on social media where students were learning tables of 2/3 by singing it in chorus and dancing on its tune, thus new ideas are being developed.
Ch- you were talking about demographic dividend, do you think commercialization of education should be there?
Me- yes sir, there is nothing wrong in commercialization of education however it should be regulated, so that masses can afford the education.
Ch- How will you promote vocational education?
Me- sir the government should...(interruption)
Ch- Bhaskar, government should have done many things in last 70 years but it has not done, what you will do tell us..think and then speak
Me- Sir, I will allow private players to invest in education sector, spending under corporate social responsibility should be obligated and some foreign universities are trying to open their branches in India but the govt is not allowing them to open, they should come and open their branches.
Ch- so do you think, a university of Finland will open a branch in your Saharsa?
Me
- sir, Bihar has huge rate of migration for education, if they could open a branch it would be so good, even if not in Saharsa atleast in the capital city Patna.
Ch- Ok Bhaskar your interview is over.
(The questions are not necessarily in the same order as asked in the interview, questions of different members have also got mixed while recalling and writing them, however, these were the questions basically asked. Obviously, the flow of answering these questions was not as smooth as you would feel while reading my answers, still I have tried to replicate the words that I spoke. Interview was stress free. Since, questions were opinion based so the entire interview had huge magnitude of subjectivity, so, can’t say how impressive I sounded to them. Fingers crossed now, anxiously waiting for the D day. I wish all the best to future aspirants.)
Shashank Shekhar Singh:
Optional: Geography
Hobby: Watching Movies
Chairman:
1. meaning of name
2. Errors related to 3D projection of Glob on 2D map
3. Tapi Pipeline
4. Indias stand on Taliban
5. Maldives Issue
M1
1. History of your district
2. Why IAS after graduation from IIT
3. Declining textile in traditional regions; Ways to revive
M2
1. Have you read 'around the world in 80 days'
2. International Date line
3. GM crop issue and Cotton in particular
4. Reason for decline of Textile In Kanpur
M3
1. Intern Company
2. Qualities in me according to your superior
3. Qualities in you according to yourself
4. Qualities of good administrators
M4
1. Cross question on your good qualities
2. Work done in NSS
3. Significance of NSS
4. Significance of Black Panther
Interview Transcripts 2023 pinned «Please share any new Interview Transcript (CSE/IFOS) of 2018 session that you find ANYWHERE at the profile id @Yo_Yo_Choti_Singh (including your own one) asap. TIA #Sharing_is_Caring 🙏🙏🙏»
Vinay Karwal
Smita Nagraj Board
6mrch
Last to go forenoon
Background : Geo optional, E&C engineering, worked with police, robotics and startup mentioned in DAF
Chairperson
1.Introduce yourself
2.what did you do in startup and some associated ques.
3. Concerns in haryana
4.why sex ratio is a concern. Why it should be equal
M1(lady member)
1. Prospects and current scenario of startups in india
2.startup india program and its progress
3.what would you do as an startup india head
4.electronics knowledge in admn how use
5.cases i worked with police( mainly tech crimes)
M2
1.Technology which can be user in talwar case
2.I as an investing officer in talwar case
3.capital punishment for rape of under 12 in hryna-favour/oppose and why
4.robots in police can they
5.anywhere in world?
M3
Institute known in world for robotics.
Techs in vision, motion and speech in robotics
Can they be used as pets
Country where they are used
History and Geo link
M4
Why regional imbalance in hr
What to do in agri
How diversify
Examples
Isnt it good that agri contributions in gdp good with time?
What can be done
Chairperson
If married at gunpoint in bihar wt u do
(I said i"do
After that suitable action)
What about girl
If she is not convinced then
Iview over
Payal Goyal:
Background - civil engineering, Yoga hobby, Haryana- place of birth
Dr. Manoj Soni's board
Chairman
Q. What were you thinking when sitting outside the room.
Q. How do you handle such situations when you get nervous?
Q. You do yoga. I assume only asana. I said I do prayanama as well and their names
Q. Why did you choose civil eng. In btech
Member 1
Q. What did you do in your internship.
Related to earthquake so next question based on it.
Q. If you were administrator in the Bhuj earthquake, how would you have handled it?
Q. What is required to do all the steps mentioned above - communication
Q. What is role of navy in wars.
Q. What are irritants in indo pak
Q. How India handling it
Q. How successful in dealing with Pakistan
Lady member
Q. What role civil eng play in infrastructure projects?
Q. You admit they play imp role. Then why do you want to come in administration.
Q. Policies in civil aviation? - UDAN - what being done- how much fare
Member
Q. What is smart city? Govt scheme regarding it.
Q. NHAI- when formed, aim, how successful in meeting its role.
Q. Reasons of farm distress? What schemes of govt
Msp 1.5 times of which cost? What are different types of cost?
Last member
What did you do as student mentor.
How would you improve literacy of women in Haryana
Have you faced any such barrier?
Who is more inspirational - your mother or father?
Which system better - first past the post or proportional representation? What advantage and disadvantages? How minority views represented in First past the post?
Which election held recently? Italy- which system in it?
Where proportional representation system present.
Chairman: thankyou. Your interview is over.
Nutan Khade
Panel: Sujata Mehta Ma'm
FN 1st to go
Optional ..pol science
Background : textile engineering
CM..
1. Tell me about yourself.. you have lived in mumbai for 4 years..what are factors for decline of textile industry in mumbai..? (Thanku Bhagwat sir for guidance regarding this)
2. MH pioneer in textile since British era.. what you will do to promote handicraft and powerloom sector simultaneously?
2. Had you thought of joining textile sector during graduation or civil service?
3. How you got encouragement to join civil service?
M1 (lady member ) ( daf based)
1. You have worked in water conservation projects... n you know aanna Hazare's work... ??
2. How will you expand its to other parts of MH and india??
3. What are state level measures for water conservation? ?
M2( looked like from North east)
1.in bangladesh textile factory there was fire related incidents and lax regulatory enforcement by that govt but still brands like max Spencer are outsourcing to these countries.. many women labourers died in that... why it happened??
2. so how we should act so that such incident will not occur??
2...3 follow up questions Unable to recollect..
M3:
1.Why dairy industry expansion is not happening in Marathwada region like in satara district??
Specially dairy is helpful for women empowerment? ? What you will do to promote it?? ( I told about bulk milk processing(bmp) at amul in Gujarat.. those should be promoted marathwada region so that storing and milk being perishable commodity )
2. Why subsidies with sunset clause but we see mnrega like subsidies are continuing... what's reason for that?? (From my early mentioning in answers )
3. Tell us indo nepal relations history for last 30 years ?
4. Tell us difference between gorbachev and putin's approach in terms of foreign policy??
M4:
1.There are no permanent friends and no permanent enemies in IR..justify it? He asked further about pre cold war and post cold war changes in this approach ??
2. What's your take on Brexit?? Why since beginning UK is always anti eu and pro usa??
3.since you have worked in administration.. what is approach of people to look at women? From societies point of view and from your seniors' side as well??
Again CM:
1.. Do you support Gandhi's thought ?
2. Where do we see his values are being implemented on ground? ?
3. So you support Gandhian thought.. he used to be pro civil disobedience.. do you still support his this idea in present era??
4. You know MH is pioneer in e governance.. what project your depy is implementing regarding this.. ?
5. How will you ensure that illiterate farmer gets his records of rights online??
Is there any mechanism?
6. Do you want to share anything?? ( I thought little bit n was little uneasy but then she asked say say what you want to say...then i wished her on women's day)
7. What's theme of day this year?
8.why it's celebrated?? History? ?
9. Do you think women are empowered really??
(It was combination of textile+ ir+ few job related questions) not many questions on daf and hobby!