UPSC interview, T. C. A. Anant board, 3 Mar 2020 (PSIR)
3 Mar 2020
Board: TCA Anant Sir, 1 female + 3 male members, afternoon session
Date: 03/03/2020
Work Ex: IRS IT
Hobbies: Yoga, Learning Russian Language, Author
Optional: PSIR
Education: Mathematics
Chairperson: (reading educational qualifications and work exp)
Q. Why make the switch at the cost of losing seniority? (His tone made it look more like a concern rather than a real question. Member 3 even said that she would become CBDT Chairperson if she continues and others seemed to agree).
I gave a small and prepared answer to which he agreed and said that he doesn't want to discourage me from pursuing my dreams.
Q. Where are you posted?
(I told the location and the specific field of taxation I'm working in - Transfer Pricing)
Q. What exactly is Transfer Pricing? (Answered with an example of Royalties. Sir seemed real interested in understanding the basics of it)
Q. How do you determine the correct value of a transaction?
Sir seemed happy with answers related to Transfer Pricing and the whole Interview turned towards taxation and transfer pricing.
Member 1:
Q. So when you make the adjustment towards the Transfer Pricing, don't you think you're deterring the FDI in country?
(Very logical question as this is the exact complaint of the industry towards TP. thus, it was answered with facts, figures, the position of international law and Income Tax Act and Rules)
Q. What about the new tax slabs? Who will be benefitted? Is it just a window dressing?
(Again answered with facts)
Q. Hasn't your department become more of a revenue collector dept rather than a facilitator?
Member 1 seemed satisfied too.
Member 2:
Q. Why just Russian language and not any other?
Q. Would you like to get posted in Russia as IFS? (Sir's question was so long and my answer made everyone laugh when I said that my only choice is IAS :p)
Q. Tell us more about the book you're publishing? What's the subject?
(Here the Chairperson also intervened to ask the methodology of book, the answer went smoothly)
Q. What changes are being brought by govt to make e filing of Income Tax returns further easier for taxpayers? (Very specific question as changes were not announced in the speech but got inserted in the fine print of amendments of IT Act - answered to satisfaction of all)
Member 3:
Q. Has your book been published yet? If yes, I would have gone home with a copy? (Laughter in the room with a comment from Chairperson sir which I couldn't hear over the decibel levels :D)
Q. Why does IT department harass taxpayers so much? Don't you think you'll be shutting down businesses with such practices?
(Answered with statistics of scrutiny and assessment conducted by dept and state of economy)
Member 4:
Q. So are you saying that the selection process of a case or the CASS System (IRS based) is error free?
(Straightaway said - No, sir. It is not)
Q. So why isn't that a cause of concern?
When Member 4 was asking questions, Chairperson and Member 1 had some discussions. My guess is that they haven't asked me anything other than IRS.
Member 1 was given an opportunity again to pose questions.
Q. What else is govt doing to revive the economy? (I again started telling about tax - here they interjected that let's move away from taxation now.) ( I told FDI liberalisation?
Q. Then why isn't the FDI coming? (Explained with ranking in Enforcement of contracts)
Q. We have honored our contract in the AGR issue? (Didn't seem like a question - more like a remark - but I took it to take my point forward that it took 15 years to resolve which is precisely the problem of delays and uncertainties)
Interview ended. No formal declaration. Just "okay" by Chairperson.
Overall impressions:
1. I've attended more serious mock interviews than this panel. :D
2. Chairperson sir doesn't ask many questions himself but never loses interest in your answers. He keeps engaged when others are asking questions and even asks questions from there.
3. Diversity of questions was less. That could be because of the fact that Interview wasn't more than 20 minutes by any means and also the fact tha
t it was driven by answers I gave.
Ramya R
Bassi sir board
Tamilnadu
Ece , TCS, Swasth bharat prerak( poshan abhiyan)
Cp: Do you mimic everyone? ( out of the blue question) I said I can do a few
Do you cook everything? ( I can cook something)
So you were in ncc ( I said sir this is not my daf)
He then said oh sorry sorry then he took my daf
Speak about Artificial intelligence for two mins
M1: Why there is no silicon valley in india?
What about brain drain?
M2: what has happened with the telecom sector?
Do we need 5g in India?
M3: what did you achieve in poshan abhiyaan? ( daf)
What is bharat net?
How many villages have completed
M4: india is rich but with poor people : explain
Tamilnadu water scarcity problem
Cp: any other interpretation of m4 statement
Three things for rural development
Your interview is over
Is this your photo?
Notice:
Ramya R:
Sir One of the candidates called Aditya attended medical with me yesterday (03-03-2020) at lok nayak hospital. He hasn't signed some forms.
The hospital informed me today