UPSC interview, R. N. Choubey board, 25 Feb 2020 (Uttar…)
25 Feb 2020
25th Feb 2020
Piyush
R.N.Choubey sir Board
Birth- Varanasi(Uttar Pradesh)
Education- B.Tech,Materials Engineering, IIT Kanpur.
Hobby- Playing Badminton,Skipping Rope
Optional-PSIR
1st Attempt, 22 yr age
I wished them Good morning at 3pm
Chairman:Good afternoon,Piyush..Please sit.
Chairman: Explained the process,its just a conversation,say no to questions u don’t know.
1. U said Good morning,So which part of the world we have to take ur interview now for you to be correct
Me: told GMT+5:30,London,South America
2. Tell me about your educational background and work exp in 1 min?
Me: Varanasi schooling,BTECH in 2018,no work experience
3. Have u heard about RBI?
Me: Yes Sir. (Shayad)
4. Tell me functions of RBI?
Me: Banking sector Regulator and monetary policy function
5. Now rate the performance of RBI on these two functions u have mentioned with reason.
Me: Fairly good ..inflation rate is within range, but there are some challenges in banking regulation front
6. What are these challenges?
Me: NBFC liquidity issue,RBI itself accepted it has to be more proactive in its approach
At this point Chairman stood up and goes behind his Chair...and kept on stairing me for the rest of the interview standing
Member 1:
1. You come from Varanasi,How will u explain the city to someone and attract them to visit?
Me: Spiritual capital of the world,Ganga ghats,Kashi Vishwanath temple,Banarasi Saadi, Paan,BHU....Varanasi is beautiful in its own way. (Ratt k gya tha)
2. How do u see the job of a civil servant or administrator?
Me: Two functions Sir,Maintaining law and order and Implementation of govt developmental Schemes. And these two are interdependent.if no law n order ,developmental functions gets stuck
3. Why Police Commissionerate system implemented in UP?
Me: speedy control of crime in big cities,Police hierarchy and curb confusion between executive magistrate and police.So in big cities like Lucknow and Noida where crime can escalate quickly ..this system is implemented
4. Is it in Gautam Buddha Nagar or Noida,what’s the difference?
Me: Sir,In GBN which is district and Noida is city within
5. There is talk of transparency in gov. Have RTI resulted in increasing efficiency in government functioning?
Me: Definitely Sir, with 70 lakh RTI applications filed every year..there is pressure on govt officials to perform as info can be demanded by public anytime.
6.Tell me the amendments in RTI Act and Why?
Me: started with CIC,IC salary tenure in hands of Central govt ..he interrupted
7. No, the amendments by previous government
Me: No Sir, I am not aware.
Member 2:
1. You had responsibility to work as security officer in college festival.What were the challenges u faced?
Me:Explained the role , forged ID card and managing crowd.(Lekin Bus Bunk Mara tha)
2. You know the term waging war? Do you know which institution has the authority to declare war in India?
Me: I think it’s Cabinet Committee on Security (Galat hai bro...it’s President on advice of council,but they didn’t correct me)
3. Who are the members of this Committee?
Me: Prime min,Home min, NSA is also related (Ab ye kuch bhi Bol raha hai)
4. Do u support the use of military in internal security matter of the country? Military use on our own citizens?
Me: Sir,Are u talking about J&K,AfSPA? He said Yes.
Sir,Desperate situation needs desperate measures. (Subah hi ye line suni thi)
M2: What?
Chairman interrupted: He is saying na ...use military in desperate situations only. (Sirji,Aap khade kyu ho?)
5.You play badminton doubles.Why not singles?
Me: My playing style is more of attack and power play which is more suited to doubles..So My Coach put me in doubles team...but I play singles as well
Member 3 :
1. Have u heard of Panchayati Raj?
Me: Yes,Sir...73rd CAA 1992
2.73rd Amendment u mentioned is very important?was there PR before it?
Me: Yes there was. But I don’t know the details
3. How many layers are there in Panchayati Raj?
Me: 3 —Village panchayat,Intermediate level,Zilla Parishad
4. Do all states have intermediate layer?
Me: No Sir,If I am not wrong there is population limit of 40 lakhs,its upto the states
5. Which states do not have it?
Me: based on population limit-Sikkim,Goa, Arunachal (kyun guess kar raha)
6. Are u sure?
Me: No Sir not too sure
7. We discussed about RTI ,So who was the person behind RTI?
Me: No idea Sir
8.Let me give u a hint..is the person male or female?
Me: I think it’s male but I am not sure Sir. (Ye kaun si hint hai)
9. Have u heard of ____ committee related to railways
Me: No Sir.Not heard. (Loyal only to Bibek debroy ,no one else)
Member 4(Lady member): eloquent accent, science background
1. You studied in IIT Kanpur,such a beautiful campus.What are the two changes u will make in IIT Kanpur or u enjoyed it?
Me: Yes Sir,Sorry Ma’am ,I enjoyed it but 2 changes can be hostel integration of 1st,2nd,3rd year students-Senior junior communication gap bridge
Secondly, Being a Material science graduate I have never visited Iron and steel industry.So making industrial visit compulsory. (Karna bhi nhi Chahta tha)
2. Then I will not ask u about iron and steel industry. What is ur fav subject in Material Science?
Me: Was not able to recall any subject.made up one subject that I do not remember ..it was something like material Processing
3.Followed a Processing question
Me: I was Ready with the statement —I am not able to recall Ma’am.
3. How will know the composition of steel?
Me: Nhi pata. (Ma’am was like ..Tereko kuch aata bhi hai?)
Chairman: Thank you. Ur Interview is over ..but we give every candidate this opportunity to ask a question that u might want to be asked.
Me: PSIR,My optional subject
Chairman: No tell me the question.
Me: I don’t want to Sir....With a laughing face (Leave me alone now)
Chairman: Thank you then...u may go young man..nice talking to you,all the best.
Feedback: Cordial board,smiling chairman,easy general questions
I Messed up at the end and guessed some answers..Not expecting more than 155-160
Background: B.Tech electrical engg from IIT Delhi
Optional: Sociology
Hobby: Blogging and listening songs.
Board: TCA Anant
Chairman
What were you doing after graduation?
Why sociology?
Difference between sociology and anthropology.
I think anthropology has an element of racism as it studies only primitive societies. What do you think?
M1:
What do you mean by innovation? (Innovation Award mentioned in DAF)
What do you blog about?
How many followers do you have?
How do you invite critism?
Communication - changing for good or bad? (Told about positive and negatives - privacy and data protection issue, trolling etc)
Right to expresssion?? (Told if it threatens law and order or violates fundamental right of other then it should be curbed)
But for that (to limit f.r. exp) the govt will require the data of the person (e.g. personal chat etc). So is surveillance reqd? (+ Counter questions)
M2:
Should we have whistle blower protection in pvt companies? Why?
How to deal with frivolous complaints? (I suggested to not allow anonymous complaints and bar or take action on repeat offenders.)
Counter question- then how to protect the whistleblower? More counter questions.
Why are we bailing out a pvt bank?
Isn't it against the principle of capitalism?
Why are we allowing pvt banks to operate if they are going to fail and govt will bail out?
M3:
Law authorities are not able to work. Do you agree. (Couldn't understand)
Then he explained - in situations like in Delhi, the law requires you to kill the leader of the mob, but the media says that you should shoot in the air etc. What will you do? (I was hesitant to say that I will shoot, tried to suggest alternatives - preventive detention).
But the situation requires you to shoot. What will you do? ( I said that if situation requires the authority can take any action permissionable under the law)
But the media is not allowing the authorities to work. There is media trial. Who should decide whether the action is right? ( I said courts)
Have you heard of Magisterial probe? What is it?
A counter question regarding Magistrate's judicial power.
M4
How much of national integration we have achieved after independence?
Can you name all 8 NorthEast states and their capital?
Do you think linguistic reorganisation of states was good?
Why Telangana was created despite both states speaking Telugu language?
Should Hindi be made national language? ( I said no)
What are constitutional provisions regarding it?
What happened in Pakistan and Srilanka when they tried to impose a language?
12th march
Dinesh. T
B.E in mechanical
Optional: Psychology
Hobby :Recreational cycling
College activity: NSS
Board B.S. Bassi
Last to go(6th)
chairman:
1. So your hobby is recreational cycling, whats the difference between other types?
2. What type of cycle?
3. What benefits did you gain?
4. Any adventerous stunts in cycles?
5. What happens if your safety in any activity is not guarenteed?
M1: (mam)
1. Your optional is psychology....why everyone feel comfortable and find it easy to learn it...many dont feel biology and physics easy
2. How is it useful?
3. You know about id, ego, superego of Freud...what are they?
M2:
1.There are many quotients like intelligent, emotional and spiritual quotient..whats the difference?
2. You are from mechanical..there also psychology is present in organisational research...where would you place intelligent and emotional quotient there? (Bit unclear)
M3:
1. In Tamilnadu water crisis why cant we use desalination like in arab countries? Or any other methods?
2. Which PM came to India with desalination plant offer in Gujarat?
3. Why politicians immediately shut down their social media accounts in case of issue?
4. Iam all for social media regulation...whats your take on it?
5. Is psychology an inadequete science?
6. What did you do in NSS?
7. What did you for technology based social work?
8. What did you teach the small children in computer?
9. What other tech based work did you do?
M4: (tried to stress me)
1. How is psychology adequete science?(continued from M3)
2. Is it on the same level as other basic sciences like physics etc...
3. No no how can say its adequete...(was stubborn)
4. Give me a study for how it is 100% adequete as in (reliability, validity, replicability....)
5. Do you believe in liberty?
6. Are you prohibitionist or anti prohibitionist?
7. Why should you prohibit liquor? Then shall i prohibit cycling?
8. Why can't i prohibit water?
Why can't i prohibit air?
9. Who are you to decide what i should drink or not?
10. Do you still believe in liberty?
11. Are you still prohibitionist?
12. Have you heard about renewable energy?
13. What about nuclear energy?
14. Which countries are major dependents of nuclear energy?
15. What is ISA and France's role?
16. In What stage the ISA in?
He asked few other questions couldn't remember.
Chairman:
Is this your photo?
Thank you you may leave.
The board was cordial and supportive.
Got a Bassi salute😜 at the end.
Those who gave interviews in last four weeks, plz take out some time today and write down your transcripts (at least questions) and share with us. Request you again.🙏🙏❤️😁😁 #Sharing_Is_Caring Share your transcripts @kaptaanjacksparrow @patriot_saint or @ddhankher
Sachin kumar dubey
Ma in history from Bhu varanasi
interest- active in student politics,,letter writing,, anchoring
optional-history
board - Sujata Mehta
date- 4th march
time-10.30 to 11.00
chairperson-what is Gandhi model of economics?
can we achieve 5trillion economy goal by Gandhi model?
is Gandhi relevant today?
importance of heavy industry and urbanisation in economy?
M1- all question from history..
1857 revolt
subhash chandra bose
veer savarkar
governor general of india
M2- questions on hobbies
should student politics disturb education?,
, should students allowed in student politics?
what is letter writing?
why do you write letters?
what is main characteristic of anchor?
what preparations should a anchor do before any function?
M3- relationship between industry and environment
success of ganga action plan
sanitation in UP
fund of swachch bharat mission in buget 2020
district wise comparison of sanitation in up
how will i make ganga pollution free ,if become DM of kanpur
M4- what is ease of doing business
what problem a entrepreneur faces?
importance of skill labour
how can we make skill India programme more successful?
How to connect rural market to urban market?
chairperson-any other question?
Me- no mam..
thank you....you can go now.. your interview is over..
3 out of 5 members were satisfied with my answers including chairperson...
chairperson was not happy only in 1 question...
rest 2 members were unsatisfied with me many answers