UPSC interview, Manoj Soni board, 13 Feb 2020
13 Feb 2020
Anurag Mishra
Date: 13th Feb 2020, Afternoon Session (1st to go)
Dr. Manoj Soni board
Background: BS-MS from IISER, Pune. Worked for a year each in NCBS, Bangalore and in Zurich (both research positions in ecology)
Chairman (extremely cordial)
1. So you studied in IISER. How is the education at IISER different from traditional colleges where they offer BSc and MSc?
2. What was your research topic in Zurich?
3. Why did you leave Zurich, if it isn’t too personal a question.
4. Don’t you think the country is losing a person trained in sciences?
5. That too, biology is a need of the hour. We are having BSc Biotechnology, but I feel unless you know both biology and technology, how will you do Biotechnology?
6. Is a career in research still open for you?
M1 (poker face, seemed a bit disinterested)
1. What is Eutrophication? (I had mentioned Lakes in my work experience). What nutrients cause Eutrophication?
2. What are the types of Lakes?
3. What are the different layers in a lake ecosystem?
4. Which stage of succession in a lake has the highest biodiversity?
5. Why does elephant give 1-2 progeny, but mosquitos give million? Give the evolutionary basis, not genetic basis.
6. What are r and K selected species? Will you find r-selected or K-selected species in stable ecosystems?
M3
1. Have you interacted with Forest Department? Here I said no, but with Bugun when I did work in Eaglenest Wildlife Sanctuary.
2. I have friends in Forest Dept. They don’t seem to do anything scientific? How do you think your background will help?
3. Are you aware of the evolution of methodologies of tiger survey in India (I said only in the last few years, he did not pursue it further)
4. What do you think of the numbers being thrown out in Tiger Census? Do they mean anything?
5. If I tell you a forest has 10 tigers, as a DFO what other information would you ask me? Is the number all that is important? (This went a lot back and forth. At one point I thought we were discussing tiger census)
6. What animals do you photograph (wildlife photography written in my hobbies).
7. Ok tell me if I have a plantation how do I improve the productivity?
M4
1. Nicely set up questions about Odisha, asking how many years I have lived there etc. .. Have you seen a Paddy Field? How doe it look? When is sowing and harvesting done?
2. Why is there problem of hunger in Odisha?
3. Odisha is a classic complicated case of forests-tribals-mining complex issue. What do you think?
4. What is govt doing for agriculture and to remove hunger?
5. What are the schemes for tribals in Odisha?
6. Have you seen Dugong? (No.) Ok tell me something about Dugong (herbivore, found in Gulf of Mannar, feeds on sea grass). Where is Gulf of Mannar? Do you know there is a water body called Dugong Creek in Andamans? You should go to Andamans, there is a Bbsr to Port Blair direct flight (I said there is from Kolkata). He again stressed I must visit Andamans.