UPSC interview, Manoj Soni board, 28 Feb 2018
28 Feb 2018
Shivanand
B. A. Political Science
Dr. Manoj Soni Panel
Afternoon Sesson
First to be interviewed
Medium of Interview- Marathi
Entered and greeted well, asked to sit.
CM- Shivanand, how would you like to communicate? We have a Translator for you. You can opt for any medium.
Me- Thank you sir. I would try to speak in English for better discussion, but sometimes I may need help of Hindi/Marathi. Would that be fine, sir?
CM- yes, sure. So lets start.
You graduated in Pol Sci in 2012. What kept you going since then?
Me- told about 2 interviews in first 2 attempts. Told about my selection as Asst. BDO through MPSC.
CM- So you are a BDO now?
Me- No sir. Resigned after a month’s training to focus upon Civil Service preparation.
CM- surprised.. confirmed if I have resigned or taken any Extension.
OK. You pursued so many activities during these years. ( Read out- Worked for sex workers, communal harmony, etc). Tell me about Psephology thing that you did before Punjab elections in 2017.
Me- Told about our 4 days Punjab tour.
Subsequent questions on this.
Member 1- Asked about Naxalism in Maharashtra- why, where, its nature.
Asked difference between Kashmir situation, North East militancy and Central India’s Naxalite movement.
Have you heard about Surgical Strikes? Tell me about it.
M2 Lady member- What Nanded (hometown) is famous for?
A few questions on Guru Gobind Singh, Gurudwara construction, Maharaja Ranjit Singh..
Can you think of any link between IPRs and Film industry? (Hobby- watching short films)
Told about copyright issue.
Asked economic impact of its violation on film industry.
Told about scripts and music related things, their misappropriation and ultimate loss, etc.
But she wanted more. I said Right now Im recalling this only! She said OK.
M3- ( He was talking too slow and too long) How come you arranged these SC-ST students Interaction Camps? Where?
Problems of these girls? Solutions?
Why SC-STs still lag behind even after having so many schemes and constitutional provisions?
As a DM what would be your priority towards their empowerment. Told about Education.
M1- What was your observation about Drug Menace in Punjab? Is it a reality?
Initially told about unemployment, stagnancy in Agri etc. He said these things are everywhere. Then I told about the Supply Side, Neighbouring nation’s hand.
He asked have met any Drug Addict there? NO!
Told about my interactions with Locals in Punjab and their admission of the problem.
CM- Tell me again what prompted you to visit Punjab only?
Udta Punjab, Drugs issue, curiosity of how a new party (AAP) is getting momentum there.
Who financed the tour?
Where did you report your observations?
(Explained Informal nature of our tour, no institutional backup; Reporting- written blogs on it!)
M4- Tell about State funding of Elections. How would it facilitate our election process. Can it eliminate money power in elections?
I was explaining, but he was not happy. Then I started in Hindi and explained with more clarity. Told about combination of efforts for fair elections- electoral bonds, parties undee RTI etc.
OK. If you are posted as DM in Punjab, how would you tackle Drug problem?
Short term- identify and check on supply side; Long term- youth, jobs, etc
Lady member- What was your prediction and actual result?
Told her how we failed in our prediction.
CM- Its really appreciative that you quit your Govt job to pursue Civil Services and these activities.
Now tell me as an Administrator what would be your FIRST priority among your own activities? Would it be working for sex workers or communal harmony or anything else?
I said Its Communal Harmony!
Why so?
Social fabric, hurdle in our development process.
How?
Platforms like Mohalla committee .. explained.
OK Shivanand, on our part, your interview is over.
Is there anything that we should ask you OR anything you wish to tell something?
Me- Sir, I compose music. Currently I am working on a short film named “Bahishkrit” which is based on Social Boycott Law enacted by Govt of Maharashtra. May I sing 2 lines from the film!!??
(The CM seeme
d taken aback for a moment. Mam was smiling. )
CM- yes yes, sure.
Had some water with his permission.
I started-
हुआ क्या है आज हमको ये कहाँ हम जा रहे है
मंजिले तो गुम हुई है रास्ते भी खो रहे है
हुआ क्या है आज हमको..
I stopped. Everybody was looking at me.
CM- Well Shivanand, I had told your interview was over. But before you go, do tell me 3 positives of India.
Me-
1. Demographic Dividend- billion+ minds.
2. Unity in Diversity- “India a living museum of cultural diversity”- Iran Prez
3. Resources- if utilized them propery, we would a Developed Nation very soon.
CM- OK Shivanand. Your interview is over now.
आपको भविष्य के लिये बहूत शुभकामनाये !
Greeted all and left the room with smile.
CSE 2017 interview.
Smitha Nagaraj mam board
Date 28-02-2018
Background - Public administration optional, civil engineer by graduation , work ex nill, native of coimbatore, tamilnadu, cricket as playing sport.
Chairman - Tell me what coimbatore is famous for? Palghat gap? Wind energy in TN? Wind energy negatives? solar energy potential? Status of roof top solr? How to make it effective? Fossil fuel vs green energy? ( all these were either from DAF or based on follow up questions)
Member 1 - why are engineers in india not of good quality? How to improve employability? Why engineers dont want to do low level jobs? Do they think they are over qualified? Should diploma make mandatory before engineering? Why is there craze for white collar jobs?
Member 2 - status of agri R&D in india? Why no investments in research? Can GM help food security? Take on GM food crops? Politician bureaucracy face off? What should a bureaucrat do when he is coerced by politician to do him a favor?
Member 3 - name 3 leading FDI contributors to india last year? how such a small nation like maldives can pump in FDI? recent move by govt to plug round tipping? How does DTAA work? name two changes in present Indian cricket culture to make it win the world cup?
Member 4 - Honesty or efficency, which is desirable for civil servant? How is stand up comedy spreading in india? Can BCCI give up 25% of its revenue to support other sports? Will india win world cup? Name 3 pace bowlers for world cup ? Why didnt you include Umesh yadhav ( purely DAF based)
Chairman - what is your take on identify politics? Should it be encouraged? Why is it still thriving in the era of globalization?
Thank you. You may leave. Let's hope india wins the world cup ( everyone were laughing for that statement including myself ) .
Interview time - 35 minutes approx.
Very cordial board but wide range of questions really tested my resilience and spontaneity. Fumbled at times but managed to keep it going.
Background (IIT BHU (Varanasi), Computer Science, Samsung R&D Bangalore Software Engineer, Mathematics Optional, Bihar Home State, CAPF Assistant Commandant Topper)
Chairman (Dr. P.K. Joshi) Forenoon 28 Feb 2018. 3rd candidate.
How much marks did you get in Maths Class XII?
Which force have you been alloted?
Why SSB?
When we have BSF as a border guarding force, why need SSB?
Suppose you are posted as a DM in a village school and asked to address students of Class VIII- XII, what would you speak about for promoting Maths which students don't like?
Maths Question 1
Maths Question 2, 2(a)
Member 1 (Lady member)
Munger is famous for? (Came as a shocker for me because I am from Saharsa, Bihar)
Do you do Yoga?
What is the status of women in Bihar? Do you think women has been empowered in your state?
What is accountable governance?
How to ensure government accountability?
Member 2
What was the project you worked upon in Samsung? Two follow up questions
What is the state of R&D in India?
What is the need of high end R&D when our basic skill needs are unmet?
Member 3
Should we go for making strong laws to provide security to women?
Are laws against Dowry enough? Why are they being misused? What are recent changes in Dowry law?
Situational Question: Your domestic help comes to you and complains to you about her drunkard husband who comes from work and beats her under the influence of alcohol. What would be your step of action?
Member 4
What was the earlier name of BHU?
Who founded it?
Who gave the money?
Who founded AMU and when?
Dont you think that the British sowed the seeds of division by helping the setup of a Hindu University and a Muslim university?
Why is Varanasi named so?
Why is IIT BHU not doing too good? (Asked in Hindi)
Wht is Kashi famous?
What is 3rd Industrial Revolution, 2nd IR and 1st IR.
No Questions on Hobbies. Cordial board. Last Member was intimidating.
Time Duration: 30minutes
ketan:
Arvind saxena. 27 feb AN
Which newspaper, why, migration from india as brain drain, gdp n measure of inequality, decline in cattle trade,
Polio what, why pulse mode, (daf)
Skills, jobs, adhar, bank privatization, why psb have high npa, why tax necessary,
zoology, bharatpur ecosystem, zoology syllabus and proposed cut down of syllabus, bt cotton,
Padmavat, jauhar, khilzi, neemrana, south korean n japanese, tourism, ghg, biodiversity and climate change.
[28/02, 15:17] Keerthi: Keerthishri IRS CCE:
Transcript
Chairman read out my daf before me. Clarified some details.
1. Questions on urban development and state of planning in india
2. Hall of nations demolition ... Pragati maindan..
These are related to my daf.
What are u comfortable in ? Ir economy or sports
I chose IR.
1. What do u think about the diplomatic isolation of pakistan.
My answer was on the lines that we have been engaging with pakistan diplomatically. Gave ajit doval bangkok meet and kabul meet
Do u watch tv debates discussions about pakistan.. i said i have no access to tv. He said u must be reading newspapers... Pakistan has been shown in negative light . Have you come across any positive report .. tell about it
Chairman also asked about rain water logging and floods... ways to deal ,
[28/02, 15:18] Keerthi: Keerthishri IRS CCE:
Member 1
I guess it was based on hobby
Tourism in india... Which places attract people the most.
How do we diversify
Other than economic benifits what do we get from tourism.. i said national integration and he said what from foreign tourists.
I said forex. People ties.. helps in future diplomatic engagement as people are familiar with other nationals...
Member 2
Difference between architecture and civil engineering.
Is an architect necessary or sufficient condition.
Opinion polls and exit polls.. science behind exit polls(dint answer this science). Are these authentic.
Member 3
Service related.
1. Tax reforms i can suggest
2. Good smuggling
3. Norms for gold entering india
4. Golden triangle
Member 5.
Bangalore women safety
Bangalore averse to outsiders
Women and pub future
[28/02, 15:21] Keerthi: Member 2
What do you think about education of lawmakers? Which organisations are working on these lines
Board bassi
Chairman
Block chain , cross questioning and conversation on the same topic
M1
Role of RBI in monetarily policy
How things are done
What are the tools
How all this affects growth of the country
Role of RBI in banking sector
Pnb fraud who all responsible
Role of RBI
Diff btw LoU and LC
Chabahar port and its importance
M2
What is the issue with land records modernisation program
How tech can help
M3
What is sir creeks issue and counter questions
What else can bsf do etc
What is the siachen issue and related questions
Size of siachen glacier
Malacca strait
China’s importance for it
What percentage of chinese goods pass through it
M4
Question on a recent railwat committee (debroy) and it’s recommendations
What is the biggest challenge for railways among the recommendations
Chairman
Related to merger of services in railways...long conversation and grilled me a bit on this
Thankyou
Amit Punde
Date of interview 27th February
Graduation: B Tech Production
PG: MA Sociology
Optional : Sociology
Hobbies: reading, trekking, traveling
Chairman Bassi Sir
C:
so u r a production engg. What is mechatronix?
Applications?
As a shopfloor manager, what are your priorities?
Who will benefit with the increased efficiency?
M1;
He talked some 2 points about efficiency and then then questions abt trekking.
Where do you trekked recently?
Some discussion on Youth Hostel trek at Manali.
If anything happened where you could not complete the trek? I gave example of Alang fort.
M2:
Iran president visit to India and the message India gave through this in the light of various sanctions imposed by US?
Why farmers suicide in maharashtra?
Dose present budget provisions would impact positively?
Maharashtra karnataka boundary issue?
What can be done?
M3: lady member.
Role of Pune in 1857 war.?
What about other maratha sardars?
Rani of zansi and her relation to Pune.?
Love hate relationship of Pune with Rajneesh(Osho) in 1970s?
china's policy in South Asia.?
Is china aggressive towards India?
Why China aggressive towards India.?
What do you think whether China become superpower?
Plus points of China and USA to become superpower?
US relations with South America states?
Impact of lower sex ratio?
After Nirbhaya case, what change do u find in Indian Society?
M4:
Indo Japan relations.? What are Japan's interests in India?
In the present scenario what is the probability that India will win a war against Pakistan..? (He wanted answer in a mathematical probability range from 0 to 1)
Where is Tista river?
What is the issue?
What are the immediate benefits and to whom?
Thank you.
Manoj Soni Board
27-2-2018
Background- Punjab, civil engineering, Anthropology
Hobbies- Squash, Bhangra, Rubik's cube
C- Are you comfortable in talking about census? What is census? Who does it? When started? How is the exercise done?
Have u read the latest census?
What are the key takeaways?
U r missing imp point about youth.
Demographic dividend?
Is situation of skilling up to mark?
Make in India, Digital India. What will they do if we don't have skills?
3 things that u have learnt from 2015 to 2018 during prep time?
Were these things not there in u before?
M1- Women are only proxies. Ur experience of reservation in PRIs? What needs to be done?
drug problem in Punjab. Reasons, 2 most important steps that u'll take after becoming DM of ur distt
Since u r from Punjab. Which all regions were partitioned?
Only Bengal and Punjab? No other region in NE?
Was Burma partitioned from British India?
M2- Why so many graduates unemployable?
What needs to be done?
diff bw civil in IITD, DTU and any other state university?
M3- why different colours on squash ball?
Name world class squash players of subcontinent.
Govt spending so much on IITs thinking that they need engineers. Don't u think u'll waste resources of govt by coming in civil services?
How will u use ur knowledge of engg. in indian postal services?
U have learnt only analysis in IIT?
So u think that it is right to come to civil services from IIT?
Radcliffe line? Macmohan line? Is macmohan line accepted? On what principle was it drawn?
Where all face-offs bw India and China?
Should we stop trading with China?
Any country where people voluntarily not buying products of another country?
Not heard of Japan and US?
Why Japan could rebuild it's infrastructure after WW2?
Why India is not doing even having huge resources? Compare with Japan? Use ur analytical bent of mind.
Why Japanese so skilled?
M4- are new IITs and IIMs diluting the brand name of old IITs and IIMs?
Why so less skilled personnel in India?
What needs to be done?
Should we impose some restrictions on freedom of speech and expression? 1-2 follow up questions
Should we ban social media?
But There is so much misuse of social media. Shouldn't we ban social media?
What can be done to reduce misuse of social media?
C- if u r very senior bureaucrat and govt made a policy which u think is not good. That policy is against ur convictions and u think that policy is also against public interest and national interest.
Will u implement that policy?
Your interview is over. Thanku
Totally random Interview.
Time: around 30 minutes
Board member : Ms Smita Nagaraj
Vijayendra R ( interview date 28/02/2018)
serving currently in IRS IT
Optional : Anthropology
Time around 5:15 to 5:50 pm
Last to go among all boards😊
Chairman :
It's already two years in Service don't you think going to IAS you will have career disadvantage ?
Where you posted currently ? Don't you think compared to department , private people have better competence in AAR ?(job related )
What did you do in social welfare activities ?
M1:
How many genes avg human have ?
Which is smallest and largest gene ?
How do genes vary ? ( he was particular about SLP ) I knew a bit , it was more technical so did not venture into it .
Who is No 1 tennis player now ? What's so great about federer even now ? Why is tennis not that popular in India ? What challenges it face ? Do you think politics in apex tennis association is affecting its development ?
M2
What is AFSPA ? Do you thing it's violation of human rights ? Do you think it's needed in j&k ?
Police reforms ? Do you think police has colonial mindset ? Why no reform taken ? Prakash singh police reforms ? Do you think police is more of political service than public service ?
M3:
Why is today special ? ( It was national science day )
What is your view on Karnataka flag issue ?
M4:
What is APA ? ( job related )
Why do we have APA n AAR is it not overlapping ?
What is your view on women's cricket ? Who is the women cricketer who made a difference in semifinal in women's world cricket ?
Chairman ( last )
In Bangalore so many issues Gauri lankesh , Tipu sultan , and so on ? Why is it , what is your view ?
Then tipu sultan ? What you view ? Do we need to have critical thinking in school two to three views ? We just follow what is taught ?
Do you think we need critical thinking in department as well ?
You interview is over .
It was overall balanced and mix of daf, job and gs , both opinion and issue based !!
Goodluck those still left with Interview !
Bassi Sir Panel
27th Feb Morning
Around 30 mins
Ch : Mangesh , You have done electronics engineering an having political science optional also currently working in Bank. ( And Looked at me)
I said "Yes Sir" ( I thought he is checking my confidence).
Tell me about Venezuela crisis
Tell me about Yemen crisis
Developments in Nepal. Why Nepal important for us ?
M1 : different frequency band in communication ? Many subsequent technical questions
1G 2G 3G 4G difference
GSM vs CDMA ? Why CDMA not popular over GSM . Anything to do with licencing ?
M2 : use of robotics in Army ?
Introduction of robotics vs job losses. Opinion
Why Afghanistan unstable? What are sectarian divisions ? Why not normalcy restored
M3 (Madam): why demand for Marathwada statehood? Reasons.
Difference between Marathwada movement and Vidarbha movement for statehood .
Similarity between Marathwada and Telangana demand.
What are disadvantages of adverse sex ratio ? To men and to women?
Why development in Bangladesh important for India?
Role of India diaspora.
M4 : what is exposure of SBI in recent PNB fraud?
Tell me about PNB fraud ?
Who should bear loss of it ?
What was wrong on part of other banks ? Their mistakes
Difference between LC and LoU .
What is NPA ? Steps taken for its resolution ?
What is insolvency and bankruptcy code ? Detailed discussion
Ch : tell me about Pradhan Mantri Fasal Bima Yojana ? Details of it
Talk on MSP . Talk more. Any committee on it
Is this your photo ? It's lovely photo Mangesh.
Thank you.
Promoth P:
Board : Smita ma'am
Date. 28. 2. 18
Optional and grad: law
Chairperson.
1. What are the problems a civil servant faces while in office?
2. What kinds of resource crunch? (Follow up )
3. Give an example where officers have worked out these problems?
4. Why do national law university students prefer working in corporate sector?
5. Have national law unversities failed in their mandate?
6. Lawyers bill a lot so why not practice law?
M1:
1. Female models being used in auto expo. Views
2. Should we bring in a law to ban such practices
3. Define son of the soil doctrine
4. Which indian state never had such a doctrine
M2:
1. Will the us japan help india if China attacks us today
2. Should CJI accept posts after retirement
3. Transparency and public office holders
M 4:
1. Measures taken by government to curb black money in real estate
2. Amendments to benami act
3. Why was IT act not amended to achieve the same ends as benami act
4. Is retrospective tax good
5. What was the nature of the 1024 obsolete laws repealed, name any 3.
M 5:
1. What is medical tourism
2. Why is it called tourism
3. What is surrogacy
4. Should it be allowed
5. What is the legal status of single parent family
6. Legality of police encounters
7. What will you do if you were sp and what will you do to reduce police encounters.
Lavanya:
M2
Are you good in banking.?
what are the criteria you consider before giving a loan.?
what kind of democracy is India.?
what is a parliament.?
what are the functions of parliament.?
how is it constituted.?
what are the 2 houses.?
what are the other names of lower house and upper house.?
what is numerical strength of both houses.?
what kind of government is state government.?
what are the names of legislative bodies in state.?
Is government of state government formed from both houses.? are you sure.?
what is NSS.?
what did you do as an NSS coordinator.?
M3
what is your way of pet caring.?
you just take care of your domestic dogs and that's it.?
what did you do as a part of nature club.?
do you think your activities as a part of nature club.? had any impact.?
why do we need afforestation.?
what are benefits of having a good forest cover?
what is the percentage of forest cover in India.?whether it increased or not.?
M4
why should we be ethical to animals.what is the need for that?
why did you join banking after chemical engineering.?
what are emerging fields in material science research of chemical engineering.?
is'nt Nano technology one among them.?
Omendra Chauhan:
28 Feb 2018 (FN)
Dr. P K Joshi Board
Second one to go
Name: Omendra Singh Chauhan
B.E. Mechanical Engg, BIT Mesra Ranchi
5 years in Automobile MNCs
Place of birth: Kanpur City
Optional: Pub Ad
Chairman:
1. So Omendra...you did schooling from... worked in automobile sector....(long initiation) tell me what did you do in Hyundai?
2. ...(contd) work profile in Toyota?
3. ...in Maruti?
4. How is Maruti different from Hyundai? (work culture and all)
5. What was your roles and responsibilities in these companies... (Long discussion)
6. Kanpur was known as Manchester of East...what happened to it? tell me what are the industries in Kanpur and why they are facing issues..and what kind of issues?
7. What can be done to help them?
8. What are the differences between Ranchi and Kanpur?
M1:
1. (something continued from CH related to Ranchi and Kanpur...industrial and economic growth..)
2. What is demonetisation and what happened? Positives and negatives of it?
3. What was income disclosure scheme (somewhat on the topic)..when did it happen? what happened?
4. Did demonetisation work? failures? success?....(some counter questions...)
5. Defense related industries in Kanpur? in UP? in India? (some counterqns on defense industry..)
6. long intro to question related to water deficiency situation in India....why so? what geographic climatic factors responsible for same? wht can be done?
7. (counter qn) What is river interlinking? any project? what would be its positives and negatives?
M2: (member who always looked dissatisfied)
1. (contd discussion on Ranchi) Why is Ranchi not developed, if it is not? What can be done? (counterqns on same)
2. Do you know about Shobhan Sarkar? What did he dream...( some news in 2013!) What did govt do? What happened there? 😡
3. Mejakhas (in DAF)..where is it? why did you go there for schooling? What is its topography? what industries there? any new project coming there? (bad experience on this discussion...in between his reaction was you dont know about your surroundings)
Lady Member:
1. so you play table tennis...( I told frankly I played in school, not been playing since sometime...she smiled and said its ok) So how do you keep yourself fit? what do you play now?
2. Who are famous TT players in India?
3. What do you think is future of Electric vehicles in India? ( Many counter qns on problems of charging, infra, industry in detail..handled pretty well)
4. Which countries currently have EV market growing? anyone in our neighborhood?
M4:
1. (contd discussion in EV market, future of Automobile industry and India's position and efforts?)
2. What kind of batteries are used in EV? Why India doesnot have them? What issues involved in charging infra related?
3. What kind of energy requirement we will have to meet such demands in EV market? and some counter qns...
4. What kind of reforms do you suggest in industrial development? (Long discussion...about labour reforms, infra... handled this part satisfactorily I guess)
CH: OK your interview is over.
(No qns on hoobbies/optional etc....overall mixed experience...board was cordial in general though one member was little intimidating and tried to grill on some qns...I maintained my calm composure and honestly told 'I am not able to recall the facts at the moment' in few counter qns)