UPSC interview, Sujata Chaturvedi board, 18 Feb 2020 (3)
18 Feb 2020
Shankaran
Board : Sujata Mehta
Date: 18th Feb FN
Optional : Economics
Degree: BE (EEE) in PSG Tech, Coimbatore
Work exp : Data Analyst for 1 year
Hometown : Hyderabad
Hobbies: Football and Running
CP
1. is this you in the photo
2. please briefly introduce yourself wrt your educational and professional background or work experience if any
3. you worked with a Data analytics firm right.So were most of your clients based out of India and did you work with multiple clients at the same time or you just associated with a single client alone at a time.
4. Could you please describe the project with each client
5. So what does data analyst do here and what's their role here and what algorithms and all you used.
Me:"(I didn’t understand what she really wanted). Told what kind of data we take from customers and social media. (Wasn’t satisfied with the answer. So she repeated the question again. ) So mentioned what kind of algorithm and model we chose and what do we with the data
6. Fair enough, tell me 2 applications where data analytics can be used in Public Sector.
Me: One, GST where govt is taking initiatives like setting up specialised wing. Second is health sector where we can understand gaps in rural areas and also collect imp data(like patient symptoms)to raise red flags before there is health crisis. ("Now since I mentioned rural, my whole interview veered towards rural areas especially other members")
7. That is all ok, but what's the point of all these data analytics if there is no data in rural areas since digital literacy is low.
Me: I agree with your point Mam. But govt is taking various initiatives like Bharatnet, digital India("She didn’t seem very happy mentioning govt programmes").
So I added- Mam, now we are witnessing that smartphone penetration is improving in rural areas. Also if we can make them understand the benefits of using internet by making them aware, then in near to medium term future, it is hoped that digital literacy would improve.
CP: She nodded.
M1:
1. your hobby is Football, so which club do you support.
2. So, currently what is their standing in PL Table
3. Your optional is Economics. So is Ricardian theory of Rent relevant in today's world
4. who sets the interest rate.
5. is frequent repo rate reductions good for India.
6. In India there is no indigenous search engines, data storage is a problem. What can be done ?
M2
1. What are the factors that inhibit growth in rural areas. Do cultural and traditional factor play a role
2. Don’t you think cultural factor play a major role in preventing growth in rural areas
3. why it is that education in rural areas is poor . What can be done especially for girl child?
4. (Mentioned pvt players can be roped in). So how would you encourage them?
5. Ok what measures would you take to bring in online education to rural areas.
M3
1. Given a choice, what would you choose a)set up higher education centres in rural areas or b) set up manufacturing with huge employment potential
2. Which field of education centres
should be brought in and in what areas should the focus be on
3. So what are the main areas of manufacturing in CBE
4. So how are they doing now and what are the major challenges they face ?
5. What are the factors that inhibit leveraging benefits of demongraghic dividend
M4
1. What is Project Tiger
2. What is Social Forestry
3. You know there are some states where they give free power. Is it a good idea and why ?
4. What is Finance commission and what is their role
5. Tell me why AP got bifurcated.
6. Why are we focusing on select regional areas like Mumbai, Chennai, Kolkata, Bluru, Delhi. Why not focus on other areas since these are already developed
CP. : Is there any question or areas left out of daf that you think we should ask you ? Ok your interview is over.
Overall felt cordial. But kind of felt Grilling on certain topics and followed up questions based on some keywords in my answers.
Manish
Sujata Mehta Board, 19/02/20.
Chairman: 1.Introduce yourself. 2.What you do in your free time. 3.My related questions like pre gst & post gst changes, challenges faced, experience, biggest challenge & how you tackled it.(no fact, figure or reform needed asked). In some replies she cross-questioned.
4. View on GM crops, cross question.(out of my hobby- vegetable farming)
M1:-1.Opinion on politicians revising their salaries by passing bills in Parliament while govt. servants get their salaries revised after a decade via. Pay commissions. ( bcz of my 6 years of govt. service).
2.lot of people come to delhi & create pressure on urban amenities & urban planning.(Cross questioned it upto 2 levels)
3.who is your favourite bureaucrat & why?
M2. 1.What you grow?
2. What is waste to energy concept?
3.How to tackle land fills problem? What is bioremediation & biominning?
M3: 1.How to serve in badminton?
2.As an Administrator, how will you promote badminton as a sport in India? (Cross questioned upto 2 levels)
3. As an administrator, how to promote female adolsence health? (Cross questioned it upto 2 levels) only current affairs baed applied ques.
Chairman again:
1. View on terminator seeds.some other questions ( not able to recall)
M4: 1. End of Inspector raj as claimed by various finance ministers, issues of tax assesses harassment .
2. What is operant conditioning? Who gave the concept?
3. What is your opinion on IQ? cross questioned.
4. Today, in new forms of communication, cases of espionage & surveillance is increasing. Comment
Chairman: Anything you want to ask or tell.
Your interview is over.
Disclaimer: Around 75-80 % of
questions.
Observation: DAF based questions, more focus on experiences in my case.
P
interview board- R N Choubey
date-24 feb 20
optional -Anthropology
edu- btech-cse, mba(business economics)
hobby- reading, trekking
job- pertains to agri trade
C- tell me about yourself?
what is soil health card?
what is pmfby?
do you think it is successful? what is the need for soil health card?
dont remember 1 more question
M1-lady- what is precision agriculture? what is quantum computing? what did you not like in btech? what would you like to change?
M2- why did you take anthropology? what did anthropology teach you?
AGR-telcom? many counter questions
case study-what if your subordinate commits a mistake while writing a report which you forwarded to the senior. He presented the report and appreciated you. Later you come to know about it?
M3- issues of economy? why rural consumption demand is poor?
Trekking, its effect on environment and solution? which right is the most imp right as per you?
M4- immunity available to governor?
what is gvc? gvc in food products?
multiple state capitals-views?
2-3 questions i forgot that M2 and M4 asked.
Very cordial board esp the chairman
Prashant sagar
Satyawati Board :
Afternoon : 5th to go
Prashant Sagar
IRS IT
Hobbies : Poetry , story writing etc
Chairperson : Read out the DAF for almost 5 minutes, with me correcting in between.
Chairperson : Discussion on abolishing Taxation. With Cross questions.
Member 1 :
Have u heard of Malinowski?
Heard of redcliffe brown?
Why do we have ILP even today ? Why not integrate them.
Name a thinker of jurisprudence (that I don't remember)
Member 2 :
Do you remember anything of engineering?
Discussion on location of my village.
Tell me about your priorities in Jehanabad?
How will you ensure attendance of doctors?
Next preference?
What about law and order?
Don't you think you should keep it first. What about hero worship habit in Bihar?
Member 3)
Difference between murder and homicide.
Difference between dacoity and robbery.
Dacoity still being prevalent
Constitution and constitutionalism
China has constitutionalism or not.
Member 4 :
Tell me about dastangoi
Do you go to mushairas
What is different in dastangoi?
Origin of dastangoi
4R in water conservation
Give example of Reuse and recycling
Give it related to water.
Dr Akr
Interview Transcript CSE 2019
Board- Smita Nagraj
Date of Interview - 24.02.2020
Amit, MBBS,
Home state - Bihar
Optional- Anthropology
6th attempt, 4th interview
Medical officer for 8 yrs in Bihar
Currently in ICLS based on CSE 2016
CH- How are you?
You still working as medical officer or left?
How do you like ICLS?
Big leap from medicine to ICLS..why did you decide to join civil service?
Bihar is lacking on most fronts. What is it that you think is not working for Bihar.
What are the 3 reasons according to you?
What is the one thing that you would say did improve at the PHC you were working at during your time there?
What would be one thing that you would have liked to work on to improve service based on your experience?
M1- Have you heard of IBC? What is it? How far do you think it has helped the Companies and the banks? Have you read a balance sheet?
Where is the share capital mentioned.. Asset side or liability side? What is it for the owners? (I kept saying it is a liability for the company, he kept asking what is it for the owners? In the end he said he wanted to here that the company was a separate legal entity and the BS was for the company and not the individual and said " you are the expert in the field so you should have said this")
M2- situation in China..why do you think China is not letting Indian Aircraft carry supplies to and evacuate its citizens from there?
Do you think situation is worsening or improving?
Mohalla clinic- your views about it..
Do you think this concept would help improve the situation in Bihar if implemented there?
M3- You worked 8 yrs as medical officer, then you joined this service, now you are appearing again..do you think its worth losing so many years of seniority for? ( Was grilled on this.. shared my personal reason then he said 'I understand your decision')...
Its not necessary you wilI get IAS..What if you get postal service or something like that? (He relented when I pointed out that I have filled IAS and IFS only)
M4- You have mentioned you sing..what kind of songs do you like to sing?
Which Raga would suit the situation of this interview?
On a serious note... ibc.. why do you think ibc was brought? What has been the performance?
Telecom sector.. your views.. is it going to impact economy? How?
Ch- continuing with telecom sector, is it something similar to what happened to aviation sector?
What should the government do? Should we be liberal? Or should we intervene or let them be?
Why shouldn't we leave them? New players will come and replace them, isn't it?
Name- Manish Kumar
Date of interview- 24.02.2020 (afternoon session).
Profile- Schooling in Kendriya Vidyalaya, B.Tech in VNIT, Nagpur (Civil engineering), worked in IOCL for 1.5 years, currently working in CWC (for last 4.5 years).
Hobbies- Cricket follower.
Chairman of board- Air Marshal Ajit Bhonsle sir
Chairman
Read out the DAF loudly and said- So, you have studied in Kendriya Vidyalaya, Bhusawal, then went to VNIT and have now worked for 7 years.. you have a good profile..
1. So, we hear a lot that 70% of our cities are going to go dry by 2040.. by that time, availablity will be 50% of demand.. So tell me the steps you would give for Water conservation in long term, medium term and short term approach
2- tell me features of jal mission.. I asked sir Jal Jeevan mission or jal Shakti mission?? He said jal Shakti..
3. Is the aim of govt to provide piped drinking water a pipe dream??
Passed on to M-1 (lady member)
1. So migration is a lot in news .. What are your views??
2. So you feel that migration is necessary and good??
3. But what about pressure on resources??
4. Tell me some countries which have seen lot of migration in recent times..
5. Why we are stil not adopting rainwater harvesting on a large scale?
M-2
1. Why do you want to join civil services??
2. So there's no diversity in your job?
3. What us preamble??
4. Preamble is a lot in news these days.. why??
5. What are the features that are in danger??
6. In which year secularism was added in preamble??
7. Any other words were added??
M-3
1. What is V in VNIT??
2. Tell me something about Visvesvaraya..
3. So, he was awarded Bharat Ratna.. India's highest honour.. tell me name of one IAS officer who was awarded Bharat Ratna..
4. No one?? So you have lots of scope to serve as a civil engineer too , isn't it so??
M-4
1. So, you have studied political science.. tell me what's in communist manifesto and its author.. (only told Karl Marx and said don't know about its contents)
2. Tell me about Friedrick Engels.. (cudnt recall) :|
3. Tell me name of some communist countries in the world..
4. What is constitution??
5. So, a country cannot run if constitution is not there??
6. Yes.. Britain is running without a written constitution.. correct
Chairman-
So what do you plan to do after interview?? (Told him sir no plans as such.. wanted to watch highlights of today's day in India new Zealand but India already lost.. so, will watch India vs Bangladesh in women's world cup)..
Chairman smiled and said.. you may go.
Overall, board was cordial.. may have missed 1-2 questions..