UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 19 Mar 2020
19 Mar 2020
VJ
Date of interview- 28/02/20
Afternoon - first candidate
Board- Smita Nagaraj Ma'am
Chairwoman- (Cordial and very attentive, focussing on details)
You got selected in CAPF did you join ? Why not ? Which service you were allotted ? Why did you appear then ?
You belong to Rajasthan, where are you currently living ?
A long description of haphazard urbanization and then asked about unregulated colonies - should we provide them civic amenities so as to reduce the problems of waste etc. ?
Suppose you are Municipal Commissioner and there is an unregulated colony, how would you deal ?
If the people refuse to be resettled?
Eviction or regularisation ?
Is it good to regularise ? Doesn't it send a wrong message ?
What would you do ?
Only humanitarian concerns, what about other concerns ?
M1:- ( Clear headed gentleman )
You have an interest in IR why not PSIR optional ?
Tell us about the US Taliban deal ?
How many US forces ?
What are the dual enemies they are fighting ?
What would happen after the deal ?
You have worked in Coal India in Maharashtra, what is the difference between there and coal operations in say West Bengal ?
What was your job profile in Coal India ?
M2:- (Incoherent questions)
A long lecture on China vs India in terms of giving market access (China has given less market access but still ahead of India) What do you think of it ?
Capitalism with Chinese characteristics ?
Repeatedly pointed on my DAF saying you have written keen interest in IR so I'm asking a tough question ?
What are the anthropological and sociological characteristics of Chinese people in light of the previous question i.e. economic growth of China ?
(I told about the middle kingdom syndrome of Chinese people since the time when China was virtually an international colony, CW intervened at this and asked China was an international colony ? I explained )
Difference between Xi and Modi ( I said Xi has more authoritarian tendencies - he replied woh toh modi me bhi hai and started laughing, CW thankfully intervened and passed on the mantle to other member )
M3:- ( Stoic man, knowledgeable, didn't look much satisfied )
In last year's budget there was an issue regarding foreign borrowings , what was that ?
How did we borrow earlier ? (I said multilateral institutions )
How about bilateral borrowings ?
What's the problem in borrowing through sovereign bonds then ?
Bhutan has been able to take advantage of proximity with India in the Hydro power sector but not Nepal, why?
(I said Sir the relationship is mutually beneficial as we buy in summer and sell them in winter , quickly objected saying where did you read that )
Is China building any hydro project in Nepal ?
If India refuses to buy power from the projects built by China in Nepal whom would it sell ?
M4- (An old gentleman, helped me whenever I struggled in any answer)
What's the voltage we use in transmission now a days ?
Why do we transmit at high voltages ?
Gurdaspur - Chittagong swap- we lost sea access to NE due to this, do you think lack of connectivity hampered development in the NE ?
Doklam crisis ?
(I answered but he said you are partly correct and partly wrong and then explained)
Despite numerous policies like the act east why our relations with south East Asian nations have not realised the potential ?
(Answered to his satisfaction)
CW said your interview is over, thank you.