Interviews

UPSC interview, Bharat Bhushan Vyas board, 18 Mar 2020 (2)

18 Mar 2020

Akram khan

DOI-18-3-2020

Board- bharat bhushan vyas sir

Hobbies- travelling, coin collection

Qualifications- mbbs,m.s.(ophthalmology)

rajasthan

Last to go in forenoon

Interview time- 35 min

Chairman

1.akram are u still working somewhere ?

Ans- yes sir i have joined as senior resident in shaheed hasan khan mewati, govt medical college in nuh district of harayana after cse mains examination 2019

2. which satellite is called a s eye of sky ?

Ans- sorry sir i am not aware of this

3. why ayushman bharat is also called as national health protection scheme ? What is the word "protection" in it signifies ?

Ans - sir ayushman bharat is a govt flagship scheme to provide insurance based health care with a limit of 5 lakh annually on a family floater basis.

So it will give not just health care protection but also protection from economic vagaries. So i think due to these reason it contain the word protection to enable ease of living to people.

4. Every disaster lead to some positive outcome later on .

What are the positive outcome of corona virus outbreak ??

Ans - yes sir , like as every cloud has some silver lining. So in the same way the recent outbreak of COVID 19 also bring some positives with it like

A. As people started giving so much importance to hygiene and sanitation, so if we can channelise the growing enthusiasm about such practices we can curb to a significant extent problem like cholera which leads to ariund 2000 death per day and TB which took around 1500 death per day

B. Also , it is a sign that we should boost R&D in pharmaceutical as currently india is dependent on import for around 75% of APIs .

C. It show a way that we need more robust health care sector both in public and private sphere to deal with such Kind of problem in swifter way.

D. Sir as we see there is lot of fear mongering due to rapid spread of information. So we need a better regulation in social media to prevent such unnecessary spread of misinformation and self regulation can be a better solution.

D. And sir as our medical tourism industry is already growing well, so we can expand it further to give world class health care.

5. What are the positive outcomes for economy ?

A. Also as the pandemic leds to siginicnat blow to global economy, we need better b/l, Regional and m/l ties and coordination to tackle this kind of global issue in holistic way.

B. Also it give a boost to india in the form that different countries as now skeptical about too much dependency on China for import, porduction etc. So india have opportunity to extract some benefits due to same by efficient reforms like labour reform, taxation reform and other things.

Sir ask anything more, than i said that sur there can be more benefits but i am not able to recall more

6. What is the growing matter of carbon in world ? ( Proper wording of sir are little bit different)

Ans- i did not remember what ans i gave, but both question and my answer are little bit vague

M1

1. Did u travel in india or outside india too ?

Ans- Sir i did got opportunity to travel outside india, so till now i travel only in india

2. U like travelling, where did u like to travel ?

Ans- sir i like historical places a lot so travelled to different forts in Rajasthan and other states. Also like to travel in hilly areas like mussorie, shimla , manali and similar places.

3. Then he asked about some program (which i never heard, nd not even able to recall)

Some more Questions i am not able to recall

M2.

1. What are your views on one election in india ?

Ans- sir one election concept is supported by various bodies like ECI, Law commission of india and others.

Ans- Sir the intention behind simultaneous election is good as it can save a lot of money, help in reducing deployment of forces for election duty and will reduce the deployment of other staff like teachers and other govt official for election duties.

But as it is novel concept in recent times it have some issues also like studies suggesting tilting of voting behavior, problem in cases of fall of any state or central govt midway between 5 yr terms and many m

ore.

2. How will we persuade states for such move ?

Ans- Sir as at present we do not have any concrete evidence as how it will go, so we can start it on a pilot basis and if it seems successful we can expand it on pan india basis..and through thus mechanism we can persuade states for greater good of people.

3. There are frequent cases of anti defection seen now a days. What are the reforms we can do to prevent such cases ?

Ans- Sir we can make some reform like position of speaker can be made more transparent .

Also we can follow the directives of various committees like anti defection cases can be tackled by a neutral body like any trubunal/ ECI etc

And can also modify the provision of anti defection law to make it more effective.

4. How can we make role of speaker more transparent ?

Ans- sir like in U.K. where after elected as speaker he/she resign from party to make the post neutral, we can follow that model.

Some more Questions i am not able to recall

M3.

1. U talked about medical tourism, and also about lack of health care. Doesn't it contradict to each other ?

Ans- sir they both can go hand in hand , because currently the bright spots of medical tourism are restricted in metros and some big cities where people from different countries come for good quality affordable health care.

But as their are pay disparity in different countries so that trtmnt many times are not affordable for masses.

And as health is the social good so its our states responsibility to provide UHC at affordable rates. But still that penetration is not upto mark due to many reason.

But we need both to boost our gloabl image and to act as social welfare state.

2. How can we balance them? How will they go hand in hand.

Ans- sir we can have favourable policies to promote medical tourism. And when the overall footfall of medical tourist will increase it will lead to growth in technologies and will lead to economies of scale.

And in long term due to ripple effect the goal of affordable and universal health care can be attained through both private and public participation.

3. What is PPP model in health ?

Ans- sir in PPP mode there are different model in health like in my college in surat the MRI machine is set up through PPP model where land is provided inside medical college campus and a trust is running the facility at subsidised rate.

Also services like telemedicine is provided in reporting of cases in radiology.

Other services too started in various states like for dialysis and other things.

4. What are the prospect of mental health in India ?

Ans- Sir there is growing awareness related to mental health care in india..as we have amended mental health act 2017 which change many provision like non penalizing of commiting suicide and expanded rights of patients seeking mental health.

But there are some dark spots too like at present we are allocating less than 0.1% of healthcare budget on mental health and also no. Of psychiatrist is just around 4000 in India which is far below the desired number of above 13000.

Sir also still a lots of stigma is present like as we see during our graduation time even when a patient with depression arrive lots of people treat them as lunatic .

So we need to strength the positives and to decrease the negatives through greater awareness generation , increasing mental health care budget allocation and similar efforts.

5. What can we do to improve mental health care in India ?

Ans- sir apart from these steps we need to expand mental health care worker no. Also psychiatrist should me motivated to work in areas which have high burden of pt.

Sir apart from it we need to give proper training to deal with issue related to mental health.

Some more Questions i am not able to recall.

Sir constantly nodding and making me feel very relaxed

M4 ( lady member)

1. She asked some program rrlated to hill forts ( but i ddnt remember)

Ans- sorry mam bt i did not know abt it.

1a. What is the condition of faculties in ur college ?

Ans- mam in some field it is good and in some it is low. And there is no super speciality branche

s at my graduation time so there is no faculty of some branches.

2. How we can ensure greater availability of doctors in medical colleges ?

Ans- mam numerous measure can be taken

A. Overall rate of recruitment should be increased

B. There should ne option for private practice if a doctor is opting out from NPA( Non practicing allowance), as on ine hand it will decrease pay disparity between govt and private doctor and on other hand provide quality health care to more no. Of people who are seeking private care as the govt doctor van utilise their vast experience there.

C. We can boost the morale of doctors by giving annual appreciation award for best service.

3. As a health secretary what step would u take to ensure better availability of faculties in medical colleges ?

Ans- mam first of all i will try to increase budget expansion for increased recruitment

Second policies cam be formulated for overhaul of medical education so that better good quality faculty can be built

Mam also the steps to promote use of technology like telemedicine can be used so that provide good quality lectures in colleges where there are lack of faculties.

4. How to ensure their retention as in some branches like anaesthesia and radiology people usually prefer private job ( of faculties)

Ans- mam we should ensure that in medical colleges the infrastructure should be improved like the availability of all machines , functioning O.T., cleanliness and hygiene etc.. it will boost the morale of doctors that even in govt hospital/colleges they can utilise their full potential and can effectively use their experience.

Also R&D should be connected with better academics so that quality of education can improve and those who left govt college can be retained to expand knowledge in that field too.

5. As a secretary how would u allocate money for buying of medical equipment ?

Ans- mam the allocation of money would be as per need..like first of all the basic equipment like xray machine, ecg, ultrasound etc should be first made available in functioning condition, than if enough budget is available we can go for purchase of high end machines, nd if budgetary constraint is their we can use PPP model .

6. What factors will u consider before buying and allocation of dat medical resources ?

Ans- mam there can be numerous factors like patient load , need of machine like basic medical equipment at primary centre and more of higher equipment at secondary/tertiary.

7. So akram you do coin collection. What is the change we see in coins from medieval to modern time? Tell me in brief.

Ans- mam there are numerous changes like material from gold , silver to aluminum and cupro nickel

Also the size changes.

Also there is change engravings of coin and mam similar more changes .

8.what do coin signifies apart from monetary use ?

Ans- mam they give insight about prevalent political system like different king/dynasty have their mark on it...also they show religious patronage as we found coin with religious deities....i am speaking more bt mam stopped me and asked new question..

9. There is growing issue of migration . What are the factors leading to it and what are the issues it creating ?

Ans- yes mam the issue of migration is growing both at domestic and international level due to both pull and push

factors.

Mam the push factor are more pressing as people have less avenues at native places due to which they migrate mainly to industrial places or metro cities..

(I want to tell more, but mam seems interested in migration due to livelihood reasons, and hence stopped me)

Mam the issue of protectionism is rising and there are growing negative sentiments against migrant population.. which is against the greater goal of multipolar world and globalisation.

Also due to pull factor people with greater degree of speciality move to technological advance countries.

10. How can we ensure that problem related to migration can be tackled ?

Ans- mam this need multipronged approach like there is need of greater livelihood generation in place of out migration and we should be more ac

comodating to people who are migrated to another place.

Also at domestic level we need to build rurban clusters and on international front we need more b/l, regional, m/l agreement to open gates for rules based adoption for people seeking greater livelihood avenues.

11. Tell me something about reproductive tourism ?

Ans- mam reproductive tourism is earlier $2 billion industry in which people from foreign countries come to seek services for surrogacy.

Bt after the surrogacy bill the commercial surrogacy is prohibited and only altruistic surrogacy is allowed.

Although the intention behind the move are good bt their are some scope of improvement.

Mam it is in greater good of surrogate mother's because there are numerous instances of abuses and exploitation on lure of renting their womb for money.

So it is in greater good for people welfare bt will affect the reproductive tourism..bt for greater good these small backlashes need to be beared.

12. Akram since u r doctor, i want to clear my ine doubt that whose name is their in the form of a child born through surrogacy ?

Ans- sorry mam bt i am not aware about it

Mam is constantly nodding and smiling

Chairman

1. Recently Sambhar lake is in news. What is the issue ?

Ans- yes sir, it is in news because recently lots of birds bith indigenous and migratory died in it and it's vicinity.

2. What is the reason of mass death of birds ?

Ans- sir as per reports the main cause is avian botulism which leads to mass death and later propagate through dead animals.

3. What steps we can take to prevent such future incidents ?

Ans- ( i fumbled here as i am not aware abt it thoroughly)

Sir we need to increase the workforce of veterinary doctors to tackle such incidents swiftly..and also need to remove dead bird at early stage so to prevent source of propagation of disease..

( Sir was not satisfied, ans ask me to give some concrete steps..bt somehow i become cluelessness..i think for a moment and say sorry sir currently i am not able to recall anything else)..

4. What are the five engines of growth or five sector which can lead to growth of rajasthan economy ?

Ans- sir the 5 big enginess for Rajasthan's economy are

A. Travel and tourism industry in which we stant at 5th no. Nationally

B. Gems and jewellery in which jaipur is big centre apart from surat

C. Handicraft as we have many GI product which are in grt demand like blue pottery, sanganeri block printing

D. Textile as bhilwara is a textile hub

E. Mining as in many mineral rajasthan ranks 1st like lead and zinc and overall supply more tha 9% ot India's total Mineral wealth.

Thank you akram, your interview is over

Overall board is very cordial, vyas sir is full of energy and make u feel comfortable..other members are good too

P.S.- there may be 10% addition or subtraction in content i say in interview and what i write in transcript bt the bigger theme are same..

Hope u all guys and girls find it helpful..

Best of luck to all future aspirants

Pardon me for my disastrous English😜