UPSC interview, Bharat Bhushan Vyas board, 19 Feb 2020
19 Feb 2020
Name : Anil Kumar
Hometown : Churu, Rajasthan.
Background : Computer Science & Engineering, MNIT Jaipur.
Service Experience : Software Engineer with Samsung India Electronics Limited.
Optional : Geography
Hobby : Watching and playing Cricket, Teaching, Reading Non-fiction.
Interview Date : 19th feb 2020 (First to go in the Afternoon Session).
Interview Panel Chairperson : Bharat Bhushan Vyas Sir.
Chairperson:
1. Do you feel the weight of UPSC Chair ? (Pointing to my gentle sliding of Chair when offered the seat and smilingly saying you can push it harder too).
2. What were you doing after resigning your job ? (Asked while reading out my DAF information regarding graduation and service experience).
3. What is Census and how it is helpful in policy making ?
->What is so special about this year's census? (1-2 follow up questions on my response).
->Why is it conducted in phased wise manner and separate enumeration of houses & headcount of population?
->Link between Census exercise and current NPR ?
4. What is SCO ? Do you think it is just an other multilateral organization without serving any important purpose for securing India's national interests ?
(1-2 follow up questions with regard to China, Indo-pacific and IRC).
Member 1: (Almost all questions asked from Hobby Section)
1. Question from Hobby section...(Reading Non-fiction)...which books you have read recently?
->Listed 2-3 books ( 'A Gentleman Spymaster : R N Kao' , '21Lessons for 21st Century', 'Everybody Loves a Good Drought').
2. Questions asked related to the book '21Lessons for 21st Century'
->What all lessons did you got from the book?
->Do you subscribe to author's point of view with regard to future scenarios discussed in the book?
->Various Schools of thought on Artificial Intelligence (AI) technology?
-> Is regulating AI in present time necessary to curtail future repercussions of this technology?
-> What is India doing to reap benefits of AI and other similar Industry 4.0 technologies?
3. What is Secularism concept ? Is mentioning the word 'Secular' makes our constitution secular in its spirit ? Are you aware of any debate on secularism in india ? What is your view on all this debate ?
4. What is Institutional Memory? (Context : With reference to the book 'A Gentleman Spymaster: R N Kao').
-> 1-2 follow up questions about R.N.Kao and R&AW.
Member 2(Lady Member):
She also kept all discussion related to my hobby section, i.e. Teaching.
1. What all teaching experiences do you have till date ?
2. How do you adjust the teaching methodologies while switching from school level to college level students ?
3. Do you think that urban students require same kind of educational and teaching strategies as that of rural students?
4. Suppose you are a school principal in a rural locality, then what will be your priorities for betterment of education in that area?
5. How do you assess the Right to Education(RTE) Act with regard to its efficacy of fulfilling the objectives of the act ?
6. Did all your knowledge or information regarding teaching pedagogy in india comes from theoretical studies or some ground level experiences from rural, tribal and urban areas?
Member 3:
1. You have Geography as your optional subject and Rajasthan as home state, then tell me the role of geography as the contributing factor in backwardness or non-development of Rajasthan?
2. Questions on Arawali Range...Its Climatic impact on Rajasthan, Illegal mining happening in Rajasthan and recent supreme court directives on this.
->Suppose you are the DM of a district that involves illegal mining under your jurisdictional area, what will be your priorities to curb the same?
3. Do you think that the MNCs have not contributed enough in growth and development of Indian economy in its manufacturing and services sector ?
(Context : Question generated out of conversation while discussing my service experience in Samsung India Electronics Limited).
4. Samsung's investment plans in next 4-5 years in india.
Member 4:
1. Why you choose geography as your optional despite having t
echnical bac
kground ?
2. What benefits geography offers to an administrator in governance and policy making ?
3. Simultaneous Elections of LokSabha and State Assemblies...Pro, Cons and your opinion on the issue.
-> 1-2 follow up questions on Elections and ECI.
4. Do you know about recent Locust Attack in India?
->Is Rajasthan suffering from this attack ?
->Which region of Rajasthan under attack ?
->Any suggestion to curb this?
Chairperson :
1. Have you heard about Green Crackers? Is such initiatives are sustainable in curbing air pollution in india?
2. Suppose you are the government nominee in Monetary Policy Committee (MPC), what will you recommend about the stance of policy rate cuts ?
-> 1-2 follow up questions about recent slowdown in economy, rise in inflation and issues in Monetary Policy transmission.
Chairman : Our conversation is going quite interesting but have to wind up due to time constraints. Your interview is over now.
Overall Experience:
-> 30-35 minutes interview...Very nice and pleasing experience.
-> BB Vyas Sir was quite cool, composed and interactive...Helped in maintaining my confidence and energy level throught out the conversation.
->Panel members asked questions from almost all sections...although 2 members heavily focussed on hobby section.
->Bottomline: Prepare your DAF quite diligently.
I hope this will help to all those who are yet to go through the interview process or the near future aspirants.
P.S. : Sharing the interview transcript with delaying of 2-3 days because of certain other commitments.
Ajinkya Patil
Chairman - P.K.joshi
Date - 17 feb , afternoon hrs - 4.05 - 4.35
Optional - Geography , BE mechanical
Hobbies - Watching Football and match analysis.
Extra curricular - Event for Acid attack victims , drought relief work - Paani foundation
Chairman - Why did you choose mechanical engineering and then why the turn towards civil services ?
C - Do you think technical domain will help you in generalistic civil services ?
C - As a geography student tell me the difference between geography and geology ?
C - tell me about the evolution of himalayas and shiwaliks ?
M1 - You are DM of the district. How will you address the case of mob lynching ?
M1- what are problems of vidarbha and marathwada ? Do you think separate vidarbha demad is the solution ?
M1- Swami vivekananda's quote about football . Do you know it ?
M1- What is India's rank currently in football ?
M2- What is the meaning of your name ?
M 2 - You are from the technical background. What do you think are the necessary changes in make in India programe and skill development ?
M2 - As geography student tell me about the significance of Tibet and POK for India ?
M2 - Why Is India lacking in football and not cricket ?Can you name Some states known for football ?
M2 - chappak movie ? What message it gave and why did it did not became successful ?
M2 - Tell me about the contribution of Mahatma Phule and Shahu maharaj.
M2- Tell me something about Maharashtra - Karnataka border dispute.
M 3 - What are the reasons for economic slowdown in our country ?
M3 - how will you increase the investment in the economy ?
M3 - Do you think corporate tax cuts has really lead to infusion of money in the economy ?
M3- Why are foreign countries reluctant to invest in Manufacturing sector ?
M4 - You come from Karad. Tell me about karad in 3-4 lines.
M4 - How will you stop the sale of acids ?
M4 - Do you know Beed district ? What is it known for ?
Hint - lowest sex ratio . What do you think are the reasons ? How can the female foeticide be addressed ?
M4 - Sugarcane is a water guzzling crop ? Why is it being promoted still ? Why is govt not moving away from sugarcane ?
Thankyou
Rahul Reddy
Bhim sain bassi board
Chairman-
Very welcoming and greeted in telugu ‘’Mr Reddy Kurchondi”
1.Came directly to point-Why do you want to join cs
2.Being mechanical engineer tata ashok leyland pays you lot of money why not that?
3.are you coming for that power dadagiri and all?
4.chalo if i dont give you car ,half of salary will you still serve?
Member 1
1. What are we referring to when we say war targets and what do our forces target?
2.tell me about uav and manned vehicle difference
3 what are the strategies adopted by army at border
4 what are other applications of uav
5 tell me abt narayana junior clg and type of teaching there
6 did it help in your mechanical engg
M2- lady -she was facing chairman and looking behind to ask qstns
1 tell me about ne insugency
2 forest rights act
3 no of tribals in telangana
4 what is vipassana(daf)
M3- cordial of everyone
1 what is trickle down economics
2 what is alternative theory
3 what is welfare economics
4 what must state adopt
5 what is karting
6 what exactly did you do
7 do you drive in an race
M4 - his voice was very low could not even listen qstn
1 not able to listen said sorry sir i cant hear- he skipped the question
2 what is thermo couple
3 new development has come in painting tell me
Chairman sir- final authenticity check
1 what did you do as a traffic commando
2 tell me date time and year
He said Thank you- i was still in mood of interview did not leave-he told to leave politely🤐
Stopped me again , showed my photo and asked if it is me #bassithings
Overall board was cordial.