UPSC interview, M. Sathiyavathy board, 17 Mar 2020
17 Mar 2020
Name: Harikrishnan.K
Civil engineer, hobbies- fish keeping and watching parallel movies
5th slot- Afternoon batch
Board: Sathyavathi madam
Even before walking in, chairman wished "Gudevening Harikrishnan". I wished them back
C.M: Is this your photo?
- Yes mam
C.M: Was this photo taken ages back?
- No mam.. I took it a year back
C.M: But you look very young in this photo
- Smiled and said "Mam.. I have put on some weight. Maybe that's the reason it looks different". Every one started laughing. M2 interfered and said "UPSC is very hectic. So aspirants are putting weight due to the long study time". (I smiled).
C.M: So.. you are from Palakkad?
-Mam, I was born in Palakkad. I am from Tamilnadu
C.M: Where exactly in Tamilnadu?
- Salem
C.M: Reads my profile to the board
C.M: So you were in this Green Eco Organisation. What is it? What are the activities you were doing there?
- Mam.. It is an NGO in our college. We are focussed on environmental conservation. As my college is located close to the Sathyamangalam Tiger Reserve, there is an issue of increase in plastic pollution in the forest region. So we conduct anti plastic campaigns. We also did tree plantation and awareness campaigns.
C.M: Do you know about green corridor?
- Thought for a moment and told about the National green highways mission. She interrupted and said, "No.. not that.. green corridor which is related to organ donation". (Though I have heard, I was not very confident) Sorry mam, I am not able to remember
C.M: You have fishkeeping as a hobby. Tell us what you do?
- explained them
C.M: What is another term for fishkeeping?
- pisiculture mam
C.M: You have watching parallel movie as a hobby. What is it?
- explained it
C.M: What is the most recent parallel movie you watched?
- A malayalam movie called "Elippathayam"
C.M: But that is a very old movie.
- Yes mam, it was released in the 1980s. But I saw the movie very recently in youtube.
C.M: (Smiled) Ok.. tell me what you liked in that movie?
- The movie is about the patriarchy that was existing at that time in Kerala society. But the movie doesn't stop by just showcasing patriarchy. It goes on to show three different women characters who face the challenge in their own way.
C.M: Alright.. tell me some other movie
- Mam.. I love the movie called "Mathilukal" by Adoor Gopalakrishnan. It is also an old movie. (She smiled and nodded and then asked M1 to continue)
M1: Do you know about green passport?
- I have heard the word sir. But not able to recollect now.
M1: Alright.. It is a very tuff question. no issues. As you have been involved in environmental activities, lets stick on to it. Do you know green house gases?
- explained the concept
M1: Why green house gases are increasing recently?
- Told about industrial pollution, increased energy consumption, change in life style of the people etc.
M1: Right.. increased energy consumption is a major reason. But we need energy for industries and developmental activities. What should we do?
- Told about renewable energy and its increasing adoption in the recent times.
M1: Do you have a car or bike in home?
- Yes sir. I have a bike
M1: What is the fuel standards of the fuel of that bike?
- It is Bharat Stage 4 Sir.
M1: How they classify BS4 and 6?
- Told about the difference
M1: What is the function performed by sulpher in petroleum?
- explained the function
M2: You are a civil engineer. Have you worked as an engineer?
- Yes sir. I have worked as a site engineer.
(some follow up questions such as how did your studies help in site? etc.)
M2: What is the problem you think is there with Indian roads?
- Sir, from what I have read in newspapers and what I have come across in my life, I feel that we fail to adopt the design exactly to the field. There is implementation issue.
M3: You were in Bharat Scouts and Guides. what they do?
- Talked about the role of scouts in value based education and activity based lifestyle
development in a child
M3: What are all the activities you took part as a scout?
- I had been to three scout camps, we conducted awareness rallies on road safety, women empowerment etc.
M3: How do you think scout movement can help the society?
- Sir, for any person the values gets formed in a very young age. Hence it is important to provide a very good parental and school environment. The scout movement helps in this by imparting good habits and values in the young minds. Hence it is very important.
M3: Tell me two things you cannot tolerate in a society. I mean.. by seeing such things you would become very angry as an administrator.
- Sir, can I think for a moment before answering that?
M3: Sure.. sure.. U can
- Sir, "gender discrimination" and "ignorance of the citizen" are two things I cannot tolerate
M3: Acchaa.. citizens should not be ignorant.
- Yes sir.
M4: You have lived most of your life in salem
- Yes sir
M4: Have you been to a near by place called Tiruchengode?
- Yes sir. I have been to the place (I had prepared so much on my hometown Salem. Now he starts asking about Tiruchengode which is in Namakkal district)
M4: What is Tiruchengode famous for?
- There are a lot of educational institutions in Tiruchengode. Also, the place is famous for poultry industry.
M4: There is a very famous heavy machine industry there. Are you aware?
- No sir, I am not aware of it.
M4: There is a very famous temple there. You know?
- Sorry sir, I am not able to recollect
M4: (With a very wide smile) There is a Brahma temple there. C.M interfered and said no... its a Shiva temple. M1 interfered and said I think its a Murugan temple
M4: There is a very good textile centre near you place.
-Sir, Kondalampatty is a place which is very famous for the silk sarees it produce
M4: If you had to go from Salem to Coimbatore, what are all the places you would cross?
- Sir, from Salem, we go to Coimbatore via Sankagiri and Erode.
M4: Why do you think some roads in India are very good and some are not?
- Sir, roads such as national highways we can see lasting for a very long time. However, state highways and other district roads do not. The reason is, the NHs are designed very well and implemented as per the design. Whereas there is huge disparity in building other roads.
M4: There must also be quality issues right?
- Yes sir. The quality of the materials used are good in the national highways.
M4: I will give you a situation. You are a collector and you have to lay a road between two places. What are all the steps you will follow?
- Sir, I would first learn what the two places are, the nature of the places- whether they are cities or villages. Then I would have a survey of the estimated traffic that is going to pass through the road. Then I would study whether any private property is going to be affected because of the project, as compensation need to be paid in such a situation. Then I would ask expects to design a road considering all these factors.
M4: Thank you Hari.. your interview is over.
Wished the C.M and members thanks and woke up. C.M said, the temple is Ardhanareeshwarar temple, Shiva is in a different form there. Visit it, I replied alright mam.. thanks for the information.
My opinion- The board is very cordial, all questions were related to my profile, It was more like a discussion rather than a question- answer session.
Karishma Pant
12th March forenoon
Sathyavathi mam's board
Civil Engineering, IITB
Sociology optional
State: Uttar Pradesh
1st to go
Mam read out my DAF to everybody.
M-1
1.What have you been doing since graduation?
2. Being a civil engineer, why civil services?
3. Why are there so less girls in Civil engineering? How any in your batch? Has it improved?
M-2
1. Why less rainfall in Bundelkhand?
2. Banditry has declined in bundelkhand area of UP. Almost vanished. But still why bandit culture in MP region?
3. Reasons for bandit culture in Morena and Chambal
4. Why bundelkhand is underdeveloped? How is it changing?
M-3
1. Famous people from Jhansi
2. Jhansi has a rich literary culture. Any famous works and poets
3. Smart cities
4. Anything other than data essential for smart cities
M4
1. Suppose if you are going from jhansi to tamil nadu, we compare the places. We know there are lots of differences btw india and europe, but tell us about the similarities between Jhansi n Italy?
2. Tell us about your work in Italy internship
3. Suppose if you're boarding a flight from Italy to mumbai, what will be the process?
M5
1. What are social institutions?
Examples of social instts.
2. Social mobility?
3. UNHCR has recently filed against CAA. Is it right? (We don't want to listen about intricacies of CAA)
Board was quite cordial. Happily discussing about fiesta culture amongst themselves.
No questions asked about job and hobbies.
Optional - Geography
Background - Civil Engineering
State - Rajasthan
Board Name - R N Choubey Sir (5 March Morning Session)
चेयरमैन सर
Q- अपने educational background के बारे में बताइए?
Q- क्या आपने कोई इंटर्न की है?
Q- जनजातियों के विकास के लिए उन्हें मुख्य धारा से जोड़ने के विचार पर आपकी क्या राय है? (इंटर्न से सम्बंधित)
Q- पथलगड़ी आंदोलन के बारे में सुना है?
Q- नेतृत्वकर्ता के गुण बताइए?
Q- अपनी 2 कमजोरियां बताइए? (Cross Questions)
मेंबर1 (Lady Member) (Mainly Economy Related)
Q- अपने नेतृत्व में कुछ परिवर्तन किया हो ऐसा कुछ बताइए? (Cross Questions)
Q- रेगुलेटिंग ऑथोरिटी के कुछ एग्जाम्पल बताइए?
Q- RERA क्या है?
Q- RERA अभी तक कितना सफल रहा है?
Q- शेल कंपनी क्या होती है?
Q- नोटबंदी के बाद सरकार ने बहुत सी शेल कंपनी को बंद किया था, क्यों?
मेंबर2 (Civil Engineering Related)
Q- आपने BOMBAY से सिविल इंजीनियरिंग की है, मुंबई में हर साल बहुत से बिल्डिंग गिरती है जिसमें कई लोगो की जान जाती है, इसका क्या उपाय किया जाना चाहिए?
Q- ग्रीन बिल्डिंग क्या है?
Q- भूमि अधिग्रहण अधिनियम के बारे में सुना है?, इसका पूरा नाम बताइए? इसके कुछ प्रावधान बताइए ?
मेंबर3
Q- सिक्किम के बारे में सुना है?, यह भारत में कब शामिल हुआ?
Q- सिक्किम किसलिए प्रसिद्ध है? (ऑर्गेनिक फार्मिंग और पर्यावरण संरक्षण संबंधी नीतियां)
Q- आर्गेनिक फार्मिंग क्या है?
Q- जैव विविधता क्या है?
Q- पर्यावरण से संबंधित सिक्किम सरकार के कुछ निर्णय?
Q- चुंबी valley कहा है? , यह क्यों महत्वपूर्ण है?
Q- सिक्किम के आस पास के क्षेत्र में पिछले कुछ समय में कुछ घटनाएं (बोडोलैंड समझौता, डोकलाम) जनांकिकी परिवर्तन संबंधी (प्रवासन )
मेंबर4 (सदस्य 3 के प्रश्नों का रेफरेंस देते हुए)
Q- जैव विविधता क्यों जरूरी है?
Q- ऑर्गेनिक फार्मिंग और जीरो बजट नेचुरल फार्मिंग में क्या अंतर है?
Q- हम पहले परम्परागत खेती करते थे फिर रासायनिक की क्या आवश्यकता पड़ी और फिर से परम्परागत (ऑर्गेनिक और जीरो बजट नेचुरल फार्मिंग) की क्या आवश्यकता पड़ी?
Q- क्या भारत में पूर्ण रूप से ऑर्गेनिक फार्मिंग करनी चाहिए?
चेयरमैन सर
Q- क्या कुछ ऐसा है जो आप हमें बताना चाहते है और हमने अभी तक ना पूछा हो ? (सर, आप हॉबी से कुछ पूछ सकते है) - बताइए?
Thank You. Your Interview is over.
The Board was very cordial. 😊
We are observing some trend in shared transcripts. Only 2-3 board transcripts are coming in large number. Plz share transcripts of other boards too. 🙏🙏
Transcript
Name- Loveneet Bangar
Date - 11th march
Session - Afternoon ( 2nd to go)
Job- working as an Inspector in punjab Department of cooperation
Duration -25-30 min
Board - TCA Anant sir
Chairman :-
Q1- what are you doing since 2016 after my grad ( since my job was not mentioned in the DAF)
Q2- what is the nature of job
Q3- Why cooperatives were established ( lady member interfered)
Q4 - what is the job of my department
M1:-
Q1:- Impact of entertainment industry on society.. ( from hobbies)
M2:-
Q1:- why laws are not followed in India
Q2- Why so many laws
Q3- should laws be made fit to humans or humans be made fit to law
M3 - Lady member ( very cordial)
Q1- question on my job
Q2 - old singers from punjab ( my home state)
Q3 - Industry that loses its importance in amritsar after independence and reasons ( i said textile but could not gjve the reasons )
M4
Q1- 3-4 questions on my job and then passed on to chairman
Chairman said ur interview is over
Cant recall 3-4 questions
Overall very pleasant and cordial board members