UPSC interview, R. N. Choubey board, 16 Mar 2020
16 Mar 2020
16th March 2020
BE Mechanical
MA International Relations JNU ( Currently in 1st year )
RN Choubey Sir
Afternoon Session
Last one to Go
PSIR Optional
Choubey sir first tried to make me relax and feel comfortable, then told me about the process and concluded that it will be a chat with you.
CM
1. Tell me about your educational classification and work experience
2. Do you know about Kurds force? What is the role of USA and Turkey?
3. Why US is involved?
4. What the Kurds want?
5.What is the Peace Deal between US and Taliban?
6. What will India get in this? ( Mentioned the reality that India will get nothing much, but for a short term, however, will feed India's long term interest )
M1 ( Lady )
1. You have mentioned watching nature and wildlife documentaries and learning lessons from them ( Hobby). What are the lessons?
(mentioned in brief - courage, patience and risk taking for getting the prey ) ( M3 intervened and asked who / what is your prey then? :P )
2. Do you have them in yourself?
3. Prove it.
4. How these are important in administration?
5. Have you heard about a grand project of Govt in the infrastructure?
4. Tell me more about NIP?
5. What is the funding pattern?
6. What is the role of private sector?
7. What are the challenges involved?
8. What is the status of infrastructure in India?
9. What is US doing with Taliban?
10. Why being the peace deal inadequate, US is still focusing on it?
11. But, what if in 14 months there goes some bomb blast and disrupts the deal? What then for US? ( Very much satisfied with the answer )
12. Have you heard of Anti Defection law? What is the role of Speaker in this very controversial and what are the steps to make it more responsive? ( MP home state and Current defection Turmoil ) ( mentioned Kihoto Hollohan case, Cool off period for MPs MLAs, independent authority )
13. But is the cool off period for speaker justified?
M2
1. You have a lot of interests and done a lot in NCC ( DAF based, was Under Officer and part of various initiatives ), how this will help in administration?
2. What qualities have you learned from NCC?
3. What is leadership? How will you use it in administration?
4. What is the specific role of a leader?
5. How would you differentiate between Responsibility and authority? Is there any linkage between them or both are different?
6. How in administration both have importance?
7. What will be the situation when any of one them is present in the society? ( Mentioned role of NGOs in civil society and their work )
8. In administration, for a civil servant, can there be no responsibility, but authority? How will he / she work then?
9. Presented a case study when you have 5 persons arguing over an issue and there is no consensus. How till you deal / convince them? ( Added here JS Mill's Democracy and Toleration argument, accomodation Principle )
10. But what if there is no consensus building? ( Added respect the others argument, convince them about the larger picture of service / work and even if then disagree then go ahead )
M3
1. What is this Helix Smart city Mission? ( DAF ) ( CM intervened and asked about my project of Smart city )
2. What other steps your district is taking on the same ?
3. What are the challenges involved?
4. How will you bring changes then?
5. What is the issue of climate change? And what is India and World doing for it?
6. Are all these measures satisfactory?
7. What leadership role can India take ?
8. Why US under Trump is backing off from the pacts? ( Mentioned ECONOMIC Nationalisms of US and Trump's short term interests )
9. Isn't it good for climate change?
M4 ( aggressive pal )
1. Have you heard about Social Audit?
2. Who all are involved?
3. Have you heard about recent controversy regarding ex-CJi? He himself mentioned sexual harassment and then asked what are the provisions of tackling sexual harrasment at institutional level and what is the procedure for Judiciary?
( Mentioned Sexual Harassment at Workplace act, ICC, said don't know for Judiciary )
4. What is Labour?
5. What are the recent Labour reforms taken
by India ?
6. W
hat do you know about labour Code bills ?
7. How many bills were introduced? ( Mentioned 4 and said 2 have been passed ( completely wrong here )
M4 then corrected me, and then I said sorry for the wrong info
8. How many codes were there before?
9. What will be the impact of Climate change on different countries ?
10. How is India dealing with it?
11. You mentioned about ISA, so tell me, is India doing sufficient in dealing with climate change ? ( Mentioned 175GW Renewable Energy Target, Paris climate deal INDCs and commitments; and told that India is a leading power in this field and India's philosophy has role of nature in it )
12. What is the role of COVID in climate change? Will it shift our focus? ( Explained, added that for short term yes, but our long term interests will remain dealing climate change )
CM then asked me that your interview is over. Would you like us to talk on and topic which has been left or do you want to tell us some changes in the process ?
Thankyou. Wish you all the best.
Went for 25-30 minutes.
Overall, the board, specially the Lady member, was very cordial and supportive.
Choubey sir took great interest in listening to all my answers.
16/3/2020 Forenoon session (2nd to go)
B.Tech
Sociology
Sketching,Kitchen gardening,Snooker
BB Vyas sir board
40-45 minutes
Chairman:
Greeted me.Took a glance on my DAF.
1.What is Cultural relativism?How do you see it in present context?
2.Why sociology as optional?
3.Is DTC a reality?
4.What is Angel tax and it's current status?
5.Who are Angel investors?
6.Why they are called Angel?
7.How much is our Tax to Gdp ratio?
8.Why is it low?
9.How to increase Formalisation of economy?
10.Has GST and JAM helped in Formalisation of economy?
11.What is present status of Cryotocurrency ?Who can use it?
12.Is it easy to get crypocurrency?
Member 1
1.Trump's visit and it's outcome.
2.India- US trade issues
3.GSP
4.India- SL relations and growing presence of China.
5.What is India doing to balance it?
6.What is String of Pearls
7.What is RCEP and India's concerns?
8.Trade performance of INDIA
Member 2
1.How do you see the performance of Civil servants since independence?
2.What are the sectors that are going to benefit due to Covid 19 pandemic?
3.Can you see any positive outcome of Covid 19 pandemic?
Member 3
1.Gautam Buddha and train started related to him recently?(DAF)
2.Sociology Vs Mechanical?
3.Why cricket dominate Indian sports?(DAF)
4.Why Hockey lost it's popularity?
5.What are other sports that has potential in your state?
6.As a Sports secretary how will you promote sports?
7.What is Khelo India and Fit India movement?
8.Is Ethics paper helpful in assessing the values system of candidate?
Member 4
1.Snooker Vs Billiards(DAF)
2.What is the role of Social media?Is it positive or negative for the society?
Chairman
Why IAS from IRS?
Chairman thanked and wished my luck.
I wished back the board.
The board was very cordial.But most of the questions asked were framed very long.It was difficult to comprehend and respond immediately.Overall a good experience.