UPSC interview, Smita Nagaraj board, 5 Mar 2018 (Jharkhand)
5 Mar 2018
Mayank Manish
Board: Smita Nagraj
Date: 05/03/18, Forenoon Session
Went for 35 mins
B.Tech Comp. Sc.
IIT Kgp 2016 batch
Interned in a tech startup
Ranchi, Jharkhand
Maths Optional
Not much focus on DAF. No ques from graduation, hobbies, achievements etc. Almost every ques was opinion based with follow up questions. It did not require any preparation as such.
Chairman :
1. Why more startups in IT sector and not in manufac
2. Why IITs rank low in world rankings
3. Compare IIT and IISc
4. Why we Indians lack innovation. Instead of new ideas why are just copying western startup ideas
5. Why we people are risk averse
6. How to increase institute-industry collab
M2 :
1. Give five qualities of civil servant
2. Hyperloop Tech
3. Bullet Train. Do we need it. Compare it to air travel. Why shouldn't we spend on improving existing infra instead of wasting money on it.
M1 (Lady member)
1. As a policymaker how would you improve primary, secondary and tertiary sectors
2. Is MSP a good policy. How to improve its implementation. Give some technical solutions for it
3. Name some countries which have good manuf base. Give reasons for their success.
4. Discussion on issues of land, labour, capital in manufac. sector.
M3:
1. Should we give more preference to desi e-commerce like flipkart against say amazon. Why not
2. Discussion on regulatory hurdles in opening a startup
3. Biggest issue in Jharkhand (Naxalism). Reasons for same. How to tackle. Why not use complete muscle power to eliminate it
4. Issue of Pathalgari in Ranchi. Reasons why it is happening. As a DM how will you tackle it.
M4 :
1. China does not allow amazon, fb, google to operate there. Why shouldn't we follow same policy and encourage home companies?
2. Discussion on democracy in india/china and how this strategy is not very good in long run
3. Preference bw competition vs increasing industrial base by any method possible
4. You talked about democracy, competition but US being model of democracy is talking about "Ämerica First". Your views
M2:
1. Role of frontal org (media, ngo) in helping naxalism
Extremely cordial board. All members smiling throughout the interview and cracking jokes in between. They even were very helpful and gave hints in between.